Hey Elinor! Back again to review some more let's get into it, shall we?
The world isn't against you, Deb. It's only your imagination.
I took this to mean that she can be paranoid at times? From the "world is against me" mindset, and the fact that her friend was suggesting that it only was her imagination about it. I wanted to mention it, since I don't know how you intended it to come across, but I do like the suggestion for her character and adding more layers to her!
Alex and Sasha watched me, starting to laugh.
It seems like an odd reaction to laugh at this? I imagine Debbie's tone is a bit clipped here, just by what she's saying and her thoughts about the barbecue in the last part. She's telling off her mum, which I expected to garner approval from Alex and Sasha, but laughing makes it sound... amusing, which the line doesn't warrant, in my opinion? I don't know, maybe they smile or something instead?
I could hear her fuming.
Instead of "hearing" her fuming (because we're going back to the telling thing, and what does her mother's "fuming" sound like anyway?), maybe she imagines her mum getting red in the cheeks? Or maybe her expression gets really pinched, and Deb pictures that? Or maybe her mum does do something audible, like huffing or gasping. Then the reader can actually imagine/recreate what your describing, plus it adds a little more to Deb's mum (and, if Deb is very familiar with her anger/disappointment/etc, then the fact that she can visualise those emotions says something about her home life).
For a long time I'd wanted to stand up to her,
And here is a line that I really enjoy for the reason I just said actually! You throw in more of Deb's past without telling, and it makes the conversation that she just had more impactful!
"She's going to be so mad," I replied.
I'm curious how she says this line? Does the worry that her mum will be mad close in on her triumphant feeling all of a sudden? Or is it more of a general toss out there that "she's gonna be mad" but Deb's not concerned about it right now?
In the back of my mind, there was a brief moment of hesitation, of knowing something about this situation wasn't quite right.
I think this could be expanded on? Like, Deb knows that getting in the car of two almost strangers can't be a good idea, but they've been nice to her and she's tired of her life right now, so safety isn't at the forefront of her mind? I know it does go into that in the next lines somewhat, but I feel it could have been stated a little more concretely rather that being vague about "something's not right here".
"What kind of music do you like?" She asked me.
I noticed a few times after dialogue that you capitalise words that don't need capitalising? Mostly, you have "I said/asked" or "Name said/asked", but when it's just a pronoun, it shouldn't be capitalised.
(Specifically for this one, though, I don't think you need the dialogue tag. The reader should know it's Sasha asking the question since she's the one who turned around to face Deb, and the "She turned back to me" followed closely by "She asked me" doesn't read quite right to me. Repetition dulls writing, and while there is repetition that reads fine, the dialogue tag isn't inherently necessary here, so the repetition doesn't serve any kind of purpose here other than to sound a bit funny)
The Midwest had to be the most boring part of the country,
haha wow isn't that the truth. a big pancake pretty much.
I didn't know much about it other than Yellowstone was there, so it was probably prettier.
also true :p
"We're probably just in time for the fire," Sasha said, changing the subject.
I'm someone who is supremely guilty of this as well, but the "changing the subject" is really already implied by her dialogue, so writing in that she was "changing the subject" is telling and doesn't serve much of a purpose here.
"I'm Debbie," I stammered.
"Deborah?"
I don't know why? But I love Jay's penchant for asking people their full names if they give him like, something shorter haha.
I love how fast the transition of Debbie's emotions are after she meets Jay. The way you've written it does really get across that mindset that she has where it's just confusing. Her mind is swirling and she doesn't know what to do about everything that's happening, and I think that it really comes across in the way you've written it at the end here
(I MEAN I hope that's what you were going for??)
I also really enjoy how all the girls seem to notice how open and beautiful the sky is when they're first brought to the campsite? That seems to be many of their reactions and, as someone who adores the stars and the night sky, I really appreciate this reaction and the way you describe it.
Okay! I think that's all I have for today! I really enjoyed the read
I hope you're having a wonderful time! <3
Points: 14090
Reviews: 351
Donate