Conversation in a Hallway

4 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1040
Reviews 2
This is my first post on YWS, and my first time writing about a topic my English teacher didn't assign me. I'm a little late to the writing game, so feel free to pummel away at this. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

“You’ve gotta take charge of the horse, man. Ride that pony into the sunset that is Susan’s life. Be her knight in shining armor. Be your knight in shining armor.”

Carlos’ advice must always be taken with a grain of salt. Or at least a pound’s worth. But what he was saying had some merit, even if I didn’t want to admit it at the time. How was I ever going to woo Susan without actually taking responsibility and going all out? Which at this stage was making eye contact. My relationships are all about the baby steps.

“Your point is valid,” I said. “So what’s my next move?”

“Well at this point, you need to slay the dragon.” My silence demanded an explanation.

“The dragon being your anxiety. Once you slay it, all you’ve gotta worry about is awakening the fair maiden with a kiss,” he said.

“Well, she tends to nod off a lot in Physics,” I said. “Is that when I make my move?”

Carlos shook his head in exasperation. Obviously I’d missed the Extended Nerd-Metaphor class he was taking. “I think it’d be better for you to talk to her first. Otherwise things could get lawsuity,” he said. “Keep in mind; women are not some extraterrestrial species that are beyond the scope of our comprehension. They’re just curvy, fashionable, emotionally needy versions of us.”

“And you have acquired this invaluable knowledge from the countless number of girlfriends you’ve had?” I said, eyebrow raised inquisitively.

“Are you kidding? I’ve never had a girlfriend,” he replied.

“I know. I was being facetious.”

“Oh. You just cursed my Self-Esteem Meter –2%,” he frowned. “And lower that eyebrow, lady-killer.”

Suddenly, Carlos’ eyebrows snapped to attention. I was about to condemn his mockery when I realized that his eyes were directed past my left shoulder and down the hallway.

“There’s something very bad behind me, isn’t there?”

“If you count a drop-dead gorgeous sixteen-year-old with the given name Susan a bad thing, then yes,” Carlos replied.

I turned to face my dragon—erm I mean princess, and Carlos unceremoniously shoved me forwards and into her path. I stood stalk-still until she arrived, and continued my statue imitation until she side-stepped around me. I caught her attention with a sort of throaty grunt sound and then pushed some words out of my mouth. I can’t for the life of me remember what they were, and it’s probably better that I can’t. Suffice it to say that I caught her attention.
“Hi,” she said.

“I have you in Physics,” I said. I tried staring deeply into her eyes, but then couldn’t decide which one I wanted to look into so I just ended up staring at her forehead. Deeply, however.

“That’s cool.” Susan was beginning to backpedal away from me, probably out of disgust at speaking to a boy without a letterman jacket. My stallion was beginning to stumble on its four left hooves.

“See you then,” I said, still trying to lobotomize her with my eyeballs.

“Right,” she called back. And with that word came the crashing finality of failure. She turned the corner of D building and was gone. My sleeping beauty just sleepwalked right out of my life.

Carlos began a slow-clap when I heard a voice behind say, “What is it with women, huh?”

I turned and saw That Girl From History Class. This was an unexpected, if not unwelcome, development.

“They always say they want someone funny and interesting, but they always end up laughing at what the stupid handsome guy says anyway,” she continued. “I mean you were the antithesis of funny and interesting right there, but I’ve seen you around.”

My eyes flickered back to Carlos who was pantomiming horse whinnies and sword swinging, and that’s when I made my decision. No more bouncing pick-up lines off of my friends at the lunch table. No more dating advice from Mr. Dungeons & Dragons Almanac. I was going all out, eloquence be damned.

“Will you go out with me?” And damned it was.

“Sure. When?”

“Today. Lunch.”

“Okay. Where?”

“I dunno. We’ll improvise.”

