The Funeral

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1763
Reviews 8
Note: I wrote this story for my English exam, which is next week. It's based on the theme of "Searching for Identity", so I would appreciate it if reviewers considered this. Thanks :) Be honest :)

“The night my Nonna died, I dreamt of her and later woke up about four hours before sun rise, feeling sticky sweat slide down my face in uneven, uncomfortable strokes. And, yet, I knew almost immediately that it would be impossible for me to go back to sleep.”
The Church was filled with a reverence that I think could not be replicated in any other place in the world. As per a common habit of mine, I began to look at the facial expressions of the people around me. Most were unreadable, but you could tell from the sombre atmosphere that suddenly the congregation of family and friends were in deep thought. I hate funerals. I couldn't even remember why I was at this one in particular. They all seemed so frequent nowadays.
The speaker took a deep breath and continued.
“The dream was vivid and, although I was sick at the time, I believe my new coat of sweat was purchased by fright rather than illness. The dream started with me at school and noticing my Nonna there. She was apparently there as a guest, and now that I think about it...”
The speaker laughed nervously, shedding a tear in the process – something that seemed to sharply contrast with his masquerade. It was an image that I would later ponder for hours in bed at nightfall.
“... now that I think about it, I guess it was a bit weird. But you know how dreams are. You don't pick the holes in 'em until you get back into consciousness. Until then, though, even the most unreal notions can become a reality. And there's no escaping dreams like the one I had. My first reaction to seeing her was embarrassment. I hid behind my friends, pretending not to see her.
“The guilt was overwhelming, however, so I sat next to my Nonna in the first class and only class of my dream: Physics. Again, weirdly, I sat in the opposite direction to everyone else in the class. Maybe I was supposed to translate my Nonna, whose first language was Italian. But I think the reasons were deeper. In any case, I'm not fluent in the language.
“Nonna asked a question, in struggling English, 'When I... die... will... will I raise to Heaven in Italy where I was born... or in Australia, where I will die?' And the class laughed at her, laughed at her naivety. In my dream, the laughs echoed and echoed and echoed...”
I noticed an old woman crying into her hands in the corner of the Church. She actually started wimping and, at this point, I was considering leaving because I could no longer bear the mourning nor the speaker's nonsense about his “Nonna”. I actually left my sit but someone with concerning eyes forced me back down. The person's face looked familiar but I could not generate a name for it. At my age, I forget a lot of things.
“'Give her a break. She's an emptologist', one of the classmates had said, spitefully. And I asked him what the word meant, knowing it was a product of my lucid dream. 'It's someone who holds onto their religion because it's the last thing they've got.'
“They did not give her a break though. The school's authorities took her away and the last I remember of the dream was my Nonna's wrinkled, tired face, fading away into the abyss of dreamless sleep. Nonna could no longer bear life without anyone understanding her. We need each other. I miss you, Nonna”
The speaker finished his speech and sat next to me, allowing his arm to fall over my shoulder. He called me, “Nonno”, and I just smiled. This person was keeping me alive.
The worse thing I can be is the same as everybody else.
A.S.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1596
Reviews 66
Hi! hopefully this review helps you. I liked this story even if it was very short, and didn't have a lot of description in it. I was a little confused about the ending. What i thought happened was that the mc was really the husband of the grandmother that died. But then why wouldn't he want to go to his wife's funeral? and how was his grandson keeping him alive? overall, good writing, but maybe make it clearer. good luck!
Xx This side of mortality is
scaring me to death
to death xX

-The Temper Trap: Soldier On




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 15813
Reviews 213
Hi! I'll be reviewing this today. As for your theme, unfortunately I've not had enough experience, so I'm not going to review it from that angle. I have a couple grammar nitpicks, this paragraph in particular:

I noticed an old woman crying into her hands in the corner of the Church. She actually started whimpering "Wimping" makes no sense.and, at this point, I was considering leaving because I could no longer bear the mourning nor the speaker's nonsense about his “Nonna”. I actually left my seat but someone with concerning concerned? Using "concerning" makes the person with the eyes seem as if they're...unpleasant. "Concerned" fits the tone overall. eyes forced me back down. The person's face looked familiar but I could not generate a name for it. At my age, I forget a lot of things.


It's really only some word choice errors, and some spelling. Nothing too major.

As for your plot, that might require more work. There's very minimal description, and while some authors make it work, it doesn't work here. This is a piece that requires a bit more detail. Also, I can't really place this...but the paragraphs don't flow very well when read. The wording "as per" "generate a name" isn't how a person would generally phrase their words. Just something to think about. :) Oh, and one last thing. Your MC. Why wouldn't he want to be at his wife's funeral? And why does he refuse to refer to the boy as his grandson? Those are some continuity issues.

I hope this review helps!

Keep Writing!

~Sporks!
Grasped by the throat, grasped by the throat. That's how I feel about love. That it's not worth it.

REVIEWS FOR YOU | | Uprising (coming soon!)




Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 1523
Reviews 2
Hi there,

I too have to write a creative piece for my english essay too next week!!! But I'm in a standard class and something tells me that your an advance student. Overall it's a good story and it definitely fulfills "Search for Identity." However narrative structure wise, I filled it a little confusing to understand and i had to read it twice to finally understand the ending. You mentioned that he doesn't like funerals, so you justified why he didn't want to be there, even if it was his wife's one. And I also get that you wanted to build suspense with the grandson, but it didn't pull off well. However these are small things that can be fixed. The Idea is good. Keep working on it and good luck.

John.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1763
Reviews 8
Thanks guys,

I have taken on your advice and I have rewritten the story to a great extent. I ended up making it third person so that I could capture a greater description of the events. I also changed the dream, making it set within a nursing home and ensured there was no dialogue within the dream to make it less confusing. Basically the message of the dream was to show that the Nonna was isolated in her life and the speaker learns that this is the reason she died. The MC realises at the end that the speaker, who is his grandson, has been a great source of comfort throughout his life hence, the reason the grandson is "keeping him alive".

I showed my friend at school the revised version and he understood it. My teacher is checking it now. I hope she finds it okay. Thanks again!

*Edit: In my revised version, I also made sure that the MC was not reluctant to be at his wife's funeral - in fact I made it the complete opposite; in the revised version, the MC is concentrating intently. I thought that this alternative would help readers understand that he was the husband of the person who died.
The worse thing I can be is the same as everybody else.
A.S.



Teach a man to fish, he eats for a day. Don't teach a man to fish, you eat for a day. He's a grown man. Fishing's not that hard.
— Ron Swanson (Parks and Rec)