Prologue: Once Upon a Midnight Dreary...

7 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 28282
Reviews 884
***Edited but still looking to improve. Thanks for the tips!!! :wink:


There was a letter.

The apartment was (as always) in complete disarray - paint was splattered wildly along miscellaneous objects, papers stacked in mountainous piles that threatened to fall from the countertops at any minute. A couple of cabinets were missing their doors, while those of others hung weakly on rusted hinges. Yet through the muck and murk of my disorganization the letter stood out like dirt on a white rug. The room was always a cluttered mess, yet everything had its place. I hadn’t put the letter there.
Grabbing the pale white envelope from its upright position against the bed’s headboard, my fingers numbly slit its throat and drew what was encased inside.
The piece of paper was smeared with faint pencil smudges,the letter's writer clearly having trouble writing what they needed to say. However, they must have found the words eventually, because some of the spidery letters remained bolder than the previously-written script. The handwriting was strange, old. Familiar. I found myself surprisingly afraid, my eyes slowly sinking into the print as I read, the world fading around me before shattering altogether.


Dear Alexandria R. Knight,
I have recently been informed that my days are unexpectedly numbered, and due to this fact I have an undying desire to meet you before I leave this world forever. Please understand that this is in your own best interest, and that my reason for this is quite urgent. I understand any anger or resentment you may feel towards me, and for that I apologize. I apologize for past mistakes, for abandoning your mother, for abandoning you. However, I implore that you allow me to redeem myself with a final warning.
With Sincere Regrets,
Your Grandfather, Douglas J. Peters
P.S., to contact me, please go to Palegrove Hospital, Room 9311

Though I must have read it a dozen times before finally setting it down, the words didn’t quite settle completely. Maybe it was the fact that I was jetlagged, that it was ever-nearing three eastern-standard time, that it was midnight here. I didn’t believe that this was the case, though, any weariness I’d previously felt now gone. My grandfather? Why? Ever since my mom had run off with my dad, he swore to never speak to her or, as time went on, any children that they had. I’d been my parents’ one and only, my dad passing away before I was even born. For years Mom wrote my grandfather nearly every month, begging him that he’d understand her decision and accept it, that he’d at least accept me. He’d never replied. Not once. Even when sending out my mom’s funeral invitation, I received nothing but an undying silence.
The truth was that, up until now, he seemed merely a myth. A legend etched in stone, living only in my mother’s distant rememberings. He was as much of a fable to me as Cinderella or Rumplestiltskin. This letter broke that wall of fantasy, my window of illusion. My grandfather was in fact very real. And alive.
I spent a few hours pacing the floor, a few more lying awake in bed staring at the circling ceiling fan as sleepless hours passed. The fact that I spent only a few weeks at my apartment at a time made it seem even more unsettling…after all, how long ago had the letter been put there? I’d been in New York for a month and a half. For all I knew he was dead by now. Another thing that bothered me was, how did he get the letter on my bed? After all, I’d left the door locked, I was on the second floor and in any case the windows didn’t open…a chill ran down my back at the thought. Had someone sent the letter as a trick? Had someone broken into my apartment and put the letter there in hopes of kidnapping me? Was this some scheme to have me go to the hospital, not to find my grandfather but instead a cold-blooded killer?
Get a grip, Alexa, I warned myself. You’re losing it. This isn’t one of those horror/mystery novels; no one’s out to get you. There is no crazy twisted plot, no murderous mastermind - this is the real world. You are completely fine.

Little did I know how wrong I was.
Last edited by StoryWeaver13 on Wed May 19, 2010 8:34 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Reading is one form of escape. Running for your life is another. ~Lemony Snicket




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 15421
Reviews 158
Hi StoryWeaver13
I like the story. I think its the beginning of a really good story.
I can't see anything wrong with it so I don't have any nit-picks.
I like the way that someone has managed to get a letter into a locked room. I want to know what is going to happen later on, so keep writing.
Can you pm me when you post more?
Thanks
midnightread :elephant:
The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing.
A wise man does not need advice and a fool won't take it.


Growing old is mandatory,
Growing up is optional.


Rugby is a thugs game played by gentle men,
Football is a gentleman's game played by thugs.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 30301
Reviews 770
Oh wow!

I'd love to have someone start a critique of my work this way but that's not important here lol :lol:

Very beautifully written, very evocative. I could clearly picture Alexa 'cutting the letter's throat'. Wow, wow!

They always say here, they repeat and repeat,-and with reason!- to show, not tell. Well, you have succeeded wonderfully. Now, there is a thing or two I'd like to point out.

The handwriting was strange, old. Familiar. I found myself surprisingly
Beautifully said. BUT you say the writing is familiar, yet when I read further on, she had thought her grand-father was a myth. How could his writing be familiar?

have recently been informed that my days are unexpectedly numbered, and due to this fact I have an undying desire to meet you before I leave this world forever. Please understand that this is in your own best interest, and that my reason for this is quite urgent. I understand any anger or resentment you may feel towards me, and for that I apologize. I apologize for past mistakes, for abandoning your mother, for abandoning you. However, I implore that you allow me to redeem myself.

Ok. Here. I read the 1st sentence and thought, 'aww, well this is cute. He wants to make amends'. Then I read the next sentence and went 'well, guess not. It's for HER own good, not his.' And then the last, he implores the chance to be redeemed. Do you get what I mean? Maybe you could say (I'm tired and I may not make sense, I apologize) that he truly regrets what he did, he understands her anger and resentment but it is -literally- a matter of life or death that he speak with her...Make sense? You may be thinking 'but I said that,' and it's true but the thoughts in the letter are a little scattered...

