One -- The Juggler (2nd draft)

4 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2688
Reviews 10
Well, this is my second try at this, and I say it went a fair bit better then the first. Oblivion doesn't make his appearance here, but he will come along eventually, and I think this will set out to be a much more interesting (and odd :)) story then before. Enjoy!


The autumn wind was soft and warm against Elsa’s face, tossing her hair back behind her and throwing the scattered leaves into the air. But even on such a day, she wasted no time to notice the natural beauty around her as she raced across the field towards the town. Behind her were the tall, sober trees that lined the road leading up to the Academy, but that was such a walk to follow the road, most of the students cut across the field. So it was that her feet were running a well-trod path through the tall, golden grass and it was only a few times that she stumbled in the gathering dusk.
Elsa felt as though the wind was chasing her, she could hear the and honking and general noise that emitted from any town, village or city you could find. From up ahead of her, while the buildings of the town were still dollhouse-sized, but steadily growing larger. But her feet couldn’t seem to get her there fast enough. A few times she glanced behind her, stories of young people wandering through the field when night was falling rang through her head with the same clanging an enraged cymbal player would make. Ghosts and creatures rising from the ground and catching hold of unsuspecting victim’s ankles, and then there was the story of young Jessica Torrent. The girl who had apparently been murdered and buried in that very field.
With the thought of Miss Torrent’s ghostly face, dripping with blood as the story had described, peering up at her from the ground. Elsa’s heart gave few panicked back-flips before the ground seemed to reach up and catch Elsa’s foot. She gave a small shriek as she crashed to the ground, sending a few birds flapping away in alarm. She whirled around, expecting to see a white boney hand clutching at her foot … only for her eyes to find a slight rise in the path that she had forgotten in her mad haste.
She gave a relieved sigh, “I really should stop reading such frightening stories during math.” Elsa said aloud, she had hoped that the sound of her voice would slow her throbbing heart, but it only made her feel small, as her words were swallowed by the growing darkness.
Getting to her feet, she looked down at her uniform and sighed again, though felt more annoyed now. Her mother would not be pleased when she got home. The pleated skirt was streaked with mud and her white socks would never been the same again. She was just brushing off some of the dust from her skirt when she heard the music.
It was very faint and rather tinkling, like it was coming from a rather old music box. Even so, it was pretty, in a strange lilting way
Elsa looked up in surprise, where in the world was that coming from? Surely not the ghosts. They wouldn’t play anything that nice. Unless they were trying to lure me somewhere … a frightened voice in the back of her mind whispered. But it was then that her eyes landed upon the juggler.
All she could see was his silhouette, outlined against the dim orange and crimson that was the last of the sunset. But she could see a large top-hat, a sweeping coat and the small balls that danced and spun through the air with a sweeping sort of grace.
Elsa was entranced. She couldn’t help but be, there is really no way to describe what she was seeing, but if you were ever faced with such a spectacle, you would have no choice except to stop and observe it.
The juggler was standing at a surprisingly close distance to her, and in the emptiness of the fields around them it was hard to believe that he couldn’t be spotted a mile off. If Elsa had stopped to really think about it, she would have wondered at this. But as she didn’t, she was too busy watching performance to worry about such a minor detail.
As she watched, he caught one, then two of the balls in his palm before catching the third on his fingertips and turning towards her with a twirl of his coat. “Good evening, young miss. Just what might you be doing wandering a field so late?” The juggler was younger then Elsa would have guessed. Probably only a few years older then she was. Nineteen? Eighteen? Or maybe even twenty. But he had old eyes. Kind, warm and a dark blue that rivaled the backdrop of the stars brightening above them, but as old as a ninety year old man’s.
For a moment, Elsa didn’t reply. The trance the juggling had seemed to put on her had hardly been broken, but she was conscious enough to take in his costume, which resembled a Victorian gentleman, before coming to his pale complexion and dark, old eyes. It was when she realized that it was she he was looking at with a curious, if slightly vague expression that it came to her mind that he may be expecting a reply of some kind.
“I was coming back from school,” Elsa replied with some haste, suddenly glad of the darkness, as she was sure that she was blushing and cursed herself for it. “Band practice is on Fridays and I had to stay and help Mr. Tim clean up. I was hurrying though …” she caught herself mid-babble and shut her mouth. Deciding instead to look at his gleaming black shoes and talk to them instead, which she found was much easier then trying to make eye contact. “I’m sorry. I just talk when I’m nervous. But what I really mean all around is that you juggle magnificently. And why are you wearing an outfit like that? I’m sure this field hasn’t seen an outfit like that for a hundred years—“ she cut herself off, clamping her hand over her mouth. Why couldn’t she just stop talking?
But the juggler was laughing, and she looked up to see him dropping his juggling balls into the pockets of his waistcoat as he spoke. “No, no, I’m the one who should be apologizing. That is, seeing as I make you nervous …” he said this so knowingly that Elsa was certain that her face had turned the color of her hair. Red.
“That really isn’t what I meant.” She replied, frowning and actually rather annoyed with him. “It’s this place. I don’t like it.”
“Surely you don’t mean this sorely innocent field?” the juggler asked incredulously. Elsa hadn’t expected it, but there was real astonishment on his face. Or so she thought from what she could see of him in the dim light. “The field, I’m certain, has nothing at all against you.”
“Because you would know.”
“Of course.”
The juggler very suddenly dropped into a deep bow, tilting his top-hat upwards. “I’m afraid that it has come time for me to be apologizing again, so early in our acquaintanceship. Here we’ve been having this lovely argument about whether this field – which as I said before is sorely innocent – likes you or not and I haven’t even introduced myself. Ptolemy would be horrified, were he sneaking up behind me at this moment. My name is December.” With this finale, he held out his hand, which was safely hidden under the cover of a white glove.
His fast speaking and strange vocabulary had left Elsa quite confused, and she had no idea whatsoever what a Ptolemy was. But the conversation about the field had been making her head hurt, so she gratefully shook his hand. “Elsa Blackwell, a pleasure I’m sure.” She said, though couldn’t help but sound a little sarcastic.
“I know, but it’s nice to have you introduce yourself to me.” He answered with a knowing grin, giving her hand one firm shake before straightening up again. This only made Elsa more confused, but December seemed to lack the decency of explaining what he meant and continued as though she had agreed with him. “Have you noticed the stars tonight?” he said, abruptly looking up at the silver flecks of light that were twinkling in the blanket of darkness in the sky. “They have a better tendency of smiling where I come from, but they are trying their best here. Don’t you think they’re trying?”
Elsa looked up, she supposed he was right. Though at any time, she would have said that the stars were smiling quite cheerily, she was no expect in celestial emotions and would have to leave it up to the juggler, who she was now thinking was rather strange. “I think so …” she said, as she was quite at a loss to do anything but agree with him. “But,” her gaze turned off of the trying stars to December, who she thought looked like he had stepped out from a black-and-white photograph. “Where do you come from?”
December didn’t look at her. She guessed that he was trying to make the stars smile, as he answered in a off-hand sort of way that might have been just him avoiding her question. “Oh, quite a ways away. Shall I walk you home?”
"With all due respect, sir. I distrust your hat entirely."-- Jae Marquis




