Things she Learnt to Lie about [needs help please review]

12 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1477
Reviews 31
Lyra looked out of the window, slowly tracing the words engraved on the panel of the windowsill, under a cushion, "Lyra doesn't lie".
The day was grey and dreary, nothing new there for Cornwall.
The room she sat in had ivory curtains, and a large but simple bed with slightly pink sheets, the floorboards was shiny and clean. The room was impeccably in order. A small pile of unopened books sat on her bedside table.
She sat absolutely still, her dark curls falling down her neck like a waterfall, her grey eyes fixed in the distance, half-biting her cherry red lips, her porcelain coloured skin contrasting with her pink cheeks.

Lyra Goodfellow was the perfect vicar's daughter, the cream of the crop, pride and joy of her family - her temperament : dreamy, her constitution : rosy, her etiquette : flawless.

She was fairly pretty, bright, lively and in all ways delightful : the best daughter, in short, that a poor vicar and his wife could ever live for.

There was only one problem: Lyra was a liar.

Lyra wasn't just any liar, but a damned good one at that. She'd been telling lies practically ever since she could talk. She lied about not being tired and not being hungry, she lied about who had eaten the pot of strawberry jam. She lied about how the cat had gotten into the dustbin. She lied about why poor Mrs. Smithheart's front porch was covered in red paint. She lied about where Goldie's doll was. She lied, a lot.

As she grew up, she started telling new sorts of lies: she learnt to lie about what her father preached in church. She learnt to lie about her night time wanderings on the Cornish coastlines which soon became haunted by strange children, swarming with bloodthirsty sharks, crawling with fierce pitiless pirates armed to the teeth. In all these tales she was the one and only hero, the adventurous wench, the skilful warrior; and she lost herself in her newly spun web of fantasies.

She learnt to lie about the Bible class homework she'd never done. She learnt to lie about what she thought of the parishers. She learnt to lie about where she was going and the reason why she smelled of tobacco. She learnt to lie about who she spent the night with, it didn't matter any more right? Who bloody well cared which idiotic spiritually annihilated cunt she'd fucked all night long?

She learnt to lie about where she came from. She learnt to lie about what she believed in. And in the end, she learnt how to lie about who she was. All these things that she learnt to lie about, all those dark secrets whispered to a cold night, they were drowning her in the very whirlpool she'd created.

Only then did she start lying to herself.

To herself, she learnt to lie about how she had become this way. She learnt to lie about how much she cared. She learnt to lie about why she lied so much in the first place. She learnt to lie about why she kept pretending nothing was happening. And most of all, she learnt to lie about the few things she knew left to be true.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 7718
Reviews 136
The opening maintained a sort of loose grip on the present then as it went further along it slipped into a kind of afterthought.

The character seems to make alot of contemplations concerning herself, not her actions or others or even the actions of others.

Her continued explanation of her lying got a bit old, I'll be honest, past the first two portions she explained.

I liked her description of her stories and the creation of worlds and characters that inhabited them, very well done, I always like a kind of lost, dreamy catch to any story.

I'd suggest focusing more on the story itself, going beyond the character's almost monotonous of her skills as a liar, it was good to be honest, but if you wish to take this further, her thoughts should be kept to an interesting measure, never fully taking the stage.

Unless this is intended to be a thought and philosophy fiction then by all means, I know what its like to pour discussions and debates into a single thought of a character.

I liked it, would love to see more, just tweak a few things.

Exe's and Oh's, Eraqio.
A story's not a story till you've made it up you see.
Look Mexico.




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 9
I really liked this a lot. When i first saw where you were going with this and the ending came into view it did hit me pretty hard and it was sad which is very, very good. it was well written anyway, but right around the part of the spiritually annihilated cunts i realized it was better than i thought, that it was going somewhere definite and really sad. i don't know what to say about it, except i know something's really good when it gets me like this does. i mean you really set everything up for the point of the story nicely, so when you see where it's going it's almost emotional. my only problem is that, for me, it kind of peaks before the ending rather than at the ending. i know what you're trying to do with the ending but it doesn't come off as powerful, i guess, as it does a paragraph before, so the last few lines come off as being a little repetitive.

i only put in the part about the ending because you said you wanted it critiqued and that was the only fault i found, but it's great anyway the way it is. i mean i got halfway through and i said "oh this is good" because it winds down and down, just getting better and better because the lies are getting worse and worse. i'll say it again, that when i anticipated the ending, it really came at me strong. and i've got The things they carried lying around. i think i might start that one next, now.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 72525
Reviews 1220
Lyra Goodfellow was the perfect vicar's daughter - the cream of the crop; pride and joy of her family; her temperament, dreamy; her constitution, rosy; her etiquette, flawless.

