Hi Froggy,
Mailice here with a short review!
Belated welcome here on YWS!
Let's start with your story. I found it very refreshing and intriguing. I like love stories, especially when they go more in a certain direction. What I found exciting about you was the way you managed the introduction, giving the reader all the information they need to follow the story.
I liked the way you went about repeating yourself in places and using different methods to show the reader that someone is in love. I also liked that you managed not to start with an awkward scene or insert where Lucas gets lost or something, but you stay on the straight path.
Overall, though, the story was still a bit in a building phase. There were some parts that technically need to be developed a bit more, while other parts are read over again because of minor mistakes. You can do that by writing and reading more, for example. This way you learn to develop more of a structure and find some mistakes all by yourself or even passages that need to be rewritten a bit.
In summary, it was nevertheless a great first chapter and I'm curious to see how the plot will continue.
Some points I noticed while reading:
It had been about a month since Lucas's freshman year in high school started when he first started getting distracted by Evelyn in class.
Your first sentence is like a person's appearance; you don't want to judge because of a superficiality, but you do it subconsciously anyway. You create a repetition here with the first sentence, which you paraphrase best. (two times "started"). For example, you could create two sentences like this: "It had been about a month since Lucas's freshman year in high school started. It was the same time he got distracted by Evelyn in class."
They were, as Forrest Gump would say, "like peas and carrots." They walked to school together, they went to class together, they sat near each other, ate lunch together, waited for each other's clubs to finish, they walked home together, they texted each other at night, they hung out on the weekends.
First of all, a great connection you make with a film. Your next sentence has a great structure, but I would try to put the repetition here ("together") in every part of the sentence. This helps to intensify what you were trying to do. If a different structure appears in between, it doesn't seem so great.
I took her two months before she could be closer than ten feet from him without crying
I don't know what exactly you wanted to say here. I think you meant to write "It took him" but I'm not sure here.
Evelyn had always listened to him, even when he was talking too much. Unlike Mom or Dad or anybody else, Evelyn always listened.
This whole section has a repetition (listen / listened) but it seems unprofessional here because to me it seems like you're always saying the same thing. That is of course true with repetition, but in this section it reads as if you have put obstacles in your way. You could have put some examples in here to make the paragraph flow more.
"Hey, Lucas," the teacher said, making Luke lose his train of thought "name three parts of an animal cell." Luke looked at his teacher with a blank expression. "Come on Luke, we just went over this."
You used the name Luke earlier and I think it would help better if you added that Lucas is called Luke by some. I thought here at the beginning that it was a different person.
No, you can't be thinking like that, you'll only become more awkward than you already are.
You create Lucas' thought processes from the second half on, I think that's good. But I would write them separately in a new line or emphasise them with italics.
As they walked home, they began speaking to each other.
The beginning here seems a bit simple and you could certainly expand it a bit.
"No. Nope. Nothing in particular." he said, obviously distracted.
"Are you sure?" he nodded "you know you can tell me anything, right?"
"I don't really think I can tell you about this one." he said right before immediately regretting it
"Oh? You can't tell me? Is it about a girl?" Evelyn said teasingly. His face went red with embarrassment. "Wait, really? Who is it? Tell me!" "No" he said quietly
"Come on, please!"
"No, you are too close to the person for me to be able to tell you."
"Hmmm, ok" she said suspiciously.
This whole section has some punctuation errors. (Missing full stops, different capitalisation), etc... I'd read over it again.
Have fun writing!
Mailice
Points: 0
Reviews: 1232
Donate