z

Young Writers Society



Catch a Falling Star

by KuroiOokami1234


Please critique it to shreds! I'm just starting poetry and really want to improve.

Can you catch a falling star in your hand?
Can your thin fingers keep a hold of the grains of sand?
Can you stop the hate that runs in our veins?
Can your words and actions stop the pains?
If you stop and listen, can you really hear?
If I hold your hand, can I remove the fear?
If we stand here together, can we make a difference?
If we quiet our thoughts, can we hear the truth in the silence?
Together, you and I, can we vanquish the hate?
I believe our peace is possible, if we only sit and wait.


Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.







Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
319 Reviews


Points: 9100
Reviews: 319

Donate
Sat May 07, 2011 9:03 am
Jashael wrote a review...



Can you catch a falling star in your hand?
Can your thin fingers keep a hold of the grains of sand?
Can you stop the hate that runs in our veins?
Can your words and actions stop the pains?
If you stop and listen, can you really hear?
If I hold your hand, can I remove the fear?
If we stand here together, can we make a difference?
If we quiet our thoughts, can we hear the truth in the silence?
Together, you and I, can we vanquish the hate?
I believe our peace is possible, if we only sit and wait.


Hello, Kuroi. I must apologize, but I can't critique it to shreds! This was nicely done, though we all know one can improve always. I'm just not sure how I can help you with this one. I'm just a reader now that would like to tell the writer that: I love the rhythm, the rhymes, the words used were great! I liked the style: using questions all throughout except for the last line to add punch. Nice, nice! =) Keep writing! :D Sorry I couldn't have been much more help with this one. But I do hope you keep on posting!

Jash ♥




User avatar
112 Reviews


Points: 1617
Reviews: 112

Donate
Thu May 05, 2011 4:33 pm
mellophone7 wrote a review...



I love this, and I also cannot believe that this is one of your first poems. I did notice a few errors, but I think that everybody already covered them.
I disagree on the punctuation/flow. The question marks didn't seem to interfere with the flow at all. I also agree with EtCetera when he said that it was very thought-provoking. This is great for your first try! Keep it up!!




User avatar
7 Reviews


Points: 990
Reviews: 7

Donate
Thu May 05, 2011 3:37 am
FragmentsOfSorrow wrote a review...



Wow, that was just...beautiful!

I love the first two lines the most, I think.
The first line, to catch a falling star, is something I think everyone subconsciously wishes they could do...Something to save for a wish one wants to make, something along the lines of a safety net, or a shred of hope.
The second line, to try to hold sand in your hand, is a task that has instilled hatred and anger for me, personally.

You portrayed, very creatively, this sensation of having a sense of hope, but then replacing it with such anger.
Absolutely beautiful.




User avatar
51 Reviews


Points: 2427
Reviews: 51

Donate
Thu May 05, 2011 1:06 am
Fortissimo wrote a review...



This is really good, I can't believe this is your first (or one of your first) poems that you've written. It seems that it has already been "torn to shreds." I just want to commend you on your effort, and success! You have a lovely writing style! Please continue poetry!!!

~Fortiii




User avatar
10 Reviews


Points: 1750
Reviews: 10

Donate
Tue May 03, 2011 5:50 pm
Riot_starter wrote a review...



I liked how it was so deep. There really are a lot of emotions hidden behind your words. The only thing I would have a problem with is your rhyme scheme. It kind of bothered me. But I'm a little obsessed with words flowing, so maybe I'm just nit picking. Don't stop writing, this was really good.




User avatar
156 Reviews


Points: 7297
Reviews: 156

Donate
Sun May 01, 2011 7:29 pm
KatTrain wrote a review...



Can you catch a falling star in your hand?
Can your thin fingers keep a hold of the grains of sand?
Can you stop the hate that runs in our veins?
Can your words and actions stop the pains?
If you stop and listen, can will you really hear?
If I hold your hand, can I remove the fear?
If we stand here together, can we make a difference?
If we quiet our thoughts, can we hear the truth in the silence? difference doesn't rhyme with silence
Together, you and I, can we vanquish the hate? You've already talked about hate
I believe our peace is possible, if we only sit and wait. You've been talking about action so why are you saying action is possible through inaction?




User avatar
522 Reviews


Points: 18486
Reviews: 522

Donate
Sun May 01, 2011 4:32 pm
Lavvie wrote a review...



Hi there. Lavvi in to review for you.

So, I found with the interrogation marks all over the place that it sort of ruined the flow over all. Flow is rather important, because it affects how others perceive the poem. Your rhymes were a little simple: I'd like for you to expand on those a bit. Venture into another world of more descriptive words and so it shall help the audience picture the things in this poem. I'm not entirely sure what your goal was for this poem, though...what's the metaphor behind it? You need to be clearer about it.

Yours,
Lavvi




User avatar
53 Reviews


Points: 1244
Reviews: 53

Donate
Fri Apr 29, 2011 1:06 pm
EtCetera wrote a review...



Can I say bitter with the world and humanity much? All the questions you asked were thought-provoking in nature and extremely complex for they initial simplicity. I really like the way that this poem is open to interpretation on every line and each interpretation could change the whole meaning of the poem. No grammar or spelling problems as far as I can tell, so very nice job!




User avatar
5 Reviews


Points: 1040
Reviews: 5

Donate
Tue Apr 26, 2011 10:29 pm
Pokemonbragirl wrote a review...



This was AMAZING. It's beautiful and means so much. I don't quite believe that you're new to poems and if you are.. I feel incredibly silly about my poems. I really admire this poem and want to see more of your writing :) Awesome job




Random avatar

Points: 1425
Reviews: 13

Donate
Tue Apr 26, 2011 10:22 pm
alwaysjustme wrote a review...



I love the poem! I can't believe your just stratingto write poetry. It's a beautiful poem. It captured my intrest. I liked the rythem of the poem. My two favorite lines are: If you stop and listen, can you really hear?If I hold your hand, can I remove the fear? I think this a really good poem. Btw welcome to YWS! I hope you love it here as much as I do! Most of the people on this site are very kind and helpful. I'm looking foward to reading more poetry from you and if you would like me to review anythting else just tell me.





It's Monday and you folks are beginning to wonder about the show, aren't you
— David Letterman