You will be remembered

4 posts
Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 2
I wrote this yesterday, uhm a review would be appreciated THANK YOU :D :elephant:

"You will be remembered"
____________________________
By: Kite

*on editing*
Last edited by kite1992 on Thu Dec 30, 2010 12:40 am, edited 1 time in total.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 13952
Reviews 168
Hello, I'm going to be your reviewer for today. Now let me be clear, this poem bothers me, it seems slightly juvenile in sense, you practically hit us on the head with the idea of 'remembering' it doesn't make me feel nostalgia it irritates me compleltly? But that where this poem fail and easily remedied diversify the phrase 'Remember the soso'.

The imagery is indeed beautiful but it lackluster, it seems tacked on. I know that sounds harsh. There is some verses which it works. This one especially stands out.

Remember that fateful day?
The hour we left for life's path,
The minute I ran astray,
The second you jumped to save,
The moment you layed, blood-stricken, and pale.


See this here is by far best stanza, I have so much imagery in this, for instance you have references to the youth but also of the tragic event as first image that comes across with 'jumped to save'is football.

But something lacking it's pretty but it seems lackluster. I never saw the poem vividly which is what you don't want.

I'm sorry this isn't much help and harsh, but it was a good try.

Hope this helped.
You poor take courage
You rich take care
This earth was made a common treasury
For everyone to share
All things in common
All people one
We come in peace
The orders came to cut them down

Billy Bragg - The World Turned Upside Down




Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 4038
Reviews 25
Hmmmm... there's no image, little metaphor, save for one sentence metaphors.

So, instead of thinking in similies, this is like this, rain is like God crying, pain is like an alarm clock, etc... Try and weave a web of metaphor that ties every experience to an image, and all of these images together as well.

So, to start, figure out a basic image to encapsulate your surface emotion. Laughter. You mentioned flares. So, laughter is a flare. Why? It ignites, shoots sky high. Flares are distress signals, is laughter a distress signal? Sometimes. Flares are also warning signs.

Maybe laughter is the warning sign, that which warns you of anger.

So, if laughter's the flare, anger's the fire.

Are you following my train of thought?

Instead of arguing and shouting, you probably flickered and fanned together. And maybe you grew, burning the wooden carcass of your former self. See? Flames don't argue and shout, but they do flicker. Humans don't flicker, but if humans were ablazen with the flames of anger, their shoutng would be alot like flickering, and their arguments would taint the air like smoke.

See where I'm going?

So, I'd recommend throwing this poem away, and starting anew. Ditch the rhyme scheme. Rhymming is a package. Would you buy a half full box of cereal simply because the box looked cool? Possibly, but you'd regret that when you began starving, and if you sold such a box it's safe to say very many people would be disgruntled.

Rhyme, without proper image and metaphor, is like a half empty box of cereal. It leaves the reader unfulfilled.

So, pick an experience, and tie it to an image. Maybe a babies bald head is like the moon, maybe Christmas is like an oven, maybe your family are like paper dolls, who knows.

Pick an experience, tie it to an image, and explore that image, while keeping it tied to circumstance. That's metaphor, and the base of the art of poetry.

If you have any questions, send me a message! I full of resources, ideas, and... erm... right, YWS rules...
You know how dumb the average guy is, right? Well, mathematically, by definition, half of them are even dumber than that.
JR ‘Bob’ Dobbs

TW's Red Cross Blue Shield. A CRITIQUE FOR EVERY YWSIAN!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 44360
Reviews 1087
Hey there Kite :)

I have to agree with the other reviewers. It feels as though there is something missing from this poem. :? I don't really feel emotionally attached, if you get what I mean. I think that you need to be more vivid with the imaginary at times, but without literally telling us. I think that someone else has mentioned this.

The second you jumped to save,
The moment you layed, blood-stricken, and pale.

I really liked these lines! I love how descriptive you're being. In fact, I loved the entire stanza. But these were my two favourite lines. Although, you've spelt laid wrong.

You definitely have a good rhythm in this poem, so well done for that. :wink: Also, it's not hard to understand, which is a very good thing. I especially liked the rhythm on the last few lines of your poem.

Overall, I did think that this was pretty good. All you need to do is polish it up a bit.

Keep writing,

xoxo Skins
I didn't know what to put here so I put this.



Daddy Long Legs are more closely related to crabs than spiders and somehow the idea of crablike creatures with spider legs that have escaped the entrappings of the primordial sea and now crawl over land and can walk up and down walls and ceilings creeps me more than I can adequately describe.
— Snoink