Warning: This work has been rated 16+.
The hard, frozen ground crunched beneath his heavy footsteps. He stumbled down into the earthy ground, falling on his hands and knees. A drop of blood trickled aimlessly out of the gash on his head, and it fell with a silent splash. Yet the sound of it echoed through the icy fog that swept its way around him in every direction. The blood found its way through the decomposing leaves of recent autumn. It found its way deep down into the cracks of the cold, dry ground. The man started coughing violently, and down rained more splatters of red. The red slowly mixed with the dusty brown, and as the coughing diminished the man let a smile creep to his lips. He stared at the mixing colors with a strange twinkle in his eyes. After the span of a minute he flicked his head back up. Dead trees of every size outnumbered him on all flanks. He was surrounded by the greyness of the trees, lost with no sense of direction.
The cold bit through the tattered remnants of clothing that clung to his sticky body. His soul was slowly fading from the world that he walked. It would soon leave his rotting body, the body with all its sores and scabs, cuts and bruises. It would fade into the fog, lost in the depths of time never to be remembered. The man could not let that happen. He had to keep searching. As he struggled to stand upright, his knees buckled and he fell face first, smashing his head into the red and brown ground with a resounding thud. He looked up, disoriented, and a loud screeching started to fill his ears. An assortment of voices talking, whispering, screaming at him. No escape. No escape. His hands went over his ears, hoping to block the screeching and moaning of the loved ones he once knew. It helped to no avail. All he could do was listen. And then he heard her over all others. A sad moan filled the air, a sort of whisper that pleaded. No, please... don’t do this... no. Then the screaming came back, but this time it was only her voice. And with it the man also screamed. Screamed into the grey woods with all the strength left in him. The tears forming in his eyes started blurring the trees, and he curled up into a whimpering ball on the frozen ground of red and brown, and the world around him faded. Faded into a dull grey.
-----
His eyes opened. A clear ray of sunshine brushed playfully over his face. He lifted his head without restraint and glanced quickly around the room in which he lay. The bright color on the walls, a pale yellow, it seemed familiar. The soft white sheets that his back has sunken into, the clock on the wall- a different bird sound for each hour. The dusty brown hardwood floor. It seemed like home to the man. No, it was home, it had to be. His hands tightly gripped the bedding to make sure it was real. He slowly laid his head back and stared at the plain white ceiling, relaxing his grip. He pulled his arms around himself and hugged tightly, and a slight whimper escaped his lips. Because where his hands had been two bloody prints had taken their place. Panicking, he lifted his hands and stared at them. Clean. He looked back down at the bedding. Clean. Before he could think any further he heard a soft pattering of footsteps approaching the door. The worn hinges creaked and the door slowly opened. And there she was. The light danced on her pale, smooth skin, and the most beautiful smile lit up upon her bright innocent face. Her icy blue eyes burned with a deep passion, a love so strong towards a man so pitiful. She wore a bright yellow dress, brighter than the dandelions she grew in her neat little garden. Her natural, soft black hair glimmered with the morning sun. Before he could open his mouth to greet her, she froze. Her expression was locked in a choking grimace. Suddenly the man felt like he had been hit by a gunshot, and the memories came pouring back to the man.
-----
That night. That night before he ended up with the woman. God, what had he done? That woman, that oh so beautiful woman. Dead because of him.
He faintly remembered their faces. He remembered wandering around the dark, crumbling streets that night. Always wandering with a brown bagged drink in his hand. Somehow, the man had wandered into this beautiful woman. She had smiled the same smile, and as he stared at her for what seemed like the first time he saw the fire in her eyes light up. She had taken his hand in his most desperate hour, she led him through the darkest places, the deepest and most troublesome times. But it was not the first time the man had met her, for he knowingly drank a lot over the years and forgot. Luckily he had her there to care for him. When they slept in bed together, during the latest hours of the night, she would listen to his fervent panting as the moonlight shined upon them. She would listen to the fervent panting turn into groans. She would listen to the groaning turn into a fitful scream of terror, a scream that pierced the peaceful calm stillness of the night. Then she would gently stroke his hand, the hand that was wrapped tightly around her throat, slowly choking her to death. She would ease him back into a fitful sleep by talking softly to him. She was helping him, she told herself. All he needed was someone in his life to save him. She was the one that would save him. Every night she gently traced his hand with her slender fingers as it gripped her throat. I’m helping him.. I am, I really am. She told herself this every night as a runaway tear streaked down her pale, moonlit cheek.
But every night the man choked a little more out of her. A little more of her resilience and love towards him and his haunting past. The struggle to try and help the man she loved grew harder and harder as the days dragged on. Finally, after countless nights, she stopped trying to remove his hands. She closed her eyes and let go of not only his hand but everything she saw dear in him. His life, his situation, it spread to her. An infection that she could not avoid. She knowingly infected herself, hoping love would be the cure. But it was not. As he gripped her throat in his nightmares, she did not bother trying to calm him. She let him slowly choke her to death; the sweaty, cold fingers tightening and tightening, with her hoping and praying he would finish the job. But he never did. He would wake up and cry like the pitiful man he was. She realized that was what he was- pitiful. He always would be. No matter how much she tried, or thought she could try, nothing would help the poor man. Now here she was, dragged down by something she could not handle. It was her own fault for getting into something that proved too much to bear on her tiny, frail shoulders. After the man finished mopping up his tears, he would plead for forgiveness and tell her how much he loved her. And she would automatically reply I love you too. The emotion and feelings gone from her voice, but the man did not notice. He was too far gone in his desperation and delusion from what was reality and what was not. He clung to her words of love, though. He clung to it tighter than his oh-so beloved’s throat, for that was all that he had in his sorry life.
