Anorexic One

3 posts
User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1118
Reviews 8
I learn to love color
I learn to love sound
I see many whispers
When you're not around

I feel the long strides
That music completes
Sometimes I feel fragile
Bony thin, obsolete

But when the light shines
She shoves food in me
I don't understand
Why I must eat

She says don't forget
My carrots to see
My protein to leap
Hot cocoa to dream

Oh, but what I would give
To shrink and to leave
To be fully complete
Without having to eat

So now I see red
With black as I sleep
My life as no one
Just please let me shrink.
Last edited by redpen123 on Mon Feb 21, 2011 2:08 am, edited 1 time in total.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2543
Reviews 131
First off, nice piece. Not that I like the subject, but I'm always interested in seeing writers try to tackle it. Usually not a big fan of rhyming poetry because they can get pretty technical. It just seems as if there's a lot more rules to follow, and sometimes more to critique.

One suggestion I'd make is to get rid of the spacing between each line and break the poem into stanzas. That helps to further establish the actual rhyme scheme, and it saves this piece from being just one, long and extended stanza. It's easier to read and, in my opinion, much more fluid when it's broken down into pieces (which sounds really ironic for some reason).

redpen123 wrote:I learn to love color
I learn to love sound
I see many whispers
When you're not around

I feel the long strides
That music completes
Sometimes I feel fragil
Bony thin, obsolete

But when the light shines
She shoves food in me
I don't understand
Why I must eat

She says don't forget
My carrots to see
My protein to leap
My hot cocoa to dream

Oh, but what I would give
To shrink and to leave
To be fully complete
Without having to eat

Just please let me shrink.


It could look something like that. Obviously you can break it up however you see fit (or not at all, if that's what you'd prefer). Again, just a suggestion.

Now, second thing: that last line really stands out. Partly a good thing, as it connects with the common thought that anorexic people share ("just please let me shrink"). Partly a bad thing, too. You did pretty well in keeping a uniform rhyme scheme throughout the piece, but then you just throw in this last line and it throws the poem out of balance. My suggestion would be to either work the line into the piece, make one more full stanza to fit it into, or to get rid of it completely. Or you can leave it. Your choice.

Overall, though... again, good piece. Very simple, not a wide variety of word choice but you get your point across well. Keep it up, eh? :)




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1118
Reviews 8
Thanks for the critique! I wrote this poem on a whim, and just to let you know, I'm not anorexic. Sometimes I just like to capture the emotion of certain hardships, whether I've actually experienced them or not. Typically I don't go for rhyming poems either, and this is way more straightforward than my other works. But I'm an advocate of new styles because my goal is to be skilled at every kind. Hopefully my editing has improved the poem. Thanks again, earendil! :)



Everything has to be taken on trust; truth is only that which is taken to be true. It's the currency of living. There may be nothing behind it, but it doesn't make any difference so long as it is honoured. One acts on assumptions. What do you assume?
— Player (Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead by Tom Stoppard)