The Cursed Ones - chapter one and prologue

12 posts
Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 1657
Reviews 2
I'm a beginner writer, and I'm trying to write a short story. Except the plot might be a little too big. I'm not sure how good or bad it's like right now. I would really appreciate it if you put your comments on it!
Thanks! :elephant:

Note: I changed some stuff from the last post, so if it seems a little different...just keep that in mind. thanks! :mrgreen:

PROLOGUE
It was 250, the Year of the Dark Eyes, which was exactly five hundred years ago.
I was borne to a family on Xetok, a royal family that is, perhaps the most powerful, richest royal family on the entire planet in all of time. I had two sisters – the eldest Kartika, the other Anastasia – a mother and a father.
Then I met the aliens.
The aliens have been there forever, as long as we could imagine, from the days when our anceint planet was called Earth. We have never seen them before, as no one else has, but we knew they were there. However, they have never disturbed us, so it didn’t matter.
That all changed one day when I walked outside the palace walls, out into the villages that our parents had ruled. And that was what had changed my life forever.
Along the streets I met an elderly man, so old and yellowing I pitied him, for he looked as though he was going to die. He was crossing the wet, raining streets, and slipped on a little puddle of water – he was surely going to die if he fell over, as if he wouldn’t already die from his present state.
I remember how I rushed out to help him.
“Oh, princess!” he exclaimed. “You saved me!”
There was something unusually inhuman about him, but I couldn’t tell what it was at the time, besides the point that he looked fragile to the point of collapsing. When I straightened him up, he said he would reward me for it.
He said that if I took the yellow gem that was in his hand, I would get anything I wished for. Absolutely anything.
The gift sounded a tad odd to me, but I couldn’t resist it. After all, who wouldn’t want their wish being fulfilled?
And I had a great wish. A giant, enormous wish that would be impossible to fulfill under normal circumstances. Except…was this normal circumstances?
For so long, as the youngest one of the family, I was often looked down upon, not treated as seriously as the rest. I hated that. I absolutely hated that, and, as sudden as a strike of lightning and as quick to spread as a disease, my want turned to a hungry desire that I could not push back.
I didn’t think about the possibilities that the old man has been playing a trick on me. I didn’t even wonder if the man himself was crazy, and that I was falling for the greatest mistake on the planet…all I wanted was the gem. The gem, which could be the solution to all my dreams…
“I wanted to be the strongest, most powerful queen on the earth!” I said loudly.
I immediately grabbed the gem, and immediately felt more powerful – like I was in charge of the world. The old man changed, too: becoming more green, his skin more stiff and scaly, strange iron-like feathers out of his back, also with spikes and thorns. His eyes turned a pure, hideous black. But I hardly noticed; the strength growing inside me was overpowering; I couldn’t see anything around me, and felt something within me growing, growing like a ball of fire and a sheen of something like pure gold enveloped me until I couldn’t think of anything at all. It was only until later that I saw the seemingly impossible change in the old man.
From then on, my life changed irrevocably. Things became more evil, as I began to see things that I haven’t noticed before: ghosts, strange shapes and creatures that lurk in the darkness. I immediately became fierily angry at everyone; cursing my oldest sister, Kartika, to the bottom of the Warzit mountains as a hideous beast, along with her many friends, who changed as well. I changed her name into Nuagua, a name only for demons; she and her few would not leave the Warzit mountains for as long as Xetok exists.
I also cursed my other sister into the depths of peoples’ dreams, and changed her into a monster of nightmares, who – and her peoples – would never see the light of day again.
My parents saw all of this happen, and were astounded. So they took their last breath and were no more.
I have never even considered the evils of what I have done, never even considered my sudden change from when I was a little princess to when I had been given my gifts.
That all happened less than thirty minutes after my change. And when I grew older, I was granted a bigger kingdom in the middle of the sky, only seen when the moon is full. That way no fool of a human would dare enter my presence; they would be fried alive before they even take a step within my grand palace.
Yet one day, when I was enjoying my pleasure, a young dragon visited my golden kingdom. I would have burned him to pieces if it weren’t for what he was going to say.
“Your kingdom is prosperous right now.” He said. But then he gravely continued. “But it soon would be no longer. Many bad things are going to happen, my Queen; beware.”
“How dare you say that!” I snapped at him. “What would bring my kingdom down?!”
“A single young girl,” he said, his eyes far away. “Somewhere in the future, a young girl would bring your kingdom down. A girl no more than a decade old, with fire for her hair and the sea for her eyes, and red stars twinkling along her nose.”
I did not believe him. In a moment, within a flash of light in my golden power, the gnome was no more than a pillar of golden ice – a statue that was well suited for my castle.
Nothing could stop me. Not a gnome, not a girl, or any other beast can come even close to destroying me. I am too powerful for that – and I will reign as long as time goes.
For I am the great Queen Medara.


