The Broken -- TC -- Chapter Two

10 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 9907
Reviews 506
(Chapter One)

------------------

Lucy.

Her prison was pleasant enough, Lucy supposed. It wasn’t the prison itself that angered her, really, it was the fact that it was a prison at all. The crack in the pretty wooden door where she had punched it stood as testament to this. She’d been locked in the room all day, ever since she’d been thrown in it the previous night.

It was the … the injustice of it all that made it so bad. She hadn’t done anything wrong, had committed no crime.

Well, no crime that she could remember anyway. It was like … she had been doing something, and then suddenly she was somewhere else. That was how it felt. Only she couldn’t remember what it was she had been doing, and the somewhere else she suddenly was happened to be a forest. Also, she had been naked, which had complicated matters somewhat when the soldiers turned up.

She sat on the bed, staring at nothing in particular, drowning in an ocean of her own boredom. The predominate colour surrounding her was beige. The room had beige walls, and a beige carpet, and a beige ceiling. The now cracked door broke the colour scheme by daring to be white, as did the blind, which was black.

It was sunny outside, but only a fringe of the light got passed the drawn blind. She had the light switched on instead; the dull, artificial light appealed to her mood more than sunshine did.

She yawned. There was simply nothing to do. She’d have killed for a television, but the room was almost completely bare of any entertainment. There weren’t even any books or magazines to read. Admittedly a CD player sat on the desk next to her bed, but Lucy had tried a couple of the CDs and she’d recognised none of the songs, and she’d liked them even less.

This was, pretty much, hell.

Dull, dull, hell.

Sighing, she dropped her feet onto the carpet and stood up. She didn’t know what the time was - a clock was also on the list of things her captors had neglected to give her - but she’d been sat moping and raging on that bed all day. It was time she did something productive, and have another go at escaping.

She walked over to the door and gave the handle a little twist and push, just to see if its would open after all. Just like before, it didn’t. She kicked the door and turned away.

She’d tried the window last night and had failed to escape by it then. Pulling up the blind, and flinching as a beautiful, sunny day assaulted eyes, she examined it again. It wasn’t really just one window, it was actually six, each one too small for her to fit through. None of them opened anyway, and there wasn’t anything in the room for her to smash the glass with either.

The en-suite bathroom also offered no avenues for escape. It was a little thing, with a toilet, a washing bowl with soap, and that was it. It didn’t have a window in it, only a light bulb on the ceiling. She walked into the bathroom, saw there was still no way to escape her prison from within it, and walked out again.

She sat back down on the bed, out of ideas.

To add to the list of grievances Lucy was building up, the clothes she had been given were awful: a baggy, grey t-shirt and a baggy, grey pair of trousers. The soldiers had neglected to giver her any underwear, or even any socks or shoes. She was not sitting in comfort.

Still, when the clothes had first been given to her, she’d been beyond grateful.

When the three soldiers found her sitting dazed in the woods, she had been naked, and all too aware of it. One of them acted as if nothing was strange at all, one was polite enough to look away, and the third ogled her with a smirk.

The clothes hadn’t come yet, though.

She’d had to walk with the soldiers for a good twenty minutes, ineffectively doing her best to cover herself the entire way, before they arrived at an encampment of temporary homes. She was limping badly by that point, her bare feet complaining against this ruff treatment.

It was there that she was given her clothes.

Another soldier had approached them. One of the ones that found her began, ‘Major, we-’

The Major had held up his hand, and said, ‘Why is she naked, soldier?’

The three men shared an uneasy look. ‘That’s the way we found her,’ one said.

‘You idiots,’ the Major growled. ‘Why did none of you strip off and giver her your clothes? Eh? You should be the ones staggering around naked, not her.’ He glared at them all. ‘And look at her feet! How far did you drag her through that forest barefoot? Idiots.’ He waved a hand. ‘Go. You’re all dismissed.’

Her three escorts had walked off sullenly, whilst the Major pulled Lucy out of the open and into the privacy of the nearest building. There she had been given her new clothes and a few friendly words from the Major. Within minutes she had been packed into the back of a truck and driven down to a military base.

She had been out of the truck for little more than a minute before she had been shoved into her prison, where she had been ever since.

No one had told her what was going on, what had happened to her, or even if she had done anything wrong. Not even the Major had told her anything of importance. No one had visited her either. She wondered if they’d forgotten about her. The thought only made her angrier.

