Scarlet Rain (excerpt)

7 posts
User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 19207
Reviews 192
This is the second posting of this piece of writing. (ugh) Where is you people's sense of feedback?

Sir Dacron pressed his horse on through the rain. Thunder rolled ominously above them. It was not often that Dacron felt fear, but now it had wrapped its iron hand around his very being, threatening to stifle all life it found there. The horse shivered beneath him; almost as if it too, could sense its master’s fate. A raven screeched somewhere in the distance, briefly shattering the dismal cadence of the rain. Then, the silence crashed heavily upon them again.
It was the silence that was most unnerving; for it was not the kind of silence that is heard, but rather felt; and Dacron could feel it with every fiber of his body. Not one animal could be seen prowling about the recesses of the woods; the entire place was cloaked in solemn grey mist. Dacron peered uneasily into the shadows. His enemy was near. He could detect his evil presence on every living thing. Even the fallen trees which crossed his path seemed to shudder for what was to come. Dacron urged his horse to a faster pace. The mud beneath its hooves squelched in strange rhythm, in tune with the creaking branches. “You’ll fail! You’ll die! You’ll fail! You’ll die!” They sang mockingly. Dacron gritted his teeth. “I WILL not fail! I WILL not die.” He assured himself. The rain pattered forlornly against his armor. “I can not fail, I can not die.” He sighed.
Presently, Dacron reached a clearing amidst the claws of the forest. The first sight of his foe brought a queasy feeling in the pit of his stomach; he knew that something terrible was going to happen, it was only a matter of time.
The Scarlett knight was astride his prancing mount, and was obviously impatient.
“Ah, Sir Dacron, how nice of you to join me!” his voice had a sarcastic edge to it.
Dacron ignored him as he reined his horse to a halt and began to adjust his lance. “I was afraid you would be unable to attend, since I heard you had been detained.” He continued.
“Don’t mock me Boran; we both know what lies at stake here.” Boran pulled his horse to a standstill. Dacron could barely see his eyed underneath his black visor.
“Do we now?” his voice grew suddenly cold. “Mark my words Dacron, you will fail today, and everything you hold dear will be destroyed. I will make sure that death is not the end of your suffering.” Boran spat. “And don’t lie to yourself, honor won’t save you…not here and not ever.” His contempt slashed at Dacron.
“Your malice will not go unavenged…” his voice unintentionally quivered, “may justice smite you this day!” he bravely shouted. Boran laughed.
“You certainly have a taste for noble words coward. Let us see how you enjoy the taste of your own blood!” he lowered his lance and spurred his horse forward without warning. Dacron kicked his horse to a gallop and prepared to meet with fury.
Last edited by EloquentDragon on Wed Nov 24, 2010 11:35 pm, edited 1 time in total.
No more countin' dollars... we'll be countin' stars.

Enter, if you dare.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1853
Reviews 130
Hello EloquentDragon!

I'm so sorry to see that you were a smidge frustrated with the lack of reviews, so I have come to rescue you! It's the least I could do since you reviewed my work so well.

Impression:
I liked the story. I know that sounds cliche, but this late at night and that's the best I can come up with I'm sad to say. In general, I'm constantly fascinated by knights on horseback, it all goes back to the first time I saw The Sword in the Stone when I was kid. The love grew when I read The Once and Future King, The Lord of the Rings (I love the Rohirrim), and watched as Heath Ledger battled away with his lance on A Knight's Tale. Your story was not very long, but it gave me a taste of that world of embattled warriors fighting for the glory or to defeat a great evil.

Grammar:
I noticed a few blips of grammar error. I'll just list them for you. Don't worry, nothing to fret over.
“I can not fail, I can not die.”
Cannot is one word. Easy fix!
His voice had a sarcastic edge to it.
"His" should be capitalized since it is the beginning of a new sentence. If you had written
...join me!” he said, a sarcastic edge to his voice.
then you could have left the pronoun lowercase. As it is, it needs to be capitalized.
his voice grew suddenly cold.
Yet again, the same as the one I just listed for you. You know what to do. :)
“I was afraid you would be unable to attend, since I heard you had been detained,” he continued.
You had the opposite problem with this sentence. You needed to have a comma instead of a period and 'he' should be lowercase. The way it was had "He continued" just hanging out in the middle of nowhere when it should be attached to the previous dialogue to show Boran was speaking again. It might even work out better if you say "Boran continued."
Also, the dialogue needs to be separated from Dacron's description. It looks almost as if Dacron said Boran was late. Which is contradicted by what I read previously.

