Lady No Soul (1)

21 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Non-binary
Points 1979
Reviews 1176
ONE


I press my nose against the shop window. Behind the mist my breath makes on the glass, the colours of the dress blur together; pink and white silk and lace trimmings smearing like the paints in a watercolour.

‘Chrissy!’ Mama’s hand lands on my shoulder, pulling me away from the floating dream of the dress trapped behind the glass and back to reality. ‘Chrissy, don’t do that, it’s so unhygienic. Really, child, do I always have to remind you?’

‘But Mama, look, it’s so pretty.’ I touch the tips of my fingers to the white mist left on the glass. ‘Isn’t it the prettiest dress you’ve ever seen?’

‘No,’ Mama says, as I’d known she would.

I sigh.

‘The lace trim is very fetching, though,’ she says, and I look up at her in surprise. She pats my shoulder. ‘Maybe we’ll ask Papa about getting a new dress for your birthday.’

‘Really?’ It’s my birthday in a few weeks. I’ll be fourteen, and I’ve been longing for a proper dress, not the little-girl plaids and patched cottons I’ve been wearing since I was twelve. The dress in the window shines like water, almost changing colour when the weak December sunlight touches it, the only really bright thing under the grey sky.

Maybe, if we have enough money, Papa will say I can have a silk dress. Maybe. Maybe.

I’m almost glad when Mama taps my shoulder again. Mama never dreams of silk dresses and knowing that, I can look at the dress in the window and bid it farewell with dignity.

We’re meeting Gabriel at some gallery or other and Mama doesn’t want to keep him waiting, so we hurry on down Oxford Street. It’s busy, full of people shopping for Christmas, and I feel very small in the crowd. I’m bumped back and forth by elbows and umbrellas and brown paper-wrapped parcels, but Mama sails forward like a proud ship, calm and poised in her neat blue coat and bonnet. The wind is very cold in my nose and there’s a dry sharpness in the air that I hope means snow.

‘Come along Chrissy,’ Mama says. She holds out her hand as though she expects me to hold it when we cross the road. I pretend not to see it, but she’s insistent. ‘Chrissy, come on! Don’t dawdle, child.’

I bite my tongue and reluctantly take her gloved hand in mine. We cross the road and as soon as I’m on the pavement, I wriggle my fingers free and plunge them back into my muff.

‘Chrissy,’ Mama says reprovingly.

‘What?’

‘Chrissy.’

‘Sorry Mama. What, Mama?’’

‘Don’t scowl so. It’s not becoming.’

‘Yes, Mama.’

She sighs, and I struggle to form something like a smile. I glance up at her, but she’s looking ahead, scanning the crowd. I gnaw on my tongue and stare at the ground, but this means I’m looking at my shoes, and the faded spot on the right toe makes me think of the dress in the window, and I feel a hot rush of anger. I don’t know why I’m angry, or who I’m angry at, so I glare at Mama’s coat and think how unfair it is that she can have a nice coat and black gloves (they’re patched gloves) and I don’t have one really nice dress even though I’m practically fourteen, which is old enough to get married (no one would want to marry you, and anyway, you know thinking about that scares you) and it’s just not fair!

Now I feel like crying.

‘Look, there’s Gabriel,’ Mama says.

We’ve arrived at the gallery without my noticing, and Gabriel is outside, waiting by the steps. He comes to meet us, and at the sight of him I feel a little better.

‘Hello mother,’ he says, kissing Mama on the cheek. Then he turns me and grins. ‘Hello Chrissy.’

I grin back at him. He puts his hands on my shoulders and looks down into my face. He smiles, and for a moment, I am the whole of Gabriel’s world.

‘Well, Gabriel, are we going to stand out here in this wind forever?’ Mama asks. She’s laughing, teasing, but Gabriel turns away from me and I feel a flare of jealousy. Gabriel takes her hand and offers his other arm to me, smiling, and I feel ashamed, so I smile back and tuck my hand under his elbow and we go into the gallery together.

Gabriel’s in his element here, standing in front of one painting for over five minutes, just staring and gazing at it, drinking in the colours and the lines and the symmetry.

