The Broken girl

by Alice

Published September 23, 2007

In Random

A broken heart,
in an almost fixed life.

A thousand reasons to cry,
not a single tear shed.

A giver and a lover,
for all her life.

Bound to help others,
before herself,
if she thinks of herself at all.

She sits alone,
she doesn't cry.

She sits alone,
wishing she were there.

Where there is she doesn't care,
as long as she wasn't here.

Her life is a desert,
devoid of emotion and empty.

She hides who she truly is,
letting nobody in.

Fear is her live,
she fears for others.
But never herself.

Yet of all of this,
all she sees,
is the selfish girl she's grown to be.

She says they're better off without her,
but refuses to let them go.

They could survive without her,
probably thrive.

But she would crash,
she would burn.
Although they're not the best,
they're all she's got.


This is a prose/poem, whichever it is.

Comments & reviews · 4
User avatar
M.B.Author
Review
M.B.Author wrote a review Review · Dec 12, 2007

What an interasting poem. I like this allot. Some ryming.

And I noticed if you look at this poem really hard and really read it through. You can find the message.

Good job. I agree with everyone about those errors (no point on repeating them)lol.

-- M.B.Author

User avatar
Jennafina
Review
Jennafina wrote a review Review · Sep 23, 2007

Hey Auth! First, this is a poem, not prose. Prose is like a book.

For me, the main problem with this was that I've heard it before. Not exactly the same, but I've read countless poems with a very similar theme. If you can take an old theme, and spice it up, make it your own, that's wonderful. I don't think that's what happened here, though. See what you can do to add your own, personal twist, maybe?

Another thing that I think might improve this is if you regulated your stanzas. See if you can use the same rhythm for each one. It could make it easier to read and nicer to look at.

But she would crash,
she would burn.
Although they're not the best,
they're all she's got.

I don't understand this stanza.

Sorry about the harsh critique! I think with a little editing you could have a fine poem. Don't give up, and keep writing! :D

User avatar
Knurla
Review
Knurla wrote a review Review · Sep 23, 2007

I have to disagree with Azure in one of her quotes.

She hides who she truly is,
letting nobody in.


Instead of nobody, I think no one would sound better. That's just my opinion.

I loved this poem. It was beautiful. I think I see it that way because I feel like I can relate to it, and that's something you want in a poem/prose. Great work.

User avatar
azure
Review
azure wrote a review Review · Sep 23, 2007

Hello there! I saw you say that you posted your work and so I went to have a look :D

I noticed these errors:

Where there is she doesn't care,
as long as she wasn't here.


This part got me confused, what do you mean when you say "where there is?"


She hides who she truly is,
letting nobody in.


I think that it would be more appropriate to change in to know so that it would come out as "She hides who she truly is, letting nobody know"

Fear is her live,
she fears for others.
But never herself.


live should be life

But she would crash,
she would burn.


I think that it would sound better if you will change the second line, or maybe just omit the "she would" part.

About the overall.. it was good but I don't know if it's only me but it didn't really strike me.. it kind of lacked the intense emotion that should be present in a prose like that. But it's still good! I hope that my suggestions will help!



No person can be a great leader unless he takes genuine joy in the successes of those under him.
— W. A. Nance