Published July 19, 2007
Published!
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Brought to you on behalf of the CCF
I think these two should be in one paragraph. Or combined with the paragraph above it.
This was confusing. is the crowd still speaking after the italicized part. You need to remain consistent in order to not confuse the reader. it might be better to use quotations instead of italics.
This reads like speech but I don't know if it's meant to be or not. If it's not it does not follow the tone of your narration and will confuse the reader.
Characters
They all seem to be well defined and planned. Non of them have a flat feeling when reading. Each has a certain manner of speech that makes them unique and easy to distinguish. Even the crowd follows the manner of a crowd as we know it.
Dialogue gets a bit confusing due to the format. Some times it italics, sometimes not. And then when you place italics and I'm not sure why it really gets confusing. If it is a thought it helps to tell us so.
Plot
It is very strong. Everything flows along at a steady pace keeping the reader going. There are no side trails(Sub-plots) which is good for this piece.
Descriptions are strong but not over powering. The image of Sabradan being shot was powerful but not over gruesome making it easy to read and see.
Well Done
I think it had enough conflict, but that's just my personal preference.
Good, this, and Clau did the nitpick already.
Sabradan's dialog being in italics makes it really annoying to read, I have to say. I can guess that you did it like that because, in real life, he would be speaking another language so you put it in italics. But really, the italics just hurt my eyes...
Don't have this break between paragraph and dialog.
The first sentence should be a question. I'm horribly bothered by the fragments, but I have no idea what to do with them... I thought I'd say so XD
Having both of these -ful verbs so close bothered me. I don't know how I would rewrite it, honestly, but it didn't read right, imo.
I really want to make this two sentences: "A man stepped forward, flanked on either side by an armed body guard. Pushing through the wall of bodies, Ali immediately recognized..."
I can't really give my impressions? I love Ali, like I said, although here the reason why I love him only shined through a paragraph which was very repetitive of what I already knew: he really enjoys killing.
The pacing was nice, and the dialog was nice.
One thing though that bothered me: I'm hooked, I liked it, I want to know more, but what is the conflict? In the last chapter, we had the question, 'will the men agree to the plan?' in this chapter, there really isn't any conflict. True, you don't need conflict in every chapter, but I don't feel far enough in to be allowed a conflict lacking chapter.
There should still be conflict, it's so close to the beginning of the story. There has to be some central question, or a question specific to this chapter, that shows up in each section. Without that, this chapter just feels like it is getting the guy killed, and forwarding the war. But why do I care, now? What question is being answered by this chapter? Sure, though, it forwards the plot, but since that is all it does and there isn't a conflict for me to go "will such in such happen" I don't care as much.
For example, if there was the possibility that Ali DIDN'T kill the guy, and he survived, this would suddenly become a lot more interesting. The plan didn't work. What will Ali have to do to fix this? Will the plan still work? You see what I mean.
You don't necessarily have to change anything in the chapter unless you can easily find a way to fix this, but keep it in mind with the rest of the chapters. Your writing is still very good, and the story is still really interesting. But I'd like if it had more conflict.
This was my favorite part. Written beautifully.
I like Ali. He seems very self-assured with a flair for the dramatics. Someone who sees something as either black or white, with very little room for grey.
It seemed very easy for him to attack Sabradan. For such a powerful man in those particular surroundings, he didn't have any sort of guard or protection?