‘Isn’t it beautiful?’ he says, wonderingly. ‘Isn’t it beautiful, Chrissy?’

Mama’s on the other side of the room, looking at an oil painting of dogs lying before a fireplace. I step closer to Gabriel. ‘Yes, very,’ I say, and it is. It’s a portrait of a girl, a young woman; she’s standing by an open window, one hand on the sill and the other holding a rose against her cheek as though smelling it isn’t enough but she must touch it to fully experience its beauty. The glow of the sunset lights on the bowl of cherries on the table and in her half-open eyes, and creates shiny diamonds in the glass window-panes.

‘See how there’s so many shadows,’ Gabriel says. ‘Shadows and light. If you look—can you see, Chrissy?—if you look at the light, you can tell where there must be a shadow. You’ve got to have both for the picture to be real.’

‘I love the light in her eyes,’ I say. ‘And the fruit. Doesn’t the fruit look real?’

‘Yes, it does.’ Gabriel smiles. ‘It’s because of the light.’

‘Oh?’ I ask innocently. ‘Is light important, then?’

Gabriel laughs. ‘I’d like to draw you again sometime soon. You don’t mind sitting for me, do you?’

‘Oh no!’ I assure him. ‘I love it.’

‘What do you love, Chrissy?’ Mama joins us. She looks hard at the portrait and frowns. ‘Does that girl have red hair?’

‘Oh no,’ Gabriel says easily, and it occurs to me that it might not matter to Gabriel even if the girl in the portrait had hair red as a fox-tail.

‘It looks distinctly auburn,’ Mama says. ‘Red is such an unholy colour. Unchaste.’

‘Mother, it’s brown.’ Gabriel steers her onto the next painting, slyly winking at me, and I feel a warm glow inside at our shared jest. I pat Mama’s arm as we stand at the next painting.

She looks down at me, a little surprised. ‘What was that for?’

‘Nothing.’ I smile at her and she smiles back all the same.

‘Now here,’ Gabriel explains eagerly, ‘the blending is the important thing, do you see? With pastels you really have to blend and blend and blend. You see, Chrissy, there’s no harsh lines anywhere—it all fades together and there’s almost no distinction between the colours, but the artist has the skill not to blend so much that the colours fade away altogether. They still keep their vibrancy.’

I like this painting too. It’s a picture of a baby boy with yellow curls all around his rosy face. He’s sitting in a doorway, one hand extended upwards like a plump pink star, the other steadying himself against the stone step. His bare toes peep from the hem of his blue skirts like little pink fish, and I wish I could reach out and touch them. A strange longing swells inside me, spreading like a smile; a longing to join the little boy in the picture and take his outstretched hand and feel his tiny fingers wrap around mine and never let go.

‘It must take a lot of skill to colour like that,’ Mama remarks.

‘Well, all art takes skill,’ Gabriel says a little pompously, ‘but once you get the knack of them, pastels aren’t that hard.’

‘I think they’re pretty,’ I say. ‘I like the way it all fades together. It looks like a rainbow.’

‘Maybe I’ll try you in pastels, then,’ Gabriel says, then explains to Mama, ‘I want to try Chrissy’s portrait again. She sat so well for me last time.’

‘I really don’t think it good for you to paint her too much,’ Mama says. ‘Children get nervous and high-strung under too much close attention.’

‘But Mama!’

‘Chrissy, what did I tell you—’

‘Mama, I’m not—’

Christina.’

I flinch. She’s raised her voice, and everyone in the gallery must be looking at me. Please don’t let her carry on, don’t let her scold me in front of everyone, not in front of Gabriel, please please not in front of Gabriel—

‘Christina, you will not use such a tone with me, and especially not in a public place. You should be ashamed of yourself!’

My face is red. I’m hot with embarrassment. I want to throw my coat and muff on the floor and run out into the street. ‘I’m sorry, Mama,’ I whisper, hating the choke in my voice. I sound like a baby.

‘Very well.’ Mama pauses. ‘If you want to sit for your brother again, I would suggest that you learn to moderate your temper.’

‘Yes, Mama. I will, Mama.’

