Shrive: Prologue

14 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 13816
Reviews 563
[removed, under revision]
Last edited by Writersdomain on Thu Oct 29, 2009 5:08 am, edited 1 time in total.
~ WD
If you desire a review from WD, post here

"All I know, all I'm saying, is that a story finds a storyteller. Not the other way around." ~Neverwas




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9692
Reviews 3900
Intriguing!

I don't really have any comments, per say, but only because it's intriguing and I'm wondering what is going to happen next. Which is good!

Questions I'm wondering:

Who were the people that in that house?

What role will the house play?

Who were these people and why do they matter?

Why those three words? They seem a bit odd on a tombstone.

And yeah. I would encourage you to keep writing, but you're kind of a writing machine, so just keep doing what you do best. And, again, it's lovely to see you on again. :)
Ubi caritas est vera, Deus ibi est.

"The mark of your ignorance is the depth of your belief in injustice and tragedy. What the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the Master calls the butterfly." ~ Richard Bach

Moth and Myth <- My comic! :D




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1618
Reviews 155
Allo Writersdomain --

On a hill beside a shimmering river, there stands a manor. Its walls are high and inside there stands a giant hall, gilded with gold and plastered with glistening paint. Around the hall stand numerous small houses and three long barracks built of black brick with cracked windows.


Nyeeeh, I'm not a fan of this opening. That awful comma makes it seem like the first sentence has a gigantic fracture jutting through the middle of it. And then you repeat the "there stands" bit in the second sentence, which makes ugly, unnecessary repetition. You go on with more boring physical descriptions, and they're not interesting enough to draw me in.

If you're trying to create a foreboding atmosphere from the get-go, take out the shimmering, gilded, and the glistening. Those words make the manor seem like a fairytale palace, and that confuses the mood.

*

One snowy evening I could see a doctor with his horse and a carriage storm into the manor, and men rode to the gates of the manor for news of its lord. Sir Medlon Kellan died on that cold January night, and his wife left the manor in the hands of their eldest son. That morning, a wounded sun rose—scarlet like a scar running across the sky, and the manor drank the blood of the sun.


Now I know I can be a total stickler about repetition but PLEASE MAKE IT STOP.

Prok wept.

*

the manor drank the blood of the sun.


I will say, though, that I absolutely love this, er, personification, whatever you'd call it. I dig this imagery.

*

Anyway, this could be a good prologue, but you've gotta tighten up a lot of your sentences. Some of them are needlessly awkward, and you might want to consider going easy on the adjectives. Find strong nouns instead.

Prokaryote




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6202
Reviews 38
I agree with Prokaryote, the opening isn't as good as the rest. It needs something attention-grabbing. This sounds like a great story, though! I want to find out what happens.

inside there stands a giant hall

'There stands' again. Giant sounds childish, maybe use something more interesting.

Around the hall stand numerous small houses

You don't need the numerous, it's nice without.

One snowy evening I could see a doctor

Maybe it's just me, but something seems wrong about the tenses there. I think it should be saw, not could see.

That morning, a wounded sun rose—scarlet like a scar running across the sky, and the manor drank the blood of the sun.

Just love this sentence, especially the 'wounded sun'. Brilliant.

In the shadow of the city, there stands a gate

Enough with the 'there stands'!

Dust. Blood. Glass.

This is our confession.

This, above all the rest, gets my attention and makes me want to read on. It's exciting.
"What if, doctor, we need these knots and these tangles because they're the only things holding our souls down - and if we untied the knots and untangled the tangles and stretched them out ... would our souls just float away?"
~Luke Kennard, A Practical Course in Entry Level Expressionism




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 12534
Reviews 93
Wow, nice imagery^^ It really does grab my attention, the beginning is a little boring, particularly because I don't care much for the small houses or barracks. The end is very interesting, however, and I am left wanting to know more. Which is good^^ Well done.
Most people see what is and never what can be. - Albert Einstein




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5407
Reviews 75
Lovely. Is it going to be a horror story? If so it sounds like a good scary one. OK, I want to know what happens to the house, does anyone else live in it after it's been boarded up, how about the two adopted daughters? Do they connect in the story somehow? Or the wife, or is she so torn up by her husbands sudden death that she can't bare look upon the manor? I love love love, the last sentence.
"This is our confession."
Superb! That right there just makes my head go in twenty different directions. Great job!
The heart wants, the body needs, and the mind suffers. - me




User avatar
Gender Other
Points 4759
Reviews 39
Don;t really have too much to say about this. All I can really say is Bravo. This kept me interested even with mostly description and non character interactive action (which to keep me into is very difficult) and made me wonder what was going to happen next, and makes me want to skip through time to find out.

The description was smooth and well worded, and gave me a wonderful picture of what you were displaying. I can honestly say I had a cat run down my spine by the house pure image Please post the follow up! Or I will find you....
That User Who Changed Their Name A Dozen Times And So No One Ever Knew Who They Were Half the Time and When They Did Only Used Bolt.

The tragic tale of losing all #Brand for nothing in return.

The Take Away Is You Probably Know Me As Bolt




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 42011
Reviews 922
'allo, 'allo. I know I'm a latecomer here, so I'll try to avoid repeating anything people have already said unless it bears repeating.

