Bound :: Ch 2 :: being revised

12 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1759
Reviews 8
Before I begin- or, rather, you begin- I want to mention that for some reason this chapter was a pain in the arse to get out, and I struggled with it a lot. I had to force a lot of things onto the page where normally I could bleed my fingers typing so fast and long. Thus said, please give me harsh critique! I know there are plenty of things wrong with this chapter, but I just can't see them. I'm hoping you guys will. Thank you, beforehand, for your time and effort! Also, the chapters will be a bit (or a lot) longer than the prologue, so I'll have to submit them in two to three segments. I'll probably post them in the same thread- so if you're desperate to read it (ha!) you should check back. Or ask me in your post to inform you by PM when I post the next part.

Please read:
Bound :: Chapter One

Chapter Two
Sun filtered through the shutters, a ladder of light stretched out across the bed. Asher stirred, waking to the warmth on his face, and reluctantly sat up to brush dark curls from his eyes. He could hear cabinet doors opening and closing in the cooking room, clay pots grating against each other as his mother prepared the morning meal. Laiala was still asleep in her own bed, a stubborn lump under fur blankets. She refused to get up until food was ready and its scents wafted through the open door.
Asher half-tamed the dark, tangled forest he stubbornly believed to be hair, and dressed quickly. His mother offered him a smile as he stepped into the cramped room, ducking, as usual, to avoid collision with the pans hanging from the wall.
“Surely you’re not going in that!” she admonished, placing flour powdered hands on her hips as she inspected him. The boy glanced down at his academy clothes, plain blue trousers and a white robe.
“Mem, I wear this to school every day.” He pulled a face, leaning against the counter and appreciatively sniffing the seasoned vegetables and eggs. Vanelle smiled again and tilted her face away from him so he wouldn’t see her amusement.
“Surely The Council would appreciate your best clothes at-”
“The Ceremony!” Asher jerked upright with cognizance, then fled out of the room, just barely remembering to duck under the pans. His sister sidestepped to let him pass, then splayed out her skirts and spun slowly to show her mother. She was fitted in a lavender violet chemise, with a dark purple skirt and white blouse. She had painted a swirling design below her left eye, and black hair washed down her back in a wave of curls.
“You’re beautiful, dear,” Vanelle murmured, pulling off her smock and wiping her hands on a cloth. “You look just like my mother.” She smiled wistfully, watching her daughter spin around a second time. “You’d best go help Ash. Sky knows what he deems appropriate formal wear.”
Laiala grinned. “Sky knows what he deems inappropriate formal wear.” She turned and followed her brother’s trail back to the bed room, finding him in the midst of his upturned wardrobe. He glanced over at her as she came in, frustration creasing lines between his eyebrows. He had stripped himself of garments, leaving only his white cloth undergarments, and was holding up three different trousers. He dropped them when Laiala delicately stepped over the cloth covered floor.
“This is impossible,” he stated, gritting his teeth and kicking at a pile.
“Trying to find the perfect outfit that says ‘I should get a dragon’?” Laiala teased, kneeling down to shuffle through a pile. “Damn it, Ash, what were you thinking? Now the clothes you wear will be wrinkled.” He crossed his arms and grudgingly allowed her to hold up a pair of red pants to his legs. She studied it for a moment, then tossed it down and searched some more.
“Will you hurry it up?”
“Found it!” She produced cream-colored trousers, threw them at Asher, then dug deeper and pulled out a crimson shirt. “You’ll look beautiful.”
“Beautiful?” he scowled, but she ignored him and pushed the cloth into his chest.
“Change,” she demanded. They glared each other down for several seconds, arguing with their gazes, then Asher turned away and stepped haphazardly into the pants.