Part One
CHAPTER ONE
MY SISTER’S DEAD
6:19 IN THE MORNING. DAY 28, THE YEAR OF THE SINGING DOGS. YEAR 750
Melissa Horiek stood up on her bed and looked outside. Horrible. Simply horrible.
I can’t believe it, she thought. Tears formed at the corner of her eyes. The dark, cloudy sky looked even blacker than before; no other sound except for the sounds of her clock and the distant sounds of wolves perturbed the silence. Even the noise of nosy counselors coming over to comfort her parents had vanished. Melissa shook her head for the twentieth time, and sat back down on her bed with an angry thump for the fiftieth time that night. I just can’t believe it.
It couldn’t have happened. It couldn’t. After all, what were the chances? That your mere fifteen year old sister would die in a bus crash on her way to school? That even the most reliable school district has failed to keep her alive?
Rumor all over the place said that the bus driver has gone nuts – drinking Yizbal, they say. Only previous research has stated that the driver must have been drinking the alcoholic drink for plenty of years; and although students come to school and back home safe each day from this bus driver without even expecting a thing, that day, that one day that Jennifer happened to go on it…well, guess what: it crashed.
Melissa felt so hurt, mad, and like she was going to burst out crying that she banged the wall. Hard.
OUCH! She thought, immediately pulling back and waving her now red fist back and forth. Even with all the pain she had within her, it just didn’t seem possible that this physical one would hurt too.
“Melissa?” she heard a voice calling for her from behind the door.
“Come in,” she sighed.
The door slowly creaked open, revealing a sad and tired looking woman, still dressed in her pink and blue polka dotted pajamas, her hair fuzzed up in curlers. Melissa saw this and at once tried to smile, feeling all guilty and stupid inside. Of course. It was her mother.
“Are you okay?” her mom asked, a little wrinkle snuggling between her two eyebrows. “Melissa, is there anything wrong?”
She tried to smile, but, in the few hours they have been mourning so far, she seemed to have forgotten how to smile. “No, no, everything’s fine,” she lied.
“Are you sure?”
Melissa nodded again – a bumpy, bobble-head kind of nod – and sat on her bed again, resting her chin on her collarbone, closing her eyes trying to look sleepy. But she couldn’t. How could she? There was way too much in her mind right now.
All she needed to be was alone. She could take care of this herself. She always could.
She sneaked a glance at her mother through her peripheral vision. Even if she could take care of this by herself, surely her mother didn’t realize that. Yet.
Just to think: Only a few days ago, she and Jennifer were still at the pond trying to catch frogs, slipping them into girl’s lockers while they were still out playing. Remembering them both laughing hysterically when they found out….
“Why did it have to happen to us?” Melissa finally croaked. Her voice sounded like an old granny’s’. “Why do all the girls in our family have to die?”
Her mother came forward, smoothing her daughter’s mahogany red-brown hair. Usually Melissa would shake her hand off; she wasn’t really the type that would enjoy something like that. But tonight she didn’t even bother.
“I have no answer for that.”
But still, Melissa couldn’t help it. Was it really their fault that each time a child in their family died – which, so far all of them did except for the youngest, Melissa – that they just came up from the dead again?
Her mother looked on, looking across the plain of starry fields’ right outside the window. It was as though she was trying to search for a world in which there was no curse to devastate, either.
It all started over five hundred years ago. King Fredrik was a young king – better than all the rest. He had led the Shamians in a way that no other king has done: full of peace, always thinking of every single one of his citizens.
Though, no one knew about his past – or the past of his father, his grandfather, or any of his ancestors. Such a thing was a complete mystery to the people of Sham.
They said that , one dark, pitch-black summer night, in which everything was covered in complete darkness except for the shining full moon overhead, the king has received a letter – a letter with a gold seal of a circle with a dot within it, and three lines sticking out of the circle, all equally spaced. On the end of each line were two curls branching off of them. Without so much as a warning, he went on his legendary stallion, the one that had a mane that blazed like fire, eyes that were deep like the sea; which, according to the legends, was just like the appearance of King Frederick – except across his nose were red freckles like stars.
“I may not come back anytime soon;” he said to a young maiden, her name Annabeline. They were engaged, but it turned out that the two may never see each other again. “take care of my country for me. I will put my trust in you.”
She asked him where he was going, if it was dangerous, if he was going to be safe there. Yet the only thing King Frederick said was that an ancient enemy was going to attack, and he needed to stop her, for the sake of his kingdom.
He was never seen again.
But it wasn’t long that, precisely ten years from the disappearance of the king, that, during the stroke of midnight, a guard protecting queen Annabeline had seen a gold-sealed envelope – the exact one that their king has disappeared with years ago.
According to the legends, it had read:
Your king is dead. After all, such a one like him does not deserve such power! From this time forth, I will set a curse on you: Who ever deceases in your country will not remain deceased; they will rise up again as new ones. And from this time forth, who ever decides to continue their magic, they cannot!
No one knew why this enigma set a curse on Sham, but the effect on the guard was immediate. He began to get his eyes all bright, and then he turned to stone. Yet before he was completely deceased, he managed to cry out of the castle window:
“Zonyabanyi! Ash-gaweh!” he shouted in the language of their time. Which, translated, meant: “Beware! An incredible danger is upon us!”