Okay, my first comment is actually on the title. This is the prologue to "Shrive", yes? If so, I'd say that in the title. Something like "Shrive - Prologue". As is, the title is about the next worst thing to titling it "Untitled". You have a title (unlike most of my works... >.>), so use it! Treat the world to your genius!

Moving on from that...

The first two paragraphs: I know a lot of people talked about how they didn't care about the house in the beginning. My suggestion would actually be to take the first two sentences of the first paragraph, then talk about the family, then add on whatever other information needs to be added in how idyllic it used to be all in one paragraph. This makes us immediately care about some people.

Then add the descriptions about how it has fallen basically into ruin later on, after we hear about the family departing and whatnot. It would add to the "before and after" idea.

The last few lines were wonderful. Chilling and suspenseful. I was getting serious "horrific fairytale" vibes by the end of it.

I want more. Must move on to your first chapter...

~GryphonFledgling
I am reminded of the babe by you.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 53415
Reviews 1125
WD!

So I've been meaning to look at this for a while... I don't know why I haven't reviewed, to be honest...

I. NITPICKS

Its walls are high and inside there stands a giant hall,


I... ah, okay. This confused me, because I thought you meant a hall like, you know, a hall, that when you open the front door of your house, it's there, and I was going to say that halls don't really stand, they stretch. But alright, I see what you mean. That's not what you're talking about at all... but it did throw me off.

to be clean and white like the clouds that barely shadowed a sun.


... a sun? Because there's more than one sun for you to be talking about?

That morning, a wounded sun rose—scarlet like a scar running across the sky, and the manor drank the blood of the sun.


rose-scarlet? Is there supposed to be a space in here somewhere...?

Okay...

II. WORDINESS

To be honest, in some places this read a bit like you were trying to confuse us. That may be because I'm quite simple minded and thus enjoy simple prose, but all the same. Your sentences got a bit meandering in places and they took me several goes to understand. Though your writing is really good, it just threw me off when you did this. Don't be afraid to break sentences up, to look at new ways of saying things. To be honest, reading your other reviews, this is probably a matter of personal taste, and I wouldn't worry too much about it. It just kind of gave me the impression that you were trying to impress me rather than interest me. Again, I wouldn't worry too much, but it's just something for you to chew on.

III. OVERALL

I enjoyed it :) I'm going to go read Caibidil a Haon!

(... That's Chapter One.)

Hope I helped, drop me a note if you need anything!

-Stella x
"Stella. You were in my dream the other night. And everyone called you Princess." -Lauren2010




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1340
Reviews 5
I enjoyed this, it kept me hooked. Lots of people have critiqued this already and I'm not going to try and improve on that. Short piece so this is going to be short. A few things I liked to start off with.
The opening sentences i half agree with people; yes you need to maybe condense this a little, but you must keep some to set the scene in my opinion. There does seemed to be a quite a bit of words that meander into different things that I'm not too keen on. Repetition has been already picked up on so I won’t hold your attention for that.
Overall great use of imagery, I would definitely like to see the next part as that last sentence got me going.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 4198
Reviews 30
Hmm…I don’t know what to make of this one. But I do know it sounds interesting, I hope you do keep writing. This story hits me as sort of a dark tale. I think that there is defiantly something to hide and perhaps something going on inside the manor.

All the best




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 37290
Reviews 367
I enjoyed this section of your story a ton! Espescially the last line. It will stick with me forever, very memorable. 'This is our confession' is a great line. I am bursting with questions...and thats good. I cannot wait to read more.
"Chase your dreams, and remember me, speak bravery,
Because after all, those wings will take you up so high."
-- Owl City, "To the Sky"
✯ ✯ ✯




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2474
Reviews 47
Wow, that is a really good prolouge. It's very interesting, but I think that you should leave it alone and totally forget about it for about a week, then come back to it. You will read it and see places that you can add more to it, or where you can add something to make the whole description part just a wee but less confusing. I was a little bit confused about what had happened with the gate and the stone. I know that the stone is a gravestone, and I assume that it is for the guy that died, but has it really been out there for so long that the words have been worn away? That would take over a hundred years. And is the cold fence surrounding the gravestone, the house, or both? WHat became of the house? You were talking about it, then all of a sudden you changed focus to the gravestone. BUt, other than that, it was REALLY good. You have good description words and I love the way that you write.
Many ask me if I see the glass as half full or half empty. Well, I don't know about you, but I see the glass as, WHO DRANK HALF OF MY MILK?!?!?!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 8846
Reviews 531
Hiya, darling.

You know the drill. If you have any questions or my handwriting is illegible, please tell me.

Image

Image

I like how the prologue is in present tense. It gives it some staying power. I also like the contrast you have set up between what was and what is.

Hope this helps,
Cal.
Fraser: Stop stealing the blanket.
[Diefenbaker whines]
Fraser: You're an Arctic Wolf, for God's sake.
(Due South)

Hatter: Do I need a reason to help a pretty girl in a very wet dress? (Alice)

Got YWS?



"And what is the use of a book," thought Alice, "without pictures or conversations?"
— Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland