Maharaj The Magician [edited]

20 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9692
Reviews 3900
Okay, so this is the nit-picky review! The better review, full of lovely commentary on the actual story, is on TWS (since we need to get that place up and running!) This review is primarily stylistic things or just things that came to mind while I was reading... because I know how much you loooooove line-by-line critiques. :P

It's attached as a Word file. If you can't get it, just bug me!

...now! I'll be off to write the critique on TWS! Live long and prosper!
Attachments
reviewforjigglypuff.doc
(44.5 KiB) Downloaded 37 times
Ubi caritas est vera, Deus ibi est.

"The mark of your ignorance is the depth of your belief in injustice and tragedy. What the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the Master calls the butterfly." ~ Richard Bach

Moth and Myth <- My comic! :D




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 6517
Reviews 798
....you complete me.

XD.

Thanks! :)
Mah name is jiggleh. And I like to jiggle.

"Indecision and terror, thy name is novel." - Chiko




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 28467
Reviews 675
First of all Jiggs, thank you a billion times over for reminding me of my WRFF thread. I ish here…ten days later than my normal. *eek*

Darn Birds

Okay, the thing that bothers me is the lack of description of the dream the first time the raven is brought up. It’s so little description that I missed it the first time I read through the story and I was confused when the raven was mentioned the second time.

Characters

I do like the two main characters, most especially Maharaj because he is unique and reminds me, in a way of a mix between the Emperor of San Francisco and William, the Huge Cat Guy, both of who appear in several of Christopher Moore’s books. I’m not sure why but I do really like it.

As for Jake, well, I think we need to know a little more about him. Like how old he is for starters. Obviously this is just the beginning but just remember to add more too him, probably pretty soon.

What should you give away?

The only real problem I have with this is that you don’t give us enough. Usually I see a problem where people info dump at the beginning but here, I think you need to add a little more and slow down the ending a bit.

Overall though, this is really good and I’m sorry that it took me so long to get around to this. *slaps herself with a fish*

~lilymoore
Never forget who you are, for surely the world will not. Make it your strength. Then it can never be your weakness. Armor yourself in it, and it will never be used to hurt you.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 6517
Reviews 798
Thanks Lily, I just updated this - it's the most revised edition now.

Cheers
Mah name is jiggleh. And I like to jiggle.

"Indecision and terror, thy name is novel." - Chiko




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 62375
Reviews 315
So...I know I said I'd only review the latest chapter, but I needed to get my thoughts in order first, so I thought I'd write some brief notes here, on reading this 'revised' version. You've been told several times, I should think, that the beginning was a stunner - right in the middle of the action; media res; and enticing description...the magician is really something and for me, that should have really been the focus. I liked the dialogue in general, and I thought you did well with keeping each little section fast-paced, but with enough details to give us a sense of what it was about.

I agree with Ky - the MC became boring as soon as he stepped into the normal world. We had so many littler storylines running here: the magician, the disrupted family, the naughty sister, the failing of schoolwork, Jenna...and there seemed to be little overarching focus on any one particular storyline. I'm not saying take the others out and just leave the magician one - I can see what you're trying to do by creating an all-rounded character. :D I'm just saying that give the magician-one a little more of a focus (since I assume that's the central story for the novel from your title).

Currently, each little section is short and snappy - but this means that the magician one is, too. Why don't I hear the MC constantly thinking about the magician? What are his feelings towards things? Why does he come across as deeper when with the Maharaj, but shallower when with his friends and family? The switches between road, house, bedroom, school, class are quite fast - not necessarily a bad thing - but the magician story seems to get lost amongst all the other little ones. I want to see it on his mind. I want him to keep thinking about it, rather than just dismissing it for the time-being.

Anyway, I liked it overall, and I'm off to reread the next chapter now!



Minds are like parachutes. They only function when they are open.
— Sir James Dewar, Scientist