Land of Sky, Land of Rain (Chapter One)

34 posts1, 2, 3
User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 26
I shall post edits first, then good parts.

You know, I bet the average teacher could spot us right off. Most students probably can too for that matter. We all know the type. The kid you sat next to on the bus who did nothing but stare out the window, while you wondered how the heck she could do that without getting a neck cramp. (And what on earth was there to look at on a road in suburban Arizona? And could this possibly get any more awkward?) The kid who you can just tell will be more familiar with the cast of some fantasy novel than with their homeroom class? Yup. That’d be us. Us weird, quiet, lame loner kids. My teachers and parents have been trying to rationalize my behavior pretty much since I was born. “Oh, Emma’s only having trouble making friends because she’s new!” “She’s just a little shy, Mrs. Harbor, that’s all...” “Don’t worry; she’ll grow out of all this eventually” “Erm... I’m sure this is all just a phase she’s going through....” “... A very long phase” Blah blah blah. They never seem to have much hope or conviction about this all. And who would? This is me we’re talking about. Emma Bering, age 14, certified nerd, straight-B student, friendless, unpopular, annoying. Now tell me, what kind of person would have much hope or conviction about some one like that? Anyone…? Exactly. The only people who think that there’s somehow still a chance for me are those who’ve just met me, but they all learn eventually.

Vernon is right. This needs to be broken up. And since I don't have a better way, I will simply repost his--with my edits:

Vernon wrote:You know, I bet the average teacher could spot us right off. Most students probably can too, for that matter. We all know the type: The kid you sat next to on the bus who did nothing but stare out the window, while you wondered how the heck she could do that without getting a neck cramp. (And what on earth was there to look at on a road in suburban Arizona? And could this possibly get any more awkward?)

The kid who you can just tell will be more familiar with the cast of some fantasy novel than with their homeroom class?

Yup.

That’d be us.

Us weird, quiet, lame loner kids.

My teachers and parents have been trying to rationalize my behavior pretty much since I was born:

“Oh, Emma’s only having trouble making friends because she’s new!”

“She’s just a little shy, Mrs. Harbor, that’s all...”

“Don’t worry; she’ll grow out of all this eventually”

“Erm... I’m sure this is all just a phase she’s going through....”

“... A very long phase.” Blah blah blah.

They never seem to have much hope or conviction about this all. And who would? This is me we’re talking about. Emma Bering, age 14, certified nerd, straight-B student, friendless, unpopular, annoying.

Now tell me, what kind of person would have much hope or conviction about someone like that? Anyone…? Exactly. The only people who think that there’s somehow still a chance for me are those who’ve just met me, but they all learn eventually.

Yeah. All I got is grammar and spelling in this section, except the bolded line. I would suggest cutting it down to: (What on earth was there to look at on a road in suburban Arizona?) I suspect the "and" and the second part aren't really necessary.




I might as well get it over with while I still have my senses.

I'm not sure, but a different phrase might work better here. However, as I've none to offer, it is totally your call.




Before first period begins, we have almost an hour with nothing to do until classes start, owing to the stupidity of our bus schedule.

Pick one of these, since they mean the same thing. My preference is given to "before first period begins," but you pick.




The Boulder Ridge School Library is a huge and tiny building at the same time. I know that doesn’t make sense; bear with me. It doubles as our sub-division's public library so it's huge





It really seems much smaller than average though, since everyone directs their attention towards five shelves and the computers. That’s because 75% of the books there are nonfiction, and almost all of the rest were written for small children by authors with a certain disdain for their wide-eyed, drippy-nosed audience

Use "since" instead of "because", because you use "because" in the next sentence. **blinks** Wow, that sounded weird. I hope you get what I meant.




“Your card is bent.





I take a deep breath, reaching into my very final reserves of patience.

“Listen. This is the very same student ID I’ve been giving you since I started middle school.

I would cuts the very's. It sounds better without them.




“Coolness,she says in a bored voice





We all start running--jogging, actually, trying to keep from tiring out before the end of our first lap. Not that that will help much. I can already feel my breath coming short, much sooner than usual.

The double dash is an em dash--a long dash. I guess it's just my preference; it seems to flow a bit better. Also, you should break the second sentence into two with a period.




One lap finished. “Four minutes,” the PE coach tells me.





I keep tripping. Probably I’m stepping on some rough patch of uprooted grass or something, but when I look back, I can’t see anything.

Split the sentence.




I’m vaguely aware of falling; I must have tripped again.





I do not have a fever.

Serious nitpick. I would say "don't," because you use contractions everywhere else in the paragraph.




I know that it’s Elizibeth’s cell phone because it’s on the corner of her desk





I realize then that she’s been working on the discussion questions for the past forty minutes

Nitpick again. "Then I realize" might flow a bit better.




There has to be a logical explanation, I’m sure there is.

