Stop and Stare (Part 5)

18 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1193
Reviews 262
This isn't going to be overly long because, well, there's not much to comment on. (I hope you're happy - you're making me look like a crappy reviewer, thanks so much. ;) )

Probably the biggest thing off with this is Charlie himself - don't get me wrong, he's still awesome, but he doesn't have as much... spirit? I guess. He's a lot more pessimistic. Which, a lot can be explained by the killing, his reaction, but reading the first chapter then reading this, you'd swear it was two different people. Even just the style of writing is different (not blatantly so, but the little stylistic things that separate characters, like how you write him compared to Zoey).

I'm not sure if this is a good or bad thing. Personally, I really liked Chapter 1 Charlie (ain't that a snazzy nickname =) ). But this person is also good too. I think the writing itself is better here. But, I'd edit one of these, fix it, make it consistent. And work on keeping them all consistent, though they probably are I'd guess.

Oh, and the whole thing where Austin's dad said murder, that was a little... I don't know. I'm not sure what to take from that. But of course, that's just a teensy thing I'd thought I'd mention anyways.

Other than that, there isn't really much to comment on. You have well-developed characters, good plot, nice descriptions... I barely even know why you asked me here! (Other than, of course, to get buried in well-deserved compliments.)

Hopefully next part I'll be at least a little more helpful, because right now my reviews of you are extraordinarily lame.

loveness, ultraviolet <3
"Blah blah blah. You feel trapped in your life. Here is what I am hearing: happiness isn't worth any inconvenience."

~asofterworld.com




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 44887
Reviews 816
Ohai, Freak.

I'm here to review. Yes, I'm totally aware of the fact that I was supposed to review this weeks ago but I only got around to it now. You probably hate me, right? Too bad. Anyway, this review is going to be as helpful as a piece of meat is to a horse. Not very helpful at all. In fact, I'll probably just end up saying things twice that the others have already caught. xD

Anyway, it's been some time since I last read this and I must say, I'm glad I picked it up again. I had all meaning too but C'mon, I was a lazy girl those days. I'm trying to change my habits though. Okay, enough with the mumbling, let's get started on this meat, shall we?

Firstly, I like the beginning of this chapter. I really like the way you connected that shoe tying thing to the dilemma he was facing at the time. It's like two wonderful pieces of a puzzle. ^.^

My first peeve about this was the pace. I'm going to agree with what someone said before me about the pace being kind of slow on this one. You had a lot of interrupting actions such as the lighter and the paper. It seemed to drag down the story a little bit but it's nothing too bad. If you could cut it out in some parts and make it feel less cluttered, go ahead but don't if you feel like it's all worth it. In the end, it's your call. xP

The ending, I think was a good place to leave off. It's hard to find that center piece of two chapters where you can part them to post on YWS.

Overall, I like this chapter on Charlie a lot. I think his emotions came out quite clear. Hopefully he doesn't stay a wimp forever and hide behind his lies, that would be sad. This was a good, enough of characterization and such and such to make us feel closer to Charlie as well as giving us some more feeling. The pace was a bit too slow for me but it happens when you're trying to explain feelings and whatever so it's nothing much that I would worry about but if given the chance, try to loosen them up.

Alright, here was my lame review. I'm sure if was sooo helpful. Not really. :/
Also, the dad creeps me out on new levels of creepiness.

Kay, I'll try to get the next one done soon!

-Punk
There are three rules for writing a novel. Unfortunately, no one knows what they are.
-W. Somerset Maugham




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 23786
Reviews 403
Yuss... ;) Caught up to part 5. Where are my cookies!!

Well, I figured I've read enough to at least offer my thoughts on the story up to this point. One thing I can really appreciate is the authenticity of your characters. There's just something very genuine about the way you've molded them so far. There's that sense of internal conflict overpowering Charlie's character. I think the way you shaped Austin's character complements Charlie very well, too. The way they interact is smooth, and humorous at times. The fact that you downplay certain scenes with spurts of humor here and there works really great for the story. It keeps it from sinking too deeply into a dark place considering the plot and all.

I'm also a big fan of the way you've shaped the dialogue and slang. I'm not too familiar with the way people speak in Britain, but I guess that's why I find it so smooth to read through. It's like a whole different culture from mine in ways. I'm not sure if you'd disagree or not. xD

I was really into the way Charlie's parts of the story read off in my head, but when I got to Zoey's it seemed like there was more error and choppiness in the writing. It wasn't as smooth for some reason. It seemed like small nitpicks and such continued to pop out at me more often while I was reading Zoey's parts of the story. Reading in Charlie's POV though seemed so much more natural. But I don't know, maybe that's just me being picky over character's. xP

One thing I really did like about the way you shaped Zoey's part of the story was adding in a character like Luke, her brother. I think as far as relationships go from what I've read so far, you've really done well in varying the types of relationships. There're so many different levels of depth involved already, and I'm still in the beginning of this story. So I think in establishing the ways your characters interact with eachother was nicely done. It makes me curious about Charlie's dad and the absence of his mother. The fact that Austin's dad acts very paternal toward Charlie peaked my interest as well.

I think if I had to point out any flaws in this so far it'd mostly be in the second chapter of Zoey's part of the story. That chapter seemed like it could use a bit more attention than any of the others. It was still a nice read, but it might be a good idea to give it another glance over. I know it's probably been awhile since you've looked at your earlier chapters. :lol: I feel so weird commenting so far back!

Anyway, good job with the pacing of this all. I find that to be one of the most challenging things when it comes to my own writing. It's very easy to tell when the pacing is off though. It seems like you've already gotten so much great feedback already. I can't wait to read on and see what happens. What I've read so far is great. I'm not sure if you're close to ending your story or not, but from what I can see I still have a long way to go! So many chapters. xD Keep up the awesome work.

-Smylin'
Paul is my little, evil, yellow bundle of joy.



Remember when dad's shoulders were the highest place on earth and your mom was your hero? Race issues were about who ran the fastest, war was only a car game. The most pain you felt was when you skinned your knees, and good byes only meant tomorrow? And we couldn't wait to grow up.
— Unknown