Starched, Even (short story)

4 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1090
Reviews 3
Keys, keys, keys.
Where are they? He has misplaced them.
His hair falls haphazardly, grazes the collar of his stiff oxford shirt.
Maisie ironed it for him, starched it, even. For a special occasion, she said.
He wouldn’t exactly call this a special occasion.
He feels the creases on the fabric below the fourth button, the creases her fingers made as they folded the shirt over, folded it neatly away into the depths of his closet.
There has never been any special occasion. At least not one that calls for that starched oxford shirt.
He does not understand why it is now, why he cannot go on his sweatpants and the Rangers sweatshirt she always wore, even when there was a game on and it was his lucky sweatshirt.
He misses home, misses the anonymity of the state university, and the unanimity of the Saturday games, the sea of orange sweatshirts.
The city was Maisie’s idea. He’s only there because of her, and now he sits alone in the back of a dozen yellow cabs each day; listens to the driver tell, play god-awful music, swerve and turn the meter on early, off late. And repeat.
Never the subway, though. He hears it, through the grates in the sidewalk as he walks to work, a loud, steel monster, an enemy.
His enemy. His enemy that connects this city, this prison of concrete that he lives in. Blocks and avenues of people and people and strangers and the rattle of the subway connecting it all, linking it all together, linking together all the reasons why he knows he should not– cannot be there any longer.
And yet he trudges on.

His keys are on the coffee table, he’s seen them now, picks them up, and his scarf; goes.
In the street he finds a vendor, hooded, Cuban, buys a bouquet of flowers from the boy.
Cannot look hi in the eyes because he is too similar, too similar to the descriptions he was given, the wall of pictures he was forced to look at during the inopportune times he was asked to stand, move from the cracked, vinyl chair at NYPD, Precinct 33.
Too similar to the eyes he imagines Maisie saw, and he doesn’t want to imagine.
He hails a cab, gets in and the driver yells, and plays god-awful music, swerves and turns the meter on early, off late.
And he gets out and he’s across the river, and he thinks again how Maisie would’ve wanted to be in the city, how she loved the city, was the reason he was in the city.
But her family hadn’t known that, picked New Jersey, off the interstate where freight trucks rumbled by all day and the sky was always gray. Yes, they hadn’t known that, hadn’t known her.
And he doesn’t know her now, either, only knows the slab of stone with her name engraved across the front, the slab of stone where he kneels and leaves the flowers and itches the collar of the shirt that she ironed. Starched, even.


(I am planning to enter this work in a writing contest, so as much critique as possible would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1098
Reviews 2
Hey! I'm Kenzie, and I'm here to review.

First of all, nicely done. And I wish you good luck in whatever contest you're entering it in!

mechi. wrote:oxford shirt.
About that, you mention it a lot. We already know he has on an oxford shirt so it's not like it needs to be said more than once.

mechi. wrote:him


That's pretty much all the nitpicks I have to point out.

Here are some pointers:
> Characters They seem flat, maybe try and make them really stick out and their personalities shine. It seems to me just the main character is flat so good work on the girl.
> The Storyline It seems as it barely anything happens; he loses the keys and gains them again. That's just my opinion.

A tip is to just read over before you post. And nice job spacing it out by the way, it makes it so much easier to read!

Nicely done, I loved it! Good luck again!

~ Kenzie ~




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 13816
Reviews 563
Hi there mechi! Glad I stumbled across this short story! I'm WD, and it's nice to meet you. So, this story has a lot of potential--you already have some honest emotion budding and, in general, your writing style seems to be coming along. I like the focus on thought process and I like the present tense--it makes the reveal at the end a whole lot more powerful. There's a lot going on that's good here, but I'm going to take you through a few nitpicks and then talk about some of my larger impressions of this story, kay?

Keys, keys, keys.
Where are they? He has misplaced them.
His hair falls haphazardly, grazes the collar of his stiff oxford shirt.
Maisie ironed it for him, starched it, even. For a special occasion, she said.
He wouldn’t exactly call this a special occasion.


So, I know funky spacing places more emphasis on individual lines... but when there is too much funky spacing, the emphasis just dies out, because it is overused. That's what is happening here. This beginning has a nice, stream-of-thought-esque feel to it, but the excessive one-line spacing doesn't do anything for this. It just makes it look weird. If you really want to use spacing for emphasis, pick one line that you want to take out and use it on that.

He does not understand why it is now, why he cannot go on his sweatpants and the Rangers sweatshirt she always wore, even when there was a game on and it was his lucky sweatshirt.


This sentence is confusing.

