Brothers

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1215
Reviews 13
This is not a complete short story, it's a small bit of a longer story I'm writing. There are lots of other fragments on YWS as well, so it's the same characters coming up again in different bits of the story. I just want to post some parts on here to see people's reaction particularly when it's dialogue. Any comments, reviews, impessions or opinions would be great. I really really appreciate it xx

“My brother’s a liar,” Daniel said at last, shifting his position awkwardly as we sat together in the bitter cold,
“He never went to war. He’s right to say we both suffered pneumonia in our childhood, and he’s right to say that the army would not take one of us. But to tell you that he was the one who was sent away to war is a lie. You know his lungs are wrecked, and they have been that way for years. Of course the cigars are no help, and the brandy is no help, but his weakness is nothing new.”
I sighed, and leaned back in the doorway where we crouched on the step. Daniel lit another cigarette and passed it to me, but I tasted nothing. The bitter, icy cold of November and the wind that howls though the city, once a terror in the night, now only a reflection of the stabbing betrayal in my heart. Were there no limits to John’s dishonesty, and selfishness? Would he say anything and lie through his teeth to be who everyone has come to expect him to be?
Reluctantly, I turned back to Daniel and in a smoky breath asked him to elaborate.
“I went to war, Cameo. I lost my sight and took a bullet in the leg while John set his sights on this underground business, while he chased the most elusive women around town and sold the easiest for a small fortune, where was I? A world of blackness surrounded me, while he bathed in his own sordid success. While you, and all the other people of this town grew thin and hard, John carved his niche in the underworld.”
“I assumed you had always been blind, John told me that’s why you couldn’t fight, I can’t believe he would throw that back in your face, his own brother. Not only did you suffer while he made a dishonest fortune, but he never said a good word in your favour, other than to patronise you! I can’t believe it… I can’t believe you don’t tell people the truth!”
Anger was rising in me like a fire, and I ground the butt of my cigarette into the stone doorstep until my fingers singed, my teeth gritted against the lies as well as the cold. Daniel simply shook his head, calmly, slowly. Leaning his head on his arms, and his arms on his knees, he shrugged,
“What good would it do? I know the truth, and now you’ve found the sense to see John for what he really is, you know the truth too. Anybody with any reputation, or sensitivity in this town doesn’t give John an inch, and only smitten women and impressionable boys tend to believe a word he says. The truth will out, and one day John’s world will come crashing down around him. I don’t need to say a word, I’m content to simply sit back and wait for his golden walls to crumble. John has betrayed himself by lying, cheating, spreading rumours, and in good time it will be clear for everyone to see the truth.”
I wasn't born to mourn, but I mourn the day
I stand here alone:
Fighting my heart for dreams, my mind for hope




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 3590
Reviews 30
Truly amazing piece of work, i must say you were able to make the environment for your characters such that i could feel as if i am there!
i think there was only 1 type in the third last line where you said "the truth will out..." you should probably correct that.
The story was short that made it even better as i believe that reading big stories on the web can be very distracting (that's just what i believe).

I will be waiting for more if your work and will read your previous once.

Hope i helped

Yours truly
- Stephene
Message me if you want to talk :)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1215
Reviews 13
Hi Stephene,
Thanks for your review, I'm glad you like the story :)
Just to say 'the truth will out' is not a typo, I did mean to say that. The story is English so there's going to be phrases/spellings that a lot of people on YWS don't recognise, but that is a totally ordinary saying:
http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/390200.html
I agree with you about reading long stories online, I just can't concentrate on them!
I wasn't born to mourn, but I mourn the day
I stand here alone:
Fighting my heart for dreams, my mind for hope




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 22884
Reviews 245
he’s right to say that the army would not take one of us. But to tell you that he was the one who was sent away to war is a lie.

There's a bit of roundabout and overcomplicated nature to these words. Especially because it reads like exposition (as if Daniel were saying, "my brother said earlier that he was in the war, but he was lying."), when I take it we've already learned in the past that the brother already said this. So while it might make sense in this excerpt to explain this, in the whole story, it's over-explanatory.

You know his lungs are wrecked, and they have been that way for years. Of course the cigars are no help, and the brandy is no help, but his weakness is nothing new

A example where normal people would use more contractions. "...and they've been that way for years...the brandy's no help." I think the overall dialogue could benefit from more contractions and casual word choice so it's less formal and rigid sounding.

