z

Young Writers Society



this christmas

by Firestarter



Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.







Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
37 Reviews


Points: 890
Reviews: 37

Donate
Sat Dec 03, 2005 2:47 pm
Amice says...



Oh, well excuse me, Firestarter :)
I'm from Ohio, so I'm sorry for my Ohio-an critique
:P

-Amice-




User avatar
1259 Reviews


Points: 18178
Reviews: 1259

Donate
Sat Dec 03, 2005 11:28 am
Firestarter says...



Fireworks... makes me think of July 4th, not "December eve".


Well, I'm from England, we have fireworks on November 5th, and then a while after, some around Christmas, and then at New Year. So it's almost a "firework season", so to say.




User avatar
37 Reviews


Points: 890
Reviews: 37

Donate
Sat Dec 03, 2005 2:00 am
Amice wrote a review...



Great poem! Just a couple notes...

In the first stanza, you went from present tense to past tense, and in the second stanza, back to present. :?:

"metacarpals"? :? I think that drops the romantic theme of the rest of the poem.

With death so eerily close I shut my senses

Is this poem about death, or what? If you mean death of something in particular, then say so.

Fireworks... makes me think of July 4th, not "December eve".
But the next line does well to point out the loneliness felt as an indirect result of others' affections.

Overall, I enjoyed reading this poem. The rhythm was pretty smooth and the rhyming (such as it was) wasn't forced.
Good job Firestarter :thumb:

-Amice-




User avatar
665 Reviews


Points: 6165
Reviews: 665

Donate
Fri Dec 02, 2005 3:22 pm
Chevy wrote a review...



Wow...how romantic. It had a really nice flow and gave you a real appreciation for the Winter Season. I enjoyed the first stanza the most.

Chevy's Critiquing Scale
far left colon - not so great
far right colon - excellent

Title ..... | - - - : -|
Flow ..... | - - - - :|
Creativity ..... | - - : - -|
Imagery ..... | - - - : -|
Language ..... | - - - : -|
Consistency ..... | - - - - :|
Length ..... | - - : - -|
Ending ..... | - - : - -|
Overall ..... | - - - : -|




User avatar
266 Reviews


Points: 1726
Reviews: 266

Donate
Fri Dec 02, 2005 2:28 am
backgroundbob says...



Weird.... I'd have to say that it was all pretty darn good (and the beginning was *excellent*) except that the last two lines sounded way cliche to me...

Eh, no accounting for taste.




User avatar
493 Reviews


Points: 1040
Reviews: 493

Donate
Fri Dec 02, 2005 2:26 am
Misty says...



the last two lines were completely sweet. The rest was so-so...




User avatar
122 Reviews


Points: 1115
Reviews: 122

Donate
Fri Dec 02, 2005 2:18 am
Brian wrote a review...



"perhaps a million strangers, all living and breathing. I can't tell them "
Take out perhaps. It sounds wishy washy, and it doesn't fit in with the tone.

"With death so eerily close I shut my senses. "
This line seemed unnecessary. It's restated what you already pretty much said, and it makes it less profound by being so direct.

"In the last few seconds before a winter sunset dies
there is warmth inside and coldness out; my "
Awesome part number one.

"I can't tell them
I am little more than a ghost, because they are little more than a blur. "
Awesome part number two.

Great poem. You got a lot in here that is really good (such as the two sections I pointed out), and it reads really well. Thought it was great.





You cannot have an opponent if you keep saying yes.
— Richard Siken