Explanation of what? Of Mendel? Or of what's happening to Emma? Make it clear.




You’ve been reading too many weird fantasy books lately, I tell myself firmly.





I would not admit this under torture, but I love taking notes off of PowerPoint Presentations. It requires no effort or creativity or brainpower of your own, yet you always know you have the answers right. All you need to do is remember them. I turn to a blank page in my Social Studies notebook and scribble down the title at the top of the page while the rest of the class complains.

Try "I wouldn't admit this to anyone, even under torture, but...".




“C-c-c-c-c-c." She sounds like a disk skipping.





“C-c-c-c,” suddenly, my Mom’s voice is interrupted, or, is it interrupting?

Should be:
"C-c-c-c." Suddenly my mom's voice is interrupted, or is it interrupting?





“That won’t be necessary,” Mom says.

After this you need to have something about the end of the conversation. Maybe something like:
"That won't be necessary," Mom says.

"Alright," I sigh, and hang up.

I turn to leave.

Or something like that.





Now the parts I found very good (only some of them--otherwise I'd have to type up the whole chapter):
I’m sure there are people who have it much worse, people who would think I’m just being a whiney loser who doesn’t know anything about life.

Yes, I know, smart kids aren’t supposed to hate school, right? We get good grades, what are we supposed to complain about? We should love school. Sorry to disappoint you all, but if that’s a requirement, then I don’t qualify as a “smart kid”.

owing to the stupidity of our bus schedule

almost all of the rest were written for small children by authors with a certain disdain for their wide-eyed, drippy-nosed audience and firmly believe that they are only allowed to write monosyllabically about empty little stories that probably have a hand in creating the average American kid’s hatred of reading.

This little oasis is the refuge of a good 200 kids seeking, quiet, air conditioning, and boredom relief.

The “library security guard” (must… resist… rolling… eyes) is technically a member of the faculty, and all.

While this fascinating conversation proceeds, a small but very irritated line of people has formed behind us, trying to push past me and walk in.

I can take this as an omen of just how much the rest of the day is going to suck, but nooo, I decide to remain optimistic, heaven knows why.

She should start her own business: “Kathleen’s Character Reviews: Have Every Flaw I Think You Have Ridiculously Blown out of Proportion for Only 75 Cents!”

Whose stupid idea was it to throw 50+ eighth graders into the Arizona midmorning and have them run for an entire class period?

Apparently, all these facts combine to make me “healthy” despite having passed out five minutes ago. She sends me to Science.

But it’s a little difficult to be grateful when you’ve been listening to something that sounds like that first victim in a horror movie for forty-three minutes.

It’s “girl” handwriting, neat and happy and evenly spaced. Every girl at Boulder Ridge School writes like that except me. My writing is tight and scribbly and illegible.

Teachers here are very strict about the great anti-cell phone rule.

Doubtless tomorrow she will panic at the sight of her test study guide and beg me for answers as though we’ve always been best friends and she’s never been rude to me.

I’m smart enough to figure out that my mom wishes I was some happy preppy cheerleader and not this weird silent loner with no friends and no life.




So, overall, this looks like a long review, but almost all of it's grammar and spelling. (I'm OCD about those, so expect it whenever I review.) There are very few things I would change about this chapter. Congrats!!!!!
My username is a relic and in no way accurate.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 32
GOSH!!! hun, make it WAY shorter!!! even i, who read a 289 pg book in one day was scared of reading tht!!!! cut it up!!! Otherwise, gj!! :lol: :smt064
Why did you hit me?" he groaned groggily, blinking like an owl.

"Why are you in my bed!?" I countered, wriggling in embarrassment.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1090
Reviews 241
this is really good! can't wait to read the rest!
“We’re still here,” he says, his voice cold, his hands shaking. “We know how to be invisible, how to play dead. But at the end of the day, we are still here.” ~Dax

Teacher: "What do we do with adjectives in Spanish?"
S: "We eat them!"




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 790
Reviews 2
Constructive Criticism, well I can't find much to say.
I wonder how you're going to connect to the bent ID, the ringing phone (that only Emma appears to have heard) and the fainting at P.E. to the bloody ceiling and over all plot.
I haven't read Ch. 2 of any further, so these isn't much more I can critic. Overall, hope you'll be able to tie that all up.
Your voice is good, it fits Emma's personality well, not formal, but the way you would expect a teenager to sound, a bit sarcastic.
Maybe try putting a bit more to lead up to this, about Emma's life at home.
Anyway, good job, I enjoyed it.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1068
Reviews 582
This was a good beginning. Really, I enjoyed it. Despite the fact that many of the scenes didn't really seem to have a clear point to them, your MC's wry sense of humor kept it entertaining.

But, personally, I try not to break up my stories so much. Example: ***. It just makes the story feel jerky, for lack of a better word. Try to tie some of those short sections together.