The road seemed mercilessly long that morning. Asher wasn’t sure if it was the nauseous feeling in his chest, or his sister griping about dust on her skirt. Folks still had paper lanterns hanging from their houses, a silent reminder of the wish he had made the previous week. He crossed his thumbs in the folds of his robe and wished again.
The academy was bustling with activity, a sure sign to onlookers that something was happening. Students were talking among themselves, as usual, but sixth year students spoke louder, laughed longer, and joked every time they got a chance. Asher could hear the anxiety beneath the excitement, and he smirked at it all. Such morons. There was no use being nervous about something you had no control over.
He crossed his arms to hide his own shaking hands.
“Asher! Laia!” A familiar hat bobbed up to them through the ocean of people, and Jate stumbled out before them. He took Laiala’s hand and kissed it lavishly, extracting a few giggles from her. “You look beautiful, as always,” he mumbled against her skin, keeping his lips there until Asher kicked him. Straightening, he surveyed his friend. “And you look… decent.”
“Shut up.” Asher grinned. “I can’t believe you’re still wearing that stupid hat. You couldn’t leave it home for this one occasion?” Jate pulled it off, exposing the top of his mousy brown hair, and casually inspected the black material.
“I think it’s perfectly formal,” he said pretentiously. “Unlike that ragged excuse for pants you’re wearing.”
Laiala pressed her hand against Asher’s chest before he could lunge out at the boy. “Stop bickering like children! Kesha is gathering the class.” She grabbed her brother’s sleeve and pulled him through the crowd towards their mentor.
“-and fetch Henia and Toshi, will you?” Kesha was telling a boy. “They’ve wandered off somewhere.” Shouldering her way through the crowd, oblivious to manners as usual, Laiala squished herself between two people at the very front. Asher stood behind her, finally released, and crossed his arms again.
“Nervous?” Jate looked up at him, but Asher refused to meet his friend’s eyes. After ten years, Jate had gotten good at reading them.
“No,” he scoffed back, digging his fingers into his forearm. “Why would I be?” He glanced at the person next to him, a stocky girl who greeted him sometimes in the corridor, though they’d never been formally introduced. Now she only had eyes for their mentor.
“I’m nervous, too,” Jate said after several minutes. Asher swallowed a sigh. “What if I get a- a sheep? Or something worse.” He shuddered.
“Everyone! Quiet down!” Kesha called.
“A rat?” Asher offered, and earned himself a glare.
“You’re not helping.”
“Shh!” Laiala punched Jate halfheartedly, then turned back to the teacher in the center of the circle.
“Silence, now!” Kesha bellowed over the pandemonium. She tapped her fingers against her hip impatiently as the deer totem hanging around her neck glowed a soft yellow. Whispered shut up’s and listen’s ran through the crowd, and the clamor silenced.
After gazing around at the faces closest to her, she relaxed. “Right. Now. I know you are all excited- trust me, I know- but listen closely. The most due respect must go to me, yourselves, the guides, and The Council-” The name started a buzz of noise, and the woman closed her eyes until it ended. “The carriages will arrive here shortly, and you will be in the hands of the guides. They will show you around Amayil in groups- you are to be silent, and listen to what they have to say. The city’s history is important, believe it or not, and when we get back you will be tested on what you learned.” No groaning protests, surprisingly. Asher uncrossed his arms, watching the back of his twin’s head. No doubt she was soaking all this up like a new sponge in the well. “Individually, you will be called upon by a messenger, who will be wearing The Council’s emblem on his collar. He will bring you before Them, and you will be Judged. You will be Bound. And then, you will be brought back outside, where I will be waiting. That is as much information as I can give you on that matter.” Kesha paused, her eyes meeting Asher’s, as was understandable. His head was far above the rest of the student’s, and therefore easier to look at than a swell of eyes and faces. Still, it unnerved him, and he was glad to respectfully lower his gaze.
“We will arrive home late today if weather or circumstance permits; if not, early tomorrow. Your guides will explain regulations to you in the carriages. Are we understood?” A chorus of agreement, then voices yelling again, bodies moving away from the pack to dawdle around the field, now clear of lesser year peers. Laiala turned around to face Asher, her ocean eyes bright with exhilaration.
“Can you believe it?” she squealed, making both him and Jate flinch. “Today’s finally come! Finally!” She spun on her heels, stumbled, and Asher grabbed her shoulders to gently settle her back on her feet.
“Yes. So don‘t kill yourself before it‘s barely started,” he admonished, holding back a smile and not moving his hands away. She could feel them tremble against her blouse, and she pressed a palm over his knuckles.
“You’ll get a lion. I know you will. We wished on it.”
He swallowed. Yes, but that’s not what I want. “Wishes don’t always come true, Lai.”
“Ours will.” She patted his arm, then shaded her eyes against the sun. “The carriages! They’re coming! Come on, come, come!” In her haste, she even forgot to snatch hold of Asher. He followed more slowly as her and Jate ran with the rest of their peers to gape at the formality of it all.
A presence came at his side, unwelcome, but not leaving. “Tor Kesha,” he said courteously. She chuckled.
“I hope you and Mr. Jate will behave. It would be rather unfortunate for a repeat of Nuadar to occur, wouldn’t it?”
“Rather unfortunate,” Asher agreed, flinching at the memory. It had seemed fun, at the time, to ignore orders and jump the bull pasture fence. The consequences had proven otherwise. He looked down at the woman; her white mentor robes with the academy’s horse emblem galloping on the elongated sleeves stood out against her dark South Region skin. She looked back up at him, harshly for a moment, then her face softened.
“Everything will be fine, Asher. You will be Bound to a very honorable creature.”
Teacher or no, he couldn’t prevent his snide tone, it was the only emotion that covered his hope. “How would you know?”
“Because I am years beyond your age, and I know these things. I’ve witnessed countless girls and boys being Bound.”
“Ash!” Jate yelled to him, and gestured frantically for him to hurry.
“I should go. Thank you, Tor Kesha.” He took off towards the carriage Jate was leaning precariously from, not glancing back to see her sad smile. He climbed inside, crushed himself between the guide and a protesting Jate, and knocked knees with the girl sitting across from him. She smiled, and he looked away.
“Where’s Laia?” he demanded.
“Went in a different carriage,” Jate responded, resting his hat in his lap and fussing with his hair. “This is Asher,” he told the guide cramped into the corner. The man nodded and hastily scribbled it down on a small writing pad, his eye glasses slipping to the end of his nose. He pushed them back with a knuckle and glanced around at the five students.
“Right. So shall we begin the rules?”
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++



Another note before you begin (this is the second part of chapter one). I changed Asher's name to Kodi. For personal reasons, and also because there is a semi-new book published called The Innocent Mage by Karen Miller (it's actually very good and I suggest it to you if you're reading Bound), in which the main character is named Asher. And his best friend's name begins with a J. I wasn't going to let it bug me, but it ended up doing so anyways. I just felt like I was stealing Karen Miller's characters, which is not the case at all. So. Asher = Kodi. No other changes were made.
I also want to thank everyone who critiqued the first part of chapter one, and also anyone who replied to the prologue as well. You guys have been so awesome, and I love hearing your feedback, good or bad. So please do what you can to rip apart this following. I'll love you eternally.

RATED PG13 for slight language. It's actually not even PG13 worthy, but I know some people are sensitive about swears.

Chapter One (Part Two)

The city stretched around them for miles; more colors and scents and people than Kodi had ever seen at a Moonflower Festival. He stared up at the monstrous buildings, awe smothering the air from his lungs. They loomed over the streets, watching the crowd crammed together between their marble walls. Marble- not mud brick. Marble.

"Boys- girls- stay together please," their guide yammered, nervously herding the five teenagers into a circle. "This building that we're stopped at is the Amayil Archives, first built when the Nurrians fled the civil war in the North...”

"Whoa," Jate breathed, his neck craned all the way back to see the carving above the library's gateway.

“...it was burned down during Resuku’s Revolt, and was restored to accommodate a larger collection of books and information in the Kiielo Dynasty three decades later...”

“Imagine living here.” Kodi looked around at the people pushing past their small group, and the finely groomed horses pulling carriages down the cobble stone street. Bounds, in both human and animal form, followed their Guardians.

"Now if you'll come this way- come this way, please, all of you." The man started down the street, and the five teenagers followed him.

"I feel like a duckling," muttered Jate. "I wonder where the other groups went off to."

"Must have all gone different ways," Kodi said absently, only half listening to his friend. There was a lady and her chameleon Bound selling some strange fruit, most likely from the South Region. Kesha was always going on about her home's colorful diet. And there- a person, with the tail and ears of a mouse, helping his Guardian load chicken crates into a carriage. Everything was everywhere. The buildings, Bounds roaming freely, carriages, and venders- selling rugs, clothes, meat, fruit, sweetmeats and pastries and everything. Kodi could hardly see it all, even with a head's height above all the others.