The bitter, icy cold of November and the wind that howls though the city, once a terror in the night, now only a reflection of the stabbing betrayal in my heart.

This figurative speech here doesn't really do it for me. "The cold and the wind were a reflection of the stabbing betrayal in my heart." Just sounds too much like 14-year-old, vague, melodramatic poetry.
Also, it's not a full sentence. It's lacking the word "were" between "night" and "now."
Also, it's in the present tense. "The wind that howls through the city."
Plus it reads as:
"The cold and the wind, once a terror, now only a reflection of betrayal."
So you're saying that the wind was once a terror but now reduced to a reflection (as in the wind is the only thing that's a reflection)...and you've left "the cold of November" all on its lonesome as an awkward fragment.

Were there no limits to John’s dishonesty, and selfishness?

I hope before this story, we learned something about John's dishonesty and selfishness. Because just from Daniel's quote, I don't really get a huge sense of "stabbing betrayal." So he said he fought in a war when he didn't. Big deal. Lots of hotshot guys say that. (Granted, we haven't gotten to the part yet where it was actually his brother Daniel who suffered in the war.)

he chased the most elusive women around town and sold the easiest for a small fortune

If this is the first time we're learning this, then you might want to rework this for more oomph. He chased elusive women and sold them? It makes him sound like a poacher. Which is weird.

Not only did you suffer while he made a dishonest fortune, but he never said a good word in your favour,

Unnatural sounding. The MC just reiterated everything Daniel said in his/her own words. And is "a good word in your favour" how the English normally talk? Just checking. It's just hard to say, "He never said a good work in your favour!" with enough anger and emotion to be believable.

Anger was rising in me like a fire,

The comparison is too basic that it seems cheap. Anger=fire, okay. Like "Laughter burst out like rainbows."

my teeth gritted against the lies as well as the cold

Strange, forced phrasing.

"...I can’t believe you don’t tell people the truth!”
"What good would it do? I know the truth, and now you’ve found the sense to see John for what he really is..."

Buuuut...Daniel just did tell someone (part of the collective people) the truth. This comes across as fake modesty or a stab to get some pity.

Sooo...them's my thoughts. Overall.
1) The dialogue is a little stiff. Then again, I don't know the specifics about their personalities or what their relationship is, so that may be the case.
2) I don't really get a sense that these are two real people having a conversation, but that it's two characters trying to move a story and make the reader think/feel/believe certain things.
3)There's too much strange, forced figurative language, especially for such a short excerpt.

Lemme know if you have any questions.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1215
Reviews 13
Hi thanks for that review, I like a critique I can sink my teeth into. It's very in depth!

First of all I'll explain that this is not a short story or anything complete, it's halfway through something else so yes it will seem strange if some explanations/descriptions are short and others long, but it makes sense in the long run trust me.

1. I guess it is a bit roundabout but what he is trying to say is that his brother lied about some of the information, and not about others. Saying 'he lied' is not good enough here because it has been lied about in a very sneaky way.

2. The dialogue is quite formal and rigid, that's how I'm writing this so if you don't like it that's your preference, I don't really want to change that. He isn't going on and on about his brother's habits, he's just stating them as a fact because everyone knows it, but nobody knows his lungs are wrecked from a childhood illness.

3. Yes this description needs changing/expanding. I totally see your point here.

4. Yes we do learn all about John's selfishness and betrayal before this... the protagonist is his ex-girlfriend which isn't explained here, and there is a lot of other stuff in the story. Also, this is set in the past so the war in question is the 1st world war, and it is definately not normal or acceptable to ever lie about having fought in a world war. It is a very big deal here, still. This is a betrayal for Daniel because while he fought and lost his sight in the war, John had an easy time at home - he didn't use this to his advantage and do anything beneficial, he actually became a pimp. And then lied and said he was a war hero and it was Daniel who had stayed home and was blind since childhood. He actually suffered a great deal, so in context, it's a betrayal.

5. This sentence means that John tried to seduce the most elusive (rich, uptight, beautiful etc) women, and at the same time pimped out the bodies of poorer more vulnerable girls. It's not nice.

6. "Never said a word in your favour" is totally normal. It means that person only spoke bad words about you.

7. It is not false modesty, he is telling the girl he is in love with, and the reader, no other characters
I wasn't born to mourn, but I mourn the day
I stand here alone:
Fighting my heart for dreams, my mind for hope



Veni, vidi, scripsi ~ I came, I saw, I wrote
— steampowered