She learnt to lie about who she spent the night with; it didn't matter any more right?

Who bloody well cared which idiotic, spiritually annihilated cunt she'd fucked all night long?

Other than that, I didn't notice anything odd grammar-wise.

Honestly, the beginning did not hook me. You lumped all this physical description of her into one paragraph, and it read as an infodump. I suggest excising that paragraph entirely. You tell us later on that she is beautiful, and that is all we need know. The color of her complexion, hair, or eyes is not relevant to the rest of the story.

That aside, once you got to the lying bits, I was intrigued. You lead into this well, and how you slowly built up the lies from minor to major was wonderfully done. I also liked the repetition of "she learnt to lie;" it gave a definite rhythm to the story which I enjoyed.

Overall, this was well-written and I enjoyed reading it. You just need to trim down the beginning so that it doesn't drag. :D
Secretly a Kyllorac, sometimes a Murtle.
There are no chickens in Hyrule.
Princessence: A LMS Project
WRFF | KotGR




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 7
I chose this because I was intrigued by the interesting title. It was good and the main character was well drawn, however I thought it ended too soon. I thought maybe something would happen to the main character and she would see the consequences of her lies.

Keep writing




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1477
Reviews 31
Thanks to all for answering, sorry I've been a bit absent lately...
Eraqio and Pringle, this is about the lies not their consequences or other poepl, it's supposed to speak for itself, which is why i suppose Kyllorac is right and I could skip the initial description... It's just it would then seem like poetry in prose rather than fiction.
I wanted a real character with a universal value.
Snillaz, I realise what you say about the last paragraph, maybe shortening it, i haven't got the time atm, but will certainly look into it!
xxx




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 690
Reviews 1
I found this piece of writing really intriguing and I hope you will carry on with this soon!
I thought the repitition throughout was well applied and is what kept me hooked. I also liked how you used short paragraphs to add impact.

All these things that she learnt to lie about, all those dark secrets whispered to a cold night, they were drowning her in the very whirlpool she'd created.

I liked this metaphor a lot.

Lyra looked out of the window, slowly tracing the words engraved on the panel of the windowsill, under a cushion, "Lyra doesn't lie".

This was the first line of the story but you didn't explain why that was carved into the windowsill. I think to continue this piece of writing you could try going into that further.

the floorboards was shiny and clean

It should be the floorboards were shiny and clean.
Don't know if this will help but I enjoyed reading it a lot!

Roisin :D




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 9
Isn't "Lyra Doesn't Lie" what was engraved into the windowsill? Which is why it's in quotes. Maybe if the last comma was changed to a colon it would be clearer.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1477
Reviews 31
Yuh, I guess, snillaz, do you think it should be longer, like more details about every single lie, and building up a world around her, sort of like more Tim O'Brianish...
xx




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 9
i think it's good how it is you know. and i just finished the things they carried and i liked it a lot, which is why i came back :). the only thing i think this lacks that tim obrien's does is that her lies seem less particular and interesting and characteristic of a life. like "pot of strawberry jam" and "cat in the dustbin" seem over used and little-english-fable like. but you know this piece has a lot of fable elements to it, like her being the rosy cheeked vicar's daughter, so it doesn't get overly cliche either. anyway i'd like it better if her lies were more personal and intricate kind of, but that's just me and what i like. cuz this works well as a little english fable gone wrong (i mean gone dark, not like badly written). hey i like reviewing. peace out i think ur a good writer




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1477
Reviews 31
Peace girl! So are you!
hah, ok yeah, i'll see what i can do.. "practice makes perfect" right?
Anyways, i'm still debating whether or not to write something for a school contest, so might do that next.




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 9
haha yeah ok. i'd love to read it when it's done.



You have been de-shenaniganed.
— WaffleCat