But his awe passed quickly, fading to boredom- with the help of the guide's droning voice. Jate obviously felt the same, his hands shoved deep into his pockets with his head lolling back. He couldn't concentrate if nothing exciting happened. "Do you think-"

"No," Kodi cut him off quickly.

"You don't even know what I was going to say!"

"You want to run off somewhere. I said no." The boy halted, and Kodi warily stopped as well. "Jay-"

"Come on, Ko. We need an adventure. We haven't done anything exciting since-"

"We got thrown around by bulls?" He clenched his jaws together, remembering Kesha's warning. "You can run off and have an 'adventure' if you want. I'm sticking with the group." He spun around on his heel- and faced a mass of unfamiliar faces. Stunned, he whipped back to his friend's brilliant grin. "You-!"

"Race you to the library!" Jate took off down the street, one hand securing his hat against his head. Kodi followed quickly, his heart squeezing in his throat. Kesha was going to kill them- slaughter them.

"Jate!" he called angrily, trying to catch up. If he lost his friend, he'd be completely alone in some strange street in the largest city of Kaean. He jostled past people, ignoring their complaints, keeping his eyes secured on Jate's obnoxious hat. Until something caught against his foot and he went sprawling out over the cobblestones. His senses blanked, and he floated on a cloud of pain for some time.

"Geez, you're awfully pathetic." The scorning voice lifted him out of the reverie. "You look like a bird that's flown into a window."

"Help me up," Kodi muttered through clenched teeth, and a second later an arm wounded around his shoulders to unsteadily lift him to his feet. He could feel Jate's breath against his face, and he winced and turned away from it. "You really need to chew on mint more often."

The other boy laughed as Kodi straightened some more, pressing a hand to his back.

"Good, you're being an asshole like usual. I thought you might have banged your head up and would start giving out flowers to children."

"Shut up. It's my shoulder that I hit." He pressed a hand to it, causing pain to shoot across his collarbone. Gritting his teeth, he pushed Jate off of him and looked around. The hustle of the street was dimmed, rushing past the small seclude they were in. The dirt under Kodi's worn boots was much softer than the cobblestone streets they had been traversing the past few hours. "Where the hell are we?"

"I dragged you off into an alley before you were trampled. You've got to cut down on those starsweets, y'know. I could barely lug you a foot." Jate patted Kodi's stomach, then pushed his hat back to survey the brick wall. "Guess they aren't so rich and mighty that they can afford marble all 'round."

Kodi wasn't listening to him. "Look at this." He brushed his fingers against a jumble of nonsense symbols, written into the brick with black chalk. Jate pressed up next to him to squint at it.

"What does that mean?"

"I don't know, it's... weird. I've never seen anything like it before."

"It's a different language." Jate traced one of the symbols with his thumb, eyebrows knitted together.

"That's impossible. There's no such thing."

"It's called Hyento." The two boys jumped and instinctually spun around at the new voice. The woman twined her fingers together to rest them over her pregnant stomach. “The language of Seers.” Kodi glanced over at Jate, then back at the lady. She offered them a sad smile. “Do you know why your people are Bound?”

“It’s always been that way.” Jate, for once, was bashful in front of her beauty. Kodi wasn’t sure if it was because she was carrying, or because she was quite obviously wiser than them. Not more knowledgeable, like their mentors, but wiser. It surrounded her words like a thick cloak, choking out any argument.

“No, not always.” She was staring up at Kodi, but he felt infinitely small beneath her gaze. “You are Bound because there is magic inside of you. Magic too great for one person. So it is divided, between a Guardian and a Bound, and therefore neither are too powerful. That is what creates the Bound; your own magic. Not The Council’s.”

“Ah,” was all Jate could say, his voice faltering in that one syllable.

“Who are ‘seers’?” Kodi asked, determined not to feel so belittled by this woman. But she simply shook her head and turned her back to them. Her hair, redder than any fire Kodi had ever seen, fell almost to her waist.

“My name is Evalen,” she whispered, her voice blowing around Kodi’s ears like wind.

“Evalen-” he began, but she was gone. He blinked, blinked again, then turned to Jate, who was staring at the Hyento again. “That was odd,” he said after a second.

“What was?” his friend asked, not looking up at him. He was tracing with his thumb again, trying to make sense of the faded black lines.

“Evalen.”

“Who?” Jate met his eyes now, and Kodi saw in them no Evalen, no Hyento, no fiery hair. Jate did not remember.

“Nevermind,” Kodi said softly, then cleared his throat. “Nevermind,” he repeated, louder. “We have to find the group.” Laiala would have been proud of him as he grabbed Jate’s arm and pulled him off down the street. It wasn’t until they had finally located the group and the tour guide was yittering on to them about the importance of staying together and not getting lost, that Kodi realized what the woman had said. Your people. Not our people. And she didn't wear a totem; did that mean she had no Bound? No, that was impossible. He stared past the tour guide's shoulder, trying to make sense of it all. Hyento, Evalen and her disappearance, the absence of a Bound, and Jate's sudden memory loss.

Adventure was kissing the edge of his mind, but he wasn't so sure that he wanted it. Adventure was Jate's occupation, not his.

“Are you listening to me?” the guide waved his notepad in front of Kodi’s nose. “Why would you even want to run off like that? You could get lost! These streets aren’t safe at night! I would lose my job!”

“Excuse me-” the man whipped around to face the boy who interrupted, but he stood his ground against the rage. “Is this boy Kodi of Senyuur?” The guide finally noticed the winged staff sewn into the messenger’s collar, and bent low in apology. The dove sitting on the boy’s shoulder tweeted sweetly, fluffing up her wings.

“Yes, yes it is.” He wrung his hands together nervously. “My deepest sorrow for-” He was waved away so the messenger could step up to Kodi. Jate nudged his side.

“Kodi of Senyuur?”

It took a moment for him to find his voice. “Yes, sir?”

“If you would follow me, please.” He began making his way through the crowd, slipping easily between the people. Kodi followed silently, fear clamping his throat shut.
Last edited by Dr. Tick Tock on Thu Sep 24, 2009 12:17 pm, edited 4 times in total.
|Doctor is prone to rants. Slap her if she starts rambling.|




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3981
Reviews 24
Hello Doctor. :) You said be harsh, so harsh I shall be. . .

