Swan Song (4)

18 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 42011
Reviews 922
Yay for more of the Bastard Princess story!

Seconding Jabs in that it sounds very mature here. I mean, the other part did too, but I noticed it more here, maybe because it was longer and that much more involved. While I know that kids can remember remarkable amounts and specifics of their favorite stories, this seemed a bit much. It is still a marvelous story and I love the style in which it is written, but for the context of how it is being told, it felt... off.

Also, again with the rape reference in the story. Does Solea wonder about it at all? And it seems a bit graphic and blunt for a fairy-tale. I know a lot of fairy-tales that we are exposed to now have been sanitized many times over the years, but even in the first half of the story we had, instead of saying that the king and queen had sex, it is just that they "laid" together. Sort of that specific sense of "he knew his wife" that we find in the Bible and stuff. And then here, all of a sudden we are getting really specific. Why not "he could have had his way with you" or something? I know it's nitpicky, but it bothers me just a bit in terms of consistency and Solea's understanding of the world.

A bit nitpicky too, but for the first half or so of just Solea's entries, she really didn't use a lot of contractions and she tended to use "shall" quite a bit. It made her sound so much more formal than in previous bits and it was a bit distracting. I know we all keep harping on this voice, but it's just kind of a bit part of the story.

I loved the Black Swan and all of her speculations on him and his treatment of her and everything. It was all just so heartwarming.

I'm hooked. I really am. I have no idea why it took me so long to get around to reading this. *headdesk*

~GryphonFledgling
I am reminded of the babe by you.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2383
Reviews 67
Hi,

AHHHHHHH! MUST KEEP READING!! The poor baby girl! Solea has captured my heart! I worry every second if she is going to be okay. She almost seems real, but you can definately tell how fictional she is, and not just because she is in a story. The story of the bastard princess is good too. Sometimes, though, I feel as if you should have made it a seperate yet connected thing with Swan Song. Like, a "Before it all" piece. There were a few run-on sentences and grammar mistakes. Along with spelling, too! Eyeing, not eying.
The queen was devastated, of course, but she raised her daughter carefully as if she would be queen anyway, teaching her daughter the ways of the military and showing her how to act in a very political world, even as the king kept the firstborn with him and taught her firsthand the many things she would need to know when ruling a country.

That seriously is in dire need of rewording os something. It doesn't really fit nor flow.
I also, personally, don't like how most of this was an almost entirely different story. I like it. All of it.

Farewell,
A.
You think you are any different from me,or yourfriends?Or this tree?If you listenhard enough,you canhear every living thingbreathing together.You canfeel everything growing.We are all living togethereven if most folksdon't act like it.We all havethe same roots,and we are allbranches of the sametree.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 17359
Reviews 253
Snoinkus.... je suis... back. Don't know "back" in French yet. Sigh.

Anyway, I chowed through the first entries here. Absolutely chowed. Chowed and was relieved that Solea was back in good hands!

My advance knowledge is hindering me again here...

I guess my main thing is the part with the bastard princess, because I didn't chew through that. It had too much dialogue and in-scene stuff for it to seem like a fairytale. Also, the length and amount of detail in it.... Possibly, if Solea has it memorized verbatim? That could work. Or, if you could simplify it down into something more fairytale esque (and cut out the finer layers of plot that she tells,) then it would definitely work better, methinks. As it is now, that's a huge amount of writing for a girl to do in one sitting, so maybe you could split it up at the very least, create some suspense that way with it so that we're following two stories instead of one with the occasional visit from another?

Overall, though, I continue to admire the brilliance of this.. and the brilliance of how it relates to what is to come. It's making my evening. It's making me want to go review. It's making me want to go read and write. Good fantasy... it does exist these days! It does! It really does!

*supreme happiness*

Rach
I don't fangirl. I fandragon.

Have you thanked a teacher lately? You should. Their bladder control alone is legend.



Be sure you put your feet in the right place, then stand firm.
— Abraham Lincoln