Coven Born Chapter One (part one) REWRITE

11 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 51
Ok I didn;t want to post the rewrite seperate, but I think it would be easier for reviewers especially since I tweaked alot of the beginninig. The history mentioned is mostly the same, but I think the story has evolved with all the previous help.

Also I took as much of the critques into consideration as I could and worked them into the story. tell me if this came out any better.
________________________________________________

Chapter 1

-The Prophecy-
(one month earlier)

The anxiety within me was beginning to become over powering. All night I had pictured what today would be like, playing it over and over in my head. The nerves have yet to settle in my stomach. I shouldn’t be feeling this way; today is supposed to be the easy part, and yet I was fighting a battle inside my own mind.

“Riley, stop worrying,” said Samantha.

“Huh?” I sprang back to reality from my oversized thought bubble. “Sorry, what?”

“I said stop worrying,” repeated Sam. “It’s so clear on your face. I haven’t seen you this pale since you got that stomach virus two years ago.”

“Sam, how can I not worry?” I asked. Sam was one of my closest friends. We had begun our journey for sisterhood during the same year. We had met through our classes and made fast friends. “It’s not like I’m being given just an ordinary assignment. Sam, I’m receiving the mission today. You know how serious this is.”

“Yes, but that does not mean you stress out about it,” replied Sam. “Look at what my mission was.” Sam had a point. When she had been given her mission she was charged with protecting and guiding a pair of ambassadors to anther kingdom. Sam completed her assignment without problems, but it had taken a great deal of time. Three months passed before she returned.

“That does not mean I can’t stress about it either,” I declared. Sam stopped walking then. She put her hands on her hips and glared at me. Her eyes were screaming at me, asking me why I had to be so negative. I just sighed and said, “Fine, but can we keep going I want to at least be on time.”

We had been walking down a series of corridors, making our way to the Missions Office. Sister Innet and Sister Sarah were its only staff. Their jobs did not make them the highest-ranking sisters, but it did provide them with the privilege of giving out missions. This was especially important for sisters in training, like me, who were receiving the mission.

After rounding another corner Sam and I finally reached our destination. I turned toward Sam, hoping for some words of reassurance. Looking into her eyes revealed the confidence that she had always seen in me. I could always rely on Sam to cheer me up or calm me down when I needed it. I took one last glance at her as if it were the last time I would see her.

Sam was only seventeen, but she and I were the same height. Her hair was dirty blond and it looked like long strands of waves extending from her head; she told me she hated cutting it unless she had to.

Her attire was only slightly different from what I was wearing, but that was only because she had completed her mission. Inside the coven, sisters would wear different color shirts to show their rank. The majority of the coven consisted of students wearing yellow, teal, or brown shirts.

Sister wore yellow in their first three years of training. While students in their fourth, fifth, or six year of training wore teal. Brown was worn only by students in their final two years, during which time a student may be given their mission. Once their mission was completed a sister would receive a red shirt, like the one Sam was wearing now. She would receive a white shirt after graduation, which happens to be only a month away.

Sam also wore simple black breeches tucked into worn boots. She was dressed for physical training that would most likely take place later today.

Both Sam and I had dreamt about the day we would be able to wear white. Becoming a full trained sister was a great honor and in the coven, honor was an important key to rising in the ranks.

Since I was going to receive my mission today I still wore brown, but instead of a shirt I wore a tunic. It was important that I wore more formal wear then a plain shirt. A black belt was fitted across my waist. The tunic fit well with the belt on even though it was a little long. I also wore a black breeches tucked into the cleanest boots I could find at the time.

I could always remember Sam telling me that brown never flattered me, especially when I wore a tunic. To me, brown was a useful when it came to fieldwork since it allowed me to blend in with my surroundings.

I brought my eyes back up to meet Sam’s gaze. Her expression had not changed. “Riley, remember not to worry about what mission you receive, but about fulfilling it. You must focus very hard for it is the gate that leads to sisterhood. I have faith in you Riley, and there is no doubt that you will complete whatever it is you are set out to do. There never has been.” When Sam finished I fought back tears. Her words were memorable and I would always treasure them.

I reached over to her and we embraced each other in a hug. “Thank you,” I whispered in her ear. She pushed me away, but kept her hand on my shoulders.