‘Good. Now. Shall we continue?’

I don’t look at Gabriel, but as we follow Mama into the next room, he reaches down and gives my hand a quick squeeze.

* * *


We catch the omnibus back home, which leaves me feeling grimy and even more miserable than before. Mama sends me to clean up for dinner and I slowly climb the stairs to my room. Lizzie’s already there, laying out a clean dress for me to change into.

‘Did you have a good time at the gallery, Miss Chrissy?’ she asks, coming to take my bonnet and cloak.

‘Yes,’ I say flatly. ‘The gallery was lovely.’

She looks at me shrewdly. I feel my face flush and I quickly sit down on the bed and start to unlace my boots, but I tug the wrong end and I’m left with a hopeless tangle. I wrestle with it for a moment longer but my nail catches painfully against one of the lace eyelets and I give up, flopping backward onto the bed. Behind my tightly closed eyelids, I’m desperately trying to hold back the tears, because I am not going to further humiliate myself by crying in front of Lizzie and crying won’t help anything and I don’t even know why I’m so confused and miserable, it makes no sense.

‘Miss Chrissy?’

I swallow hard. Lizzie lifts my foot and I feel her fingers start to work on my laces. I lie still and, even though I feel it’s not very mature, enjoy the moment of quiet with the fire crackling in the background, the vague murmur of movement from downstairs, the pressure of Lizzie’s fingers digging into my foot and the rush of cool air as she conquers the tangle and pulls off my boot. I sit up and pull my other foot into my lap and begin to tease the knot loose, more carefully this time.

Lizzie rises and starts moving quietly about the room; she takes my hairbrush and sets it neatly on my bureau next to my box of hairpins, then takes out a clean handkerchief and sprinkles it with a few drops of lavender water. Her quietness soothes me somewhat, and I say, ‘How’s your sister’s baby, Lizzie?’

‘Oh, she’s doing fine, thank you, miss.’ Lizzie folds the handkerchief and places it next to my hairbrush. ‘The water’s warmed for you, miss.’

I go to the table and pour water from the jug into the bowl. Steam rises into the air, and I begin to wash my face and hands.

‘She was a bit colicky a few nights ago,’ Lizzie says. Her voice is a little muffled by the washcloth over my ears. ‘She’s better now, though, and I think she’s getting over it.’

‘I’d love to see her sometime,’ I say, drying my face with the towel and looking with distaste at the grimy water left in the basin. I’d never say so to Mama, but sometimes I wish I wasn’t the youngest child. I wish I had a little brother or sister so I’ll know what it’s like to have a baby in the house and so when I have my own children, it won’t be quite so alien an experience. Having children seems to be the best thing about getting married; after all, I can’t be sure that my husband will actually love me, but I can be sure that I’ll have children.

I think about this as I change into my clean dress. Does Lizzie’s sister love her husband? Does he love her? I want to ask Lizzie, but I’m sure that wouldn’t be proper, so I hold my tongue and sit down in front of my mirror to brush my hair. My hair shines in the lamplight, but the sight of it always makes me feel sad and somehow helpless. It’s not the most original wish in the world, but I do sometimes hope that I’ll wake up one morning and find my hair miraculously changed to golden. When I was little, I used to pray for golden hair like the princesses in my stories every evening, and extra hard on Sundays; and it was always such a disappointment to wake up on Monday to find it still as brown as it was when I went to sleep.

Lizzie’s hair is brown, so maybe her sister’s is as well. She found a husband and had a baby, though. Maybe things like how she looks doesn’t matter, though, because she’s a servant. Does her husband love her, anyway? Her baby probably loves her, but it can’t be nice for her if her husband doesn’t.

Does Papa love Mama?

That thought is so disrespectful and unexpected that I stare at my reflection in dismay. Of course Papa loves Mama, otherwise he wouldn’t have married her.

But does Mama love Papa?

I slam the brush down, gather up my hair and twist it into a bun so tight it stretches my eyebrows. Twice, I stab myself in the scalp with a hairpin, and when I finally finish, my black mood is back, heavy on my shoulders like a funeral shawl.