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5732
Reviews 24
Aaaargh! Why does everyone taunt me with cliff-hangers? :D

First of all I'm Bek :) and I love emoticons. And I'm still practicing at this reviewing stuff, so I'm sorry if my "help" is not very helpful.

Now to the reviewing:
I loved it! Where on earth is the rest of it? Put it on the website! Please! But you made little errors which were annoying to my eyes as I read. I'll just do a couple of them:

“Elsa Blackwell, a pleasure I’m sure.” She said, though couldn’t help but sound a little sarcastic.

This is one of the most common errors in all the work I've read on this site. Replace the full stop with the delightful comma--people, the comma is your friend! The full stop is your enemy! Jokeless, you should read through your work and proof-read it yourself at least one more time. Truly, your work is lovely EXCEPT for little mistakes like that. Another one:

'But as she didn’t, she was too busy watching performance to worry about such a minor detail.'
This makes no sense. The "as" shouldn't be there. The sentence should be 'But she didn't; she was too buy watching" etc.

I like how you left us hanging. The way you wrote made me want to read more, straightaway. I wish this was a book so I could buy it or something. No comments on your plot so far, because I'm not good at reviewing--I'm still an amateur among...well, amateurs. Keep writing, please!

Bek :)

Also for some reason I imagined December as Johnny Depp. :D What's wrong with me? I have no idea. But there is NOTHING AT ALL wrong with your work...or Johnny Depp.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 30301
Reviews 770
Hi there Jokerless, I'm Tanya, here for a review :D

Elsa felt as though the wind was chasing her, she could hear the and honking and general noise that emitted from any town
I think there's a word too many here :D

Elsa looked up in surprise, where in the world was that coming from? Surely not the ghosts. They wouldn’t play anything that nice. Unless they were trying to lure me somewhere … a frightened voice in the back of her mind whispered. But it was then that her eyes landed upon the juggler.
You should always italicise a thought.

Well, those were my only nitpicks. I really enjoyed the beautiful flow of this story. The sentences were effortless to read and very visual, I could easily the night, the field and the juggler. Great job! Would you pm me for the next chapter?

Tanya




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 37408
Reviews 182
Hello there, I shall be your reviewer today. Be prepared for a long and grueling set of controversies. No, I am totally kidding. I'm always a nice reviewer. :smt036

The words in bold are my comments.