And no sooner had the thought passed through her mind, the door clicked. Lucy jumped, startled by the sudden sound after the long period of near silence. The handle turned and the door opened.

Dressed in a smart, black uniform, a man stepped into the room, dragging a plastic and metal chair behind him. Lucy hadn’t met this particular soldier yet. His eyes met hers, and she thought she could see some level of pity in them, although it was hard to say for certain though.

He had high cheekbones and hollow cheeks that - instead of making him look handsome - combined with his pale skin, thin lips, and dark, deep-set eyes to give him an almost skeletal look. He looked like some incarnation of Death, come to fetch Lucy and take her to the afterlife.

‘Hello, Miss Taylor,’ he said, as he placed the chair next to Lucy’s bed and sat down on it, taking off his Officer’s cap as he did so. ‘My name’s Lieutenant-Colonel Haart’ He placed his cap on the CD player next to the bed. ‘I hope you’ve been comfortable so far?’

Lucy eyed him warily, and leant away from him, pressing her back against the wall. She had already decided she didn’t like him. ‘Not really, no. I haven’t,’ she said.

‘Oh. Well, no, I suppose you wouldn’t have been. I’m sorry, it was a stupid question.’

‘Yes,’ agreed Lucy, ‘it was.’

The Lieutenant-Colonel frowned. ‘Is there anything in particular that could make your stay more comfortable?’

‘Yeah. Don’t make me stay. Let me go home.’

‘Miss Taylor, I’m sorry, I-’

‘Don’t start with that crap!’ she said. ‘Shut the hell up. You’re not sorry! So stop acting it. You lock me in here without telling me anything and now you’re here, with your empty, pointless words and apologises. Keep them! Keep your crap to yourself.

‘Please, just let me go home. That’s … that’s all I want.’

The Lieutenant-Colonel frowned. ‘I can’t do that, Miss Taylor. If I could, I would. But I can’t. As I said, I’m sorry.’

Lucy glared at him, and decided not to say anything. Let him talk about being sorry. She hoped he would chock on an apology one day. Let him talk himself to death.

When it became obvious to the Lieutenant-Colonel that Lucy wasn’t going to reply, he spoke again. ‘I don’t know if you’ll care, but my men have found another in the woods. A boy. He’s on his way here now. I’ve been told he put up a bit of a fight before they managed to subdue him.’ He leaned closer to Lucy. ‘Why didn’t you fight, Miss Taylor?’ His voice dripped with curiosity.

Why hadn’t she fought?

Why would she?

She had been lost, and alone, and scared. Sat in a forest she didn’t know, with no recollection of how she’d got there, naked and shivering, she had clutched at herself, and cried.

The soldiers had rescued her. Why would she fight them?

Lucy eyed him darkly, but didn’t answer.

The Lieutenant-Colonel sat back again. ‘Well, it’s not important, I suppose,’ he said, looking disappointed regardless. ‘Anyway, you’ll meet the boy when he arrives. His name is Leo Thornton. I don’t suppose you know him, do you?’

Again, Lucy didn’t reply, but the Lieutenant-Colonel read enough into the blank look that must have passed over her face. ‘No?’ he asked. ‘Never mind, that isn’t too important either.’

He looked at Lucy in silence for a few seconds, then sighed. ‘Look, Miss Taylor, you’ll be staying here with us for at least another day. Perhaps even another two days. Is there anything I can offer that would make your stay more comfortable?’

Lucy continued to sit in silence. It was a stupid, immature way to act, she knew. She might have asked for something to keep her amused. A TV, a book; anything. But there was much satisfaction to be had in being stubborn too, and right then she was feeling rebellious.

The Lieutenant-Colonel sighed again, and stood up. He put his cap back on. ‘Once again, I’m very sorry, Miss Taylor. I’d like to help you more, I really would. I’m doing all I can, and it’s a struggle just to keep you as comfortable as you are. You should know, there are some that think you should be put in a real holding-cell.

‘I’m your friend here, Miss, but you’re making it very hard for me to help you.’ He turned and walked to the door.

At the last moment, just before he left the room, Lucy broke her vow of silence despite herself. ‘I want answers,’ she said. ‘I want to know what’s happening. I want to know why I can’t go home. I just … I just want answers.’

The Lieutenant-Colonel looked pained. ‘Yes, I’m sure you do,’ he said. ‘I’m sorry.’ He left the room, locking the door behind himself.