I’m at the door, ready to go downstairs, when Lizzie touches my shoulder. She smiles at me, and I think she knows that I feel out of sorts. ‘You look very nice, Miss Chrissy.’

‘Thank you,’ I say, even though I don’t believe her.

‘You could see the baby after dinner, miss, if you really want to.’

‘Really?’ A little of the bleakness lifts.

‘My sister always pops round just before I finish for the day. If you come to the kitchen after dinner, you can see baby while Cook and I clean up.’

‘Oh, I’d love to!’ I exclaim, not caring that it might not be proper and what Mama would call ladylike. I want to see the baby, suddenly desperate to reassure myself that brown hair and a turned down mouth doesn’t mean a childless future. I smile at Lizzie, the shawl of unhappiness slipping from my shoulders, and I go down the stairs to dinner.
"TV makes sense. It has logic, structure, rules, and likeable leading men. In life, we have this. We have you." -Abed Nadir




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 1590
Reviews 10
OK, I'm new to YWS, so I don't know if this is the reviewing section, but this is my comment xD

I've only read the first couple paragraphs, but I really like this. I will carry on. I don't usually read this kind of fantasy thing, but I actually enjoyed the part I read.

One thing I noticed was,
"It’s busy, full of people shopping for Christmas, and I feel very small in the crowd, bumped back and forth by elbows and umbrellas and brown paper-wrapped parcels, but Mama sails forward like a proud ship, calm and poised in her neat blue coat and bonnet."

I think this would be better if it wasn't as long as it is, maybe you could shorten the sentence to something like:

"It’s busy, full of people shopping for Christmas, and I feel very small in the crowd. I'm bumped back and forth by elbows and umbrellas and brown paper-wrapped parcels, but Mama sails forward like a proud ship, calm and poised in her neat blue coat and bonnet."

I only changed one comma for a full stop, but it flows more now, I think :/.

Anyway, I really like these characters. I've only read a small part, but Crissy's character really shows through. Her mother is also prominent. She's an awesome character, really strong. I enjoyed her dialogue.

So, I've said about everything I thought about, I'll get back to reading the rest.

I like your book so far :)
"Muse are my religion. Dom Howard is my God"




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1717
Reviews 42
Hi I'm shadow and I had the pleasure of reading your story.
I'm a dyslexic so I'm not going to get into any critiques about spelling or punctuation (I only found one though :D)

I found the character of Chrissy someone I could relate too and you handled the awkwardness of being in that in-between stage of girlhood and young womanhood beautifully. I really liked how Chrissy seems to see and feel in colors, it was very interesting.

I had a hard time figuring out where and when this story takes place. (I understand it is only the first chapter) I think if you could give your readers more hints as to when they are especially it would help us latch onto the plot faster.

I am a sucker for art so I LOVED the whole gallery scene with her brother and the paintings. I would suggest when you first mentioned Gabriel letting your reader know who he is. Chrissy was bemoaning her marital status just before and after mentioning him so I wasn't sure if he was a beau or not.

I loved the moments with Chrissy in her room, how you write her thoughts is lovely.

I did have a problem with Lizzie though. Throughout your story you strongly hinted the family was poor and the fact that they have servants seems slightly out of place. (unless Lizzie is their only servant, but in that case she wouldn't be helping Chrissy dress.) Also servants rarely/never would have felt free enough to mention their private lives and often families would only hire single individuals. This is just a historical inconsistency but as I'm still not sure the exact time period of this piece it may not apply at all.

Lastly I loved how you used the silk dress as a vehicle to get the whole plot going. That was a lovely idea! and it really put us in the mindset of your fourteen year old character.

All in all I really enjoyed this piece and would most assuredly read more.

Happy writing!
~Shadow~
"D*** the torpedoes! Four bells! Full speed ahead!"~ Admiral David Farragut




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 17359
Reviews 253
Hi Twit!

I am so intrigued. Unfortunately, the single thing I'm perhaps most intrigued about is why this (which reads like historical fiction) is in with the fantasy novels. It doesn't bother me the historicalness or whatever, because goodness knows fantasy could use with something different; it just makes me wonder what's to come, because I have no clue. Which is part of the beauty of it.

