[Post Deleted]
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hayden it was great as usual!
BUT the snake needs LEGS he isn't cursed yet, so he needs legs then he can loose them latter. Okay? Sorry this is just.....bugging me....legs....LEGS!!!
Okay I am done....legs
L.E.G.S spells LEGS!!! Yay!! Okay now I am done....legs
Awesome!!!! There were things I may not have agreed with in a biblical sense, but all and all I found your story GREAT!
One question? Why did Eve carry a spear at the beginning? Just wondering...
(Still can't wait to have your books on my shelf some day!)
Keep writing,
~FW~
Moo;


Firstly, I want to say that I very much appreciated the review before I write anything else. Just know that.
Now, I must say that it stings.
After multiple people told me that my writing was flawless and imaginative, your review stung pretty well. But, I thank you for the criticism.
I definitely see what you mean about “hooks”. I'm definitely going to work on that.
I agree with what you said about Eve seeming robotic. Getting into my characters has always been the hardest part of writing for me. I always make them so flat. I can never get into the meat of the character. That’s a challenge for me.
I see what you mean about me adding romance to my piece or using unneeded description. Romance has always been my thing. I’m big on romanticism. The problem is I don’t know how to use it effectively…? I need to change that, I guess.
I definitely agree on the “info dump”. I have a problem with that, too. You’ll probably find it in most of my writing. It is often used when I describe the appearances of people. I have a really hard time expressing what the characters are like through actions.
By the way, I’m now simply dreading over the mess I made with the “fruit-eating” scene, as you pointed out...
Overall, your review was helpful. I want my story to be emotional. I want it to be powerful. You’re the first person who really ever told me it needed improving. I look forward to making it live up to your expectations
I’ll let you know when I edit the piece so you can see how I've improved it.
Thanks so much for the help!
H.
P.S. Feel free to review my story "Unbound". I really liked what you had to say!
http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/viewtopic.php?t=79413
Hey there Hayden, Moo here at your service with a review. Seeing as no one has really nitpicked this or pointed out some of the more obvious flaws, I'm going to do so now. :3 Additions will be in bold, and anything that I feel should be deleted will be
crossed out.Any other comments will be in italics.Okay. Not a great beginning. Your hook is basically non existent, followed by some robotic description of Eve's movements as she moves through the forest. If you look at this section hard enough, the narrative is composed of movements and nothing but. Eve did this, then she saw that, she walked over there... See what I mean?
As for hooks, I suggest you read a little more about them here. They don't have to be positively explosive, believe me that even the simplest hooks work just as effectively. Stand alone lines work quite well, but try to work around it and find a way of writing hooks that fits you best. Remember, statistics show that readers only read the first three paragraphs of a novel before setting the book down because it was too dull, or continuing to read and ultimately deciding to buy the book. Your hook must grab the readers attention, take their interest hostage at gunpoint and drive them on to finish reading your work.
A little bit of further reading: http://www.ehow.com/how_4556500_write-hook-fiction.html
This paragraph really disagrees with me for some reason. Maybe I'm slightly biased because I hate rhetoric and I think that writing is so much more effective using plainer diction other than 'blossomed.' Blossomed just seems way to romanticised for such an un-romantic piece. She felt curious. Sure. No need to romanticise that. But what about fear? Does she not feel scared, nervous, conscious of the being? Surely a dark, shadowy fiend would be out of place in the Garden of Eden.
'Rush' is also a soft sounding word, and I think to effectively describe the shadow you should go for something like 'jerked away from her sight.' It creates a more animal feel to the shadow, dark and quick footed, too fast for the human eye to discern clearly among the brush.
Chaotically... Not buying it. Too syllable-heavy and violent to describe a light wind. I think 'quiver' is a nice way to describe the leaves, it leads on well to the frightening appearance of Lucifer.
Again, this point is about emotion. Describe her red hot fury at the insolence of the man.
“Man, do you realize what tree you eat of?” Eve yelled. “It is the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil!”
I also noticed you used a lot of dialogue tags at the end of your speech. I won't say much about it, other than that you should read this. It highlights everything that has to be said. Look over all of your dialogue and you'll see what I mean.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/SaidBookism
Oh no, the dreaded appearance info-dump. I'm sure you probably know, but people around YWS have an intense fear of info-dumping, and for good reason. It's one of the biggest writer sins. Well all do it, don't get me wrong.
Also, seeing as you used a human as a guise for the snake (Very good by the way, I liked that
And what does attraction feel like?
You already used that simile before, try to vary your writing a bit. I'd like to finish by saying I really enjoyed the ending. Powerful.
I'm sure you've noticed I haven't gone over the scene with the fruit being eaten. It was a little sloppy and chaotic with Adam rushing in out of the blue, eating the fruit and then seemingly becomes crippled with the knowledge of evil without even dropping a line. I've already spent quite a while on the review already, so maybe you can ask someone else for help on that bit :3
Overall Impression
Overall I have to say I enjoyed the new take on the Bible story. I thought that your story itself was interesting and brought new thoughts and ideas to the table, so congrats on that. But unfortunately some of the flaws in the writing spoiled the overall effect that the piece had on me. Definately work on emotion and hooks. Otherwise the writing was pretty sound with only a few mistakes. The rest of my suggestions were merely that; ways that I think the story would become more powerful in its message and help it to resonate throughout the reader's mind. Well done on what you've got so far, but there is always room for improvement!
