Broken Birds

7 posts
Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 335
December

December took a long drag on her cigarette, then tipped her head back and blew a series of smoke rings, watching them rise and dissipate. A crow flew overhead silently, its ebony feathers in stark contrast to the sky’s indifferent gray.
How she envied it its wings.
She was on break, standing in the vacant lot outside of the hospital. It was a shitty little place- bleak, empty, covered in sharp, gritty gravel- but December loved it simply because it was outside, freeing her from the world of doctors and nurses and immaculate whiteness, the world of endless testing. It gave her glimpse of the raw, fresh-air reality that she so yearned for.
December was a test subject, a Guineau Pig for everything from cancer treatments to cosmetics. At the moment she was being prepared as a test subject for a potential lung cancer cure- that was why she was smoking.
It was because of her useless left leg, a birth defect, that she was forced to live this God forsaken life. All the test subjects were “flawed” in some way- deformed, retarded, blind, deaf, even simply homosexual, which the government had deemed an abnormality and therefore a defect. December hated the monotony of her life, the objectification, the blind submission to an authority she disdained.
The only thing she loved were her fellow test subjects. They tended to be tough and feisty and were sometimes unpleasant to be around, but beneath their rough exteriors they were genuinely good people. Hardship had given them a kind of integrity.
Surveying her drab surroundings, December thought wistfully of the life she had once led. She’d been a musician, a gifted and passionate violinist. Until the Regime began its campaign to ban music completely.
She sighed. It all seemed so far away, the days of grand concert halls and silken gowns. Onstage, lost in music’s beautiful haze, her leg didn’t seem to matter. Once upon a time, people had thought she was beautiful, brilliant, remarkable- not just a girl with a gimp forced to take pills and injections.

Shiloh

I gazed longingly at December from a tiny hospital window, observing how delicately she held her cigarette between two slender fingers.
I’m a dyke, that’s why I’m here. I’ve loved December from the moment I met her- I know it sounds sentimental but it’s true. I couldn’t resist her shy smile, her solemn grey eyes.
And she’s kind, kinder than anyone’s ever been to me, really. You’d think that in a place like this, where we’re all used to being treated as the dregs of society, people would have some empathy for a lesbian. But no, I’m still told that I’m sick, wrong, a sinner. December, though, she doesn’t pass judgement.
I sighed and turned from the window, back to my work. I’d been put on a new class of antidepressants with potentially dangerous side effects. My job was to keep a journal of the results, updating it every hour- how I felt, how I thought, what they did to my body.
If they don’t kill me, I can only hope they’ll do me some good. God knows I’m depressed.

Asher

From the moment I got here, my only thought has been breaking free from this place.
My parents ignited the spark of revolution in me when I was young, with tales of Che Guevara and other nearly forgotten revolutionaries of long ago. Then the Regime came to power and began its attempt to smother any irregularity, any individuality. I have Bipolar Disorder, and was dubbed a freak and sent to this oppressive, twisted hellhole. I’m not about to take that lying down.
I was in my workshop, amidst wires and switches and endlessly complicated parts. Bombs were a last resort- I’m not a violent man, simply bitter and desperate. I’ve tried negotiating honestly with the administrators, asking for better conditions and more initiative- they’d laughed me down without a moment of serious consideration. I’ve tried sabotaging the medical equipment- they simply enforced more secure protection. Finally, enraged and exhausted, I found some instructions on the internet for making bombs from scratch and did what I could to scrounge up the necessary parts from lab equipment. If only I were smart enough to construct a bomb…
More difficult than the bomb, however, were my attempts to organize the other test subjects. A sole revolutionary is powerless, but there is power in numbers. Rebellion calls for unity. I thought that would be easy to find- we should all be angry, indignant, determined to overcome. But my proposals were met by scorn and disinterest. I’m the only one here who hasn’t been beaten into submission.
That’s not what I want. I want to inspire and ignite these people and lead them to triumph. Even if we fail, I want to be able to say we tried. The apathy here makes me sick.
I intimidate the others- they see me as angry, unpredictable, maybe crazy. They don’t see that all of my fury is out of compassion for them. The best kind of revolution is rooted in love.