------------------

Author Notes:

-- Yay, Chapter Two. This took longer to write than Chapter One, and I'm not quite as happy with it.

-- It's 1,800 words. Less than I'd like, but it's just about passable, I suppose.

-- As with Chapter One, the above is only a first draft. It'll be edited quite heavily once I've finished the entire first draft. Of course, I'll refer back to any suggestions you give when it comes to editing this.

-- In particular, I'd like to hear about: a) is the chapter interesting enough? Or did parts of it bore you? and b) your thoughts on the POV character (Lucy). But as always, all advice, suggestions and thoughts are equally welcome. =)

------------------

Chapter Three.
Last edited by Sureal on Wed Nov 12, 2008 9:02 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I wrote the above just for you.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1290
Reviews 42
Wow
I really loved this.
So much that I had to go and read the other chapter.
Please keep writing!

(sorry, I'm too tired to do a full critique)
"...she was a lovely lady, with a romantic mind and such a sweet mocking mouth..."

- 'Peter Pan' by J.M. Barrie




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9917
Reviews 297
Wow, great chapter, though I think you should change this part:

[quote] She sat on the bed, staring at nothing in particular, drowning in an ocean of her own boredom. The predominate colour surrounding her was beige. The room had beige walls, and a beige carpet, and a beige ceiling. The now cracked door broke the colour scheme by daring to be white, as did the blind, which was black. [quote]

I think you should take out the The predominate colour was beige, if you are going to put in that each item was beige.

I didn't see any major grammar mistakes, but then again, I don't catch those very often.

Oh and another thing I don't feel one bit pressured reviewing stories. It helps my own writing in alot of ways to learn from others, as well as my own mistakes.

Good luck and let me know when you've got the next chapter posted.
As your pretty, so be wise,
Wolves may lurk in every guise.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 13719
Reviews 243
It's back =P This thread looks lonely.

The crack in the pretty wooden door where she had punched it stood as testament [s]to this[/s].


ever since she’d been thrown in it the previous night.

into, I reckon. Otherwise it's just saying since when someone threw the previous night :) Or you could just get rid of the it.

was, [comma] happened


The predominate colour surrounding her was beige.

Kind of lengthy and dull. I recommend: "A predominate beige surrounded her."

just to see if it[s]s[/s] would open after all

I think you a word out here.

She’d tried the window last night and had failed to escape by it [s]then[/s].

I think there would be too many little words at the end to understand, makes you a little confused. Get rid of the not-necessaries.

it was actually six, each one too small for her to fit through.

Exaggerate! It would tell us exactly what it's like. Too small to fit through could mean anything from 1.5 metres to 15 centimetres. You get the idea. Use a simile or whatever--compare it to the width of a dwarf's arm. Ignore that last randomness.

no way to escape her prison from within it

Find a way to emphasise the 'still', otherwise it looks like she's thinking something she doesn't know, if that makes sense. Also, I reckon you use a lot of 'escape's in too close a succession. I don't like how it's written either, maybe: "She walked into the bathroom, saw it still offered no exit to her prison, and walked out again." Keep it short--I hate small, annoying words :D

One of them acted as if nothing was strange at all, one was polite enough to look away,

Vary/delete the repetition, and change the latter 'one' to 'another'.

Lieutenant-Colonel Haart.’ [full stop] He placed his


apologises

Apologies?


LUCY

To be honest, she seems... not flat - she's interesting, certainly - but not human. So far, all I've gathered is that she likes to be kept active and, of course, the TV. She has fashion taste too :P But think about it--she's in a cell, for part of it not advancing the story whatsoever, so you might as well tell us about her. What are her family like? Where does she live? Does the emptiness of the cell offer a rare serenity, and a break from the mad city rush? Whatever, I recommend some character development here. I don't think you need to worry about it going slow, because you would have already had an interesting chapter under your belt, so boredom shouldn't be an issue. No necessity to go overboard either, but in a space (probs between when she got up to test the door, and lay down on her bed staring at the wall) just get us to know her a bit--make us care. I did like her response to the Lieutenant at first, though. Very realistic, but again, it was a major transition from the silence in the room.

Regarding you have written however, I'm liking it. Of course, I think she might be a little more perplexed than you have portrayed her. If you yourself were lying in a cell, don't know what's going or where you are, would you be sitting feeling bored? If you would, of course, then just say something direct like 'the silence of the room didn't intimidate her'.