“Go,” she said nodding her head towards the door. A smile appeared on her face and I realized that I had been smiling, too. I took a deep breath and turned towards the door. “See you at graduation Riley.” With that I walked through the door, making sure not to look back for I was afraid I would loose the confidence that had arisen in me.

After closing the door quietly behind me, taking it all in, I lead my gaze around the room. It was of decent size. There was a storage closet behind the sister’s desks, which I guessed most likely held the legendary list. The list held all the names of the sisters who had passed their missions. Sam was included in that list and I hoped to join here soon.

“Ah, Sister Riley, right on time,” greeted Sister Innet. “Please sit. We will begin in a moment.” She was gesturing towards one of the vacant chairs in front of her desk. I took the seat and took the extra time to continue my examination of the room.

Sister Innet sat at her desk filing paper leisurely while sister Sarah was standing over a crate leafing through mounds of folders. Both the sisters wore all black clothing with a black hooded cloak. Neither had their hoods on so their faces were clearly visible, each worn and showing years of experience.

Crates seemed to be everywhere about the room. Some were on the floor while others were stacked on top of each other. They were all filled to the brim with papers. A bookshelf was placed in the corner behind me. Many of the books looked worn and old, but what they didn’t lack was size.

Given the purpose of the room there was a large amount of seating. The sisters each had their own chairs. A couch was against a wall that could seat two and there was also another seat next to me.

“Sister Riley,” I turned my head so I was facing Sister Innet. “Once Sister Margeret is present we will begin.” My first instinct was to drop my jaw, but I knew that would be disrespectful. Instead my mind went into a bit of a shock. Sister Margeret was very special to me. She was also one of the four head sisters of the coven.

I only knew one other sister of the four, Sister Carmen. She was in charge of the finance and maintenance of the coven. The three remaining sisters were constantly coming and going. They mainly were messengers to other covens throughout the realm.

My story had always been different from the other students. I did not know whom my parents were or if I had any other family. Sister Margeret had found me on her travels and she had taken me back to the coven with her.

She then proceeded to raise me. Normally that would not be allowed since the coven permitted no girls under the age of nine to be present at the coven. The age rule did not apply to orphan boys though. I was the one and only exception since it was Sister Margeret who had found me.

As I got older she left the coven more often. Sometimes she was gone for a week, other times a month. During which time I would be in the care of another sister usually of high rank. When I was eight, only a year away from being an eligible student, Sister Margeret took me aside to tell me she was going away. It puzzled me since it was not unusual for her to travel.

She began to explain that this time was different, and that she would not be coming back for a few years. I remembered being sad since Sister Margeret was like my adopted mother and me her child. She did not tell me why she would be gone for so long, but she did say I would not be staying with another sister like the previous times.

That is when Sister Margeret took me to one of the student classes for first years. She told me that I would start sisterhood training even though I was too young. It was for the best and since I had grown up at the coven I was more then qualified to start early. All this information at once had caused me to become confused.

It was that first class that I had met Sam. Sister Margeret did not return for three years. Even then she did not stay long before leaving again. Before Sister Innet had mentioned her name I was unaware of her return to the coven. It had been five years since I had last seen her and eight years had passed since I had last talked to her.

That did not explain why she would be attending my mission hearing. The news of her being present is very strange. Almost all my friends have already had their mission meetings and none of them mentioned a head sister attending, or any extra guests for that matter. Even though the news of seeing Sister Margeret caused me to be overjoyed, nervousness still lurked inside me. I did my best not to show it though.

Not long after the mention of Sister Margeret, by Sister Innet, the head sister arrived scurrying through the door. When she entered I immediately stood up with my hands at my sides, as was protocol when in the presence of a head sister.

“Oh do sit down Riley. I am much too tired to for properness at the moment,” stated Sister Margeret. I was a little taken aback, but I obeyed anyway. Sister Margeret sat down lazily on the couch taking in deep breaths.

Her clothes were clearly worn from her travels. She wore black, mud stained breeches tucked into matching boots. She wore a loose purple shirt and a black hooded cloak. Sister Margeret’s apparel showed no trace of her rank, which meant she must have not wanted anyone to recognized her. Normally head sisters wore gold tunics with the insignia of the coven they represented on them.

Sister Innet cleared her throat and began to speak once again. “Riley, today you will be receiving the information on your mission that will lead you on your way to the becoming an official sister of the coven. Are you aware of this?”