Melissa suddenly woke up, her eyes wide with surprise; shaking her head with such shock. The words of the story her father and mother had told her years and years ago had echoed in her head. It flowed freely, haunting her. She turned, and realizing that her mother was shaking her shoulders.
“Melissa? Melissa?” Her mother cried. “Melissa, are you okay?!”
The girl tried to pry off her mother’s fingers, putting the most reassuring look on her face. “Mom, it’s okay,” she explained, her grin turning sheepish. “Just had another bad memory, that’s all.”
Her mother let out a wistful sigh. A tear streamed down her pallid cheeks, dripping daintily off her chin. “Lissy, you worry me sometimes,” she whispered clutching her daughter in her arms as if she weren’t ever going to let go again. “How did you just zone out like that?”
Melissa shrugged, not at all disturbed by the strength in her mom’s arms. “Talent,” she replied.
They just sat their for a while, absorbed in their memories. It was a very peaceful time, where there was nothing but warmness and thoughts in the air, and Melissa felt herself soften so much that she felt she could cry again. It seemed possible that the very calmness was mending her broken heart…
But all too soon, her mother broke the silence.
“Oops, look at the time!” her mom then exclaimed, looking at her ever-present pearly yellow watch on her wrist. “It’s almost time to get up and go to work! Melissa, make sure you take care of yourself well. Good bye!”
She was in such a rush to get out of the room that the moment she was gone that Melissa felt like an empty space was in front of her.
Melissa looked up at the door, now swung open, and found herself staring at it blankly. On normal circumstances, no one would let their employee go back to work hours after his/her child has just died…but Elizabeth Horiek’s boss was no human. He was a blind, thoughtless, apathetic Cursed One that thought of nothing but himself and did nothing but roll around like a log and drool like a helpless baby, which, in essence, he was. By no means did he care if one of his many employees had a dead relation.
But that was what Cursed Ones were like. There was no helping it, which was one of the many things that drove Melissa absolutely crazy.