December

December’s vacant gaze fell on the patients within the window, with their deformed faces and limbs, their blind, milky eyes, their anemic pallor. Some had defects that were not visible, but were betrayed by the agony in their faces. She was one of them, one of these tired, tortured souls.
This place, December thought, is a cage full of broken birds.
A cruel cage, and she would likely die here.
Countless times, she’d thought about taking it into here own hands. Death, that is. They all had, but no one ever had the guts to go through with suicide.
Why should she keep toiling away? If she was to die here anyway, why give them the sick satisfaction of killing her themselves?
December returned to the laboratory. Filling a large syringe dangerously full with one of the most potent treatments, she slipped it discreetly into her sleeve and headed back to the vacant lot.
She lay down, felt the pebbles press indentations into her back. She stared directly up at the patch of smoggy sky. Realizing suddenly that this would be the last thing she ever saw, December began to sob, her entire body shuddering with grief.
Then, trembling, she inserted the silver needle into a vein in her wrist- through the translucent, paper thin skin and into pulsing, blue, vulnerable vein.
Her pulse slowed, her thoughts lagged, and gradually her vision began to dim.

Shiloh

I gathered her limp body, kissed her cold, pallid lips.
She’d really been all I had to live for here. I couldn’t imagine returning to a life of monotony and sickening tests knowing I would never again glimpse her luminous eyes, her sweet smile. December had been my only solace, my motivation to endure this life I’d been forced into. She was… I don’t know. A glimmering gem amongst dull stones, a bird of paradise amidst common sparrows.
Setting her corpse back down gently, I noticed a syringe tumble from her limp hand. I picked it up and held it to the light, the dying sunlight illuminating an oddly colored liquid. It was halfway full. Half a syringe of this was all it took to overwhelm the system, to bring swift death.

Asher

I stared pensively at the entangled corpses sprawled across the ground. Shiloh’s lifeless lips were still brushing December’s cheek, her limbs draped protectively over December’s waiflike frame. There was a stark, morbid beauty to the scene- even dead, Shiloh loved December ardently.
At least they were finally together.
“Shiloh?! Jesus, I heard someone else snuffed it… but Shiloh?!”
I turned around- it was Jasper. He and Shiloh had been close. They were the only two homos in this place, so they’d hung together.
“Of course Shiloh,” I snapped. “She was in love with December. I thought you of all people knew that, fairy.”
I met his eyes then, and realized they were brimming with tears. I felt an immediate pang of remorse for calling him fairy. Reaching out, I placed a consoling hand on his shoulder.
“Hey, Jas, I’m sorry, man. I liked Shiloh too, and December.”
He didn’t acknowledge me, just gazed in disbelief toward the corpses at our feet.
“They were martyrs,” I said absently.
And then it was like a hurricane hit me. I looked at Jas with wide eyes. “They were martyrs,” I repeated, this time with urgency. “They liberated themselves, they beat this sick, sick system the only way they could.”
I was met by an uncomprehending stare. “Suicide is hardly heroism, Asher.”
“But it is, don’t you see? They fucked the system. The fascists can control every aspect of our lives, but they can’t control how we die. They need us. They lose us,they lose scientific progress. I think this is the answer, if I can find a way to organize it. I know I’ll give my life for liberation.”
“Ash, slow down. Are you seriously suggesting mass suicide?”
“Yes, as a form of revolt! It’s not as if we have anything to live for anyway.”
“You’re nuts, Asher. There’s been enough dying already, okay?”
I felt a rage coming on, roiling up within me, irrepressible. “You don’t understand! You can either sell yourself like a whore to this corrupt regime and die at their hands, or you can join me and die nobly in the name of liberty! Do it for Shiloh, Jasper, in her honor.”
I took some capsules out of my pocket, a medication for manic depressive behavior that I had been testing. One by one, I forced them down my throat. The world tilted and spun, my heart sped, the blood rushed in my temples. I was exhilarated. I could feel in my bones that this was the beginning of an end, that others would follow our example until the administrators gave up and freed whoever remained. At last I was doing something meaningful, something revolutionary, and if I had to die to do it, so be it.