“Yes,” I replied as expected.

“Are you aware that if you do not complete this mission you will not be able to become a full sister and that there are no second chances?”

“Yes.”

“Good, now that that is over with, Sister Margeret do you have the book?” asked Sister Innet.

________________________________________

nothing was added on the end sorry to disappoint so it remains a cliffhanger
Searching For An Explanations...
http://www.realityhitchhiker.blogspot.com/




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1090
Reviews 5
Advanced Critique in the Fantasy forum? :O For every paragraph/sentance I thought felt awkward, or worded weirdly, a wrote a comment in or underneath it. The fonts aren't working for me, unfrtunately.

Chapter 1
ggg

-The Prophecy-

(one month earlier)


The anxiety within me was beginning to become over powering. All night I had pictured what today would be like, playing it over and over in my head. The nerves have yet to settle in my stomach. I shouldn’t be feeling this way; today is was supposed to be the easy part, and yet I was fighting a battle inside my own mind.

[s]My anxiousness was begginging to overpower me. I had pictured what today would be like all night (that last part is unnescesary). My nerves hadn't settled at all (stomach can be taken away).

and yet I was a fighting a battle inside my own mind. should be removed. The sentance can stand on it's self without it.


“Riley, stop worrying,” said Samantha.


“Huh?” I sprang back to reality from my oversized thought bubble. “Sorry, what?”

from my oversized thought bubble should be removed.

“I said stop worrying,” repeated Sam. “It’s so clear on your face. I haven’t seen you this pale since you got that stomach virus two years ago.”


“Sam, how can I not worry?” I asked. Sam She was one of my closest friends. We had begun our journey for sisterhood during the same year. We had take out had met through our classes and made became fast friends. “It’s not like I’m being given just an ordinary assignment. Sam, I’m receiving the mission today. You know how serious this is.”


“Yes, but that does not mean you stress out about it,” replied Sam. “Look at what my mission was.” Sam had a point. When she had been given her mission she was charged with protecting and guiding a pair of ambassadors to anther kingdom. Sam completed her assignment without problems, but it had taken a great deal of time. Three months passed before she returned.


“That does not dosen't mean I can’t stress about it (no either),” I declared. Sam stopped walking then. She put her hands on her hips and glared at me. Her eyes were screaming at me, asking me why I had to be so negative. I just sighed and said, “Fine, but can we keep going I want to at least be on time.”


We had been walking down a series of corridors, making our way to the Missions Office. Sister Innet and Sister Sarah were its only staff. Their jobs did not make them the highest-ranking sisters, but it did provide them with the privilege of giving out missions. This was especially important for sisters in training, like me, who were receiving the mission.

That last sentance is unnesessary.


After rounding another corner Sam and I finally reached our destination. I turned toward Sam her, hoping for some words of reassurance. Looking into her eyes revealed the confidence that she had always seen in me. I could always rely on Sam to cheer me up or calm me down when I needed it. I took one last glance at her as if it were the last time I would see her.

You shouldn't say 'Sam' all the time. 'She' and 'her' are perfect substitutes.

Sam was only seventeen, but she and I we were the same height. Her hair was dirty blond and (no it) looked like long strands of waves extending from her head; she told me she hated cutting it unless she had to.


Her attire was only slightly different from what I was wearing, but that was only because she had completed her mission. Inside the coven, sisters would wear different color shirts to show their rank. The majority of the coven consisted of students wearing yellow, teal, or brown shirts.

You might've wanted to use more descriptive words here, like 'golden, teal, or auburn shirts'.

A Sister wore yellow in their first three years of training. (no While) Students in their fourth, fifth, or six year of training wore teal. Brown was worn only by students in their final two years, during which time a student may be given their mission. Once their mission was completed a sister would receive a red shirt, like the one Sam was wearing now. She would receive a white shirt after graduation, which happened to be only a month away.


Sam also wore simple black breeches tucked into worn boots. She was dressed for the physical training that would most likely probably take place later today.


Both Sam and I had dreamt about the day we would be able to wear white. Becoming a full trained sister was a great honor and in the coven, honor was an important key to rising in the ranks.


Since I was going to receive my mission today I still wore brown, but instead of a shirt I wore a tunic. It was important that I wore more formal wear then a plain shirt. A black belt (no was) fitted across my waist. The tunic fit well with the belt on even though it was a little long. I also wore a black breeches tucked into the cleanest boots I could find at the time.

