Her Last Song

7 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 17
[spoiler]This is the first story I've posted on this site! I should have posted this earlier because it's due tomorrow and it has A LOT of problems. An explanation for this piece is at the bottom.[/spoiler]

Alma grew up nurtured by song. From the time she was born, her mother sang as she cooked, cleaned, and darned socks. She sang when Alma skinned her knees and she sang when Alma graduated elementary school - her mother’s voice woke her in the morning and lulled her to sleep at night. But Alma began to notice a break in her mother’s singing when she winced from walking up the front steps of the house or when Alma hugged her too tightly . Her mother went to the doctor, and soon after medical bills began to pile up and her mother began to sing less and spend her time sleeping. The neighbors ushered in to take care of Alma, her mother, and her house. Her mother was very sick, they told her, her mother needed her rest or the disease would take her completely.

The disease, or bone cancer Alma soon found out it was called, had somehow managed to turn her mother to glass, and Alma became afraid to touch her or even be near her mother. As if her very proximity would cause her mother to shatter, she was frightened to touch her; Alma very well knew that she would be unable to fix her when she finally fell apart. She avoided her mother for the most part, only kissing her in the morning and evenings and bringing her breakfast. She took her meals in her room or spent time outside with the other children of the barrio, unable to handle the silence.

As weeks passed and with each week arrived a new problem and new bills, Alma found herself hiding things from her mother. Whenever her socks were worn with holes she learned to darn them herself. She learned how to tape up her shoes so her mother wouldn’t be burdened with having to buy anything. She hemmed her pants, and she cleaned the house when the neighbors were unable to come. It became common for her to dawdle after school, to allow her feet to take her to any place in the barrio. Anywhere else besides her silent house.

One day, she found her feet carrying her to the local parish, and there she prayed. She prayed to Jesus, Saint Mary, God, Saint Raphael - anyone who would hopefully listen and make her mother better. To make her mother sing again, to make her happy. Weeks passed and with every week she went to the church after school to pray once more. Her mother’s long hair was falling out in clumps, drifting to the ground like forgotten papers.

Alma visited the church again on Thursday, holding her left shoe in her hand. It had finally split into two unfixable pieces. She set the broken shoe on the pew next to her and pressed her hands together, she closed her eyes and prayed as she did everyday hoping that some saint would take pity on her mother’s burden and lift it. A hand rested on her shoulder. She looked up to see Father Ortega.

“Back again, mija? Praying for your mother?”

Alma nodded, and looked at the ground. Her eyes were watering. Ortega sat next to her, silent.

“Why don’t they listen to me?”

“Who?”

“The saints….God…they all ignore me. They’re not helping my mother. I don‘t understand,” her voice was shaking slightly.

“You want to know a secret, Alma? I’ve been studying God and the saints for most of my life, and I don’t understand them either, but I do know that you’re not alone and that they do hear you. They act in strange ways that you and I can’t possibly understand.”

“Will my mother get better?” Alma asked; she was looking at him now. She found it rather easy to talk to him, it was like talking to her mother. Complete understanding and love.

“I don’t know, but we can hope, can’t we? We can love her can’t we? We can be with her and help her through this, can’t we?”

“I haven’t been with her,” Alma broke out into a sob. “I’ve been avoiding her.”

Father Ortega placed his hand over Alma’s, “This is hard thing for you and your mother, and you’re dealing with it the only way you know how. It’s not the best way, but we all do it. We all run away from are problems when we should be facing them head on. Come, let’s talk to your mother.”

Father Ortega pulled her up gently by the hand. Alma picked up her shoe and followed him out of the church.

“What happened to your shoe?”

“It’s been falling apart, and I don’t know what to do…”

“I’ll buy you another pair.”

“Thank you, Father.”

When they reached the house, Alma unlocked the door and led Father Ortega in. He walked ahead of her and towards her mother’s room where he knocked on the door. “It’s Jorge Ortega,” he said. “May I come in?” Her mother was silent, but eventually welcomed him in. Alma waited in the kitchen.

After a half-hour of waiting, the Father walked into the room. He smiled at Alma and wrote down her size shoe and promised her a new pair the next day when she came to church. He left soon after, and as Alma walked towards her mother room, she heard a noise. It was soft as a whisper at first, but grew until Alma realized that it was her mother - singing.


[spoiler]The prompt was write a piece with a surprise ending for my creative writing class. :)[/spoiler]
Last edited by Dahlia on Wed Mar 11, 2009 9:18 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Do you want a critique by Dahlia? If so, Click here!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1124
Reviews 21
I'm really sorry, but this is going to be one of those worthless "I loved it" comments. That was amazing! It was so... it can't even think of the words. You made the characters believable, I love the way how you described everything. It was just... awesome!
and I could kind of see how you meant for Father Ortega to be Alma's father, but I didn't see it until after you had pointed it out.

Again, sorry I couldn't give any constructive criticism, but I can't find anything that needs very much improvement.
----
If you can't dazzle the world with your knowledge, Then baffle them with your bullshit.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6517
Reviews 402
Hey Dahlia! I'm so glad you posted something. You've been doing so many great reviews (I see you around a lot), and you deserve a bunch of reviews yourself. :)
---

From when she was born, her mother sang as she cooked, cleaned, and darned socks.

"From when" -- this is too wordy, darling. From clutters up the sentence. Consider rephrasing: "When she was born", or "From the time she was born".

But Alma began to notice break in her mother’s singing when she winced from walking up the front steps of the house or when Alma hugged her too tightly

Notice *a* break. Small typo, no biggie!

As if her very proximity would cause her mother to shatter; Alma very well knew that she would be unable to fix her when she finally fell apart.

