Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
*LOCKED*
Plagiarism.
This has to be my favorite part. I love how it brings two worlds together--two fathers. However, if the jew's father is dead, how is it that he "says" the same thing, shouldn't it be past tense..."said" the same thing? And did they really make the people into buttons? I know the soap part is right, but I never heard about the buttons.
Altogether, this is very interesting. You definetly portrayed te character and the voice very well. Pretty great.
-Medusa.
This was really good, congratulations! I don't actually know the story of the Boy in Striped Pyjamas (which you convinced me to look up later) but this does it credit! The perspective is well-written, although sometimes he is a bit mature, which will obviously come from being around policemen etc. A few little things, however.
This happens quite a lot: you repeat things unnecessarily. I'm sure you're trying to add to the young-boy-perspective thing, but it actually does the opposite and points it out that you are trying to write like a young boy.
This is also a bit of repetition. The "no emotion" is excessive. "No meaning" already indicates its impersonality and the description of the sound didn't portray any emotion at all, so I had already gathered that there was no emotion to this song, which you might do better to call a melody.
For a simile, this sure is long! You might have New Year's Eve in mind, but you could shorten and simplify it by saying something like "Six soft pops, like corks being yanked out of a New Year's Eve bottle of champagne." The way you write it I am bombarded with information that creates scenery, but this is not good when you are comparing as you are going too in-depth with something that does not actually relate to the plot (unless they really are corks making those pops).
Uh.... I have no idea what you mean by "mid tempo". "Mid tempo" would actually mean "medium speed" and in this sentence together you mean "the music died mid speed", which obviously is not what you wanted to say. Tempo = pace.
Halfway indicates that there is a specific length of space, like "halfway between the river and the hill" or something. Here you need to say "half free, half trapped."
I've done my best to explain why I found these things wrong, but overall this is a good piece of writing. Great work!
The Boy with the Buttons - 1
I liket he simplistic approach it's nice in contrast to your usual wordy approach. The said approach is good too though
I agree with the previous critiquers, you don't need to repeat soap and buttons.
It's set in the second world war, right? Did they eat from cans then?
*
Shouldn't it be stands, the tense changed
I like the use of the words
they're effective in this context.
[s]passed[/s] passes [s]pierced[/s] pierces. I love that line
In this period would they drink chhmpagne at new year? Also, is yanked the right word here? I think it's perhaps a bit too modern.
Ok, if I'm wrong then I must have gone completely loopy
Oh no! Ignore everything I've said. I just remembered that this is him talking about when he woke one night
How does this boy, if he's meant to be young, living in .... I'm unsure where
*
Lovely imagery. Perfect, your perception of how a young boy thinks is great Sarah
*
shouldn't it be wore? shone not shined
This piece was very good, Sarah. Your perceptions of a young boy are great. Please excuse my idiotic misjudgement at the start of your tenses
Well done
-Kirsten xxx
Thankyou so much for reading, KJ! I really appreciate it.
x
Only thing I really spotted that was worth pointing out was this small blurb:
Should be shone, not shined.
I know. Pathetic, right? Truthfully, I loved this. Especially the end, when she was talking to that boy. Oh, but I did have a thought that maybe they shouldn't be saying "OK" because that's a pretty modern term, and your piece takes place a while ago.
Just one more flaw: Your sentence structure. I don't know if you did it on purpose, but it was abrupt and jerky. I think if you combine a lot of the sentences, and add more commas instead of period, it would vastly improve this.
Yeah, that's all. Sad, right? I was trying to repay you for the reviews you gave me. That went well.
Anyway, keep writing,
KJ
Thanks for the reviews, you two.
Maybe I should have explained better. I've changed it above now. We weren't meant to write a piece 'inspired' by the book, more like mirroring it, etc. XD
x
This story was very interesting indeed, but I agree with the above user. At times, a writer can be "inspired" by a movie or other story and want to write something similar. A problem arises when the plot line only differs in a jagged movement. You can change characters names and seasons all you want, but if a plot line is too similar, you're up for tons of controversy.
Now, on to a small review
I myself see no need for the repetition of quote "Pleny of soap and buttons." unquote. You've already told us that you have plenty of these things in the previous sentence, so you don't need to say it again.
All in all, good job!
Hello, god I haven't commented on this site for about a year!
This is actually pretty good, must agree it is incredibly simple, but since this is from a young boys point of view it's alright.
I wouldn't say this is "inspired" by "The Boy in The Striped Pyjamas", I would say it's basically the same story apart from the fact you've changed the season and the names. The plot is basically the same. I'm sorry if I sound harsh but I'm just incredibly touchy on that subject and recently watched the film with my college.