'The tunic fit well with the belt on even though it was a little long' is a bit too specific for the reader to recognize. Get rid of it.


I could always remember Sam telling me that brown never flattered me, especially when I wore a tunic. To me, brown was (no a) useful when it came to fieldwork since it allowed me to blend in with my surroundings.

You should use a different adjective for brown every once in a while.

I brought my eyes back up to meet Sam’s gaze. Her expression had not changed. “Riley, remember not to worry about what mission you receive, but about fulfilling it. You must focus very hard for it is the gate that leads to sisterhood. I have faith in you Riley, and there is no doubt that you will complete whatever it is you are set out to do. There never has been.” When Sam finished I fought back tears. Her words were memorable and I would always treasure them.

Take out 'there has never been' at the end of Sam's sentance.


I reached over to her and we embraced each other in a hug. “Thank you,” I whispered ( no in her ear). She pushed me away, but kept her hand on my shoulder.


“Go,” she said nodding her head towards the door. A smile appeared on her face and I realized that I had been smiling, too. I took a deep breath and turned towards the door. “See you at graduation Riley.” With that I walked through the door, making sure not to look back for I was afraid I would loose the confidence that had arisen in me.

The two sentrances before "See you at graduation." should be taken out. They just clog the paragraph with useless information.

After closing the door quietly behind me, taking it all in, I lead my gaze around the room. It was of decent size. There was a storage closet behind the sister’s desks, which I guessed most likely held the legendary list. The list held all the names of the sisters who had passed their missions. Sam was included in that list and I hoped to join there soon.


“Ah, Sister Riley, right on time,” greeted Sister Innet. “Please sit. We will begin in a moment.” She was gesturing towards one of the vacant chairs in front of her desk. I took the seat and took the extra time to continue my examination of the room.


Sister Innet sat at her desk filing paper leisurely while sister Sarah was standing over a crate leafing through mounds of folders. Both the sisters wore all black clothing with a black hooded cloak. Neither had their hoods on so their faces were clearly visible, each worn and showing years of experience.



Crates seemed to be everywhere about the room. Some were on the floor while others were stacked on top of each other. They were all filled to the brim with papers. A bookshelf was placed in the corner behind me. Many of the books looked worn and old, but what they didn’t lack was size.

Given the purpose of the room there was a large amount of seating. The sisters each had their own chairs. A couch was against a wall that could seat two and there was also another seat next to me.


These two parargraphs really aren't needed. We don't need to know the exact placement of the couch and that there are crates in the room. Are they an important plot point? No. Your early paragraph already gave us all the setting we need.



“Sister Riley,” I turned, (no my head so I was. minor details like this are pointless, and just disrupt the flow of the writing) facing Sister Innet. “Once Sister Margeret is present we will begin.” My first instinct was to drop my jaw, but I knew that would be disrespectful. Instead my mind went into a bit of a shock. Sister Margeret was very special to me. She was also one of the four head sisters of the coven.


I only knew one other sister of the four, Sister Carmen. She was in charge of the finance and maintenance of the coven. The three remaining sisters were constantly coming and going. They mainly were messengers to other covens throughout the realm.


My story had always been different from the other students. I did not know whom my parents were or if I had any other family. Sister Margeret had found me on her travels and she had taken me back to the coven with her.


She then proceeded to raise me. Normally that would not be allowed since the coven permitted no girls under the age of nine to be present at the coven. The age rule did not apply to orphan boys though. I was the one and only exception since it was Sister Margeret who had found me.

The first sentance is not needed.

As I got older she left the coven more often. Sometimes she was gone for a week, other times a month. During which time I would be in the care of another sister usually of high rank. When I was eight, only a year away from being an eligible student, Sister Margeret took me aside to tell me she was going away. It puzzled me since it was not unusual for her to travel.


She began to explain that this time was different, and that she would not be coming back for a few years. I remembered being sad since Sister Margeret was like my adopted mother and me her child. She didn't tell me why she would be gone for so long, but she did say I would not be staying with another sister like the previous times.

'I remembered being sad' gives me no emotion at all. Say 'I cried all night' or 'I hugged her and didn't want to let go', something that actually shows her being terrified that her adopted mother is abandoning her for a couple years. Saying 'I remember being sad' is just lazy writing.


