Contest Entry

4 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10870
Reviews 318
The Original: http://books.google.com/books?id=Avgv-Y ... rl&f=false

Hans Christian Anderson's The Little Match Girl from the father's point of view.

I acknowledge the fact that I am cruel, but you must sympathize with me. I was fired from my job only two months after getting it, you see, and I had worked for twelve years, as my daughter was growing up, to find an employer. It is the Great Depression, and jobs are being lost all over the place.

I am a very sensitive man, although I may not seem so. It's just that I take my sadness out in anger, and I take that anger out on my little girl. I would love for my child to have an education, but I don't have the money necessary to buy her books for school. I don't even have the money to buy her decent clothes.

Although it pained me greatly to do so, I had to give my daughter, at a young age, a few boxes of matches, and send her out the door and downtown. There, for a few hours each day, she would attempt to sell matches to pedestrians. I know she must have been very cold in winter, but I figured that she was young, and, quite selfishly, I thought that she would hold up better than I would, with my arthritis-stricken bones.

I was wrong, and I admit it. I admit that, when she came home in the evening, not having sold any matches, I would beat her. She was my only refuge, and I know I can't take away what I did.

But, my friend, it is not as though she didn't take little breaks all throughout the day. She, surely, would have gone into various downtown shops to warm up, perhaps trying on sweaters in the meantime. If she didn't, how could she not have sold any matches?

Yes, Reader, I admit that I made home, for her, a very hostile environment. I made her sell the matches for her own good, that she might someday go to school like the other little girls, and wear pretty sweaters like the other little girls. But she never did, and she never will.

At first, when my dearest little one wasn't home by dusk, I though it was just because she was taking her time trying to sell matches, like the good little girl she was. I even thought, "It serves her right, working for an extra hour or two."

But after those first couple of hours, I did begin to worry, and even started to cry. My poor little match girl was gone.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3584
Reviews 58
I admit, I haven't read the story in which you switched to the father's POV. But this was really good and i found barely any issues with it.

Except for this little typo:

"At first, when my dearest little one wasn't home by dusk, I though it was just because she was taking her time trying to sell matches, like the good little girl she was."

Though is supposed to be thought. That's about it! I hope you win.
"Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today."
-James Dean




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2973
Reviews 102
Hi Kaykel,
I'm not that familiar with the Match Girl story (It was a long time ago when I used to read those stories). But your story kinda lacked any emotion. It's almost safe to say it was 99.9% telling and absolutely no showing at all. The father just told of his grief, he didn't show it. There was no way to really feel the story or any depth of sadness since all it was was telling.
You had a great idea for a story though, it's always interesting when someone takes on the point of view of the proposed bad guy of the story. I think if you worked it a little harder and followed the "show not tell" rule that it would make it a much more intriguing story.

~Dakota
What is important is to know fear and yet take a step forward.
Rosette Christopher

Looking for peeps to review my novel:)

novel.php?id=1142




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 53415
Reviews 1125
(To all, sorry about bumping, but it's a contest entry :))

Hey Abigail! Stella here... at last...

I. NITPICKS

It's just that I take my sadness out in anger,


take my sadness out in anger sounds weird.

Okay...

II. OVERALL

This is almost too short to give you any specific issues on. I wasn't too sure about your voice. I know he's supposed to sound detached, but he sounded almost too detached. I would have liked to see more emotion over his daughter's death- also, what about things that happened before the story began? His wife's death, perhaps, other children? And his daughter herself, didn't have much of a character. What was she like? A sad little thing, or bright and chirpy and happy?

That said, I liked your setting of the Great Depression, it was rather inspired, and an interesting point of view to tell the story from...

Hope I helped, drop me a note if you need anything!

-Stella x
"Stella. You were in my dream the other night. And everyone called you Princess." -Lauren2010



If you can't describe what you are doing as a process, you don't know what you're doing.
— W. Edwards Deming