But you should be pleased to know that there's really not too much to harshly critique. The beginning was a little slow. I had trouble getting through the first paragraph. The rest of your story seemed to be a bit . . . lighter, than the beginning. I would encourage you to try and work that in, use something to instantly hook me when I begin reading.

I wanted a bit more description. Like I was wondering what the mom looked like. And also, when Asher says "Mem" I was wondering if that was a typo or if it was some nickname he has for her or if he has a speech impediment of sorts. But I think a bit more description would do some good. I want to know what this world Asher lives in looks like. Keep in mind it doesn't have to be long-winded descriptions, just some things thrown in here and there that help me know where the story is set.

Oh, and I didn't catch this before, but your post is called "Chapter One", but it's really the prologue? You might want to clarify that a little better.

Honestly, that's about all I can think of that I can critique on. I was really intrigued by the plot and you left me wanting to know what comes next in the story. I want to see what Asher is bound to, what the ceremony is, and what's the big deal about the Council.

Also, I absolutely loved your characters! I thought the voice was amazing and you had me laughing out loud. You made me care about them immediately, which I think is one of the most important things in a story.

I can't wait for more! :D
"Without hard work, nothing grows but weeds."
-Gordon B. Hinckley




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1759
Reviews 8
Okay, I promised I wouldn't post back in this one, but--

This isn't the prologue. I gave you a link back to the prologue, which I had posted previously on YWS. This is Chapter One (a segment of it, anyways). If you want to read the prologue click the link that says "Bound :: Prologue" and it will lead you to the thread.

EDIT: Oh yeah! Thanks for the critique! Geez, where are my manners?

.Doctor
|Doctor is prone to rants. Slap her if she starts rambling.|




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4198
Reviews 157
Hi, Doctor, here's me with the review. Since I'm very pressed on time I might not finish it in one go but rest assured I will get it done. ^^

Sun filtered through the shutters, a ladder of light stretched out across the bed.


You have a comma splice here, so either change that comma to an "and" are add a connecting word such as "causing".

He could hear cabinet doors opening and closing in the cooking room, clay pots grating against each other as his mother prepared the morning meal.


I'm thinking the comma would be better as an "and", since that would connect the second clause more to the first and make it seem less like it stands on its own, because it doesn't--it's just another sound in the kitchen. (is this making any sense...)

Asher half-tamed the dark, tangled forest he stubbornly believed to be hair


Wonderful imagery here, and a nice piece of characterization as well.

“Sky knows what he deems inappropriate formal wear.”


I really admire the way you've been worldbuilding in this story; you slip in little details (such as the subtitution of "sky" for what we'd usaully say as "God" or a euphemism thereof), and mentions of the Academy uniform and such, that make your world feel stronger and more concrete. It's telling that I haven't found a single infodump so far in the story, yet I already feel quite familiar with the world you've created. Good job. ^^

He had stripped himself of garments,


Meh, this is too wordy a way to say that he's undressed.

and pushed the cloth into his chest.


Now, this is one hell of a weird image and not quite the one you were intending, I don't think. I'm seeing her shoving the cloth into a hollow in his chest or something, when I really think you mean she's just shoving it in front of him or something.

arguing with their gazes,


Another piece of weird phrasing. I know what you mean, but it kind of reads like they're arguing against their gazes, not using them to argue.

The road seemed mercilessly long that morning


You just used an adverb a sentence before, so using one so soon is a bit awkward. Try to get rid of as many of the pesky fellows as you can.

Folks


This may just be an issue of personal taste, but I don't like this phrasing "folks"; it seems much too casual and colloquial for the narrative voice you're using. Just "people" is fine.

a silent reminder of the wish he had made the previous week.


Hold on, it's been a week? The way the previous part was written makes me think that it's only the day after. Make the time difference clearer from the outset--you can even just start with "a week later, he woke up..."

The academy was bustling with activity


This'd read better as "the academy bustled", make it seem more active (which fits since you are talking about "activity").

Code
Students were talking among themselves, as usual, but sixth year students spoke louder


The language here is serviceable but all rather basic. "Talking", "spoke", etcetera, can be replaced by much stronger verbs.

Asher could hear the anxiety beneath the excitement, and he smirked at it all. Such morons. There was no use being nervous about something you had no control over.


This sudden burst of superiority from Asher is rather...off-putting. He's never given hints of being smug before, so it's a slap in the face to suddenly be greeted by this smugness. Maybe you were intending to make his character smug from the beginning, but it doesn't really show. If you weren't intending him to be smug, then quickly change this scene.

Reading the later line, I can interpret this now as him putting on bravado, but all the same the smugness comes too suddenly and sharply. Tone it down a tad.

until Asher kicked him.


Kicked him where? Depending on where he's been kicked, Jate's reaction will differ quite a bit.

“I think it’s perfectly formal,” he said pretentiously.


Ouch, two (similar-sounding, to boot) adverbs in such close proximity? One of them must go. I'm eyeing the "pretentiously"--try to avoid adverbs in dialogue tags as much as possible.

“Unlike that ragged excuse for pants you’re wearing.”


"Pants" is plural, so it should probably be "those", not "that"

Shouldering her way through the crowd, oblivious to manners as usual, Laiala squished herself between two people at the very front.


I don't think the middle clause is quite necessary, since you're already showing Laiala's rudeness by having her shoulder her way through the crowd--outright telling it is a bit redundant.

After ten years, Jate had gotten good at reading them.


Took me two reads to realize that "them" is referring to Asher's eyes; you might want to make that more clear at the outset.

“No,” he scoffed back, digging his fingers into his forearm.


The repetition of "his" is a bit awkward here; the first one you can easily eliminate.

though they’d never been formally introduced.


The use of passive voice is a bit distracting here, and makes the prose seem overly formal. Try activating this--"they'd never formally met", something along those lines.

Whispered shut up’s and listen’s ran through the crowd, and the clamor silenced.


Ha, I like this, it's a very realistic touch.

They will show you around Amayil in groups-


Amayil? Though your method of not infodumping has been working wonderfully, right now I'd like a bit more information. I'm getting rather confused because I've never heard of this Amayil place before nor do I understand its connection to the binding ceremony.

Still, it unnerved him, and he was glad to respectfully lower his gaze.


