Published April 14, 2012
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi, I'm going to review your piece. I thought you had a lot of interesting ideas, so I managed to read the entire story. I don't think my review will be very in-depth, but there are just some things that came to mind as I read that I think are worth mentioning.
How can speed be breath-taking? Maybe another word would be more fitting here.
Use italics for the thoughts of the characters, I think it'll be less confusing.
I think this would be more interesting if it were turned into dialogue. That's one thing that I see throughout your story - you avoid dialogue in some places and opt to just explain or describe things. I'll mention more of these instances below.
Also, is it believable that Jaydn would go out of his way to escort this girl to a presumable far away city? At this point, I don't think so. Maybe give more background into who he is, what he does, etc? Maybe he's a traveler heading to Veridia as well, and offers to accompany her, for example.
I liked this dialogue, particularly because of the irony. I don't think you need to mention the irony here, let the reader pick up on that them self.
Where is he leaving to? I understand that they are traveling together, where could he possibly go? Maybe Aurelia leaves him, since she is feeling slightly uncomfortable. Or maybe Jaydn goes to find firewood or something.
I don't know if that last sentence made sense, though I know what you're trying to convey. Maybe try "she became determined to complete her journey" or "she set her mind to the quest ahead of her."
Parsimonious goblins? I imagine goblins would be parsimonious because they were unwilling to spend money, not because that they wouldn't spare shelter. Maybe they are just distrusting goblins, or maybe Aurelia and Jaydn didn't trust them.
Now the problem I have with these paragraphs is that what you did was tell us what happened, and what kind of person Aurelia is without really showing us anything. As a result, you've missed out on a huge opportunity to expand your story to describe interesting events and provide characterization. In fact, your whole story is about Aurelia and Jaydn's journey to Veridia. The idea is so straightforward that you have so much room to be creative with the events that take place on their way to the city (ie. their goals, motivations, the friends and enemies they make along the way, the eventual revelation of the characters' pasts, etc).
I don't feel like Jaydn's response is believable, considering that he has feelings for her. It really is a bigger deal than Jaydn seems to think... Are there more like her? Jaydn makes it sound like this is not that uncommon.
Now I really like the idea that Aurelia has no soul. But you can and should do a lot with this idea. For example, maybe you should slowly reveal how or why she lost her soul (or whatever Aurelia knows about losing her soul) as the plot progresses (instead of just telling us at the end)? Great idea, many possibilities.
Another thing that I'm sure would interest the reader is Jaydn's feelings for her. You can develop a complicated relationship between them, for example maybe Jaydn is somewhat religious (to whichever God you invent in your world), and maybe he suddenly feels conflicted when he learns Aurelia as no soul. How can he love someone like this? This could also give him more reason to help her complete her quest.
Good line, I think. Let's us peek into Aurelia's mind. This is the kind of characterization that your story needs more of.
I thought this was kind of corny haha. Also you don't need to say "a little black bird..." since we are already aware that this bird is a character in your story. Maybe it would be easier to refer to if Aurelia had named the bird at some point.
Try "unusually quiet" instead.
Now, more importantly, when I read that they had simply -arrived- at Veridia, I was honestly kind of disappointing, because I never got to understand their struggles and immerse myself in this world you've created. This really ties back to my previous point - that you missed the opportunity to elaborate on the obstacles they faced during their journey.
Also, you totally missed the chance to describe to the readers the stages in the relationship between your characters. I mean, I knew you meant for them to fall for each other, but maybe you could have give us reason to think otherwise in order to keep our interest? I guess what I'm saying is, you made their "falling in love" too easy or too obvious.
I love dreams as plot devices, but I think it would have been better if you showed us the dream instead of just telling us. It could have provided a lot of foreshadowing and could have helped compel your readers into reading further.
Who is thinking this line? It really confused me... it can't be Aurelia because she doesn't lack pride (according to Jaydn), and it can't be Jaydn because he already said that her end would be due to her pride...
I felt this event was completely out of the blue, which is unfortunate because it is very important to the story... it's the climactic ending to the quest. Maybe the appearance of this witch would have been more ominous and frightening (as I'm sure you had intended) if you had mentioned her or warned us about her earlier in your story.
I thought it was kind of funny that Jaydn was completely useless in the final confrontation between the witch and Aurelia. Other than the fact that Aurelia only got a chance to defeat the witch because she was distracted with Jaydn, I just felt Jaydn shouldn't have been such a weak opponent.
Also, I wasn't a big fan of the fact that the bird, Arania, could simply snatch the stone from the witch. If it was so easy to take the stone, what stopped her from seeking out the witch herself, stealing the stone, and bringing it to Aurelia (and therefore keeping her daughter away from harm)?
I thought it was strange that you decided to describe how Jaydn looked at the end of the story.
I thought the way you ended was good, since it tied back to what she had said earlier.
Overall, and once again, I thought there were a lot of interesting ideas in your story, and that there is plenty of room for expanding and improving the plot. In particular, you need to show us the events and the traits of your characters, and not just tell us what happened. That's probably the main thing that kept me from loving this piece.
Another thing, there were times when I felt that you were being a bit too wordy or trying to be more descriptive than you needed to be, and it was sort of a turn off. Sometimes, simplicity helps to keep the reader's interest and to help everything flow better.
I'd be glad to see any editions you make to the story, so let me know if you do.
Keep writing!
~a2sd
Lets*
It* was disappointing
Also, I didn't mind the length of the story, unlike your previous reviewer. I think the length was acceptable for a short story... (y)
Dude, this is many things but not short.
It's suppose to be 1000 words
I'm pretty sure it was... 2 years ago when i wrote it- and I haven't added anything at all.