The things in blue are errors that I found, or are just things that are giving me trouble as the reader to understand.

The things in red I added, or are letters that I capitalized.

Anything I have highlighted in green is something that sticks out to me as either good or a bit picky.

The smilies are for a psychological effect so that anything that may be a bit critical that I say is not too intense.
:smt021

The autumn wind was soft and warm against Elsa’s face, tossing her hair back behind her and throwing the scattered leaves into the air. But even on such a day, she wasted no time to notice the natural beauty around her as she raced across the field, towards the town. The "s" in toward and the "the" lengthen that sentence, and actually, it sounds better without them. Just a suggestion. :smt003 Behind her were the tall, sober trees that lined the road leading up to the Academy, but that was such a walk to follow the road, most of the students cut across the field. I think you meant to use something like, "it". Because, using "that" makes the sentence sound awkward. Try reading it out loud. :smt034 So it was that her feet were running a well-trod path through the tall, golden grass, and it was only a few times that she stumbled in the gathering dusk.
Be careful with run on sentences. Cut them in half with swords! :smt027 And about the comma in blue, since tall and golden are both describing the grass the comma really isn't necessary.

Elsa felt as though the wind was chasing her, she could hear the and honking and general noise that emitted from any town, village, or city you could find. You forgot a comma. :( From up ahead of her, while the buildings of the town were still dollhouse-sized, but steadily growing larger. Taking those words out makes it much easier to read. Try reading it both ways. :) But her feet couldn’t seem to get her there fast enough. They felt like lead weights/They carried her at a snail's pace. You get the idea, put in a sentence to balance things out and show how her feet couldn't get her there fast enough. A few times she glanced behind her, stories of young people wandering through the field when night was falling rang through her head with the same clanging an enraged sounds that cymbal player would make made. Ghosts and creatures rising from the ground and catching hold of unsuspecting victim’s ankles, and then there was the story of young Jessica Torrent. The girl who had apparently been murdered and buried in that very field.
I like the dark turn the story is taking, but it's happening at an alarming rate with no balancing sentences to carry the transitions. :smt101

With the thought of Miss Torrent’s ghostly face, dripping with blood as the story had described, peering up at her from the ground. Elsa’s heart gave few panicked back-flips before the ground seemed to reach up and catch Elsa’s foot. OK, that entire series of sentences is confusing. Especially the first, which ends with no real conclusion. Try something like: Elsa's heart furiously back-flipped as the thought of Miss Torrent's ghastly face, dripping blood as the story described, invaded her mind. Or, you know, a rewording of those phrases that makes everything much smoother. She gave a small shriek as she crashed to the ground, sending a few birds flapping away in alarm. She whirled around, expecting to see a white boney hand clutching at her foot only for her eyes to find a slight rise in the path that she had forgotten in her mad haste. I've never seen an underscore used in a literary work before. Though, I believe that may only be a typo, because I'm sure that you meant for that to be a hyphen. " - " (That's not a face, that's a hyphen. :lol:


She gave a relieved sigh, Change to a period. “I really should stop reading such frightening stories during math.Change to a comma. You do that error quite often, unless it is proper in your country, in that case, just ignore me with that period issue. Because, in my country, we never end dialogue wit ha period unless it is the end of the sentence, and not followed by who spoke the words. :smt003 Elsa said aloud, That would be fine as a period to end that sentence. She had hoped that the sound of her voice would slow her throbbing heart, but it only made her feel small, as her words were swallowed by the growing darkness.


Getting to her feet, she looked down at her uniform and sighed again, though felt more annoyed now feeling more annoyed. Her mother would not be pleased when she got home. The pleated skirt was streaked with mud and her white socks would never been the same again. The sentence I have in green will work better here. What I mean is right here, between the sentence before this comment, and the one after, starting with the words: "She was just brushing off some-" She was just brushing off some of the dust from her skirt when she heard the music.

It was very faint and rather tinkling, like it was coming from a rather old music box. Even so, it was pretty, in a strange lilting way.
You forgot a period.

Elsa looked up in surprise, where in the world was that coming from? Surely not the ghosts. They wouldn’t play anything that nice. Unless they were trying to lure me somewhere a frightened voice in the back of her mind whispered. It's good to separate thoughts with a comma, not an underscore. :( But it was then that her eyes landed upon the juggler.

All she could see was his silhouette, outlined against the dim orange and crimson that was the last of the sunset. But she could see a large top-hat, a sweeping coat, and the small balls that danced and spun through the air with a sweeping sort of grace.
Besides the little nit-picks, those two sentences contradict each other. :( The first says that all she could see was a silhouette, but the other describes that she is seeing a lot of details of the juggler. But never fear! :superman: That can be easily fixed. :smt003 Just omit the "But" and add, "As Elsa drew closer," Or use whatever other starting phrase that can connect with, "she could see a large top-hat, a sweeping coat and the small balls that danced and spun through the air with a sweeping sort of grace."