And everyone knew that, for a loved one to first die and then, somehow, some way come back to “life” once more would not only be painful to the people who once knew them before but to everyone else around them. Because once they came back to “life” again, they were no longer the person they once were before. They would become emotionless, useless, someone without personality and about as human as a piece of driftwood. Plus, sometimes Cursed Ones would become so crazy that they could start murdering everyone that comes in their way…

The empty space that used to be where her mother had been was turning practically unbearable. It was almost as though a phantom had taken her place and now spent its’ time glaring at Melissa as though she was the one who didn’t belong there…she sighed, and with a thump, laid back down on her bed again.
“This is so hard,” she groaned.
The story still managed to haunt her, even though it was many, many years old and not many people believed it anymore. The stories were getting rusty, and even so, when it was first told during the time five hundred years ago, hardly anyone listened to it.
The Shamians’ view of the world was blurred now. They had lacked their interest in finding out about it, in reaching for knowledge even in their little part of an island. It was as though the sudden “curse” thing and the mysterious disappearance of King Frederick has suddenly diminished their curiosity or…like some how, some way, they just forgot how to do that. It was as though someone put this thing in their minds that said, don’t think about how the Cursed Ones came to be, don’t get outside of Sham, just stay in here. It sure seemed like that, to Melissa Horiek. Because whenever the topic of the King Frederick Incident was brought up in any place, in any conversation, people some how carefully avoided it by all means. If it was because they were afraid to be reminded of their future, Melissa would quite understand that. But there was something more to it. Like something came to a sudden halt the moment the curse was upon Sham.
Everyone liked to avoid the topic, that was true. Except for Melissa Horiek, that is – possibly the first one in centuries not to be so afraid of such a thing. And that was what caused conflict with her so much. No one understood her, and she hardly understood anybody.
Most often than not she felt like an outcast.
And most often than not the normal people of Sham looked upon her like she was more like a wild animal with nothing but savageness within it than a real, living girl. A girl that felt like everything around her was falling apart, or maybe that she herself was causing this wreck, but that it couldn’t be her fault; it couldn’t. After all, why blame her that everyone else was just as ignorant as pieces of driftwood with no concern of anything?
Melissa sighed, having the feeling one would probably get if he or she could feel bags coming under their eyes.
I wonder what Jennifer would be like if she came “alive” again, just like the other Cursed Ones? Melissa thought dazily. Right after she got her darned Accident…
That’s what people in Sham called deaths before eighty. “Accidents.”
Oh, but how lucky all those seniors are! Yet then, what would it feel like to be all old and weathering when everyone around you was yet “younger” than you? Would that make you feel older than ever, or….smaller than ever?
She decided it didn’t matter. As long as another family member didn’t die, it would be alright.
Melissa went to open the window, and breathed in a cool gust of fresh air. It felt dry in her throat and bitter in her mouth, so she closed it again and went downstairs. Once she checked the oven clock, she knew her mom was right.
It was 6:30; time to get to school.
School. Melissa groaned again, and for some reason, had a feeling that if her mother was there, she would be driven mad.
Education was not the very best thing for a mourning person, either.
After packing lunch and her schoolbag, she was out the door.
Melissa ran through the dark of the trees, hoping that no one saw her dashing figure as she speeded along the forest. There was hardly any light to guide her way, though the path was terribly familiar. It was a route she took day and night to get to and from school. She knew this by heart; even the first time she came, she had a vague feeling of where to go. The wind guided her way down the hill, into the trenches, into the valley of where the small school of Eastern Sham lies.
Was that what her Accident going to be? Getting mulled by a wild creature of some sort?!
But when she did get there, she could not believe her luck.
There, right there, was her sister Jennifer.
And she wasn’t even buried, either.
“Jennifer!” Melissa shouted, and sprinted towards her as fast as her legs could possibly carry her.
How come they didn’t even bother burying her? In normal circumstances Melissa would probably have some kind of tantrum on a calamity like that, but right now she was much too excited and shocked to get into a fit.
“WHAT happened? Why didn’t they bury you –" She shouted at her sister, trying to catch some light in her blank goldfish eyes, and once she realized that there was no point in reanimating a corpse, she sighed and sat back down on the grass. Her heart was pumping madly like jackhammers against her chest. There was no hope. Oh, man she thought, feeling frustration when small molecules of tears began to form at her tear ducts. Not now, please, not now…
But then, slowly, as impossible as it was, Jennifer’s eyes turned, along with her head. For a moment they caught Melissa’s.
They were completely white.
And then Melissa was sure. She was completely sure.
Jennifer – Jennifer Horiek– was, without a doubt, a Cursed One.
Jennifer opened her mouth, as though to say something, but the only thing that came out of it was an inhuman groan; something that belonged more to a monster than the what-used-to-be sister of Melissa.
And as the girl saw this, she screamed.