That's not to say the impending fantasy aspect is the only thing I'm intrigued about, though. The characters and the story and the writing have me as well, and I think they only enhanced my curiosity about the fantasy thing. For a short amount of space, you did a whole lot with the characters. The best thing about it is that you did it mainly through dialogue and then just a few well-selected details. It was so easy for me to picture the mother in this restricted Victorian dress. Gabriel at first came off just as a typical loving older brother, but he also took shape. Chrissy did more and more toward the end.

One of my friends laughs at me because I avoid female POV characters as if they were spoiled meat. The ones I do have are either younger than ten or very much off-beat. I avoid the ones my age and more normal because, at least in fantasy (my genre), it seems you can't write a female character without running into gender questions and sexisms questions and feminism questions. I'm so tweaked out by all the baggage that comes with writing a female (a young one in particular) that I just don't. So, I'm in a mix of awe, envy, and respect right now that you have an almost-fourteen-year-old feeling the pressures of society and that it all works so well. It read naturally, I didn't get the I-guess-not-so-unavoidable aura of commentary of gender and gender roles. Probably because Chrissy's thoughts were hers, tempered by her world, and because it was familiar to her, I didn't notice. In short, props.

So, I plan on reading onward. And would like some more. Because I am so very curious.

Let me know if you have any questions, comments, concerns, chocolate chip cookie orders, etc.

Rach

P.S. Having both Gabriel and the mom keep saying "Chrissy" all the time was brilliant. Heightened their superiority over her in a nice, subtle, almost invisible way.

Edit: Agree with Shadow about Lizzie. Chrissy did mention the issue of money, and it sounds as if Chrissy hasn't ever talked to Lizzie before now. If she gets thinking about children, though, before she asks to see Lizzie's baby, that might work. Or if she's seen him/her before? Otherwise Chrissy goes from being repulsed by the idea of crying in front of the maid to asking to see her baby.
I don't fangirl. I fandragon.

Have you thanked a teacher lately? You should. Their bladder control alone is legend.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 12987
Reviews 162
"Behind the mist my breath makes on the glass, the colours of the dress blur together; pink and white silk and lace trimmings smearing like the paints in a watercolour." Maybe rearrange this a bit? Move the section about mist on the glass into the middle, after the colors blurring together?

"Mama sails forward like a proud ship" I love this. This whole paragraph. ^^ Except for maybe the first line.

I'm confused. Is Gabriel her brother, her love interest, her mother's boyfriend...? I'm not exactly sure how he connects to them right now.

Ah. Brother. Alrighty. Maybe make that a tad more clear, earlier on?

And, the things you asked for specifically...

Characters: My impression of the main character is that she feels a bit childish for her age (but that might partially because of how her mother treats her) and she wants to grow up. She also admires her mother, but also is frustrated by her, since her mother is a very proud, controlling woman. Gabriel confused me, since - like I said - at first I wasn't sure if he was her brother or her love interest.

Interesting enough to continue: Well... It wasn't badly written, and there were some parts that were better than others, but to be honest I'm not really sure where you're headed with this.

A girl wants a dress they're too poor to afford (even though they have a maid). She's embarrassed/frustrated by her mother, and she gets along fine with her art-lovin' brother. She's not sure she'll ever find a husband, but she wants kids.

That's pretty much all you've given us so far. We're getting impressions of the characters, but where's the intrigue? Where are the tiny hints and tantalizing glimpses of plot strands to come? I have a few different scenes, but I don't feel like they're leading up to anything, and since I have no clues as to what's coming, I don't really feel the need to read more. Does that make sense?

*shrug* Not a bad start. I think you're doing a good job for the most part of showing us your characters' characteristics, and I like your description. Just make it a bit more gripping, I would say. Really grab us, from the first line. Give us a hint that not all is peachy, and something is coming. Foreshadowing is your friend. ;)
"Pay Attention. Pay Close Attention to everything, everything you see. Notice what no one else notices, and you'll know what no one else knows. What you get is what you get. What you do with what you get is more the point. -- Loris Harrow, City of Ember (Movie)




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1583
Reviews 46
Very good! You are a very talented writer!