That is when Sister Margeret took me to one of the student classes for first years. She told me that I would start sisterhood training even though I was too young. It was for the best and since I had grown up at the coven I was more then qualified to start early. All this information at once had caused me to become confused.


It was that first class that I had met Sam. Sister Margeret did not return for three years. Even then she did not stay long before leaving again. Before Sister Innet had mentioned her name I was unaware of her return to the coven. It had been five years since I had last seen her and eight years had passed since I had last talked to her.


That did not explain why she would be attending my mission hearing. The news of her being present is very strange. Almost all my friends have already had their mission meetings and none of them mentioned a head sister attending, or any extra guests for that matter. Even though the news of seeing Sister Margeret caused me to be overjoyed, nervousness still lurked inside me. I did my best not to show it though.


Not long after the mention of Sister Margeret (no by Sister Innet) the head sister scurried through the door. When she entered I immediately stood up with my hands at my sides, as was protocol when in the presence of a head sister.

'hands by my sides' is unnesessary. Knowing that she has to stand up when a sister enters is enough.

“Oh do sit down Riley. I am much too tired to for properness at the moment,” stated Sister Margeret. I was a little taken back, but I obeyed anyway. Sister Margeret sat down lazily on the couch taking in deep breaths.


Her clothes were clearly worn from her travels. She wore black, mud stained breeches tucked into matching boots. She wore a loose purple shirt and a black hooded cloak. Sister Margeret’s apparel showed no trace of her rank, which meant she must have not wanted anyone to recognized her. Normally head sisters wore gold tunics with the insignia of the coven they represented on them.


Sister Innet cleared her throat and began to speak once again. “Riley, today you will be receiving the information on your mission that will lead you on your way to the becoming an official sister of the coven. Are you aware of this?”


“Yes,” I said as expected.

Changed replied to said.

“Are you aware that if you do not complete this mission you will not be able to become a full sister and that there are no second chances?”


“Yes.”


“Good, now that that is over with, Sister Margeret do you have the book?” asked Sister Innet.


The thing wrong with your story is that more than a few of your sentances are worded awkwardly, you occasionally hover too long over description, and your character/dialouge is extremely flat. Pretty much all of your characters had little to no personality. You're not really giving Riley a chance to show her personality. How does she react to people? What does she think of Character B? All I'm hearing right now from her is 'this happened, and then this, and this, and then this flashback, and then I was sad, and then I waited for my mission'. Quite bland.

You're plot, though, sounded pretty interesting regarding the sisterhood. The mystery of Sister Margret and the Sisterhood in general is very enticing, but your characters were so blank that while I was reading it, I hardly cared.

You should really work on improving your vocabulary, and learn to better characterize. With those elements fixed, I could see this becoming a fantastic story.




User avatar
Gender Other
Points 2570
Reviews 245
Hullo!

I'm coming in with fresh eyes, so I haven't read your first draft of this chapter yet. I want to give you my thoughts on this first.

Critiquing as I go here. ;)

(one month earlier)


A month earlier than what? There's usually an event that happens, and only after that scene is written is that line delivered. It's not such a huge thing as a missing comma, but I think you can get rid of it. Instead, I suggest you write what happened, then put "one month later" or something to that effect. It would flow better, if nothing else.

The anxiety within me was beginning to become over powering. All night I had pictured what today would be like, playing it over and over in my head. The nerves have yet to settle in my stomach. I shouldn’t be feeling this way; today is supposed to be the easy part, and yet I was fighting a battle inside my own mind.


That right there was great. You snapped my attention and didn't let go. You convey the emotion without being overly wordy, something I struggle with. It doesn't just hold the reader, it pushes them forward to the next paragraph. They want to know what happens today.

“That does not mean I can’t stress about it either,”


It's fine if this is how they talk, but most people use "doesn't." Writing full sentences in dialogue can give a feeling of stiffness, and it's not very often that a writer can pull it off smoothly.

She put her hands on her hips and glared at me. Her eyes were screaming at me, asking me why I had to be so negative. I just sighed and said, “Fine, but can we keep going I want to at least be on time.”


Two parts on this one. Sam's reaction seems a little harsh. I think it's just the 'eyes screaming' part that makes it seem to harsh. It's a beautiful use of imagery, though. and on the flip side, that could say wonders about their culture, if everyone would have similar reactions. If that's the case, and there's a reason for it, then by all means, keep it.