I know, it's kind of bad. But I don't know what to do about it... :oops:
Last edited by mminc13 on Sat Mar 13, 2010 9:37 pm, edited 7 times in total.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 42906
Reviews 240
Hey, mminc13...welcome to YWS! I'm Kaedee, and I'll be reviewing your story today. First of all, I was sold as soon as I heard this line:

mminc13 wrote:The aliens have been there forever, as long as we could imagine, to the days when our ancient planet was called Earth.
It got me interested, knowing that this story was to take place in the far future. You did a pretty good job with the prologue part, which I will mainly be reviewing today. You have an interesting idea there that I like. I think it would be nice if you could be more descriptive of the princess's (narrator) surroundings, especially since this is taking place in the far future. Chapter One was a bit confusing for me. It needs much more work than the prologue. And is this all taking place before or after the prologue? I don't understand.

Here are some corrections for you on the prologue.

mminc13 wrote:I immediately began seeing changes in the things I once loved, the things I once ignored. Things became more evil, as I began to see things that I haven’t noticed before: ghosts, strange shapes and creatures that lurk in the darkness.

In what way did things become more evil?

mminc13 wrote:My sisters were kind to me, I, as the youngest of the few.
I would re-write this sentence like this: 'My sisters were kind to me as I was the youngest of the few.'

mminc13 wrote:According to her, I also had wide, coal-black eyes, and a pale skin.
'Had'? The reader learns further on that the princess's eyes become different when she becomes powerful, but does her skin ever change? I at least got the impression that it didn't.

mminc13 wrote:We all had bright futures, each and every one of us.
You don't need the 'each and every one of us' part.

mminc13 wrote:and they will strength me.
You can't say 'strength me'. But you can say 'strengthen me'.

mminc13 wrote:Along the streets I met an elderly man, so old and yellowing and sickened that I pitied him. He was crossing the wet, raining streets. I still remembered how I rushed out there to help him, as he started to trip and fall over.
“Oh, princess!” he exclaimed. “You saved me!”
You can say 'sick' instead of 'sickened'...I think that would be better! The 'raining streets'? Or do you mean it was raining on the street? I would re-write the second to last sentence like this: 'I still remember how I rushed out there to help him when he was just about to trip and fall over.' That would make more sense.

mminc13 wrote:The old man changed, too: becoming more green, his skin more stiff and scaly, strange iron-like feathers out of his back, also with spikes and thorns. His eyes turned blood-shot, then getting purple, then becoming black. But I hardly noticed.
That's kind of odd to hardly notice those big changes...I would re-write the sentence like this: The old man changed too: he became more green, his skin became stiffer and scaly, strange iron-like feathers grew out of his back, and spikes and thorns. His eyes became blood-shot, then became purple, then black.' You change tenses a lot, which is a problem.

mminc13 wrote:I noticed how my sisters were not going to get the throne, I got extremely envious.
Huh? Why would you get envious if your sisters were not going to get the throne?

mminc13 wrote:But one day when the fact that they looked down on me was more dominant, I cursed both of them forever: casting Kartika under the tall Mount Warzit and turning her into an unbelievably ugly creature along with her followers, and turned Anastasia into a meaningless blob with her followers, throwing them into the universe of only other people’s dreams for the rest of eternity.Mother and Father did not know of this, though they did notice how my normally coal black eyes started to have intricate red lines within the middle of them.
Again, the tense problem! :) You should say "peoples'". You should tell the reader that the princess herself became more evil. And how could her mom and dad not know of this?

mminc13 wrote:“Your kingdom is in prosperity right now.” He said. But then he gravely continued. “But it soon would be no longer. Many things are going to happen, my Queen; beware.” I did not know how the gnome got into here, but I got angry. “How dare you say that!” I snapped at him. “What would bring my kingdom down .”
You should say that bad things are going to happen, not just 'things'. And you should say that her kingdom is prosperous, not 'in prosperity'. You need a ?mark instead of a period at the end of the last sentence.

mminc13 wrote:“Somewhere in the future, a young girl would bring your kingdom down. A girl no more than a decade years old, with fire for her hair and the sea for her eyes, and red stars twinkling along her nose.”
Tense problem. You don't really need 'years'.