But, did this piece bore me? No, it didn't. I liked how we didn't just have another 'naked in the forest, running' kind of thing. They went together brilliantly. I suggest, however, than instead of saying Leo was alive, simply say that they found another boy in the first and he put up a fight, so are still kept wondering.I liked this piece, and this novel's going some place good--keep up the good work! This does seem a little more forced, but mostly because a lot of what's happening is in the dialogue and I still don't know what she's thinking--those things she won't say, but wants to.

----
- But don't Blink. Seriously.

EDIT: Keep pestering me!
"A man's face is his autobiography. A woman's face is her work of fiction." ~ Oscar Wilde




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 6517
Reviews 798
I agree with some of Blink's suggestions, have only this to add:

she hoped he would chock on an apology one day.


choke

*

So, the whole Adam and Eve thing just ramped up quite a bit, no? Even so, this chapter failed to engage me. On any level, really. Mind you, I quite like Lucy, but it just didn't read as well or as easily as the first chapter. I think it needs a bit more work and I think you absolutely need to give us a bit more of a background into her life.

I mean, it really does nothing for the story in the end. Argh, I just didn't like this chapter. I am wondering why it is - for both Lucy and Leo (go the L-names, by the way) - that they're not wondering more about the situation; about their friends and family; about work; about the random-ness of it all! Damn it, but they accept it all to easily, too readily and too pragmatically for teenagers, or even young adults. A little more then a stray thought on all that wouldn't hurt you.

Nonetheless, it's still intriguing enough to pull me along. I hope it goes somewhere different and new.

Cheers
Mah name is jiggleh. And I like to jiggle.

"Indecision and terror, thy name is novel." - Chiko




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 5
Lucy's a pretty interesting character, but I think we know as much about her as she knows about herself, and I wager that's not much. Has Lucy lost some of her memory? She seemed very confused, though I would be too if I were naked in the middle of a forest... hmm.

-Stardust.
A compliment is like a kiss through a veil- Victor Hugo.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 18178
Reviews 1259
I agree with Jiggs that there's just not enough emotional conflict or tension in this chapter. I was hoping Lucy might prove to be the opposite of Leo -- a character who stays calm and collected -- and just go mental and scream and spit at the L-C. Attack him or something. Slap him across the face. I think characters are most interesting when they DO things rather than accepting their fate. Otherwise they seem weak, and thus, boring. I wish Lucy would just go crazy (I read your latest chapter you posted, so there are some hints of this, maybe integrate her wildness earlier on to keep the pace frantic here?). Maybe include some emotional turmoil about being seeing naked by older men -- she seemed to take that pretty meekly. Most girls I don't think would walk with three men with no clothes on without demanding some sort of help beforehand, or kick up an incredible fuss.

I really like your ideas and your writing but I think you could have done better with this to keep the reader on the edge of their seat. One possibility is by revealing more about what's going on. In the first chapter you got the snippets of conversation that Leo heard from the soldiers, and I was genuinely excited to find it out. But here you seem to withhold it simply to create mystery. Like Lucy, I want answers!

Something else I've noticed that irritates me slightly -- even though I am full aware Colonel and Lieutenant-Colonel are two different ranks -- is the repetition of Lieutenant-Colonel. Unless it's very formal, Lieutenant-Colonels are almost always referred to as 'Colonel' in RL -- I know this is a different world but you'd think they'd abbreviate for brevity too. Or maybe use his actual name? Either way it's somewhat annoying to have to re-read Lieutenant-Colonel over and over again in the narrative.

Good, solid writing again though. *goes to read more*
Nate wrote:And if YWS ever does become a company, Jack will be the President of European Operations. In fact, I'm just going to call him that anyways.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 2338
Reviews 40
Personally, I really liked it. Everything was good that I can see. I too was hoping for someone completely different from Leo. She didn't seem like she would be a person to just yell at someone. I'd hoped she would act more scared.
Current Project: Otherworld (Novel) - 11,000 words so far
Latest Story: Overflowing Emotions.
Past stories: Burning Apart, The Beast, Binding Darkness - Ch. 1, What David Taught Me, The Banquette, Mirror of Memories, Leaving Humanity, Little Green Men, Six Days




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 26
Hmm... this chapter was interesting.