He misses home, misses the anonymity of the state university, and the unanimity of the Saturday games, the sea of orange sweatshirts.


Meeehhhh. Unnecessarily big words like 'anonymity' and 'unanimity' are poor substitutes for real emotion. What specifically is the 'anonymity' of the state university and why does he miss it? What specifically is the 'unanimity' of Saturday games and why does he miss it? The more specific you get, the more powerful this will be; detail > fancy words.

The city was Maisie’s idea. He’s only there because of her, and now he sits alone in the back of a dozen yellow cabs each day; listens to the driver tell, play god-awful music, swerve and turn the meter on early, off late. And repeat.


Listens to the driver tell what?

Never the subway, though. He hears it, through the grates in the sidewalk as he walks to work, a loud, steel monster, an enemy.
His enemy. His enemy that connects this city, this prison of concrete that he lives in. Blocks and avenues of people and people and strangers and the rattle of the subway connecting it all, linking it all together, linking together all the reasons why he knows he should not– cannot be there any longer.


I... don't get this. Sure, the subway as an enemy is an interesting idea, but what does this have to do with the real conflict in his life? It's not really clear how this fits, which makes the metaphor seem dreadfully out of place. If it connects to the primary conflict of Maisie being dead, then clarify. If not, it can go.

His keys are on the coffee table, he’s seen them now, picks them up, and his scarf; goes.


Funky sounding sentence. Read aloud!

Cannot look hi in the eyes because he is too similar, too similar to the descriptions he was given, the wall of pictures he was forced to look at during the inopportune times he was asked to stand, move from the cracked, vinyl chair at NYPD, Precinct 33.
Too similar to the eyes he imagines Maisie saw, and he doesn’t want to imagine.


Good hint to how Maisie dies, but the first paragraph is confusing. The sentences have a tendency to meander and get all warped. Good writing doesn't constitute warped, complex sentences. Good sentences are detailed, flow well and convey their point.

But her family hadn’t known that, picked New Jersey, off the interstate where freight trucks rumbled by all day and the sky was always gray. Yes, they hadn’t known that, hadn’t known her.


What do her parents have to do with this? Seems like a distraction from the main conflict of this story. The last paragraph is really great--nice ending!

So, my overall comments on this:

I. Sentence clarity. Some of the sentences here are right on target, doing well. Others, not so much. Sometimes I feel you are trying too hard to make your sentences seem creative, but, when you try too hard and it distracts from the story, they just seem warped and a out of place. So, read aloud! :) Remember: good sentences don't constitute confusing constructions or big words. They provide detail, flow well and get to the point in a way that befits the moment. Once again, read aloud!

II. Main conflict. Okay, the main conflict I see here is the guy mourning Maisie, and the slow reveal of who Maisie is and how she is dead. Awesome. But the bits about the subway, the parents and even Oxford are taking away from the power of that conflict. Why? Because I don't get how they fit in. If you want to establish Maisie's relationship with the guy before the city, in Oxford, do so with concrete details, not vague references to Oxford. And I'm not really sure what is intended by the subway and parents thing. If you want to provide details around the main character, vague references usually don't cut it, unless you're writing something longer and you have room to expand later. Not everything has to be laid out in excessive detail, but the mentions of subways and parents lead me to think they must be extremely important and, when they're not, I, as the reader, feel let down.

III. Character! It has been mentioned that your character seems flat; I am not sure I would go that far, but your character certainly needs some fleshing out. The thought process-style is helping a lot with his characterization; giving me a window into his head was a good choice. But that's not enough right now; right now I know what he's thinking but I really have no idea what he's feeling, and I'd love to see some concrete body language and movement and some real feeling in this. Does he feel nauseous? Is he sweating when he's at the grave? Is he crying? How exactly does his interaction with the Cuban boy go? What does it look like for him to miss something? How does he feel about leaving his keys? Frustration? In what manner does he walk back to his house? Dejected? Does he stalk back there? Details like this give us insight into how the character is feeling and who he is and concrete details like this will really help to round out this character and give him the life he needs for the reader to really connect with him.

All in all, an interesting story and a nice start! Keep writing! If you have any questions, feel free to PM me!
~ WD
If you desire a review from WD, post here

"All I know, all I'm saying, is that a story finds a storyteller. Not the other way around." ~Neverwas




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 1062
Reviews 10
Pretty good work!
At first as a reader you think, it’s a couple living in the city, then you think, ahhah, the couple is separated, then you get a little confused by the line about the police department, and finally, it hits you: she’s dead. So it’s nice to see how you get closer to the “truth” in little steps.
Good luck for the contest!



We join for the writing and stay for the community!
— Horisun