Maybe it was the fact that I was jetlagged, that it was ever-nearing three eastern-standard time, that it was midnight here.
I would have liked a bit more detail here. Jetlagged from where? You could have said like, "I just came back from Canada and I'm horribly jetlagged.' Or something, you know?

You’re losing it. This isn’t one of those horror/mystery novels; no one’s out to get you. There is no crazy twisted plot, no murderous mastermind - this is the real world. You are completely fine.
hahaha And here I thought I was the only paranoid one around lol

Little did I know how wrong I was
At this point, this sentence is so cliché I'm surprised it's not illegal. That being said, I LOVE CLICHÉS! LOL Seriously. It's cliché but it does the trick. Loved the hook. Would you pm me for the next?

***As usual, this is an insanely rough draft. Have fun tearing it apart all you want.
If this is your idea on an 'insanely rough draft' I'd love to see the final product! You're a natural, keep writing!!

Tanya :D




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2474
Reviews 47
I do like this quite a lot. It's very good and there is little that is bothering me. However, there is one single thing. On the letter from Alexa's grandfather, you said that there were pencil eraser smudges all over the paper...and yet, in the next sentence, you said that the words stood out in thick black ink...I'm not sure if that's what you wrote exactly, but that's what was basically there. Anyways, you can see the problem. Why would there be pencil smudges if he wrote in black ink? Other than that, I thought that it was very good and that you should most definately continue on. When you post the next part, would you please contact me? Thanks a lot. Love it!
Many ask me if I see the glass as half full or half empty. Well, I don't know about you, but I see the glass as, WHO DRANK HALF OF MY MILK?!?!?!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 28282
Reviews 884
Thanks for the input guys (I'll return the favor :smt001 ).

@ borntobeawriter
Beautifully said. BUT you say the writing is familiar, yet when I read further on, she had thought her grand-father was a myth. How could his writing be familiar?


This is explained later on. :wink:


@ dragnet

On the letter from Alexa's grandfather, you said that there were pencil eraser smudges all over the paper...and yet, in the next sentence, you said that the words stood out in thick black ink...I'm not sure if that's what you wrote exactly, but that's what was basically there.


Yeah, like I said, rough draft. I'm sure at one point in time there was a method to my madness but I can't think of it now lol. I'll fix that, thanks.
Reading is one form of escape. Running for your life is another. ~Lemony Snicket




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3981
Reviews 24
Hi Storyweaver! I'm just going to do a quick review on this since I didn't find many mistakes. :)

This was a great prologue! It had a good hook and was interesting to read. You gave just enough detail that we could follow what was going on, but held out enough that we were curious and wanted more. So good job, because that's hard to do!

The only thing that kind of threw me off was this:

some of the spidery letters remained more boldly among the faded ones.


"Remained more boldly" just sounds really weird in this sentence. Maybe try something like "stood out boldly" or just "stood out among the faded ones." Or, I'm sure you could come up with something much better than my examples since the rest of your prologue is amazing! ;)

Anyway, I really liked it and now I'm moving on to Chapter One!
"Without hard work, nothing grows but weeds."
-Gordon B. Hinckley




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1590
Reviews 3
Hey storyweaver, thanks for reviewing "cast in fire". When you have time, could you look at the revision and tell me what you think? I would really appreciate the help!

Ok, so now to the prologue. I have to agree with what was said in a preceding post... you're a natural. You've got a very smooth delivery. There are two reasons why I say so. One, your language use is minimalist and very tactful. Two, the tone is casual and straightforward. I can picture myself looking through your eyes at the room and at the letter. There's not halt in the action and I don't need to calmly take deep breaths as I stumble through adjectives and modifiers. Good work!

As a reader, I enjoyed myself until the last portion of the prologue. I understand that you're providing yourself some options as to where you will go with the story, but I think you should probably make a decision and roll with it. I felt like just a normal old Joe Schmo while I was looking through your eyes at the letter from the Grandparent. When you started speculating about murder, deception and the lot I lost interest. I was interested in hearing how this character was going to (or not going to) resolve the situation and the issues surrounding such a curious family dynamic. I guess what I'm trying to say is that the murder mystery twist at the end of the prologue didn't really seem to fit.

If you are deciding on writing about the letter and the events surrounding the potential meeting of grandfather and progeny, I think that you should probably just cut out the end of the prologue and just start your first chapter with a continuation of the situation, or with some character building chapters.

If you are deciding on creating a mystery novel, or something along those lines, you should probably just start writing the novel and come back to the prologue after you've got some good bulk to the story. Traditionally, prologues for suspense/mystery/murder stories have foreshadowing in them (think twilight zone!). I think it would be easier to add this element once you've logged some hours on the story itself.

The last line of the prologue is a cliche and flimsy. A cliche is something that characters in the story can and will use, but the narrator should probably avoid.

Anyways, overall, you've got quite a good start. I actually just read the first chapter of the novel. Good stuff too! Hopefully these comments aren't out of context with where you actually went with your story. Let me know if you would like me to clarify anything, or if you would like me to critique the first chapter as well, otherwise, keep it up!



Everything has a consequence and every consequence leads to death.
— kattee