Okay, so that may seem like a lot, but it isn't really. :) I've seen much, much, much worse. And that is being generous. As it is, I have a question about the story. Do you plan on expanding this, or is it a one time thing? I can see this as something bigger. If you do decide to write more about these two knights, I would like to read about how they came to that point. I think it would be very interesting. The exerpt is intriguing. I don't know if you actually have progressed further, but it's just something to keep in mind.

Happy Writing!
Bailey
After all, it is the pen that gives power to the mythical sword.

"For an Assistant Pig-Keeper, I think you're quite remarkable." Eilonwy

"You also shall be Psyche."

"My only regret
all the Butterflies
that I have killed with my car" Martin Lanaux




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 4343
Reviews 51
Hi, this is pretty good. I think the reviewer above me took care of the minor issues, so i won't bother with them.

A word of advice: If you want people to review your work, review other people's work. This is the idea that YWS is grounded on. When you review someone elses work, most of the time they take the time to look at yours. Sometimes they don't but that may be because they're not into the particular genre you write in.

So, review more and you will receive more reviews. If you write mostly fantasy then review more fantasy stories. You don't have to but that would probably help a bit.

Anyway, i like your story. It's a good introduction to the characters. There's tension between them, and it seems like there will be an immense battle scene between them in the near future. I look forward to reading it :)




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 19207
Reviews 192
baywolf25 wrote:Okay, so that may seem like a lot, but it isn't really. :) I've seen much, much, much worse. And that is being generous. As it is, I have a question about the story. Do you plan on expanding this, or is it a one time thing? I can see this as something bigger. If you do decide to write more about these two knights, I would like to read about how they came to that point. I think it would be very interesting. The exerpt is intriguing. I don't know if you actually have progressed further, but it's just something to keep in mind.


Thank you, I will defiantly fix those grammar problems.
Yes, this piece of writing is separated; it is midpoint between Dacron's conquests and Boran’s conquests, so it’s sort of like a mini climax. I do plan to expand this, but later rather than sooner, but maybe I should do it sooner. I'm not sure if I will though, I wrote this one day while bored when I was supposed to be doing homework; then revised it a little to post here, so its just a tiny bit to what could be a great story.

Again, thanks for your review!
~E.D.
No more countin' dollars... we'll be countin' stars.

Enter, if you dare.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 19207
Reviews 192
leebass wrote:A word of advice: If you want people to review your work, review other people's work. This is the idea that YWS is grounded on. When you review someone elses work, most of the time they take the time to look at yours. Sometimes they don't but that may be because they're not into the particular genre you write in.

So, review more and you will receive more reviews. If you write mostly fantasy then review more fantasy stories. You don't have to but that would probably help a bit.


Ah yes, thank you for pointing this out. My little intro at the start of the story was slightly random, as I had previously posted this story in the "Historical Fiction" section. It received no interest there, so I was angered that I didn't post it in the "Fantasy" section first.
No more countin' dollars... we'll be countin' stars.

Enter, if you dare.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 8890
Reviews 191
Spoiler
EloquentDragon wrote:
Sir Dacron pressed his horse on through the rain. Thunder rolled ominously above them. It was not often that Dacron felt fear, but now it had wrapped its iron hand [Don't know about using "iron" in conjunction with fear. Doesn't quite sound right] around his very being him, threatening to stifle all life it found there. [So you're basically saying this guy is dying of fear? Sounds a bit extreme] The horse shivered beneath him; almost as if it too, could sense its master’s fate. A raven screeched somewhere in the distance, briefly shattering the dismal cadence ["Dismal cadence"? Did it just suddenly get purple in here? :P] of the rain. Then, the silence crashed heavily upon them again. [I would agree with "heavy silence" if it was actually silent. As far as I understand, it's raining and there's thunder. I'd use a different word]

It was the silence that was most unnerving. It was not the kind of silence that is heard, but rather felt, and Dacron could feel it with every fiber of his body. Not one animal could be seen prowling about the recesses of the woods; the entire place was cloaked in solemn grey mist. Dacron peered uneasily into the shadows. His enemy was near. He could detect his evil presence on every living thing. [Literally or metaphorically?] Even the fallen trees which crossed his path seemed to shudder for what was to come. Dacron urged his horse to a faster pace. The mud beneath its hooves squelched in strange rhythm, in tune with the creaking branches. [?] “You’ll fail! You’ll die! You’ll fail! You’ll die!” They sang mockingly. [I wouldn't use "sang". When I think "sang" I think of songs. You've got more of a chant here going on] Dacron gritted his teeth. “I WILL not fail! I WILL not die.” He assured himself. The rain pattered forlornly [Can't we just say "miserably"?] against his armor. “I can not fail, I can not die.” He sighed.