The "was glad" phrasing is bothering me, though I don't know exactly why. It doesn't really...at least to me...it doesn't really convey a sense of relief, which I think you were intending. Or, it does, but not strongly enough.

Are we understood?”


Why would she say "we"? As far as I know, it' sonly her talking.

now clear of lesser year peers.


The phrasing "lesser year peers" is a bit awkward in part because of the unintentional rhyming, and doesn't quite work for me because when I think "peers" I think people in my year groups. "Students" would probably be fine.

her ocean eyes bright with exhilaration.


"Ocean eyes" gives me bizarre mental images; you'd best clarify it with a "blue" afterwards.

She spun on her heels, stumbled, and Asher grabbed her shoulders to gently settle her back on her feet.


"She spun and stumbled" would have more cause and effect to it. As it is, you're not really emphasizing the stumbling enough, relegating it to a clause stuffed in the middle almost as a piece of description.

She could feel them tremble against her blouse, and she pressed a palm over his knuckles.


There's not enough cause and effect here (again!), which is pretty common in rough drafts when you're just pumping out what happened after the other. In some happenings, though, it connects more with what happened before (all right, I know I'm not making sense...), so there needs to be a word bridging the two, stronger than "and". "So", for example.

(Is this even making sense...)?

the formality of it all.


*twitch* Never, ever, say "the [blank] of it all", it comes across as rather amateurish and is just a bunch of fluff words with no real substance to it. I'd rather be shown, rather than told, the formality of it all. Actually, I don't even know what this "formality of it all" is supposed to be describing. I get the feeling it's the carriages, but you need to more specific, then. Show what the carriages look like that makes them so formal.

A presence came at his side, unwelcome, but not leaving.


Took me several reads to understand Kesha came to his side. Partly it's the odd phrasing of "presence", making me think of something intangible, and "at" which I don't think is the proper preposition ("by" would be more appropriate).

her white mentor robes with the academy’s horse emblem galloping on the elongated sleeves stood out against her dark South Region skin


I don't quite understand the description of her robes, even though I've read it several times already. Something about a horse emblem on it...try rephrasing it so it's more clear.

I do like the mention of her skin being darker, though. So often in fantasy you see characters who are generic white Caucasians in generic European fantasy land, so it's great that you're mixing it up and infusing a little diversity in the mix.

Teacher or no, he couldn’t prevent his snide tone, it was the only emotion that covered his hope.


Another comma splice! The comma should be a colon, semicolon, or dash, your call.

not glancing back to see her sad smile.


Why would her smile be sad? I don't understand this.

She smiled, and he looked away.


Again, a sentence that could do better with more cause and effect than just "and".

That's all I can do for the moment, I'll be back ASAP with the overall section. Hope you don't mind. ^^
Ah, it is an empty movement. That is an empty movement. It is.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4198
Reviews 157
I'm back for the rest (which will just be my overall thoughts):

As before, I really enjoyed this and wish I could come up with more to criticize, but honestly, the plot and world both are well put together and your prose is by and large a smooth and easy read. Nonetheless, there are a few areas where you can improve.

The lack of cause and effect: I started noticing this a lot near the end, how you just tended to string actions together with "and"s and commas. It's not grammatically incorrect, but it makes for some fairly boring and unispiring prose, and important actions (such as Laia stumbling) often get lost because they're mashed between commas with nothing to distinguish them. Rely on words like "causing" and "so" and the like (for the life of me, I can't remember the formal grammatical term for such words...) to give your prose more variety and distinguish important actions and descriptions from less important ones.

Speaking of description...that's also something that you can work on. There's almost no description in this story, and though I'm glad you don't hammer the reader with description dumps, you go almost the opposite direction. So far, there's been very little description of the characters, and even less of the setting. It's especially egregious with the carriages, which you handwave away as "formal" but don't give us a concrete picture of how formal they are. I'd also like to see more of the inside of the school and such--description is a marvelous tool in worldbuilding. Don't dump or go overboard and try to describe every little detail, but do try giving us a concrete image of the settings and the characters. I know some will say slip in descriptions into the narrative proper, but hell, sometimes you do have to stop the narrative a bit to describe. Think of the way that we perceive things (especially people)--we'll initially take in their physical appearance, and maybe make a judgment from that. Then, interacting with them, we'll pick up on littler details such as their personal tics and such. Utilize that to your full advantage--for example, when Kesha first shows up, insert a basic description of her. For a while I was actually confused as to her gender.

One last little issue I'd like to point is a sense of confusion. I like that you're not infodumping, but I did start getting pretty confused somewhere along the line, especially when Kesha started going on about the city. It took me several reads to understand that they were going to the city for the ceremony, which confused me because such a journey was never mentioned before. I get the feeling you're trying to keep an aura of mystery around the ceremony, but you're going too far in that direction and ending up with more confusion than mystery. Introduce a bit more about the ceremony from the outset.

The last issue I have is a highly subjective and personal one and will probably impact the plot, so feel free to ignore me. But really, I'm hoping that Asher doesn't get a dragon. It's partly personal (I don't like dragons much and I think they're overdone--there are a lot of much more interesting fantasy creatures out there), and partly because I think a much more compelling story can be told if Asher doesn't get what he wants initially--it'd be a great opportunity for character development throughout the story as Asher struggles to come to terms with his dream not coming true, and accepting what he has. But then again, it's your story, so it's your call.

Overall, this is some great work, and I'm definitely looking forward to more (when I can steal the time to read it...). ^^ PM me if you have any questions.
Ah, it is an empty movement. That is an empty movement. It is.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 8009
Reviews 93
I've been a bit disappointed by some of the stories people are posting on YWS lately, but yours was great. The characterization was very strong, and I really like Asher.

I would suggest maybe starting the chapter a little later on, because the beginning seems bogged down by pointless details. Do we really need to hear all about Asher choosing his outfit? Is that going to be essential to the plot? If not, I'd say cut it, just to speed up the story a little more.

Some more details would be nice as well. I just can't fully imagine the setting, or the character's appearances.

Other than that, I loved it, and I'll definitely be keeping an eye out for the next chapter!