As it is, the semi-colon is incorrect. There are several ways to fix this though. You could add an "It" at the beginning of the sentence -- "It was as if her very proximity" -- though I don't recommend this was the most because then you what exactly is IT referring to? Then you don't have the best description possible. The best way here, I believe, is to add another clause before the semi-colon that makes the first part complete, like: "As if her very proximity would cause her mother to shatter, she ________ (frightened to touch her, possible? something along those lines); Alma very well knew that she would be unable to fix her when she finally fell apart." Or you could just stick with the more simple "It was as if her very proximity". Whichever you want.

As weeks passed and with each week a new problem and new bills

You need another verb in here, since it seems like the problems are passing, the way you have it phrased. Consider: "As weeks passed and with each week arrived a new problem and new bills,".

She prayed to Jesus, Saint Mary, God, Saint Raphael - anyone who would hopefully listen and [s]to[/s] make her mother better.

'Tis a clutter word in strike.

“Will my mother get better?” Alma asked, she was looking at him now.

This is an example of the dreaded comma splice. The part after the comma needs to be a new sentence. Consider either a period, or a semi-colon.

Oh wow! This was such a beautiful little story. I can see that there might be a continuation, though I do believe this is meant to be a solitary piece -- though I could be wrong. It's very nicely written, and the storyline is really sweet. I applaud you for writing something so sincere and concise.

The only plot-based qualm I can think of is that the ending seems a little quick. Mainly because I'm not entirely sure why her mother was inspired to sing again at the end -- you don't relay the meaning well enough in the story for me to catch onto it. I'm thinking it's because the Father was so kind to her daughter, and Alma was able to talk to someone about what was going on, but I can't be entirely sure. Add some more at the end, so we can see the total inspiration for the return to song.

Other than that, I really love this. I hope you post more, Dahlia! PM me if you have any questions, and I hope I was helpful. :)

~ Clo
How am I not myself?




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 15698
Reviews 369
It's good to see that you've posted some of your own work up here. And this is a good story, or at least, I rather liked it. The characters are all very good, your pacing is fine, and I could follow along with the story. All in all, a solid effort on your part.

And yet there is one problem I have with it, and it's with the part that matters to you. I honestly could not tell if Father Ortega was indeed her father. This one is going to require a lot of explanation from you, as far as within the story goes. I take it that Father Ortega is Catholic. Catholic priests are supposed to take a vow of celibacy. This doesn't mean that he can't be her father, but you're going to have to come up with a good explanation as to how it happened.

Also, I have a problem with the whole 'Father Ortega is Alma's father' idea. It seems rather cliche nowadays. Ever since Star Wars, it's been the thing to do, and has grown rather stale in my opinion. I'm not demanding that you change it though, just suggesting it.

Again, this is a good story. You're just going to need to work with it a little before it can be called a great one. If you have any questions, or just want to scream at me for something, you can drop me a PM and I'll be happy to help. Again, good job, and good luck. :)

-Conrad Rice
Garrus Vakarian is my homeboy.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 17
Rhiannon - Thank you. I'm glad you enjoyed it. :)

Clo - You're exactly right, the end is to quick. I was writing this yesterday and I got really frustrated because I couldn't think of how to convey the surprise ending/ending so I just wrote something just to hastily tie it all together. I don't know if I'm going to continue this, but I definitely want to fix it because I do like the story. Thank you so much for your review - it was very helpful. :D

Conrad Rice - I wouldn't scream at you, haha, your review was really helpful. I couldn't think of how the portray that Father Ortega was the father or how the relationship started. I know how it started and everything, but I just wanted to finish it so I could turn it in on time. I just need to figure out how to write it in or change the story altogether. The end is cliche now that I think of it. Thanks so much for pointing all this out to me. :D
Do you want a critique by Dahlia? If so, Click here!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6403
Reviews 312
As Clo said, YAY! You posted some of your own work, and now I get to return the favor!
*rolls up sleeves*

Honestly, I really adored this. It was, for lack of a better word, cute. But it was also sad slash inspirational slash wonderfully mysterious. I'll come right out and tell you that I had no idea that Ortega was her father. And (I know this doesn't follow the prompt, but) I'm not sure he should be. First of all, he's a priest, and forgive me if I'm wrong - I'm not very educated in religion - but aren't they supposed to be celibate? And why would his visit make the mother happy, when I feel like she'd be angry that he left her? And how could he not see that his daughter's life was falling apart and reassure her that she would, at least, still have one parent left?

This is the last I'll say on the subject, I swear, but before I read the spoiler, I actually liked not knowing. I liked speculating what Ortega could have told the mother that made her sing, if he prayed with her, hugged her, talked to her, or just sat and held her hand for awhile. You know? It added a nice bit of mystery that every reader would interpret differently.

(Can you tell that I'm feeling passionate about this story? ;-))

Anyway, other than that, it really does not need much work. It's very touching and wonderfully written and if you can't tell, I think you did a nice job. The only other issue I had is that I wanted to know more about how Alma reacted to her mother's disease - I know that was mostly background information, but it seemed odd that her mother was disintegrating and I got no sense of her daughter's emotions. Was she hurt, angry, sad, numb, did she not understand? Or a combination of all? You don't have to go overboard, but I would like a sense of how she's feeling.

Keep it up! Sorry I didn't get to this in time for you to turn it in, but good luck with the revision!
-Mars
'life tastes sweeter when it's wrapped in poetry'
-the wombats


critiques // nano




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 17
Mars: Thanks so much. I agree with you, we read our stories in class today and no one guessed it so I didn't tell anyone they said they looked it. :) The whole reason I came up with it was because I just couldn't think of an ending and I thought Ortega was too perfect so I wanted to add something to him that was bad so I just kind of ended up with that.
Do you want a critique by Dahlia? If so, Click here!



Don't be sad bc sad backwards is das and das not good
— LadyMysterio