Presently, Dacron reached a clearing amidst the claws of the forest. [Please provide a picture of a forest with claws] The first sight of his foe brought a queasy feeling in the pit of his stomach; he knew that something terrible was going to happen, it was only a matter of time.

The Scarlett [Scarlett = female name, scarlet = colour. Not sure which one you meant] knight was astride his prancing mount, and was obviously impatient.

“Ah, Sir Dacron, how nice of you to join me!” His voice had a sarcastic edge to it. [I have a difficult time seeing sarcasm and impatience come together]

Dacron ignored him as he reined his horse to a halt and began to adjust adjusted his lance. “I was afraid you would be unable to attend, since I heard you had been detained,he continued.

“Don’t mock me, Boran. We both know what lies at stake here.” Boran pulled his horse to a standstill. Dacron could barely see his eyed underneath his black visor.

“Do we now?” his voice suddenly grew cold. “Mark my words, Dacron. You will fail today, and everything you hold dear will be destroyed. I will make sure that death is not the end of your suffering,[Is he planning to kill him and then revive him? I don't see how death can not end a person's suffering, unless it is by magic] Boran spat. “And don’t lie to yourself, honor won’t save you…not here and not ever.” His contempt slashed at Dacron. ["His contempt materialized into a clawed demon and sliced Dacron's eyes out." Be wary of phrases as abstract as these, or your readers are going to start getting imaginative like I did]

“Your malice will not go unavenged…” [Dictionary break. "Malice" is a desire to inflict injury. "Vengeance" is infliction of harm on a person by another who has been harmed by that person. So is Dacron punishing Boran for crimes Boran didn't even commit yet?] his voice unintentionally quivered, “may justice smite you this day!” he bravely shouted. Boran laughed.

“You certainly have a taste for noble words, coward. Let us see how you enjoy the taste of your own blood!” he lowered his lance and spurred his horse forward without warning. Dacron kicked his horse to a gallop and prepared to meet with fury. [I read that as "have a meeting with Mr. Fury". Did you mean "retaliate with fury"?]


The spoiler above contains my full text critique. My comments are in [red brackets]. My corrections are highlighted in red.

Welcome to YWS, Mr. SPG (Self-Proclaimed Genius)! :D

You did well in terms of setting up a scene and atmosphere, so props to you on that point. I'm not sure what the story is, so I can't much comment on that, nor can I say a lot about the characters. In terms of technical details, you've got a bit of variety going on with your sentence structure, which is nice. However, there are places where you've also gone over the top just a bit.

To elaborate on that last point, you've got some words in there that are... pretty far out there. "Forlornly", for instance, is not only a good way to tie your tongue in a knot, but also to lose your reader's attention while they reach for the dictionary (and don't even get me started on "dismal cadence"... :P ). Try using words that are as simple as possible and instead rely on strong descriptive points or sharp metaphors/similes to show a clear picture. I'm not going to say that I'm a saint in that regard, you should see my earlier pieces (when I wanted to say "peaceful waving", I instead said "placid undulation". Not a joke), but I'm getting out of the habit, and trust me - simpler diction does make for stronger prose. Anyone with a thesaurus can have "strong" diction, but not everyone can show a clear picture using simple language. If you want to see an excellent example of simple but strong writing, look no further than the quote in my signature.

Another thing I noticed was your affinity for the semicolon (;). In this 600-word excerpt alone you have six semicolons. In my short story "The Unicorn" at 2900 words I have two, and I think that's already too many. Again - no need to use advanced tools like semicolons if you can achieve the same effect with commas and periods. For instance, check that sentence where you managed to use two semicolons, and try to come up with two good reasons why you need them there. They are very noticeable and they make it more difficult to keep up with what you're saying.

Having said all that, you did quite well in terms of building a scene (now say it like a third-grade English teacher would! :D ), and I'm interested in seeing more of this. Will you be posting it? I suggest the "Fantasy Novels" sub-forum if you will. Cheers, and best of luck!

Your servant,
cC
_




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 19207
Reviews 192
Thank you CC!
I now feel somewhat like a hypocrite, as I told Baywolf not to use "iota" and here I am using "cadence!"
But it was good for you to point that out, I was trying to narrate in the voice of a 16th century scholar who is orating the "true" Canterbury tales to a younger generation. I will amend.
(BTW, if you think this was bad, you should see my story about the Pilgrim's journey on the mayflower, heh.)
Again, thank you.
~E.D.

P.S. None of that is to be read as sarcasm, even though it is one of my many talents. *ahem*
No more countin' dollars... we'll be countin' stars.

Enter, if you dare.



Thou call'dst me a dog before thou hadst cause. But, since I am a dog, beware my fangs.
— Shylock, The Merchant of Venice