Brownie time!

4 posts

What can I improve on?

Descriptive devices
0
No votes
Clarity in description
0
No votes
Plot
0
No votes
Endings
1
100%
Beginnings
0
No votes
 
Total votes : 1


User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9593
Reviews 216
Hello... I recently was required to construct a short story from a childhood memory. It was for a school assignment, but this isn't what I handed in. Alas, it is (in my opinion) much better than what I used, but I thought of the idea after the due date. The point of the exercise was discriptive writing.

I am looking for all comments, grammatical errors or descriptive devices that sound out of place. Hope you like it!


_______________________

I quickly removed the lid and sub-consciously shook off the warning of what the container contained. I lay the lid down, and carefully avoided the soft plume of thin white powder that erupted from its holding pen. With circumspect in mind, I forced my hand into the box, filtering through the floating fine particles, and created a wave of motion in my wake. The mixture stirred as I cautiously dipped my spoon into the wave of residue, carefully extracting the instructed amount. I cupped the teaspoon in my hand as I transported it over its waiting future.

The baking powder splashed into my previously prepared concoction, sending drops of flying dregs all over the bowl. I grabbed the mixing spoon and hurriedly sloshed it around in the basin, sending brownie soaring in all directions. After adding the final ingredient, I ran the short distance to the cupboards and pulled out the deepest dish that I could get away with. With great difficulty, I heaved the immense dish onto the bench, and hauled the enormous and substantial bowl containing the mixture up, and leaned it on an angle, so I could spoon the brownies into the awaiting dish.

Ding! The Brownies were ready. I sprinted into the kitchen and thrusted open the oven door. I hastily threw my hands at the plate, eager to sink my sweet tooth into the chocolaty treat as soon as possible. Without hesitation, I grabbed the brownies and yanked the hotplate out of the heated compartment.

It was milliseconds before I realised, maybe it was the adrenalin of having a luscious meal awaiting me, or maybe it was just the innocent mind of the child that I was back then. But whatever the reason for my delayed reaction, the dish was hot, and I was already halfway to the bench…

SMASH! The Pyrex dish shattered on the floor, spluttering and splashing in every possible direction. Millions of tiny diamonds rippled across the floor and settled to a halt in impossible to reach places. Wave after wave rippled across the floor, splattering my feet with tiny beads, dowsing my calf’s in a spray of bombardment.

I looked down at the devastation, and felt my face droop to the floor. My head fell as limp as an evergreen leaf in the rain. My eyes dropped out of their sockets as I revelled at what it would all mean. As I scanned the floor for any sign of life, death or something in-between, I locked onto my target. With great swiftness, I scooped up the brown residue in a sweeping motion. Shaking off the loose glass, I shovelled the cooked brownies into my mouth, handful at a time, cleaning up the evidence.

After the mess was all cleaned up, I heaved out the recipe book, flicked to the well worn page and read “brownies.” I constructed a mental checklist for the ingredients, as I reminisced from the delectable treat I had just consumed, clutching my tummy as it rebut…

_______________________

All comments welcome, and thank you for reviewing my short story!
::XoX::KeepWriting::XoX::

GENERATION 29: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and add 1 to the generation. Social experiment.

Writing is 3% talent and 97% not being distracted by the internet




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1104
Reviews 47
I quickly removed the lid and sub-consciously shook off the warning of what the container contained. (This is a good concept to open on - but you're using too many words - maybe cut "subconciously" I do this sort of thing too...) I lay (Laid?)the lid down, and carefully avoided the soft plume of thin white powder that erupted from its holding pen. With circumspect in mind, I forced my hand into the box, filtering through the floating fine particles, and created a wave of motion in my wake. The mixture stirred as I cautiously dipped my spoon into the wave of residue, carefully extracting the instructed amount. I cupped the teaspoon in my hand as I transported it over its waiting future. (transported it towards its fate might sound tighter)

The baking powder splashed into my previously prepared concoction, sending drops of flying dregs (Drops of flying dregs? Can you rephrase this, that doesn't make much sense to me) all over the bowl. I grabbed the mixing spoon and hurriedly sloshed it around in the basin, sending brownie soaring in all directions. After adding the final ingredient, I ran the short distance to the cupboards and pulled out the deepest dish that I could get away with. With great difficulty, I heaved the immense dish onto the bench, and hauled the enormous and substantial bowl containing the mixture up, and leaned it on an angle, so I could spoon the brownies into the awaiting (waiting) dish.