Jasper

I was paralyzed with horror, fumbling for words.
“Asher, don’t. Please, son, you’re only a boy…”
“I’m not a boy!” he snarled. His eyes were wild.
“You are, Asher, you’re what… 17? Do you really want to throw your life away for some highbrow ideals?!”
“I’m dying for you… for the oppressed… for the abused…the downtrodden… for the people…” Between each phrase, he would force more capsules down his throat, attempting not to gag on them.
Panicking, I reached out and shook him, jostling the pill bottle from his grasp. I was too late; he staggered, crumpled into my arms. My vision blurring with tears, I watched the last life fade from his eyes.

* * * *

Almost a decade later, I am free. Liberated, like Asher promised, from the somber laboratory, the tedious testing day in and day out, the taxing side effects of medications, the condescending doctors, nurses, and lab administrators. We’re all free, like so many captive butterflies released in a swarm.
To my disbelief, it was just as Asher predicted. A string of suicides that lead to the admin’s reluctant liberation of the test subjects when they realized it was futile to keep us there. I’m not sure if the others saw the suicide as a kind of political leverage or simply as a release from suffering. Either way, it worked.
I’m an activist, now, in honor of Asher, in honor of Shiloh and all the others, The regime is far from overthrown, but our movement is gaining ground, chipping away slowly but surely.
I am from the class of the oppressed, the abused, the downtrodden. We might be broken, but we are resilient, irrepressible, and together we’ll rise like a wave.
"I myself am composed entirely of flaws, stitched together with good intentions."- Augusten Burroughs




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1673
Reviews 32
Wooooooooooooooooooooooooowwwwww!!!!

This is amazing. You have such a talent.

This piece has such a dreary feeling to it but it's extremely well written. And such a unique idea.

Well done.

Ced
Dreams are whispers from the Soul




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 233
Hi :D I thought this was amazingly written, you certainly have talent. At first, I was not that keen on the way the perspectives jumped around but as I read on it made more sense to the story as a whole as its not about focusing on an individual characters life and sticking with it but showing a chain of events- I thought it was cleverly done! :)

She was on break, standing in the vacant lot outside of the hospital.


You say later on that she had a bad leg so maybe here she would be leaning against a wall or something like that?

It gave her glimpse of the raw, fresh-air reality that she so yearned for.


You need an 'a' here before 'glimpse'.

The only thing she loved were her fellow test subjects.


As there is more than one, I think 'thing' should be 'things'.

I sighed and turned from the window, back to my work. I’d been put on a new class of antidepressants with potentially dangerous side effects. My job was to keep a journal of the results, updating it every hour- how I felt, how I thought, what they did to my body.
If they don’t kill me, I can only hope they’ll do me some good. God knows I’m depressed.


As you were talking about her thoughts in the present, I'd maybe say 'My job is' and 'how I feel, how I think, what they do to my body' so that it is all referring to how it is now :)

From the moment I got here, my only thought has been breaking free from this place.


I think 'arrived' might sound better than 'got' and I think the second part to the sentence could be reworded a bit as it sounded a bit odd to me when I first read through it- could just be me though :) For instance something like 'My only thoughts have been on how to break free from this place' or something similar.

December’s vacant gaze fell on the patients within the window


Is there only one window? I would have thought there would be more than one, unless they are only allowed one. I'm not sure about 'within' either, maybe 'behind' would be more accurate? So maybe something like- 'December's vacant gaze fell on the patients behind the windows of the hospital.'

She lay down, felt the pebbles press indentations into her back.