The only thing that I don't understand is WHY they're getting the animals. Are they getting them for pets, or some magical purpose, or what? I really can't imagine some teenager being given an actual lion as a pet or something. I can just imagine how that story would go. "Here, Fluffy. Who's a good lion? You are. You a - No Fluffy! Don't maul my mom! Bad kitty! Bad!"
“Don't tell me the moon is shining; show me the glint of light on broken glass.” Anton Chekhov




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 511
Reviews 127
I will relate to Magnusbanefan13 on this one and ask: Why are they being bound to animals? Is this something like daemons from the golden compass or more from like eragon? or totally different. We will probably read it in a future chapter but remember not to stall it too long.

Now into the actual contents of the story. For forced writing this was exceptionally good work. :D The start (as mentioned earlier) was a bit slow, though I am curious how do people argue with their eyes. A staring competition perhaps, the other one finnaly cannot take more and turns his head away from the other persons eyes?


“Silence, now!” Kesha bellowed over the pandemonium.


There is nothing really wrong with this part, but the word choice you used when Kesha spoke makes me think. "Silence, now!" is something a person with a short temper or anger management problems shouts. The word "Now" in the end indicates that the person can't exactly bellow the words because when you shout "Silence, now!" the now has a higher pitch. The way of making the pitch lower would be to say it slower but that would make the sentence sound awkward. Also Kesha doesn't seem like a person who would shout something like that, she gives out a more omnipotent feel, and I think she should just shout "Silence!" which can be easily bellowed. One word can do wonders to a text.


“Because I am years beyond your age, and I know these things. I’ve witnessed countless girls and boys being Bound.”


Replace "girls and boys" with "people" or "students" or whatshouldyoucallthem. But "girls and boys" sounds a teeny bit childish. Like speaking to a very young person. Granted Asher is younger than Kesha, but he can't be that young.



“The carriages will arrive here shortly, and you will be in the hands of the guides. They will show you around Amayil in groups- you are to be silent, and listen to what they have to say. The city’s history is important, believe it or not, and when we get back you will be tested on what you learned.”


2 sentences 4 "will" words. It just caught my eye how you repeated this same word, over, and over. If the word "will" is being being emphasised in these sentences make an effort of showing it to us. We don't know if you cramped that many same words there for a reason or not.

for example I would write it something like this:

“The carriages will arrive here shortly, and you will be in the hands of the guides. They will show you around Amayil in groups- you are to be silent, and listen to what they have to say. The city’s history is important, believe it or not, and when we get back you will be tested on what you learned.”

See the slight? difference. It gives the text a different feel. Distinct change in pronunciation. By italicizing the "will" words we get an emphasis to the sentences.


Overall this is, by far, one of the best pieces I have ever read on YWS. Though I have been away for some 4-5 months now, it seems the standard on writing has lowered, but you are one of the people who is bringing it back up. Your colorful use of words, and professional style of writing have left an impression on me, and I also like the story and idea. :D
To copy reality is good... But to create reality is much, much better.
-Giuseppe Verdi-




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1759
Reviews 8
Another note before you begin (this is the second part of chapter one). I changed Asher's name to Kodi. For personal reasons, and also because there is a semi-new book published called The Innocent Mage by Karen Miller (it's actually very good and I suggest it to you if you're reading Bound), in which the main character is named Asher. And his best friend's name begins with a J. I wasn't going to let it bug me, but it ended up doing so anyways. I just felt like I was stealing Karen Miller's characters, which is not the case at all. So. Asher = Kodi. No other changes were made.
I also want to thank everyone who critiqued the first part of chapter one, and also anyone who replied to the prologue as well. You guys have been so awesome, and I love hearing your feedback, good or bad. So please do what you can to rip apart this following. I'll love you eternally.

RATED PG13 for slight language. It's actually not even PG13 worthy, but I know some people are sensitive about swears.

Chapter One (Part Two)

The city stretched around them for miles; more colors and scents and people than Kodi had ever seen at a Moonflower Festival. He stared up at the monstrous buildings, awe smothering the air from his lungs. They loomed over the streets, watching the crowd crammed together between their marble walls. Marble- not mud brick. Marble.

"Boys- girls- stay together please," their guide yammered, nervously herding the five teenagers into a circle. "This building that we're stopped at is the Amayil Archives, first built when the Nurrians fled the civil war in the North...”

"Whoa," Jate breathed, his neck craned all the way back to see the carving above the library's gateway.

“...it was burned down during Resuku’s Revolt, and was restored to accommodate a larger collection of books and information in the Kiielo Dynasty three decades later...”

“Imagine living here.” Kodi looked around at the people pushing past their small group, and the finely groomed horses pulling carriages down the cobble stone street. Bounds, in both human and animal form, followed their Guardians.

"Now if you'll come this way- come this way, please, all of you." The man started down the street, and the five teenagers followed him.

"I feel like a duckling," muttered Jate. "I wonder where the other groups went off to."

"Must have all gone different ways," Kodi said absently, only half listening to his friend. There was a lady and her chameleon Bound selling some strange fruit, most likely from the South Region. Kesha was always going on about her home's colorful diet. And there- a person, with the tail and ears of a mouse, helping his Guardian load chicken crates into a carriage. Everything was everywhere. The buildings, Bounds roaming freely, carriages, and venders- selling rugs, clothes, meat, fruit, sweetmeats and pastries and everything. Kodi could hardly see it all, even with a head's height above all the others.

But his awe passed quickly, fading to boredom- with the help of the guide's droning voice. Jate obviously felt the same, his hands shoved deep into his pockets with his head lolling back. He couldn't concentrate if nothing exciting happened. "Do you think-"

"No," Kodi cut him off quickly.

"You don't even know what I was going to say!"

"You want to run off somewhere. I said no." The boy halted, and Kodi warily stopped as well. "Jay-"

"Come on, Ko. We need an adventure. We haven't done anything exciting since-"

"We got thrown around by bulls?" He clenched his jaws together, remembering Kesha's warning. "You can run off and have an 'adventure' if you want. I'm sticking with the group." He spun around on his heel- and faced a mass of unfamiliar faces. Stunned, he whipped back to his friend's brilliant grin. "You-!"

"Race you to the library!" Jate took off down the street, one hand securing his hat against his head. Kodi followed quickly, his heart squeezing in his throat. Kesha was going to kill them- slaughter them.