Chapter One I found very confusing...I think you ought to re-think it a bit! Some things that you say don't really make sense, things are unclear. I think you should just possibly re-write that small section. Think over the ideas for a couple of days. Perhaps that would help? :)

This story is promising...I hope you benefit from my corrections! I'll be looking forward to finding out what will happen next. Keep up the good work-

Kaedee
Perfect things in life aren't things.
Spoiler
*_______*




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 15337
Reviews 126
Hi, PenNPaper here to review!
My sisters were kind to me, I, as the youngest of the few

This doesn't flow smoothly. How about rephrasing it to 'My sisters were kind to me as I was the youngest of the few'?
to the days when our ancient planet was called Earth.

Were you trying to say 'from'?
. “What would bring my kingdom down .”

It seems here that you are asking, so it should be a question mark, or if you are angry, maybe an exclamation mark.
Only a few days ago, her and Jennifer were

It should be 'she and Jennifer'.

Okay this story was good overall, I liked it. Especially in the first part when you became a villain.

Good luck and keep writing, bye for now!
Writing is all about imagination~




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3686
Reviews 16
Okay. How do I put this simply. To say the least, it's very interesting, and I think that it is for certain a story that I will be following as long as you continue to write. I only saw a few trouble spots that I feel should be touched on a little bit, other than the ones mentioned above, which I soundly agree with.

I was born with pale white-blond hair, according to my mother, Queen Tania, who ruled justly and well along side my father, King Zain.


I find this piece of your story to be out of place. It's true, you are describing her mother, but it draws the thoughts away from the original purpose of the paragraph, to describe her appearance. Perhaps there is another way to phrase it? I'm not sure. I only know that it distracts from what your reader should see.

I immediately began seeing changes in the things I once loved, the things I once ignored.


This sentence is phrased strangely too, as though she regrets this, and then the rest of the paragraph makes it sound as though she herself is going evil. I think this could also be rephrased to something a little more appropriate. Not to mention that the line seems to make the things she loved the things she ignored. I can understand how that works, but you need to make sure it doesn't confuse the people reading it.

I don't have any specific quotes for this, but you sometimes reuse words in two sentences that are too close together. I find that I do this as well, more than I would like to, and it makes you sound like you can't come up with another word for what you have to say. My suggestion is to read over what you've written yourself and see if you can fix that.

But, seriously – nevertheless, Melissa still felt awful.


This is another sentence you have that doesn't quite fit the context around it. What do you mean by "But, seriously"? And then when you mentioned that Melissa still felt awful... it just doesn't sound right to me. Forgive me if I'm wrong.

Toward the end of your first chapter, it seems to end strangely. I learned for a book about writing once that you need to treat each chapter as though it is a story of it's own. it needs to have an expository, the rising action, then a climax, and many times it ends there to lead into the next chapter. The way you wrote that last paragraph just seemed too anti-climatic.

Finally, since I'm sure you are glad to be rid of my awful ranting, I only have to say that your first chapter lacks details. For that, I make a suggestion from Gail Carson Levine. When you think about writing details, imagine that you yourself are in this situation. If you can't do that, then think of experiences similar to that, when you have been sad about something, even when it's something that has nothing to do with death, then try to compare that to how your character's feeling. That should work well, it works for me almost every time.

All-in-all, I think that this story has real potential. I'm looking forward to see what else you have in store for me to read. :smt001
"'It is some time since I last heard the sound of your shears. How long have you been Eavesdropping?'

'Eavesdropping, sir? I don't follow you, begging your pardon. There ain't no eaves at Bag End and that's a fact!'"

- Sam Gamgee and Gandalf the Grey. The Fellowship of the Ring, Pg. 70.




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 1657
Reviews 2
Thank you everyone that helped me with this!!!! My thankfulness is so great I'm not sure if i could express all of it. Thank you thank you thank you.
I will try my best to revise it. I know it's kinda bad.... :smt002




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3740
Reviews 22
Awesome job! It's really interesting! There are a few errors, but other then that, GREAT JOB! =) =3
ALL HAIL ATHENA!

"If you are mad at someone, walk a mile in their shoes. That way, you're a mile away from them and you have their shoes." -Anonymous (I forgot)




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 3103
Reviews 3
Hey mminc :)

I'm here to give a small review, not anything big, just putting forth my opinions on the whole story etc..