Part two:

“Fine, but can we keep going? I want to at least be on time.”

:razz:

I turned toward Sam, hoping for some words of reassurance. Looking into her eyes revealed the confidence that she had always seen in me.


This is actually fine as it is, but perhaps you could combine the two sentences? This is just my writing style coming through, so this nit-pik isn't overly important. Just something that caught my eye.

Becoming a full trained sister was a great honor and in the coven, and honor was an important key to rising in the ranks.


Sister wore yellow in their first three years of training.


Sisters? ;)

I also wore a black breeches tucked into the cleanest boots I could...


A pair?

There were a few misplaced commas and a few typos, but I'll leave those for you to catch. If you have Microsoft Word, you can use their Spelling and Grammar check, and it'll catch most, if not all, of the errors for you. :)

Overall, it sounds interesting. PM me when you post the next one, yes? I'm very curious as to what her assignment will be. Your dialogues could grow a bit more, but other than that, you've great description and imagery. You fill us in on the history without giving us info-dumps, too, and that itself is amazing. I'm thinking you could contribute something to the knowledge base up there ^^ on it. Not too much, not too little. If nothing else, it'll give us something to link to when we critique others who need help in that area. :)
Necropolis SB / Necropolis DT

Once was Dreamer, is now LowKey_Lyesmith.

Everybody is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 4601
Reviews 141
Ah lets see



We had met through our classes and made fast friends.



That does not make any sense, well it does but you need to change it.


“Yes, but that does not mean you should stress out about it,” replied Sam.




Sisters wore yellow in their first three years of training.


I also wore a black breeches tucked into the cleanest boots I could find at the time.


I also wore a black breech
or
I also wore black breeches

Sam was included in that list and I hoped to join here (her) soon.



Sister Innet sat at her desk filing paper leisurely while sister Sarah was standing over a crate, leafing through mounds of folders.


She began to explain that this time was different, and that she would not be coming back for a few years. I remembered being sad since Sister Margeret was like my adopted mother and me, her child. She did not tell me why she would be gone for so long, but she did say I would not be staying with another sister like the previous times.


It was for the best and since I had grown up at the coven I was more th[s]e[/s]an qualified to start early. All this information at once had caused me to become confused.


Oooh like before i will say it again, nice cliffhanger and story. Is there a second part to this??


Ohh and to Dreamer, Jules did post what happened in another post. I think it as the prologue but anyway, this part starts after the other post. (I think)
--
Who is not Insane one man ask, the answer being a fool.
Are you Insane the same man asks, - "Oh yes!. The Mad Hatter being saner!"




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9917
Reviews 297
Okay this sound alot like a story i have read somewhere before....I mean alot like it. The training, the mission, the close friend.... it really sounds familiar. Just letting you know. I forgot the name. I CANT REMEMBER!!!! Anyways you probably didn't mean too. I really like it though. The grammar mistakes have already been pointed out, ao I won't go back over them. Anyways Good Luck.
As your pretty, so be wise,
Wolves may lurk in every guise.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2209
Reviews 106
I thought it was good......... :roll:

.......I think it reminds you of the terrier by Tamora Pierce....

Who said that?? *looks around with innocent puppy face*
not me.... :lol: *laughs and slowly fades to awkward silence*
If I can impact one person, just one, with my writing before I die, then I've lived a great life




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 51
its not based on anything
Tamora Pierce is my favorite author
but just because i right about a female warrior
does not mean i copied alot of people do that
and Terrier is completely different

plans for this story:

a romance
a mystery solved
lots of action
magic

and thats why i consider it fantasy

its nothing like Terrier if anything I was inspired to write this from a small part in Greg Keyes series. He had invented a coven that one of the main characters stayed at for like one or two chapters that trained women to become like assasins,

and my idea is still different

hez ur trying to get me in trouble aren't you

*scolds In_the_Moonlight (for fun)*
Searching For An Explanations...
http://www.realityhitchhiker.blogspot.com/




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1046
Reviews 51
hi, my dear your story is lively and i like the way you write them. there are some wrong usage of the english in your story. mistakes that ought not to be found. these include does not which is mostly shortened to doesn't. there are also some wrong phrases and sentences ( one month earlier) that prevent smooth flow of your story. please look into these mistakes. thank you. i'm praise by name. cheers
The Truth Can Set You Free
Maybe,
But You Must First
Set The Truth Free
_WOLE Soyinka




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 192
Why didn't you tell me??
I feel left out! :cry:

Much better I must say, but there are still some minor mistakes. Are you remembering to read your story out loud before you post?