Your dialogue is realistic, and you include little breaks when your characters pause. I like how smooth the speaking is between Gabriel and the main character.

The Mom seems pretty snappy. It's good how you include Chrissy's thought "Oh, please not again" when her mother yells at her. This shows readers her mom is usually mad about some little thing, and shows you give Chrissy thoughts a normally yelled at child would have. The situation seems so very realistic!

I like the characterization you built. Gabriel is bubbly and happy. And Chrissy just wants to be pretty, desirable, and happy with a future marriage. It is plain to see how she tries to be proper, and lacks self-confidence. I like how you show this instead of tell this to the reader.

What does Chrissy's father do? Is her family upper-middle class? Are they stuggling financially?

However, what is this "black mood" and how come it doesn't affect her so much when she is talking with Gabriel, or talking about seeing a baby?

Keep writing this novel. I love how you wrote this, and I can't wait to see what you write next!
"Which came first? The Phoenix or the flame?"

-H.P. Deathly Hallows




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1532
Reviews 153
I really like this and it's not what I expected. That's a good thing. Some people like to be surprised and I could see by the length and context that you must have worked hard on this and your work had paid off. I already like the main character and her brother and I'm actually curious about her questions of whether her mom loves her dad and vice-versa. This is very well written and I cannot wait to read the second chapter. Keep writing (That's starting to be my signature ending. 'keep writing' )
True confidence leaves no room for jealousy. When you know your are great, you have no need to hate.
-Nicki Minaj




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1820
Reviews 23
This was really enjoyable! I just spotted a few errors.

‘Chrissy, don’t do that, it’s so unhygienic. Really, child, do I always to remind you?’

I think this qualifies as a run-on. You should put a period between "that" and "it's." Also, I think you forgot the "have" in the second sentence. ^^

I touch the tips of my fingers to the white mist left on the glass.

This sounds awkward. She touched the top of her fingers to the white mist? Maybe instead: "I touch the white mist left on the glass with the tips of my fingers."

but Mama sails forward like a proud ship, calm and poised in her neat blue coat and bonnet.

Love this! Very nice simile.

‘Look, there’s Gabriel,’ Mama says.

We’ve arrived at the gallery without my noticing, and there’s Gabriel waiting by the steps.

I think the double of "there's Gabriel" is a bit jarring. You might want to mix it up a bit. Even "Gabriel is there waiting on the steps" would fix it.

‘Does that picture have red hair?’

I don't think a picture can have red hair. Maybe "that girl in the picture have red hair" would work better, unless you meant it to be this way.

after all, I can’t be sure that my husband will actually love me, but I can be sure that I’ll have children.

I like this--an interesting thought.

Of course Papa loves Mama, otherwise he wouldn’t have married her.

This is a run-on. I think you should put a period after "Mama."

I smile at Lizzie, the shawl of unhappiness slipping from my shoulders, and I go down the stairs to dinner.

This is really nice! I think it's my favorite line.

This first chapter did a great job of showcasing the characters and your writing talent, but I'm not sure it's quite gripping enough to keep readers. I know that I usually want the first chapter of a book to hook me, or else I put it down. I stuck with this one because I liked Chrissy and her voice immediately, and I didn't regret it. Nonetheless, please continue!




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 14013
Reviews 280
Hmm, I really wanted to critique this Twit, but it appears you have a fleet of reviewers who have probably covered anything I would suggest. So I might just address your question.

1 - I liked the characters, I think they were relatable and clearly you have carried them with you long enough to understand them.

2 - I will be back for chapter two without hesitation, that is if you wish to continue with it, of course. Which I hope you do!

Best,
JP
Read my latest




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 35199
Reviews 878
Twit!

So you finally decided to post some after all the teasy teasers you've been giving us! This makes me glad, and not only because I've been thinking all along that Lady No Soul is possibly the coolest title ever.