"Jate!" he called angrily, trying to catch up. If he lost his friend, he'd be completely alone in some strange street in the largest city of Kaean. He jostled past people, ignoring their complaints, keeping his eyes secured on Jate's obnoxious hat. Until something caught against his foot and he went sprawling out over the cobblestones. His senses blanked, and he floated on a cloud of pain for some time.

"Geez, you're awfully pathetic." The scorning voice lifted him out of the reverie. "You look like a bird that's flown into a window."

"Help me up," Kodi muttered through clenched teeth, and a second later an arm wounded around his shoulders to unsteadily lift him to his feet. He could feel Jate's breath against his face, and he winced and turned away from it. "You really need to chew on mint more often."

The other boy laughed as Kodi straightened some more, pressing a hand to his back.

"Good, you're being an asshole like usual. I thought you might have banged your head up and would start giving out flowers to children."

"Shut up. It's my shoulder that I hit." He pressed a hand to it, causing pain to shoot across his collarbone. Gritting his teeth, he pushed Jate off of him and looked around. The hustle of the street was dimmed, rushing past the small seclude they were in. The dirt under Kodi's worn boots was much softer than the cobblestone streets they had been traversing the past few hours. "Where the hell are we?"

"I dragged you off into an alley before you were trampled. You've got to cut down on those starsweets, y'know. I could barely lug you a foot." Jate patted Kodi's stomach, then pushed his hat back to survey the brick wall. "Guess they aren't so rich and mighty that they can afford marble all 'round."

Kodi wasn't listening to him. "Look at this." He brushed his fingers against a jumble of nonsense symbols, written into the brick with black chalk. Jate pressed up next to him to squint at it.

"What does that mean?"

"I don't know, it's... weird. I've never seen anything like it before."

"It's a different language." Jate traced one of the symbols with his thumb, eyebrows knitted together.

"That's impossible. There's no such thing."

"It's called Hyento." The two boys jumped and instinctually spun around at the new voice. The woman twined her fingers together to rest them over her pregnant stomach. “The language of Seers.” Kodi glanced over at Jate, then back at the lady. She offered them a sad smile. “Do you know why your people are Bound?”

“It’s always been that way.” Jate, for once, was bashful in front of her beauty. Kodi wasn’t sure if it was because she was carrying, or because she was quite obviously wiser than them. Not more knowledgeable, like their mentors, but wiser. It surrounded her words like a thick cloak, choking out any argument.

“No, not always.” She was staring up at Kodi, but he felt infinitely small beneath her gaze. “You are Bound because there is magic inside of you. Magic too great for one person. So it is divided, between a Guardian and a Bound, and therefore neither are too powerful. That is what creates the Bound; your own magic. Not The Council’s.”

“Ah,” was all Jate could say, his voice faltering in that one syllable.

“Who are ‘seers’?” Kodi asked, determined not to feel so belittled by this woman. But she simply shook her head and turned her back to them. Her hair, redder than any fire Kodi had ever seen, fell almost to her waist.

“My name is Evalen,” she whispered, her voice blowing around Kodi’s ears like wind.

“Evalen-” he began, but she was gone. He blinked, blinked again, then turned to Jate, who was staring at the Hyento again. “That was odd,” he said after a second.

“What was?” his friend asked, not looking up at him. He was tracing with his thumb again, trying to make sense of the faded black lines.

“Evalen.”

“Who?” Jate met his eyes now, and Kodi saw in them no Evalen, no Hyento, no fiery hair. Jate did not remember.

“Nevermind,” Kodi said softly, then cleared his throat. “Nevermind,” he repeated, louder. “We have to find the group.” Laiala would have been proud of him as he grabbed Jate’s arm and pulled him off down the street. It wasn’t until they had finally located the group and the tour guide was yittering on to them about the importance of staying together and not getting lost, that Kodi realized what the woman had said. Your people. Not our people. And she didn't wear a totem; did that mean she had no Bound? No, that was impossible. He stared past the tour guide's shoulder, trying to make sense of it all. Hyento, Evalen and her disappearance, the absence of a Bound, and Jate's sudden memory loss.

Adventure was kissing the edge of his mind, but he wasn't so sure that he wanted it. Adventure was Jate's occupation, not his.

“Are you listening to me?” the guide waved his notepad in front of Kodi’s nose. “Why would you even want to run off like that? You could get lost! These streets aren’t safe at night! I would lose my job!”

“Excuse me-” the man whipped around to face the boy who interrupted, but he stood his ground against the rage. “Is this boy Kodi of Senyuur?” The guide finally noticed the winged staff sewn into the messenger’s collar, and bent low in apology. The dove sitting on the boy’s shoulder tweeted sweetly, fluffing up her wings.

“Yes, yes it is.” He wrung his hands together nervously. “My deepest sorrow for-” He was waved away so the messenger could step up to Kodi. Jate nudged his side.

“Kodi of Senyuur?”

It took a moment for him to find his voice. “Yes, sir?”

“If you would follow me, please.” He began making his way through the crowd, slipping easily between the people. Kodi followed silently, fear clamping his throat shut.
|Doctor is prone to rants. Slap her if she starts rambling.|




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 5577
Reviews 672
Hey there Dr. Tick Tock.

The overall impression that I got of this chapter was that it seemed like filler. Nothing was really happening and I struggled to actually finish this. One of your main reasons for this is due to "how" you are telling the story. You seemed very focused on telling exactly what's happening that you often neglect the "why". Why was this ceremony taking place? What significance does it hold?

As I was reading this, I couldn't help but compare this with the sorting hat ceremony in the first Harry Potter novel. But in that scene, there was actually a purpose to it. For example, the sorting hat serves several purposes. For one thing, it foreshadows the idea of choice (Why did he chose Gryffindor over Slytherin? Isn't it because he values friendship and love over ambition) which later becomes one of the crucial points of the novel when he experiences both external and internal conflict in his struggle against Voldemort. For another, the ceremony helps to make things more convincing by showing how the magical world is still uncomfortable to him. Every-one's name was being slowly called out to be sorted except his and he starts to question if he really belongs there. This situation in a way reflects us when we have to start school or have to start school in a new place. We feel insecure and unsure, just like Harry was.

With your piece however, I found it unconvincing because it lacks that consideration of the "why" (and how it has an effect on the characters). I mean, were the characters nervous? Were they uneasy? Were they excited. Perhaps you might of had shown it, but its diluted by filler that seems irrelevant and mundane.