I hope you are... that will make it easier to spot mistakes.

Keep writing! I can't wait for the next part.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4198
Reviews 157
Whoo hoo, let's see~! This time, I know Riley's a girl. And I do apologize for my faux pas...it must wound the writer deeply when a reader mistakes the gender of one of their own characters...I apologize with all my heart.

The anxiety within me was beginning to become over powering.


"Overpowering" is una palabra (one word...sorry). Also, there's something a tad...off...about this sentence, something I can't exactly...describe. Would it be called..."passive voice"? *feels like an idiot; doesn't know* Just...this sentence could be phrased much more fluidly, methinks.

. I shouldn’t be feeling this way; today is supposed to be the easy part, and yet I was fighting a battle inside my own mind.


Y'wanna stick with one tense--in this case, the "is" should be a "was".

I sprang back to reality from my oversized thought bubble.


Cute description. :)

“I said stop worrying,” repeated Sam.


This may just be my preferences speaking, but I think the "worrying" should be italicized for emphasis. But I like italicizing every other word, so blehh. Who am I to speak. Also, maybe the dialogue tag should be changed to "said Sam again". In many cases, a simple "said" does just as well as a dialogue tag, or you could just do without a dialogue tag. *is shot for being a hypocrite*

“It’s so clear on your face. I haven’t seen you this pale since you got that stomach virus two years ago.”


Ha ha HA. I really like this--not only is it humorous, but it also helps display some of Sam's personality--she's a caring friend, but sassy, and not above gently teasing Riley. I like this--dialogue is one of the best ways of developing a character.

Sam was one of my closest friends. We had begun our journey for sisterhood during the same year. We had met through our classes and made fast friends.


These sentences feel a bit awkward. In particular, the last two sentences both start with "we", which is repetetive, to say the least. Try to consolidate either the first sentence with the second one (i.e. "Sam, one of my closest friends, had been by my side since the very beginning. We'd met through our classes, as we'd begun our journey for sisterhood in the same year"). Or something along those lines.

When she had been given her mission she was charged with protecting and guiding a pair of ambassadors to anther kingdom.


The "she was" after mission should be better off as a "she had been". Or better yet, just a simple, streamlined, "She'd been given the mission of protecting and guiding a pair of ambassadors to another kingdom". Sorry, I'm basically rewriting this for you...:( I have no idea why I'm being so thorough, particularly when my little brother's attacking me right now.

“That does not mean I can’t stress about it either,” I declared.


"Declared" doesn't feel like the right word in this situation, and doesn't mean anything in this context, either. Try to replace it with a "said', or just drop the dialogue tag altogether.

Sam stopped walking then. She put her hands on her hips and glared at me. Her eyes were screaming at me, asking me why I had to be so negative


These sentences are a bit choppy; you should try to combine some of them (might I suggest the last two?).


Looking into her eyes revealed the confidence that she had always seen in me.


Um...I'm not entirely certain what this sentence means. Sorry. :(


Sisters wore yellow in their first three years of training, while students in their fourth, fifth, and six years of training wore teal. Brown was worn only by students in their final two years, during which time a student would be given their mission. Once their mission was completed a sister would receive a red shirt, like the one Sam was wearing now. She would receive a white shirt after graduation, which happened to be only a month away.


Made a few grammar/style fixes, but honestly--I really like your description of the system of coven training. It flows MUCH more naturally than in the first draft, and you segued from Sam's physical description to the coven training in an easy-to-follow, natural-feeling way. A job well done. :)

It was important that I wore more formal wear then a plain shirt.


Again, I like your physical description of Riley, but again, this could flow a little better as "...I dress more formally than I usually did, in a plain shirt". Or maybe not, since that has a bit too many adverbs. >_> Adverb abuse is a demon I must slaughter--eventually! *gets eaten by the adverb-abuse demon*

“Riley, remember not to worry about what mission you receive, but about fulfilling it. You must focus very hard for it is the gate that leads to sisterhood. I have faith in you Riley, and there is no doubt that you will complete whatever it is you are set out to do. There never has been.” When Sam finished I fought back tears. Her words were memorable and I would always treasure them.