Elsa was entranced. She couldn’t help but be, there is was really no way to describe what she was seeing, but if you anybody were ever faced with such a spectacle, you they would have no choice except to stop and observe it stare at it in awe.
For some reason you had "is" which a first person word here. And this is clearly a story told in the third person perspective, no? As for my omitting of the word "you" it is not good to have a second person point of view change in a story, it leaves the reader with an awkward feeling. :)

I would do the entire story, but I'd just be repeating the general errors that I already have. :wink:

The juggler was standing at a surprisingly close distance to her, and in the emptiness of the fields around them it was hard to believe that he couldn’t be spotted a mile off. If Elsa had stopped to really think about it, she would have wondered at about this. But as she didn’t, she was too busy watching the performance to worry about such a minor detail.
Sorry, I couldn't help myself at continuing, even though I said I would stop pointing out mistakes. :smt003

As she watched, he caught one, then two of the balls in his palm before catching the third on his fingertips and turning towards her with a twirl of his coat. “Good evening, young miss. Just what might you be doing wandering a field so late?” The juggler was younger then Elsa would have guessed. Probably only a few years older then she was. Nineteen? Eighteen? Or maybe even twenty. But he had old ancient wise eyes. They were kind, warm and a dark blue that rivaled the backdrop of the stars brightening above them, but as old as a ninety year old man’s.
You already told us they were old eyes. By the way, the dialogue is kinda creepy, in a good way. :wink: :)
OK, now I stop. :smt003

For a moment, Elsa didn’t reply. The trance the juggling had seemed to put on her had hardly been broken, but she was conscious enough to take in his costume, which resembled a Victorian gentleman, before coming to his pale complexion and dark, old eyes. It was when she realized that it was she he was looking at with a curious, if slightly vague expression that it came to her mind that he may was be expecting a reply of some kind.
OK, once and for all, I promise. :thud:

“I, which she found was much easier then trying to I’m sure this field hasn’t seen an outfit like that for a hundred years—“ she cut herself off, clamping her hand over her mouth. Why couldn’t she just stop talking?
I love that part. :P

But the juggler was laughing, and she looked up to see him dropping his juggling balls into the pockets of his waistcoat as he spoke. “No, no, I’m the one who should be apologizing. That is, seeing as I make you nervous

He said this so knowingly that Elsa was certain that her face had turned the color of her hair. Red.
Separate the different thoughts and actions of different characters. I broke my promise didn't I? :(

“That really isn’t what I meant,” She replied, frowning and actually rather annoyed with him. “It’s this place. I don’t like it.”


Elsa looked up, she supposed he was right. Though at any time, she would have said that the stars were smiling quite cheerily, she was no expect in celestial emotions and would have to leave it up to the juggler, who she was now thinking was rather strange. You meant "expert". :) “I think so ” she said, as she was quite at a loss to do anything but agree with him. Comma. “But,” her gaze turned off of the trying stars to December, who she thought looked like he had stepped out from a black-and-white photograph. “Where do you come from?”


Closing words:

What I liked:
I tell you this with all honesty, I enjoyed this piece. It feels a bit like Alice and Wonderland. *Clears throat* Your avatar may have helped with conveying that. :backtotopic: You have a rather extensive vocabulary at your disposal, and you have used it to great effect. I like your imagery, in some parts it's undoubtedly stunning, particularly the bit with the stars. I rather liked the character of Elsa, and the world you put her in. Aw yes, who doesn't like a little dark fantasy story? :smt084

What I did not like:
As you saw, your piece was not flawless. Some parts brought me to a halt with my immersion, and that is an unfortunate event in a fantasy story. Also, unless it is appropriate in your country, you end all your dialogue with either a period or an underscore. Both wrong, except for the period, which is appropriate in some instances. Over all, some spots just left me hanging, even rereading a sentence twice at times did not help much. But don't worry, that's the worst I have to say. And honesty is always best right? There is no sense in a person lying about writing, for then how can the writer review if they aren't being told what they are doing wrong?

Conclusion:
You tale was as sweet and atmospheric as it was dark and somewhat rocky in it's overall presentation. But it was never the less, a rather beautiful tale. At such a young age, you have more than enough potential to improve. You write dramatically better than me at that age. Sadly, I gave up writing at around age fourteen, and finally came back to it at seventeen, and now here I am. So, whatever sometimes brutal criticism you may get on here, never give up. For only by giving up have people ever failed in doing what they have aspired to. Great job. :wink:

-
:smt059
"Jesus said to her, “I am the resurrection and the life. The one who believes in me will live, even though they die; and whoever lives by believing in me will never die. Do you believe this?”
-John 11:25-26



One who sits between two chairs may easily fall down.
— Proverb from Romania and Russia