-----
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey there, it's MJ, back for another review. Keep in mind that all of these are suggestions, and you can feel free to ignore any of them if you don't feel like they're helpful. With that said, let's jump in.
1)
I don't feel like 'stumbled down into' is the right phrase, just because it seems slightly awkward. I would say 'stumbled, falling down onto' instead.
2)
Wait, when did he get a gash on his head? That needs to be introduced earlier in the story.
3) . There's no need to have this in two separate sentences. It would be much simpler to say "The blood found its way through the decomposing leaves of recent autumn and deep down into the cracks of the cold, dry ground."
4) Again, it would be simpler to say "The world around him faded into a dull grey."
5)
"the pale yellow on the walls seemed familiar" flows better.
6) This seems generally awkward and doesn't make a whole lot of sense. I would take this sentence out and instead say "This was the first time I remembered seeing her, although it was possible I had met her before but been too drunk to remember."
7) This section switches the MC of the story. Before it was from the perspective of the man, and now it has switched to the perspective of the woman.
Overall thoughts:
Very well written, but with some sentence errors that could be corrected. You tended to focus on details a little too much, and you never really had a resolution to the plot. Other than that, very good job. Keep writing!
Best wishes,
MJ
So the only new critic I feel I can add is that it wasn't neccesary to say,"and the world around him faded. Faded into a dull grey." when you could have simply put,"The world around him faded into dull grey." It is blunt and the to the point without using more words than needed. Other than that, the story was quite enjoyable
Hi, HavYouCeenMyGum! I'm Pan, here to fry up a review for you today.
There's a great idea in here, and I like the sense of ambiguity and horror you have running through the piece. There are lines I love - clinging to her words of love tighter than her throat, that one is particularly chilling. However, I think this story suffers from too many words, if I'm absolutely honest, and there are a few things that need tweaking before it can reach its full potential. I've got two main tips:
1) First, there's the words problem. You have a tendency to describe every detail, to repeat for emphasis, and this has the effect of slowing down the pace of your writing. I can't isolate it to any particular section, because there is nothing intrinsically wrong with honing in on things so long as you don't do it constantly. In short, write more concisely. Cut out any details that aren't key to understanding, so that when you stop and pause and focus on something important, the reader pays attention.
2) Also, there's sentence structure. Let's look at the opening:
Length-wise and structure-wise, these sentences are all very similar, and the effect is that it starts to feel a tad monotonous. Variety, as we know, is the spice of life; try to experiment with more structures to keep it interesting. For example, I might do something like this:
The hard ground crunched beneath him - beneath his feet, then knees, then hands. Blood trickled. Fell. Splashed. In his ears, it had the sound of rock hitting metal, multiplied tenfold in the foggy air.
I've played about with it quite deliberately just to show how varied sentences can be, but it's totally up to you what changes you make. Just remember that writing needs a rhythm, and the rhythm is every bit as important as the words you choose - more so, some might say. It needs a fluidity, and that only comes from diversity. Repetition works, but it needs a purpose.
Anyway, I hope those tips helped. Keep them in mind if you come back to edit this, and for anything you write in future.
Don't hesitate to PM me if you've any questions.
Keep writing!
~Pan
Hey there Gum! Let's get right into the review.
First off, your imagery in the introduction feels a little rigid to me. Let's take a look:
So, general thoughts of the second paragraph:
You have a tendency to repeat words, thus emphasizing them. Sometimes this works. You can see this in poetry as a device to force the reader to remember a certain term as important. Here, though, it doesn't do that too well. Take this for instance
While this example is closer to the poetic device I mentioned above, it still doesn't quite cut it. There's another "body" used right before this, so that makes it three times. Consider using synonyms; thesauruses are your best friend in these cases. "Corpse" or "remains" or "skeleton" provide a much more vivid image than just body. When combing back through this, I strongly suggest you look into that.
Also, be careful of dead verbs. Things like "started to" and "went" (both from this paragraph) are weak and don't add anything to the story. Once again, a thesaurus is your best friend here. Instead of "went" you could do "crawled" or "flung". These all provide the same purpose, but they create those striking images that you want in here.
Your imagery in the third paragraph is wonderful. You explain where this person is without telling the reader. Well done! This is something I preach for all the time to people. "Show us, don't tell us!" You did it wonderfully.
So, the repetition of words were done much better in the last two paragraphs. I did get a sense of how important they were, from the woman's perspective. Like she was trying to convince both of us.
General Thoughts
I think this was quite wonderful, but started out rough, and without direction. I'm still not quite sure what's going on in the first two paragraphs at all, and they don't correlate anything with the ending to me. To better tie this story together, I would suggest either omitting the first two paragraphs completely and focusing on him and her more, or weaving the forest scene with her thoughts of when they met. The little of what I saw of the woman's thoughts in the story were honestly the best for me. I'd love to see a duality between the woman's thoughts when she first met the man and the man's thoughts after he killed her.
This was really good, though. Please don't take my criticism as not liking it, because I did! Every story can be improved on, though. I'd also suggest, on a different topic, to break the paragraphs up more. This isn't a long story, but only having six paragraphs (with five really long ones) makes it hard on the eyes. I found myself having to re-read things multiple times because my eyes wandered. There was so much text blocked together that I had troubles finding my place.
I do hope you keep writing, and I'd love to hear your thoughts down below. Thanks and I hope I helped <3