Hey, Purple! Heads up, this review's going to be a little jumbled, in terms of praise and nitpicks.
I disagree with GreenTulip. Varied sentence structure, subtle humor--not even major factors in securing my attention. Amazing. And this is only the first chapter.
The exposition's developing beautifully. You've taken the direct approach, discussing the narrator's life, explaining her flaws, but the humor threaded through glued my eyes to the screen. You also recognized when to slow down the pace, when to speed it up: isolating fragments, accentuating details, fusing action with dialogue. Now I have to actually hunt for a mistake, peel apart the layers!
You've got a solid handle on grammar. Just the occasional mistake, all of which I'll brush below. Honestly, I think they're my only nitpicks.
March 18, 2014 was the day I died.
This isn't the first time I've seen a beginning like this. Maybe "I didn't expect to die so [insert adjective]." Just be creative, which I know you're capable of .
It was rainy, heaviness in the air, and generally ugly looking.
These three expressions don't fuse. They need some kind of transition. Unless..."It was rainy, humid, and generally ugly-looking." (Ugly looking should be hyphenated.) Just check that everything's consistent: adjectives with adjectives, verbs with verbs.
This year had been one of the toughest winters I had yet experienced.
A year consists of four seasons, and yet you're suggesting that it only consists of one: winter. Easy fix. Just exchange the word "year" for "winters" and cut out the "winters" after "toughest."
...didn’t blackout or anything...
"Blackout" is a noun, but "black out" is a predicate.
He was looking at me for a while, but eventually left the bar.
No comma necessary, as this doesn't qualify as a compound sentence.
“Oh come on” an intern, Maggie, said, “Don’t be a party pooper.”
Alright, quick lesson on dialogue: When a period concludes it, but the period's followed by a speaker's tag, then the period should be replaced with a comma. There needs to be punctuation. But the speaker's tag is only concluded with a comma if the dialogue after is a continuation of the previous dialogue. If it was too confusing, this might help: http://litreactor.com/columns/talk-it-out-how-to-punctuate-dialogue-in-your-prose
“No. No. I’m fine” I walked out.
"I walked out" doesn't qualify as a speaker's tag, so a period should be inserted inside the quotation mark.
...met the humid, night air.
No comma necessary, since the adjective directly relates to the one following it.
My hands stung my face which felt exposed and moist.
This came off sounding a bit awkward. A comma between "face" and "which" could clear things up.
I pushed the door open and met the humid, night air. I held my hand out to the curb, waiting for a cab. Not even at the edge of the sidewalk...
Alright, backtracking. This paragraph has a lot of action crammed into it. And it's difficult to process, it all clinging to the same frame. Breaking down the paragraph could also help increase the pace, create some tension.
Same case with the next paragraph. But I think you gave us the perfect sample of his pain. Some writers just go crazy with trying to describe pain; you handled the situation perfectly. Touched upon it and moved on. I realized it reflected the fact that the narrator had no time to reflect; she had to get up and move. Assuming she's a she? Sorry, I'm terrible at guessing genders.
Overall, fabulous. I can tell from your prose that you're a poet. Just like Edgar Allan Poe. Everything flows so naturally, so smoothly, and the pace--my goodness, can I steal it? It's so well-measured. You don't even have to try hard; you just spout stunning descriptions. I think the word I'm looking for is...wordsmith.
I didn't intend this to be brief, but the high-quality writing ensured it. It'd be a crime to criticize. Keep it up! Looking forward to more, as always!
Points: 31200
Reviews: 308
Donate