Ding! (like it!) The Brownies were ready. I sprinted into the kitchen and thrusted (thrust) open the oven door. I hastily threw my hands at the plate, eager to sink my sweet tooth into the chocolaty treat as soon as possible.(cut "as soon as possible - it's not necessary) Without hesitation, I grabbed the brownies and yanked the hotplate out of the heated (cut heated - also, are you sure hotplate is one word?) compartment.


It was milliseconds before I realised, maybe it was the adrenalin of having a luscious meal awaiting me, or maybe it was just the innocent mind of the child that I was back then. (watch punctuation, you need to keep but... in this same sentence, or else the first sentence is incomplete - sorry to be nitpicky))But whatever the reason for my delayed reaction, the dish was hot, and I was already halfway to the bench…


SMASH! The Pyrex dish shattered on the floor, spluttering and splashing in every possible direction. (this has actually happened to me - accurate description. mention also the way your heart sinks) Millions of tiny diamonds rippled across the floor and settled to a halt in impossible to reach places. Wave after wave rippled across the floor, splattering my feet with tiny beads, dowsing my calf’s (try calves. Calf's is "belonging to the baby cow) in a spray of bombardment. (does that make sense? - even just try dousing.)

I looked down at the devastation, and felt my face droop to the floor. My head fell as limp as an evergreen leaf in the rain. My eyes dropped out of their sockets as I revelled at what it would all mean. As I scanned the floor for any sign of life, death or something in-between, I locked onto my target. With great swiftness, I scooped up the brown residue in a sweeping motion. Shaking off the loose glass, I shovelled the cooked brownies into my mouth, handful at a time, cleaning up the evidence.


After the mess was all cleaned up, I heaved out the recipe book, flicked to the well worn page and read “brownies.” I constructed a mental checklist for the ingredients, as I reminisced from the delectable treat I had just consumed, clutching my tummy as it rebut… (nice end)




I know I must sound pernickety in this critique, but its advice you're probably going to hear again and again. Like, I just took a course in creative writing, and these are exactly the same things my tutor said to me (and I hated her for them!) I know you were trying to be descriptive but don't go too far in the other direction and overwrite. Often, a simple image or one well chosen word will do just as well as the elaborate phrases you use here. If you really want to repeat an idea, spread it through the story (like nuts and choc chips into brownies) rather than find three different ways of putting it into the same paragraph.

Also, you need to watch your grammar. The couple of things you got wrong are easy t do, but you have to be aware of the tense you are using.


Contrary to what this might sound like, I really enjoyed your story. If you edit it again and be really stric with yourself, you'll be left with a good account of a childhood memory. My only other suggestion is that you experiment with word choice and point of view - this is a childhood srtory, but a lot of the words you use are mature. Does that make sense? It would seem more authentic if you tried to get back into the mindset of the child.

hope this helps :D
_______________________


All comments welcome, and thank you for reviewing my short story!
"I want my journey to be full of laughter"

Final Fantasy X




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9593
Reviews 216
Yeah, that really helped, thanks :). It didn't sound harsh to me at all. I know I always mix up the tenses, and so I went over it again, but I did miss those few occasions... I suck at grammer and editing my own work ^_^

tanks again for the in depth critique!
::XoX::KeepWriting::XoX::

GENERATION 29: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and add 1 to the generation. Social experiment.

Writing is 3% talent and 97% not being distracted by the internet




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9593
Reviews 216
Any reviews... NOTHING?!?? can I at least get some answers to my pol then??

Appreciated :P
::XoX::KeepWriting::XoX::

GENERATION 29: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and add 1 to the generation. Social experiment.

Writing is 3% talent and 97% not being distracted by the internet



You can do it, serpent king!
— Rhett McLaughlin