Hi Alchemist!
My apologies for taking such a long time to get back to this novel! I will be spending as much time as possible today trying to catch up with all the chapters you already have, and especially as you seem to have some free time for YWS coming up as well Maybe you will be doing some editing.
I liked this chapter. What I especially liked was the flashback and the backstory you supplied here. I felt like we hadn't received much of that with the majority of the characters until which made it seem like this novel was lacking depth and a complete understanding of their situation. But with this backstory we now know Hashi a lot more and also can understand his motives. I really wish you would do this with the other characters as well so we could get to know them properly as well! That aside I also thought the action in this was done very well too. You seem to have a good grasp on writing action scenes without it becoming too much of a he-died-there and he-died-here experience where it becomes listy. With you the words seem to flow and I never get bored even amongst all of the fighting. Which isn't too easy when it is me reading
I felt like you touched base on the reason why they had to leave The State but you didn't give me enough. You brushed over it and it left me wanting to know why in more detail. So yes, The State was a place where they had no disease and anyone who showed signs of having a disease were kicked out instead of treated - I understand that much. But you said The State claimed disease when they said they didn't. Did they have tests or something afterwards to insure that they didn't, or are they simply hoping that they don't. Because if it is hope than we can't blame The State as I feel you want us to. And in that case we also don't know whether our main characters are completely healthy. But then again, if The State did lie and they are perfectly healthy, then why did they lie? What was it about those people that they wanted to fake something and kick them out for? Were they a threat to them or the public? I wanted to know a bit more here...
I think that although you write the fight scenes well, I still want something a bit more. You can be killing people on a physical level, but what about an emotional one as well? Yes, Hashi doesn't feel sorry for these people he is murdering in the slightest, but make sure you show this to us. Tell us how he is chopping up people left and center and enjoying it, a smirk on his face and his mind wondering who is next. Show us that the rage is taking over his mind so he is screaming as he is chopping limbs, not caring if the blood splatters on his clothes. Tell us he can't even see the victims faces anymore, that they are simply red from his anger and blocked out by the black of hate that has been growing in him for so long and is finally bubbling over. I want you to show us that there is more than just a physical level to fighting. No, Hashi doesn't need to feel sympathy in the slightest, but he must be feeling something. So indulge and described that to us as well!
There was a section with a soldier where he sees his dead friend and then gets his hand cut off. I think that section is appropriate to see the other side of the battle as well, but I am sure you could make it have a bit more impact on us. Again, I am going to go on about the emotion because I think it is what your chapter needs most of all. I want to see the soldiers horror at seeing his mutilated friend as he inspects the damage. Mention that he could've never thought that someone could do that to a human, that he must be dealing with a monster. This soldier isn't dumb as well. Mention how he know death is coming for him. What will he be thinking about as his impending death comes? His mother, his family, his house that he will never return to? That aside, I thought it was strange that he died from his hand being cut off. I might not be an expert in violence but doesn't he need something a bit more fatal to happen? Otherwise he would slowly bleed to death through blood loss, but that might take a bit longer than the mentioned time in the chapter.
In the flashback I also found it odd that Hashi and his master knew it was State soldiers before they even opened the door and looked out! Unless they knew that they soldiers were coming (in which case, I am sure they would've fled) or knew that they might be attacked by them for certain reasons, then they shouldn't know who it is until they open the door. I would advise having them open a door first or at least mention if there is a window around that they use to identify the soldiers.
Another thing about the flashback is that it seems rather random for State soldiers to attack the master and his apprentice. Why would they do that for no reason? Were they doing anything against the rules, seen as a public threat or something else dangerous to the State? I was sincerely confused as to why this random attack happened and you need to remember that you have to give a reason. Especially for us readers who are confused and curious at this point!
Nitpick time! I only pulled out two because it seems like Zontafer got the majority of them already.
“Great Fort Mountain is before us”,
I think the comma needs to go on the inside of the speech marks instead of the outside. I have noticed this in a few other chapters.
He longed for the moment he’s going to work alone.
One thing for you to remember is that with that abbreviation it really stands for he is when you write 'he's'. And I think you can gather that this is in present tense when it could be in past to match the rest of your novel. So, if you are finding the shortened words hard to keep track of in definition, you could also avoid using them or do a little bit more research on when to use which.
That's all I have to say for this chapter! I will go ahead and try to finish reading this novel later on!
Deanie x
Points: 67548
Reviews: 1634
Donate