Hey there DarkerSarah. I read your author's note, and I am very sorry if someone was extremely unkind to you concerning the content of your poetry, but I can see where they were coming from. you make the point of saying that this is not a poem about suicide but there's still some very violent imagery going on here. And there actually does appear to be some reminders of suicide, so I think you might have just been justifying it in your author's note.
Some things we won’t ever forget.
Usually, these things are bad.
Mistakes we’ve made,
horrible,
tragic
accidents.
Sometimes they are good, but not usually.
I'm questioning a lot of parts of this poem and I decided just to quote out a small section to deal with those issues, since they seem to be apparent in every stanza. And the fact that there's so many big things all over the place is really troubling to me. I really don't like to doubt how poets decide to put their pieces together but...well I guess I should start actually breaking down the "big" problems.
For one, we have the line length. And it is absolutely nowhere near being uniform. In fact, it feels like you purposely made the structure stick out in this way, which is not really soothing to the eye or to the sound. I think there was an obvious disconnect in the relation between flow and structure because that would shift a lot of things around in this poem. The structure is broken very far apart (which could be good) but if you're going to have lines this short, there needs to be more spacing. I can see the one word lines working out if there were greater amounts of white space. There might have even been more white space originally but we all know what the publishing center does to precious formatting.
Then we're brought into the issue of word choice, which is overall pretty plain the whole way through. I could see some words along the way that seemed to just be thrown in to be flashy, or maybe they were legitimate usages that I didn't pay complete attention to. It was very hard for me to get through this poem out of a combination of word choice and faults in the structure. I know that's kind of hard to explain to you but this poem could never be described as easy.
So it's not about suicide but I get that your overall content is violent. For that, I'm going to recommend that you add a few content warnings to this because otherwise, this might be a bit of a shock to some people.
Okay, that's all I;ve got for now.
-Lizz
Points: 650
Reviews: 766
Donate