She smiled, and her face made me think of happiness and sunsets and then knights and dragons and then I cursed Carlos and his stupid metaphor as I smiled back. My horse was back on its feet and galloping.
Dear NASA: If it's not aliens, I don't care.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 60568
Reviews 537
Hey Goldfish, welcome to YWS. ^_^

Carlos’ advice must always be taken with a grain of salt. Or at least a pound’s worth. But what he was saying had some merit, even if I didn’t want to admit it at the time.


First, I would rephrase "or at least a pound's worth". That's referring to a pound's worth of salt, yes, as opposed to a grain? While I still understood it, it came across as odd because the words "at least" would suggest a smaller amount than what was originally suggested, but a pound is much more than a grain. It's a small thing, but it made me pause.

Also, I didn't like the part in red. Since this is such a snapshot piece, focusing on a single instant in the hallway, I'd suggest keeping everything in the moment. Saying "I didn't admit it at the time" makes it seem like this character is looking back on the scene and reconsidering Carlos's advice, which isn't the sort of feel I think you're going to.

“I think it’d be better for you to talk to her first. Otherwise things could get lawsuity,”


Haha, I love it. :P

I caught her attention with a sort of throaty grunt sound and then pushed some words out of my mouth. I can’t for the life of me remember what they were, and it’s probably better that I can’t. Suffice it to say that I caught her attention.


Here the narrative gets clunky. I'd just stick with the first sentence-- the fact that he doesn't say "I caught her attention by saying ____" lets us know that they were lame enough to either be forgotten or omitted.

She turned the corner of D building and was gone.


Er, D building? If you mean the school labels its buildings by letter, that's cool and all, but this is too brief of a snapshot for the school to really matter. If you were trying to make your narrator funny by saying "D building" instead of "the building", I'd cut it, because there's enough humor.

This was an unexpected, if not unwelcome, development.


"If not unwelcome" is a bit like that first point I made. I don't think this sentence says quite what you mean it to say, with the way you've ordered and worded it. Try something like "This was an unexpected, though not necessarily unwelcome, development."

:arrow: Overall

In total, I thought this was really cute! It certainly didn't tackle a big, dramatic, high-stakes conflict, but that's perfectly okay-- not all stories should. Instead you focused on a less significant everyday scene and explored it through a humorous narration and quirky analogy, which I enjoyed. Stories like these are great practice. I do have a couple of suggestions about characterization: watch your personality consistency, firstly. Your narrator seems sort of dorky, and he seems to think that Carlos is too with the whole "D&D" and "never had a girlfriend thing". Yet, History Class Girl makes these vague statements about going for the stupid handsome guy over the smart and funny one, which seems mixed up to me. Also, watch your dialogue-- both boys used pretty big words and impressive phrases for a casual teenage hallway-conversation. Keep it believable.

Anyway, good job overall! PM me if you need any help finding your way around the site.

~Evi
"Let's eat, Grandma!" as opposed to "Let's eat Grandma!": punctuation saves lives.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6280
Reviews 135
Hello! And welcome to YWS. As Evi has already mentioned the mechanics of your piece, I will shy away from them. This was really good. It was sweet, funny and has the potential to be a nice story, if you plan of lengthening it. Your dialogue was nicely put together. I loved how you showed us what has happening instead of just telling us. You have a wonderul way of describing things. Overall, I like where this is going, or where it could go. The charcters seem fun and loveable. Great job!
Got YWS?
"No one can arrive from being talented alone,work transform talent into genius" - Anna Pavlova




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1061
Reviews 31
I really liked your writing a lot. I also liked how the main character went from one girl to another. I also liked how Carlos compared everything to mid-evil times.
I turned to face my dragon—erm I mean princess, and Carlos unceremoniously shoved me forwards and into her path.
I also liked how in this sentence, the main character mixed up the metaphor Carlos was talking about. I can't wait to read more of your writing.
-Titan4ever
"A day without sunshine is like, well, night."



perceive me if you want to, i will exist regardless
— soundofmind