I'd maybe change 'felt' to 'feeling'.

Realizing suddenly that this would be the last thing she ever saw


I think 'she ever saw' might sound better as 'she would ever see'.

through the translucent, paper thin skin and into pulsing, blue, vulnerable vein.
Her pulse slowed, her thoughts lagged, and gradually her vision began to dim.


I think you need an 'a' or 'the' before 'pulsing' and as you say 'pulsing' I think you could maybe change 'pulse' to something else- like heart rate or something like that.

I gathered her limp body, kissed her cold, pallid lips.


This is fine as it is but I think it might sound better adding 'to me' after body and with an 'and' to join that to her kissing her lips.

I picked it up and held it to the light, the dying sunlight illuminating an oddly colored liquid.


So you are not repeating 'light' I'd maybe just leave 'sunlight' as 'sun' or 'sunshine' or leaving out 'dying' and calling it 'sunset'.

They were the only two homos in this place, so they’d hung together.


I think 'stuck' might sound better here than 'hung'.

I felt an immediate pang of remorse for calling him fairy.


Instead of repeating the insult, I think this could sound better as just saying 'I felt an immediate pang of remorse for insulting him.'

They lose us,they lose scientific progress.


You need a space after the comma ;)

I’m an activist, now, in honor of Asher, in honor of Shiloh and all the others, The regime is far from overthrown,


The comma before 'The regime' needs to be a full stop.

We might be broken, but we are resilient, irrepressible, and together we’ll rise like a wave.


I like how you end but I think you could possibly add something a bit more to it like saying what the wave would do, for instance- 'to break the bonds that suffocate us.' or something like that :D

Overall: I was being really picky here and all my comments are just my preference and suggestions so ignore them if you like! I thought your story was brilliant, it was really powerful in its message and unlike any piece I have read before :)

I think it all runs well as it is, the only things that I do think could be altered a bit would be December's movements when she is going to the laboratory- it is kind of skipped over and although it's not that important I think you could add more to it and how she managed to take the syringe, perhaps there are a couple of lab people looking at her strangely but she hurries past? Maybe she struggles to hurry forwards with her limp? A bit more details like that might be good :)

I also thought the part about taking pills out of Asher's pocket could be changed a bit. I wouldn't think they would allow them to look after their own medication, especially as some of them had bipolar where they would be tempted to kill themselves. I think it might be more realistic to have them sneaking them from somewhere or breaking open a medicine cabinet- something like that to show how they got hold of them.

There isn't much description on their appearances but it's not really needed, I think you have described their feelings and individual thoughts and lives wonderfully. This is a great story! Hope I've helped :D *star*
"Your mother is a hamster and your father smells of elderberries"
-Monty Python and The Holy Grail




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 335
Thanks so much! I'm a bit pressed for time right now but I'll be sure to go back and fix those typos later.
"I myself am composed entirely of flaws, stitched together with good intentions."- Augusten Burroughs




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1090
Reviews 5
Hello Fireweed,

This is a very interesting story: it tells of revolution and the spirit necessary to pursuit a rebellion that will make changes we want in our lives.

I love the names you came up with for everyone, especially December and Shiloh. Regarding the story itself...

December was a test subject, a Guineau Pig for everything from cancer treatments to cosmetics. At the moment she was being prepared as a test subject for a potential lung cancer cure- that was why she was smoking.


I think this part cuts a bit the on-going story mood. We had a previous paragraph containing a description and a desire for freedom and suddenly we read this paragraph which basically explains her situation and story. Although it is needed information, I feel it is given in a too direct way; perhaps it would be better if you could incorporate these facts on the previous paragraphs, thus avoiding the awkward "that was why she was smoking" expression.

The last paragraph is well-phrased, particularly the last sentence. I was very interested in reading more about December's past, and I wonder if you could put more music references in her POV? It would make the reader constantly compare her current situation to her past, which could develop the emotional charge of the story.

