Okay, so this was well descripted and all and surely a nice read just as I expect everything you write to be
unfortunately there was something I had to point out.
Nothing passed across our bridge except the wind
and things that flew--birds and hurt, to name a few--
and though we say the bridge gave way, a violent bend
to its demise, the twigs and limbs we found
were only show, because everyone knows
rotted wood is not what let us down.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
I like the idea for the syllabal count, but I'm not quite sure it has the desired effect because I could only really appreciate it after I read the note you added. I don't know that one syllabal it obvious enough to pick up on (or maybe it's just me; it's entirely possible I've missed something); I would suggest exaggerating the number of syllabals per line so that when the reader gets to the last line, it's as if there's much more. You compared the ending to almost falling off a cliff; I think that the more exaggerated it is, the higher the cliff will be, and the more impact it will have. Overall, *claps for poem* I like reading what you write.
-Amelia
no criticism until the final stanza- 'because everyone knows' seems out of place, disrupts the flow...for some reason it sounds like more than 10 syllables, even though it's not...perhaps because there aren't that many three-syllable words in the poem, and because is right next to everyone, so it's like a sudden overload of syllables in a simple poem.
Syllabic Count:
10
10
11
10
10
11
10
10
11
*This pattern gives it a lullaby-like tone.
10
10
9
*This breaks the lullaby pattern and suggests shortness, cuts the reader's breath off. It's like running up to a cliff and stopping just instant before you fall.
That's the idea, anyway.
This has a nice rhythm to it the whole way through, which makes it enjoyable to read. The last stanza seemed to break the flow though - the internal rhyme that was so clean in the stanzas before it suddenly became sloppy, which drew attention to one of your less-great lines ("because everyone knows"), and the length of the lines was visibly and audibly incongruous with the rest of the poem. Other than that... I like the light atmosphere of the poem, with the contrast not overdone, and I love the first and third stanzas. The lines:
and
are my particular favorites.
The language is quite simple throughout the whole poem except for "collocated" which I thought was a little inconsistent. Apart from that it was very good, the enjambment was especially effective. A very entertaining read.
Gurby