Wrote this about a month ago, and I'd like some opinions. I've done virtually no revisions thus far -- nitpicking definitely welcome!

By Halloween I was tired of Mrs. Swani and especially tired of F. Scott Fitzgerald.

Mrs. Swine-i (nicknamed by us students after her insult of choice) was arguably the worst teacher in Alabama – or at least the worst at Mayfield Academy. Swine-i was an ogre: She looked like one, talked like one, and (especially) acted like one. Trust me – just give her green skin and funny ears, and she’d be on the cast of Shrek.

As the Advanced English teacher, Swine-i apparently wanted to show us who was boss…Fitzgerald. We were about to begin reading The Great Gatsby, and as a warm-up (yeah, for our daily torture session) we were expected to write a biography of F. Scott Fitzgerald. For homework. In one night. On Halloween. Even for the most insensitive teacher, this was a little taboo.

As if to make the upcoming school year even worse, the Standard English teacher, Miss Pinedale, was notoriously nice. If not for my parents, I would be spending Halloween night stealing Fun-Size 3 Musketeers bars from our candy bowl, instead of mixing up birth and death dates.

“You need the best education you can get,” they’d said with those watery smiles on their faces, like I was three again.

At times like those I wanted to yell, “Y’all barely even went to college!”

And so I spent my Halloween afternoon trudging to Austen Park with a full book bag, waiting for Dad to pick me up.

Not many kids from school went to Austen after the dismissal bell rang, so, as usual, I was almost completely alone. I sat down on a bench next to the entrance sign and began perusing my copy of The Great Gatsby. After about ten minutes – just as I finished reading the foreword – I looked up. The park was just as quiet and empty as before, except for a woman who was walking towards me.

The first thing I noticed about her was her clothes. She was wearing a short, ruffly dress and a round hat, some sort of Halloween costume. I tried to think of what she was dressed as – oh, what were they called -- ?

The woman sat down beside me.

“Hey,” she said, like we were mutual friends seeing each other on the street. “What’cha reading?”

Please, please go away, I thought, wanting to be alone, but I showed her the cover anyway. Her mouth formed an O for a second, half a second, but then returned to normal. I noticed that she was chewing gum.

“For school?” she asked. I nodded.

“We have to do a report, too, on the author.”

She nodded sympathetically. “I’m Zel,” she said, and stuck out a gloved hand. I shook it gingerly. “What’s your name, honey?”

“Amy.” I winced a bit as I answered; Amy was such a dull name, compared to, well, Zel. “Are you going to a Halloween party or something?”

She laughed, soft and high, sort of like a wind chime. “Nah, nah, I don’t go to many parties anymore. Still, I liked to get dressed up a bit. For the Halloween spirit an’ all…you know.” She looked back down at the cover of the book. “Say, that author of yours? F. Scott? Pretty sure he lived in Paris for a while.”

“Really?” At that point I had gotten absolutely no research about him. Every piece of information mattered.

“You ever been to Paris, Amy?” Zel asked. Her eyes glittered.

“No – I mean, I take French and stuff, but I’ve never been there.”

“Well, Amy, when you do go, be sure to see the Eiffel, okey-doke? I know everybody says that, but it’s beautiful.”

I smiled politely and flipped to the “About the Author” page in the back of the book.

When I glanced back up, Zel had blown a bubble that obscured half her face. It popped – perfect timing – and instead of the small, cheerful smile that had been on her face, she was frowning. “That Fitzgerald’s wife, you know, I think she had schitzo – schitzo – goddammit, what was it?” She snapped her fingers. “Schitzophrenia, that’s it. The one where you hear voices?”

I nodded. I had heard of it.

“Yeah, they say it’s ‘cause he messed with her mind,” Zel continued. “Had to be in one of those asylums for a while. But before that, she was real different…a big-time flapper, like.” She spat her gum out. It landed silently on the grass.

“Cool.” A flapper, that’s what Zel was dressed up as. “Hey, what was his wife’s name again?”

She pulled a cigar from her purple handbag. I had never seen a cigar before, except in movies; neither of my parents smoked. She lit it with a match, held it to her lips, blew a cloud of smoke out. I saw that her eyes had turned foggy.

“Zelda,” She said quietly. “Her name was Zelda….”

BEEP-BEEP – Dad was in the parking lot, twenty yards away from us, waiting. I turned to her to say goodbye, but Zelda Sayre Fitzgerald was gone, gone until the next Halloween.

Note: Everything mentioned of the Fitzgeralds is true...except for the ghost part, I mean.

So...thanks for reading, all help is appreciated. :]

Comments & reviews · 4
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
How2EataRhesus
Comment

No...I didn't even know there was one. :]

Thanks everyone for the critique.

did you get this from the book Zel?