Now I loved Shiloh's first point of view: she is a woman who knows what she wants and that is clear to the very end. Her determination, although different from Asher's, is an intense one as well, for it is powered by strong love.

I don't know much about the condition of Bipolar Disorder, but by the time I was reading Asher's POV I already found myself comparing the different character's states of mind. I think you did good on that topic: we have a reminiscing December, a in-love/bitter Shiloh and a revolutionary/resilient Asher.

The scene were December steals the fatal injection is somewhat rushed: I'd like to read more on it, especially on what it contained (treatment for what?). And why were not any guards making sure it would be out of reach for the test subjects?

Shiloh's reaction to December's death, although predictable considering her character, is too much Romeo & Juliet. I wish her POV was more creative in showing her passion for December and the actual suicide.

Next, I was absolutely intrigued by Jasper. In a place where almost everybody had their spirits broken (except Asher, who made the surprising decision of killing himself and urging a mass suicide), who was this character? We learn he is older than Asher, but how does he manage to keep control while being a test subject as well?

By the end of the story, I felt you raise an important question which everyone should give a few moments of thought: what is worth dying for? And will people be more impressed and remember more about someone if that person dies for a cause? Good theme, open for so many interpretations and interesting opinions.

Thank you for the reading :]




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 26
Before I critique this, I just want to say that the content of this is impressive.


That being said, there were a few problems that I found with this piece.

Here they are, the things you could improve:

Until the Regime began its campaign to ban music completely.

Why? I doubt this made the Regime popular. I also doubt it made it more powerful. I can only see it making more enemies toward the Regime. Overall, this political action makes the Regime weaker.

If they don’t kill me, I can only hope they’ll do me some good. God knows I’m depressed.

In my opinion, Shiloh sounds more hopeful than depressed.

...was dubbed a freak and sent to this oppressive, twisted hellhole. I’m not about to take that lying down.

This part was good, except Asher commits suicide later, which somewhat contradicts "I'm not about to take that lying down." (I'll get back to this)

I was in my workshop...

They give him a workshop? For living under tyranny, this doesn't sound so bad. Hey, I could use a workshop!

I’ve tried negotiating honestly with the administrators, asking for better conditions and more initiative

Show, don't tell. It would be more powerful if you have the character in a scene, for the readers to see, where he does as you describe. This should be a story, not a summary.

I’ve tried sabotaging the medical equipment

Again, in my opinion, showing grips the reader more than telling.

they simply enforced more secure protection.

They do? But he gets a workshop...

Finally, enraged and exhausted, I found some instructions on the internet for making bombs from scratch and did what I could to scrounge up the necessary parts from lab equipment.

He has access to the internet? To quote your story, "they simply enforced more secure protection." You contradict yourself here. Instead of showing us how they "enforce secure protection," you just describe his workshop, his internet access, and his attempts to make bombs.
Aren't these characters under surveillance?

I’m the only one here who hasn’t been beaten into submission.

But he's not the only one to commit suicide. In fact, he manages to organize a "suicide revolution." (More on this later).

They don’t see that all of my fury is out of compassion for them.

Neither do I.

The best kind of revolution is rooted in love.

Or suicide. (More on this later).

December returned to the laboratory. Filling a large syringe dangerously full with one of the most potent treatments, she slipped it discreetly into her sleeve and headed back to the vacant lot.

This paragraph needs the most work of all.
First of all, what laboratory? You don't mention it until now.
Secondly, are these test subjects supervised? Are they honestly allowed to waltz into the laboratory, fill a syringe, and leave?
Thirdly, this paragraph should be a climax of your story. Killing herself shouldn't be this easy, and your story's climax shouldn't last one paragraph.
Also, you should show us, rather than summarize.

I noticed a syringe tumble from her limp hand. I picked it up and held it to the light, the dying sunlight illuminating an oddly colored liquid.

Honestly, these people should be supervised.

