Hi! Sorry its taken me forever to get to this, I've had a few unexpected interruptions. But hopefully the review will be worth the wait
Specifics
1.
Alright, I'm going to pick on your first sentence here, not because it's terrible, but because it's the first and it has to be perfect. The first sentence of a book is what those sneaky book buyers take a glance at when they're browsing shelves.The wretched scent of cigar smoke clung to the blue covered padding of car seats, the heavy musk filling my nostrils and refusing to leave despite the open windows.
The trouble with this is it's repetetive and clumpy. It also doesn't give us much of a feel for the story or anything to draw us in. It's a cheap trick perhaps, but a first sentence should pack a punch and give the reader something to look forward to.
Even with that aside though, let's try to strip this down a bit, shall we? How about:
The wretched scent of cigar smoke clung to the blue, padded car seats and stayed.
Then go on to describe it more after that, but try not to repeat it in terms of smell. Maybe instead compare it to a stain?
2.
Careful with those tenses!We passed yet another news stand, the words "World Series Fixed!" and “Black Sox Scandal” across every headline.
3.
That'll make it sound a little more natural. It may seem I'm contradicting myself now, but the way people speak, we don't always use our tenses correctly in the strictest sense so write what sounds natural."I hope they string up whoever did it." Spits Eli, Mr Rothmeyer's driver, with such vehement hate that makes me wonder how big a bethe hadhe's placed.
4.
Alright so I thought this would be a good place to talk about detail. You describe him as drinking and smoking constantly, but it woud be more powerful to use a simile or metaphor. Maybe 'who drank and smoked enough to keep a chain of tobacco stores in buisness'. It's a really quick example, but the trouble with words like 'constantly' is that they're too vague and over-used. When you give us an image of the drinking and smoking - 'drank and smoked so much his mouth was never empty of bottle or cigar and sometimes contained both at once' - it's far more powerful.Eli's putrid breath was worse than the cigars and whisky combined, but then what was I expecting from a man who drank and smoked constantly and a held a demanding job that left little time for washing, if the wretch ever felt so inclined.
5.
Eli flashedsme a smile through the rear view mirror, his brown rotten teeth making it the sight of nightmares.
6.
“So, sonny,” Eli glancesd back at me again as he pullsed another cigarette from his pocket and lit it up, controlling the wheel with his knees. “what's your pop make of all this?”
7. I'm confused about the whole king and country stuff. This is set in America so the fighting for king doesn't make sense, it should be president and country, surely? Which maybe doesn't sound as cool but it would keep your poor readers from being confused
8.
Most of all I wanted the Rolls Royce parked in front of Mr. Rothmeyer's house, a car of such beauty and elegance that it was unfitting for a wretch like Eli to drive it.
9.
"We're nearly there." Eli muttersed, screwing up his eyes at a policeman as he pulled into a space by the side of road.
10.
“You know what you need to do?” He asksed, reaching into his jacket on the seat next to him. I nodded, tapping my foot nervously as Idodid.
11. Alright so you really need to decide which tense you want this in as there's a whole paragraph in present here and there's no point me pointing it out all the time. Decide! I think present might work best since you end with the guy's death, but either way, choose one and stick to it throughout.
12. How does he feel about this gun? Does his hand sweat as he approaches the target, does his heart increase its pace? Does the world suddenly become so much clearer, the sounds so loud and cutting through the air? I want to feel like this is a big event, like his first kill actually means something. Either that, or if it does feel ordinary and anticlimatic to him, it would be good to see you emphasise that.
13. Good, dramatic end. You've a nice sense of action and detail here which I'd have liked to see more of earlier in the piece.
Overall
Okay so I liked the ending of this but the beginning seemed to lack in description and I wasn't really feeling the narrator's character. I wanted to know more about his reasons for signing up, more about how he wants nice things. Maybe you could have included a better glimpse of his childhood and day to day life? It's just difficult to understand why he decides on this job when there are so many other ways to make money and I want to know if it's because he's been refused work elsewhere or if this was his first choice, something he actually rather liked the idea of doing.
I think you could do with making this piece longer because I didn't feel enough for the main character before you killed him off. I'd like to see a few more sides to him, rather than just him as the killer and I'd like to see a more complete plot. What is the aim behind this piece? To show us that even killers are human or that even good men can end up being killers? I don't really know if the narrator is meant to be a villain, an anti hero or an ordinary schmuck who's down on his luck.
Generally speaking, your writing's good and it has an easy to follow flow. The dialogue's well put together and you keep the reader's attention, but it doesn't feel complete. It feels like the ending to a novel or a section of a short story. There doesn't seem to be enough plot or characterisation to support the emotional response you're aiming for.
Let me know if you want me to expand on anything and if you make any changes, feel free to ask me to take another look,
Heather xxx
Points: 6235
Reviews: 2631
Donate