If you need an example or want to see a technique in how to do this, I suggest checking out Stephenie Meyer's Twilight. Her MC is constantly doing bathroom stuff, homework, sleeping, etc., and Meyer always ties these activities in nicely with whatever her MC is going to do next.

And the ending was neat. Despite what a critiquer said about it coming out of nowehere, I politely disagree. After all, Emma passed out in gym, was feeling sick, and then she got a morbid phone call from her mother. For me, that's warning enough.

One last thing, about how her supposed best friend and her boyfriend were making fun of her for passing out in gym? I found that unrealistic. If someone in my school passed out, I would be concerned and sympathetic. I think that's how it is for most kids, or the ones who even care. If they don't, I don't think they'd bother saying anything.

All in all, great chapter. Moving on.

KJ




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3
Reviews 198
Damn, this is really good! Had me hooked all the way to the end. Finally, someone is making a story out of us loners! I feel so honored now. Apart from a few grammatical errors, it sounds really professional. For a second I forgot I was just reading an online story. I like how creepy it is. Kathleen is a bitch, no offense. The main character sounds like a real person, too. Like someone I can relate to. I'm very loner-ish as well. I can't wait to read chapter 2. Great job!




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1150
Reviews 5
The first chapter sucks, basically. the reason is the reader doesn't know to expect some thing weird whe she turns around. all the preveious "weird" things fall into a catgory "weird but normal"
If you want a vision of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face - forever.
George Orwell




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1150
Reviews 5
Actually, I like everything else of it that I've read (chapters 1-7).

It's just that you need some sing that something changed, like emma noticing that she doesn't hear a sound from the rest of the class, a dread-inspiring, unnatural silence, before she turns around. The blackout, the security gaurd, and her mothers voice dont prepare you to realize that the rest of the class might be dead. it is a shock without context.

The rest of it is good.
If you want a vision of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face - forever.
George Orwell




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 3
This was an amazing first chapter.
As I was reading, I could clearly see everything you were saying.
The sarcasm, and realness of the piece is evident.
:D
Great job!
Make note- there is no such thing as originality, but I can create my own cool
:D




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 168
Hey!!! I decided that if I am going to check out your writing, I might as well start from the beginning.

General stuff: Tellling vs. Showing! More showing please! Also, try not to tell us too much of how she's feeling, let her actions speak for herself.

Your characters (namely Emma) are kick-ass. I think Kathleen needs to be a little more subtly mean, especially if she's emma's "friend"/ I think you need to explore that relationship more.

My in-depth crit is attached to this.

coolness :-)
Attachments
Part I of Land of Sky, Land of Rain.doc
(44.5 KiB) Downloaded 45 times




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5008
Reviews 95
hello, zankoku_na_tenshi...

wow..another fantasy fiction writer..

when i read the first chapter, what caught my attention is the LONG list of succeeding chapters. God, how long are you planning to write?..is the story unfinished yet?

but still, i admire and salute those young people who try to break into the mature world through writing. i'm new here at yws, and i'm enjoying reading fiction.

Land of Sky, Land of Rain...nice title.may i ask where'd you get the idea?..

god bless.
You've got the key to my heart..but have you forgotten about a duplicate?
Sorry. I've already given it to someone else.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 28
That was wonderful. I wonder what's going to happen next. Luckily there is that looooooong list of chapters waiting to be read.
Formerly known as Vivacious.

Full of Cliches:a challenge to see who can write a piece with the most cliches.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 940
Reviews 5
wow thats really good i liked the use of 1st person in it
ATreeah was here




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4362
Reviews 263
zankoku_na_tenshi wrote:~~~
(edit: just patching some things up before I post chapter 2. I can't believe I showed some of this stuff to the general public. *hangs head in shame*)

Don't be ashamed of this! This definitely has quite a bit of potential. I know you wrote this sometime in 2006, but I saw chapter 26 I think in the latest forums so I wanted to read the first chapter. It's good and I think it has a lot of potential, I think everyone here can agree with that. The only thing I'm fuzzy on here is what the conflict is. Remember that the conflict is the main part of the story. Clearly there are a lot of probelms going on with Emma, but what's the big conflict? I'm fuzzy on that, but I'm sure you'll establish the conflict in your other chapters.

Keep writing ^^ You're pretty good it at ;)
You cannot dream yourself into a character; you must hammer and forge yourself into one.

The writer, when he is also an artist, is someone who admits what others don't dare reveal.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 2
Awesome! I really love this! I didn't find any errors in the Grammar but I'm not good at that anyway. Everything seems perfect about your characters and such, :)

Keep writing this... (Oh, I see you already have, LOL) I'll be sure to read the other chapters!

-Monday
Love of mine, someday you will die. But I'll be close behind, to follow you into the dark.
- Death Cab For Cutie



Oh, I'm sorry. My friends are in the popcorn and I have to save them.
— Tori Hansen, Power Rangers Ninja Storm