Well, I really enjoyed the concept, the whole idea of the story. I really believe that you can make something from this, a really good story. I also liked the ending sentence, however I believe you could have made something more 'powerful' to finish it off.

I'm sincerely sorry I can't do a longer review, but I've got a short amount of time and several stories I'd like to review :(
Cold Zero: The Sniper's term for the one shot you get at finishing the job, the final, irrevocable pull of the trigger. For some people, it is not that moment...

It is a state of mind.




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 1657
Reviews 2
Note: I was going to put chapter 2 here, but i put it somewhere else. sorry for the inconvenience.
Last edited by mminc13 on Thu Mar 04, 2010 1:31 am, edited 1 time in total.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 3103
Reviews 3
Mminc, you post stories chapter by chapter in YWS. However each chapter has to be in a different topic.
Cold Zero: The Sniper's term for the one shot you get at finishing the job, the final, irrevocable pull of the trigger. For some people, it is not that moment...

It is a state of mind.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 19723
Reviews 225
Hey there MMinc!

Okay so I read the chapter. It had a lot of problems, but everyone else seemed to have said them already, so I won't bother.

Moving on, I thought your story base was really good. The alien thing got me interested in the story since it's not a commonly used story. Although I was confused at some points, the story seemed to follow through well. I liked the cursed one idea, it seems really cool, although quite creepy, in a way. :lol:

I suggest one thing though, for future reference: instead of making one page for the prologue and first chapter, separate them into two different pages. Like that, people will get really intrigued by just the prologue since it's really good. So whether or not you do it for this one, it doesn't matter, but for any other book or story you want to write, I'd consider that.

Except for that, I'd just be careful with grammar errors. Rereading your chapters before posting can always be helpful :wink:

Overall, really good story. I'll go read chapter 2 later on...
Got a story you'd like reviewed?
topic75101.html

Punctuation is the difference between "Let's eat, Grandma" and "Let's eat Grandma".




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 12900
Reviews 110
Hi mminc,

Just some quick comments for you today.

I found the opening dry. It's essentially an infodump, a pile of information about the protagonist's physical appearance and family tree, presented without any real attempt to interest the reader. I only perked up when the aliens arrived.

I do like your ability to deliver a surprise twist in a short, pithy way: "Then I met the aliens." "Was it really their fault that each time a child in their family died – which, so far all of them did except for the youngest, Melissa – that they just came up from the dead again?" Both of these twists genuinely surprised me.

I also thought that the writing, while usually no more than serviceable, becomes almost poetic at times: I particularly enjoyed this line - "A girl no more than a decade years old, with fire for her hair and the sea for her eyes".

I think my key problem here was with the characterisation. The story seems very distant, especially at the beginning, as if the viewpoint character is looking back into the past without much emotion. I felt like I wasn't being allowed into the viewpoint characters' heads, so I never truly understood any of the characters. Two examples:

    Medara, a girl with a "warm heart" and adoring family, agrees to the alien's deal so fast she practically snaps his hand off. We aren't told why. What does she feel about this offer? Why does she take it? Does it occur to her that there might be a catch? How does she feel about the changes she undergoes?

    Only hours after the harrowing death of her daughter, Melissa's mother skips off to work as if nothing has happened. Why isn't she curled in a ball sobbing? Why does she choose to soldier on? Why is everyone even letting her come to work hours after her daughter died?

And so on. I feel like I need much deeper, richer characterisation to be able to follow this story.

Hope this helps, mminc.

Cheers,
Karsten




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 690
Reviews 1
Well to stat off I really liked it. It was very creative and original, two things that I put very high on my "things that make a story good" list. I loved the way you opened with the villain, I just loved how it twisted from "awww, cute little girl" to "holy crap, she evil" I was totally epic. I would like to say though is that you seemed to slap me with a lot of information. and yet what you did tell me was so little. I felt like you only gave me like half a cake, instead of the who thing, but that's probably kuz I have yet to read the second chapter. But besides that good job :D. Good luck with the rest of it.
~AJ
"Weren't you banished to FoodCourtia? Shouldn't you be...frying something?"
"Oh, I quit that after I heard about this!"
"You quit being banished?!?!"
~Invader Zim



Stay gold, Ponyboy.
— S.E. Hinton