User avatar
Trikky
Review
Trikky wrote a review · Mon Jan 19, 2009 3:38 am

Ah! Alabama! I used to live there... there are a lot of good things about Alabama, but the teachers aren't one of them. -_-;
So I'm interested, and I sympathize with your character right off. Hope that doesn't mess up the critiques, xD

instead of mixing up birth and death dates.

Is this possible? Wouldn't it be obvious, what with the death date always being after the birth date?

watery smiles on their faces


haha, great simile ;)

“Y’all barely even went to college!”

Your MC sounds pretty uneducated here; it's a little hypocritical. Also, you either go to college and get a degree or you don't.

I tried to think of what she was dressed as – oh, what were they called -- ?

I love the way this increases the tension.

Pretty sure he lived in Paris for a while.

What does this have to do with anything?

“That Fitzgerald’s wife, you know, I think she had schitzo – schitzo – goddammit, what was it?”

This is the second time one of your characters has forgotten a word for something, and it's one too many.

I liked this piece. It was well-written, but the "she was actually a ghost-- on Halloween!" plot is a little overused and I could tell where it was going as soon as she walked out of the mist in the old-fashioned outfit. So that was a little disappointing. :/
I like your style, though, keep writing, Rhesus!

User avatar
Hannah
Review
Hannah wrote a review · Mon Jan 19, 2009 3:28 am

SO! CUTE! I love it because I could definitely see what was happening after I got to see what the work was going to be about! ^_^ Definitely very cute. First comment would be that {now, keep in mind that I'm no expert either} you should try to research the type of slang/dialogue used in Zelda's time period, because I think some of the phrases she used seemed a bit jarring. Whether that's because they're inaccurate or simply because I'm odd, I don't know. ;D

Mrs. Swine-i (nicknamed by us students after her insult of choice) was arguably the worst teacher in Alabama – or at least the worst at Mayfield Academy. Swine-i was an ogre: She looked like one, talked like one, and (especially) acted like one. Trust me – just give her green skin and funny ears, and she’d be on the cast of Shrek.


First of all, the hyphen in her nick name gets a bit distracting. I don't know what you could do about that, but maybe spell it out or simplify it? ^_^ Also, when you say 'her' insult of choice, does that mean she enjoyed calling her students pigs/swine? Perhaps clarify. 'On the cast of Shrek' seems a bit too vague, and I think it might be a bit more powerful and persuasive to say something like 'she'd be the title character in Shrek' or the starring role, something like that. -nodnod-

warm-up (yeah, for our daily torture session)


I'd suggest just saying 'for our daily torture session' and get rid of the 'yeah', to make it flow more smoothly. ^_^

For homework. In one night. On Halloween. Even for the most insensitive teacher, this was a little taboo.


Beautifully done through here. I love the powerful fragments because it's really just like adding more and more torture to the situation, just one thing after the other and it gets the message across beautifully. ^_^

At times like those I wanted to yell, “Y’all barely even went to college!”


Maybe 'It was at times like those'?

– oh, what were they called -- ?


Perhaps an ellipsis rather than two dashes? ^_^

“Hey,” she said, like we were mutual friends seeing each other on the street. “What’cha reading?”


I believe 'mutual friends' refers to if you and a friend have a friend in common? Perhaps rework that middle part. ^_^

Please, please go away, I thought, wanting to be alone, but I showed her the cover anyway. Her mouth formed an O for a second, half a second, but then returned to normal. I noticed that she was chewing gum.


Don't know if you meant for the thoughts to be italicized or not, but I think they should be. Also, there should be quotation marks around the "O". I think. Hahah~ Also, why is her gum-chewing important? ^_^

“Say, that author of yours? F. Scott? Pretty sure he lived in Paris for a while.”


I ADORE this part. It's as if Zel is keeping her identity a secret but doling out little crumbs of information for Amy because she knows what she's thirsting for. So lovely.

“Well, Amy, when you do go, be sure to see the Eiffel, okey-doke? I know everybody says that, but it’s beautiful.”


This was one part where I had a problem with Zel's dialogue. I guess in my mind I don't think she'd say 'okey-doke', but that's just me. ;D


“Cool.” A flapper, that’s what Zel was dressed up as. “Hey, what was his wife’s name again?”


Perhaps a bit more about how Amy was just suddenly remembering the term. And also, that second part of dialogue seems a bit awkward. Starting a question with 'hey' is kind of like they'd stopped talking or there was a pause, and 'again' would mean that they'd spoken of the name before. Though it helps to make the sentence casual, it doesn't really fit. ^_^

BEEP-BEEP – Dad was in the parking lot, twenty yards away from us, waiting. I turned to her to say goodbye, but Zelda Sayre Fitzgerald was gone, gone until the next Halloween.


I'd probably phrase it as 'BEEP-BEEP!' rather than using the dash, and also maybe 'gone. Gone until the next Halloween, that is.' Or something like that. ^_^

I loved the piece. Good work! ^_^



the world (me) cries out for salvation (snacks)
— creaturefeature