“Shiloh?! Jesus, I heard someone else snuffed it… but Shiloh?!”

You don't tell us who is speaking here until it's too late. I think you should at least give us, the readers, a warning, such as: 'I hear a voice behind me,' before you throw this dialogue at us.
For all we know, it could be Asher speaking.

The fascists can control every aspect of our lives, but they can’t control how we die. They need us. They lose us,they lose scientific progress. I think this is the answer, if I can find a way to organize it. I know I’ll give my life for liberation.

I don't find any of this to be believable.
Firstly, if these "tyrants" have control, then yes, they can control how their subjects die. Unless, of course, they leave syringes lying around. Unless, of course, they let subjects roam about the place unnoticed.
Secondly, if they need the test subjects, why don't they supervise them? I think if test subjects are able to have a workshop, have internet access, and are able to easily commit suicide, they aren't being supervised properly.
Thirdly, there are more effective revolutions than mass suicide.

To quote you:

The best kind of revolution is rooted in love.

Not mass suicide. Think of Gandhi. Think of Martin Luther King. Think of non-violent resistance.

The characters could just refuse to cooperate. That doesn't necessarily mean they all have to kill themselves.

Unless, the best kind of revolution is NOT rooted in love, but in depression and desperation. You seem to contradict yourself here.

Between each phrase, he would force more capsules down his throat, attempting not to gag on them.

Unless the "tyrants" wanted to see what would happen, I'm under the impression that they aren't monitoring Asher. Where did the bottle of pills come from?
Characters can't just pull bottles of pills out of thin air. That doesn't work, especially when the characters are supposed to be living under tyranny.
These characters should be put under surveillance.

Almost a decade later, I am free. Liberated, like Asher promised

Is this true? I have trouble believing this.
Show us, don't tell us.
Please. This is a story, not a summary.

A string of suicides that lead to the admin’s reluctant liberation of the test subjects when they realized it was futile to keep us there.

This, actually, is a major part of your story's climax. The climactic resolution – in one sentence.

A climax is built off of conflict.
You need to draw out your climaxes. Make them longer than a sentence or a paragraph.
Don't just tell the readers what happens.

I’m an activist, now, in honor of Asher, in honor of Shiloh and all the others, The regime is far from overthrown, but our movement is gaining ground, chipping away slowly but surely.

At least he didn't commit suicide. Still, I find this paragraph to be the most far-fetched of all.
Okay, so the tyrants simply let Asher and the remaining test subjects go. But then, they simply let them become activists and openly oppose the Regime. Why? That's ridiculous. I don't find that convincing for one minute. (Unless, of course, this Regime has no power).

I also noticed that both Shiloh's and Asher's accounts were written in first person, while December's story was written in third person.
I think if you're going to have more than one character speak in first person, then you should have all of them tell their stories in first person.
Otherwise, in my opinion, you should either have only one speak in first person, or have none speak in first person. One or none, you pick.

As to your writing style, I'd say you need to show more than tell.
Show us events as they happen, rather than talking about them after they happen.
It's a story, not a summary.

I hope my critique helped.

Other than that, I found the content of this story to be impressive, intriguing, and thought-provoking.

Although your technique could use some work, your content was excellent.

To me, this story was worth reading. I'm glad I did.

Also,
I am from the class of the oppressed, the abused, the downtrodden. We might be broken, but we are resilient, irrepressible, and together we’ll rise like a wave.

I liked your last sentence.

PM me if you have any questions or concerns.
If you have a horror story on YWS, feel free to PM me.
If you would like me to critique it, say so.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2401
Reviews 95
"I am from the class of the oppressed, the abused, the downtrodden. We might be broken, but we are resilient, irrepressible, and together we’ll rise like a wave."

I love that last line, this story is inspirational. I am a novice and your story is the first I read. I have to say you have set a very high standard.

This story is hope.
Everything has been figured out, except how to live.

Jean-Paul Sartre



The highlighted children are not mine.
— AresFig