I love that there's a feeling of old-fashionedness / old times in this, even if you didn't particularly shove it down our throats. Sure, there are mentions of the dresses and how fourteen is old enough to marry, but even without those, I'd have the feeling I have now. It might be to do with the fact she speaks of "Mama" and "Papa", but also the dialogue is sort of proper for that. xD ramble ramble.

And, hmm. I really have no specific "nitpicks" or anything to make, especially since people have given you such good reviews already. So let this be a comment instead of a review.

Oh, and do I want to keep reading? Totes.


Demeter
x
"Your jokes are scarier than your earrings." -Twit

"14. Pretend like you would want him even if he wasn't a prince. (Yeah, right.)" -How to Make a Guy Like You - Disney Princess Style

Got YWS?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 130
Reviews 288
I, personally, found the characters a bit confusing to understand. I don't know why, but the dialogue feels a bit..strange. I know that doesn't sound specific enough for you, but it just seemed awkward. I did find, however, a good reason to like your piece. I liked how the story flowed- it feels like the type of story that could be read out live. Good start, can't wait to see it being developed later on.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1600
Reviews 34
I like this. I normally can't deal with women protagonists in historical fiction because I keep imagining elbowing everyone in the ****ing jaw if I lived back then and saying "that's not my problem" when people asked about me getting married at fourteen, but I liked Gabriel and Chrissy as characters a lot. Gabriel's explanation of art jibes with me, as an artist; I can go to the same museum so many times over and over again and not get bored, and a lot of times I had professors take me through museums explaining the art like he does (or during slideshows in class, it was fun for me!). I don't like the title, though. Why did you call it "Lady No Soul"? maybe it's part of the story to come in the future, but still, it's not an attractive or exciting title, or a particularly descriptive one. If you like this title a lot and think it suits the unique aspects of your story, it's okay, but I'd look for a different, more descriptive title that represents the main character's feelings (which you've detailed with warmth and good descriptions, making her look very human and not soulless) or the plot. Or anything you want, a title can really be anything, as long as it's fun. :D
I hope that somehow was coherent.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 4521
Reviews 6
This is a lovely start. The writing style is very sound, and the characters are consistent, although I'm not exactly sure that you have established a conflict. Also, the main character's apparent grumpiness and immaturity separate her a bit from the readers. Perhaps you could portray her as slightly less downhearted, unless you introduce a good reason for her black mood. Thus far I think your wording and descriptions are very clear, but your voice is that of someone younger. Maybe the girl could be tewelve or even thirteen, but she seems a little young yet for fourteen. Also, I think you made a typo here:

"‘Chrissy!’ Mama’s hand lands on my shoulder, pulling me away from the floating dream of the dress trapped behind the glass and back to reality. ‘Chrissy, don’t do that, it’s so unhygienic. Really, child, do I [u]always to remind[/u] you?’"

Other than that, this is off to a great start and I would like to read more. I hope you keep going!
Please check out my storybook; it needs members! http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/post894035.html#p894035

Insincerly, sarcastically, and nerd-i-ly,

SPYNDLE




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1147
Reviews 22
This is amazing! I really love the characters and your plot so far, and this is only the first chapter! The only thing I'd really say to work on is the characters of both Lizzie and Mama. While Mama's character is very cold in a snobby sort of way, I think you should go in more depth with her, and not make her so rough on Chrissy. Also, Lizzie seems more like a friend to Chrissy and less like a maid. Typically, a maid would not touch someone she worked for, and she would probably call Chrissy by her full name. Other than that, I saw a few grammatical errors and run-on sentences, but all in all, this was really, really good!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1061
Reviews 21
What I read of this was very good! Almost poetic!!!!!!! Though I have to admit that i didn't read very far because i was getting ready to go somwhere at the time, it was still awesome! Aweome work!

Just one thing:
When you write diolouge, when someone says something, you use this ' instead of this " When you write diolouge, remember to write the semi colin "
For example: "Hello" She said. Rather than: 'Hello.' She said.
It's written with the same button, just hold down shift when you press it.

Anyway. Your book is totaly epic! Keep it up!



Thou call'dst me a dog before thou hadst cause. But, since I am a dog, beware my fangs.
— Shylock, The Merchant of Venice