Hopefully this has helped somewhat. I think you have a good idea here so keep going.

Andy.
"To the edge of the universe and back. Endure and survive."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4198
Reviews 157
Hi, Doctor, here I am for the second part. ^^

Well...the name change is a bit odd, and I'm not sure if I like it...but I'll get used to it, I'm sure.

Your prose is by and large fine, but I'll point out some issues I had with the first paragraph:

The city stretched around them for miles; more colors and scents and people than Kodi had ever seen at a Moonflower Festival.


It feels like there's something missing from the last clause--a verb. What are the colors and scents and people doing? I think you mean that they're surrounding Kodi, or that he's taking them in or something. As it is, the second clause feels rather awkward and incomplete.

He stared up at the monstrous buildings, awe smothering the air from his lungs.


"Smothering" isn't the right verb to use in this situation, because it implies something more gradual, when I think you basically mean that Kodi's become breathless in a single instant.

Also, "monstrous" implies that the buildings are deformed and ugly, when I think you're aiming for the exact opposite impression. Pay careful attention to the connotation of the words you're picking.

Lastly, this feels like telling instead of showing. You're telling us that the buildings are "monstrous" (again, I think you mean grand or huge), without showing us. How tall are they? (okay, don't give their heights in exact feet...but do they appear to cut the sky in half, that sort of thing?) Utilize figurative language and strong imagery, they are your friends when trying to lay down a setting like this. Don't be afraid of description--we need it to truly understand appreciate Kodi's awe. Right now, I feel you're too strongly shoving on the reader the idea of Kodi being amazed by all this, while giving nothing to really back it up.

They loomed over the streets, watching the crowd crammed together between their marble walls. Marble- not mud brick. Marble.


Who/what are "they"? Kodi and his group? The buildings? And does the "their" refer to the buildings? Why is the crowd crammed between the buildings' walls in the first place? It seems to me the greatest crowd would not be between the buildings, but rather on the streets. As far as I know, in most cities, the buildings line the sides of the streets, instead of street cutting between individual buildings.

I do like the contrast between the marble of the buildings, and the mud brick which Kodi is used to. It's yet another fascinating little worldbuilding detail. You could go more in detail as to how the marble looks like; there are different kinds, after all. Not all marble is pure white.

(In fact, the image of a city made up of marble buildings in different colors, veined and unveined, is a very beautiful one. I'd suggest utilizing it. ~_^)

Now, as for the rest of the chapter:

I felt mostly "meh" about it. A lot of that comes from being very little real tension. It just feels like a lot of random things happening one after another. In particular, I felt Evalen's sudden appearance lacked in the way of drama, which is bad because I get the feeling that you intended that scene to be the most dramatic in the chapter. It just felt like poof, she shows up, then poof, she disappears. There's no real sense of mystery around her. The way the scene is written, it could just be an ordinary scene in the story.

The thing is that I feel the characters are doing random things because they don't really have a goal. Okay, I know that Kodi wants to get Bound to a dragon, but you haven't been reinforcing that enough in this chapter. So far, he's just passively following Jate around and seeing a few weird things. He's not acting on his desires. He's being passive, and that's very off-putting to read in a protagonist.

This chapter felt largely like a detour, and a bit of a disappointment after the beautifully-written prologue. That prologue made me really anticipate the scene where Kodi is getting Bound, and seemed to be setting up the first chapter for that purpose. Now I'm feeling a tad impatient and frustrated because it seems the story's transitioned from Kodi's binding to his and his pals' exploration of the city. If you maintained his excitement and anticipation and dread throughout the chapter, it wouldn't be such an issue since it'd build up tension for the reader, something to look forward to. It just strikes me that the whole "Bound" aspect isn't being played up nearly as much as it should--I still don't even know what a Bound is. Strange, given how the story is called "Bound"...

This is a very well-written story, and I won't hesitate to say it's one of the best fantasy stories I've seen on YWS and you've got some of the best worldbuilding I've ever seen (that little bit with the histories, even though Kodi and pals weren't paying attention, is a beautiful detail). I'm still intrigued enough to read on. The plot just feels rather slow as of now.

Keep up the good work, and PM me if you have any questions, comments, concerns.
Ah, it is an empty movement. That is an empty movement. It is.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3981
Reviews 24
Hey Doc! Back for part two.

This part for me was just kind of bleh. I think a lot of interesting things happen and I'm sure the things Kodi sees and hears will come in later. However, the way it's written is kind of static. I feel like there should be more wonder in what he's seeing. I want more of Kodi's thought process when he's seeing those strange symbols, and when Evalen disappears. Right now it's kind of like "Oh, there are some strange symbols. Oh and there's a strange lady. Now she's gone. Okay, let's go." I just think it's kind of unrealistic how he takes all of those strange things in stride.

There was only one typo that I noticed.

"Help me up," Kodi muttered through clenched teeth, and a second later an arm wounded around his shoulders to unsteadily lift him to his feet.


It should be wound instead of wounded.

Anyway, I really love the plot and storyline of this. Also the characters are still my favorite part of this book. They're so well defined and thought out. Hope these thoughts have helped. I'm eagerly awaiting the next installment. :)
"Without hard work, nothing grows but weeds."
-Gordon B. Hinckley




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1759
Reviews 8
Oh, thanks so much guys! Since most of you said this chapter was pointless, I'm revising it quite a bit. More description of the city will be given, Evalen's appearance will be much more dramatic (thanks airbear, I wasn't even thinking about how Kodi was reacting to that scene! Very novice mistake on my part), and the actual Ceremony for Kodi will be in this chapter.

Also, I've decided to make the prologue into chapter one, and chapter one becomes chapter two.

So I'm going to be reposting this chapter. Obviously, you guys are free to critique or not critique it. It will be in a brand new thread, and I don't think it will be in parts (we'll see, though). So. Yeah. I'm not sure if any of you are even going to read this, heh, but I'll put a similar explanation at the top of the new thread when it's posted.

Sorry for being so difficult ^-^; . You guys are the best for putting up with me!

.Doctor
|Doctor is prone to rants. Slap her if she starts rambling.|



History is the version of past events that people have decided to agree upon.
— Napoleon Bonaparte