Please send me a PM or reply here and let me know if I helped or not. :0
Thanks for the good read, Hayden. Good luck and keep writing!
~Moo xo
Wow, this is amazing! It's so beautifully written, and great imgination and emotion. I wish I could write like that. ^_^ I was crying towards the end of it! Really great job, you have an amazing talent for writing!
~Tear
This was absolutley amazing! Just phenomenal. There is no other way to describe this! Very new ideas on this story and just amazing imagery. You are seriously talented.
Wow, I can't tell you how much that means to be. Thank you so much!
Ok, so I couldn't wait, you got me all curious. Haha. So I can't find anything wrong with this. I ABSOLUTELY LOVED THIS. I can't really say how i feel about this, except by the end of this I was crying. This was very personal to me. Very very personal. But, you should think about getting published. It is that good. Keep writing. And I know everyone says that on here. but really. keep writing. Because I would so pay money to have one of these stories. You have the potential to be a famous writer one day.
THANKS!
that was rly rly good it made me think! you are a phenomenal writer hun (: Keep writing. Review minee
Thank you Amelia!
However, I am quite curious. What parts of the story do you disagree with? I'm very interested.
Hi Hayden! Glad to see you've posted another work. Gramatically, this is pretty much impecable. I really can't fault you. Your descriptions and literary devices very brilliant and well-thought-out. The whole concept is certainly unconventional and imaginative. I'm not going to press like for I don't exactly agree with the happeings and the storyline. But, don't let me put a dampner on things! Well done!
~ Amelia
Yea, I know. Eve is the infamous tempter of Adam. I tried to show that he was still eating from her sin when he reached for the fruit that she had eaten from. Because she took the fruit, Adam found it.
I just honestly feel so many Christian men (besides me) blame women, especially Eve, for letting them fall into sin. But I feel that Eve is more than just the tempter of Adam. She hurt, she cried, she regretted. I believe this tore her to pieces when she was forever separated from her beloved Father God. There's more to her story than being the temptress of man.
Ummm... WOW! That was amazing! The only thing I can say is that Eve tempted Adam to eat the fruit, but still, that was intense! Great job!
Just to clear up some confusion, I don't think you should have ended any differently. It's just... It's kind of sad it had to end the way it did. This story makes you wish it doesn't have to be that way, that Eve would realize what the serpent was just a little sooner. I think you would have offended some people if you had changed the ending, and it would have taken away from story as a whole. Anyway, that's what I meant.
Wow! Thank you so much for the review
I never thought my writing could be so moving. Thanks! 

I have to agree with most of your points.
**The ancient garden: Though I believe in a literal Bible, I also believe “six days” to God was billions of years. It just comes from my beliefs that it would be ancient to them.
Also, to me, it is an ancient garden. Historically, this probably took place eons ago.
**Eve’s appearance. One thing to know, the forbidden fruit did not bring one simply knowledge. Adam and Eve had knowledge before the fruit. The fruit strictly brought knowledge of Good and Evil. Before hand, Eve and Adam did not know what was good and what was evil. Hygiene is not good or evil. Good hygiene is natural. When she starts pulling the twigs out of her hair, that’s what I’m imagining. She’s cleaning herself. She’s keeping good hygiene.
However, I see where you might have thought this. When they eat of the fruit, they realize they are naked. Nudity is seen as shameful and evil and when they eat the fruit, they see it as such. They were not meant to understand the difference of good and evil, but when they ate the fruit, their eyes were opened.
** “Fled” I like it there. It almost feels to me that she is “fleeing” from what she once knew and was familiar with (innocence).
**The serpent as a man. Yes! This is new. I made Lucifer into a man, but I tried to make him very much alike a snake; the movement of his body, the feel of his eyes, and his dreadful voice. I wanted to be traditional too, so I made him turn into a serpent during the climax.
**I agree with this. I will change it.
I can see how you would want it end differently. I did too, but I felt it was appropriate. This is the fall of man. There is no hope and it couldn’t have ended differently for me. That is another story.
I will definitely let you know if I need your help on anything. Let me know if you need me to review something.
Thanks again!
~H. C. S.
I really want to cry inside. This was terrific. This will be the second peice of yours I have read, and I bow down to you. The feeling here is wonderful, but I am going to put in my two cents of the negative because I'm just like that with reviewing. Believe me, there's not much.
I wanted the story to end different. I really did.
You introduced many different ideas that I had never thought about. I'm really just blown away. If you ever, ever need a review for anything prose, ask me, and I'll do my best to help you improve some beautiful skills.
On a different note, I read your rebuttals to my suggestions on "Good Abel" and want to thank you for telling me what you think. Sometimes I wonder if anyone is actually reading my reviews. Just to let you know, everything but the grammar is a matter of opinion, and you can disregard whatever you want to. If I have really long reviews with lots of opinions, I'll normally say that a few times, but I haven't needed to give you a long review yet.
Please, keep writing,
Megsug
Wow! That's frickin' amazin'
I couldn't see any flaws at all :')
LOVE IT!! <3
Carry on writing (:
I have to agree. Your writing is always fantastic, Hayden. Can't wait to grab one of your stories off a bookstore shelf in the near future
All I have to say is, "beautifully written".