Hey there whatcha! Tuck here for a review tonight.
Overall, I really loved the way that you created gentle and then powerful climaxes throughout this poem. There was a strong character development in here -- a highlight for me is the way the MC gets "worn down" throughout the poem. It begins with an "I'm good!", moves to "I'm alright", and finally an "I'm fine." It was very subtle but a powerful way of showing the way the day was wearing on the reader. I also found all of these emotions very relatable -- the way there's this silent pressure on students, coupled with the crippling loneliness so many high schoolers experience. I want you to know you're not alone in these feelings, and if you ever want someone to talk to for any reason I'm around
Now, into some critique:
Your enjambment and italicized/differently styled stanzas worked well for the most part, but there was one area that I felt was a little problematic:
according to NASA, these are true
books - they can catch their reader in orbit.
This didn't have the same contrast as your other italicized sections, and it didn't have the same punch that it felt that you were going for. In fact, this section was one of the least emotional parts of the poem, and I think it could be tightened up a bit. You start with these really powerful images that give the idea of loneliness and disconnect from the world, the idea that you're not doing okay but you can't tell anyone because of the pressures piled on you, and then this section seems to be more of a transition to the final stanza than a section in and of itself. I didn't get a strong emotional feel from this section like I did from the rest of the poem. I don't have too many suggestions for how to improve this, but maybe some emphasis on your current orbit would help drive home the point about why it's so terrible to feel as if you're caught in the same orbit. The idea of "same-old-same-old" doesn't have a huge emotional impact if the reader isn't reminded of how much this orbit isn't where the MC wants to be.
Sorry I got a bit rambly there, but hopefully you're able to salvage something helpful from it!
My second point of critique is that I would have loved to see you do a little bit more with the water imagery. You bring it in once in a super powerful way ("but am I stretching for the sky or are
the tips of my hair dipping down into the glassy
water? perhaps the silvery reflection is more
perfect than the moon itself."), and yet there's a lot of potential here. There's an obvious contrast between water and the sky, so it could be cool for this to be extended throughout the piece as a continued contrast between the celestial -- which to me represents a vast universe full of potential and possibilities -- and this place that stifles possibilities and is yet still filled with wonder. Just some food for thought!
The development from the first stanza to the third stanza is truly enviable. There's this clear turning point -- a friend who is invested enough to push beyond the "I'm okay" answer, and yet it feels like a natural progression. I especially like the way you introduced some new imagery in every stanza while still playing with the same theme. This is a really, really powerful poem, and I'm sure it's going to stick with me for another while. Tightening up that middle section, adding a more punch-y italicized stanza in that same section, and perhaps extending the water motif throughout the poem instead of isolated in one spot would help strengthen this poem! If you have any questions about this review please feel free to ask! This was a pleasure to read and I hope to see more from you.
Best,
Tuck
Points: 31375
Reviews: 560
Donate