My biggest suggestion is: avoid summarizing. Avoid using flashback in this chapter, because, in my opinion, it's more intriguing and mysterious if you don't tell us how Lucy got there. The past cannot change, and since change is what hooks readers, keep most of the story in the present.

For making this chapter longer, make Lucy try harder to escape. It seems like she gave up once she ran out of ideas. Instead, show how frustrated and desperate she is. For example, even though the windows are too small to fit through, she could try to break them anyway. If she cuts her hand in the process, then she has even more problems to deal with.

The promise of change hooks readers.

Overall, I like this a lot. I must say, I've never read anything quite like this.
If you have a horror story on YWS, feel free to PM me.
If you would like me to critique it, say so.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 4890
Reviews 28
I feel I'll have to correct some of the grammar this time around. In addittion to there being more mistakes in this chapter than the last, it's hard for me to critique anything else, which is all pretty solid.

Sureal wrote:
It was sunny outside, but only a fringe of the light got passed (make this 'past') the drawn blind. She had the light switched on instead; the dull, artificial light appealed to her mood more than sunshine did.

Sighing, she dropped her feet onto the carpet and stood up. She didn’t know what the time was - a clock was also on the list of things her captors had neglected to give her - but she’d been (delete) sat moping and raging on that bed all day. It was time she did something productive, and have another go at escaping.

She walked over to the door and gave the handle a little twist and push, just to see if its (it) would open after all. Just like before, it didn’t. She kicked the door and turned away.

She’d tried the window last night and had failed to escape by it then (I'd change this to something like 'but that hadn't worked.'). Pulling up the blind, and flinching as a beautiful, sunny day assaulted (her) eyes, she examined it again. It wasn’t really (delete) just one window, it was actually six, each one too small for her to fit through. None of them opened anyway, and there wasn’t anything in the room for her to smash the glass with either.

To add to the list of grievances Lucy was building up, the clothes she had been given were awful: a baggy, grey t-shirt and a baggy, grey pair of trousers (change to "a pair of baggy grey trousers with a matching t-shirt). The soldiers had neglected to giver her any underwear, or even any socks or shoes. She was not sitting in comfort.

She’d had to walk with the soldiers for a good twenty minutes, ineffectively doing her best to cover herself the entire way, before they arrived at an encampment of temporary homes. She was limping badly by that point, her bare feet complaining against this ruff (is this some British spelling of rough? I'd assume so, just making sure) treatment.

‘You idiots,’ the Major growled. ‘Why did none of you strip off and giver (give) her your clothes? Eh? You should be the ones staggering around naked, not her.’ He glared at them all. ‘And look at her feet! How far did you drag her through that forest barefoot? Idiots.’ He waved a hand. ‘Go. You’re all dismissed.’

Dressed in a smart, black uniform, a man stepped into the room, dragging a plastic and metal chair behind him. Lucy hadn’t met this particular soldier yet. His eyes met hers, and she thought she could see some level of pity in them, although it was hard to say for certain though (delete).

‘Don’t start with that crap!’ she said. ‘Shut the hell up. You’re not sorry! So stop acting it. You lock me in here without telling me anything and now you’re here, with your empty, pointless words and apologises (apologies). Keep them! Keep your crap to yourself.

Lucy glared at him, and decided not to say anything. Let him talk about being sorry. She hoped he would chock (choke) on an apology one day. Let him talk himself to death.

She had been lost, and alone, and scared. Sat (sitting) in a forest she didn’t know, with no recollection of how she’d got there, naked and shivering, she had clutched at herself, and cried.


All of that aside, I'll get to the two things you care about most: no, this chapter was not boring, and yes, Lucy is likable. Maybe it's just me, but I like her more than Leo just a bit at the moment. Probably because instead of stereotypically freaking out when being seen naked, she remained rather calm, which struck me as a good character trait.

What's interesting about this chapter is the way the military is behaving. In chapter one I was certain they were the antagonists, and while I'm still sure they know more than they're letting on about Lucy and Leo appearing mysteriously in the woods, they don't seem so malevolent anymore. The Major being the way he was added to this. Of course, this is good misleading in case the military turns out to be evil later.

Good work. I'll try to get to chapter three tomorrow.
“The most powerful weapon on earth is the human soul on fire.”
– Marshal Ferdinand Foch



He who has a why to live for can bear with almost any how.
— Friedrich Nietzsche