Um...this entire speech, though I feel is intended to be dramatic and emotional, just came across as...off...to me. It seems somewhat out of the character you've previously established for Sam--a caring but also kind of sassy/sarcastic girl. That she's suddenly talking so dramatically and stiffly (*adverb abuse demon, take two more bites*) just doesn't jive with what I'm coming to expect from her character, and the formality of the speech kind of detracts from the emotional...ism...of it. It'd probably be better if Sam gave a more relaxed and casual, but still inspirational and caring, speech to Riley. It would fit better with her established character.

Also, the last lines...are a major case of telling instead of showing. Telling us that Sam's speech was memorable and that Riley will treasure it forever doesn't really impact the reader. They'll just nod and say, "Uh-uh, okay, that's it" and move on, which isn't a good idea for a scene such as this. Describe Riley's thoughts and emotions, beyond just "I would always treasure them". Better yet, excise such a matter-of-fact phrase like "I would always treasure them", and treat Riley's "treasuring" of the words in a more...subtle manner. Best suggestion I can think of right now: "Her words rang in my ears, and somehow I knew that they would not fade away for a very long time". I don't know....somehow I feel that's a bit tell-y too. >_>

Sorry if I seem a bit harsh here; I really don't mean to be. >_> It's just that this scene is doubly important because it feels like it's supposed to be powerful, emotional, and moving...and I'm not feeling any of it. You really want the reader to FEEL what Riley is feeling, and right now there's a disconnect between the reader and Riley, mostly due to the OOC-ness of Sam's speech (well, I don't know, maybe her character is supposed to be like that and I'm just interpreting her wrong, but...) and Riley's blase reaction to it. Again, I don't mean to sound...mean. But I know you can do better than this; you're a solid writer. :)

I reached over to her and we embraced each other in a hug.


That sentence is a bit redundant, as "embrace" means the exact same as "hug". It's enough to just say Riley walked over to Sam, and pulled her into a hug.

With that I walked through the door, making sure not to look back for I was afraid I would loose the confidence that had arisen in me.


Nicely written sentence, and I can sympathize perfectly--looking back is more than enough to cause many people (myself included...) to chicken out. On little error you made is using "loose" instead of "lose", but other than that...I really do like this sentence. It's sparse but manages to convey Riley's emotions in a relatable manner; try for more sentences like this (particularly during the above speech). :)

After closing the door quietly behind me, taking it all in, I lead my gaze around the room.


The "taking it all in" part should be moved to the end of the sentence.

Sam was included in that list and I hoped to join here soon.


I think you mean "here", not "her". :D

“Ah, Sister Riley, right on time,” greeted Sister Innet.


Again, you want to rid yourself of all unnecessary dialogue tags (I smell a hypocrite in the room...). It'd be fine just to say "said Sister Innet in greeting". And I'm sorry a flaming hypocrite is dispensing this advice to you. >_>

Neither had their hoods on so their faces were clearly visible, each worn and showing years of experience.


Nice bit of description; not much to say on this beyond "I like it". The description's sparse but I can just picture the two sisters already.

Crates seemed to be everywhere about the room. Some were on the floor while others were stacked on top of each other. They were all filled to the brim with papers.


I suggest these sentences'd be better rendered as "Crates, filled to the brim with papers, seemed to be everywhere about the room". The last sentence feels a bit extraneous and awkward, so it'd be better to emend it to the first.

Given the purpose of the room there was a large amount of seating.


Try changing that "there was a large amount of seating" to a less circumlocutious "there were many seats in the room". Actually, I'm not sure if that's any less circumlocutious, but it flows better.

Instead my mind went into a bit of a shock.


Again, this is a bit of "telling" rather than "showing". Try to show Rileys' shock rather than just tell the reader of it. Describe her physical reaction--she goes pale, her heart gives a jolt, her mind goes numb, so on and so forth. That is much more effective at conveying shock than just saying "I went into a shock".

Sister Margeret was very special to me. She was also one of the four head sisters of the coven.


Prob'ly be better written as an appositive: "Sister Margaret, one of the four head sisters of the coven, was very special to me."

I only knew one other sister of the four, Sister Carmen. She was in charge of the finance and maintenance of the coven.


A rendition that's slightly less choppy would be: "...Sister Carmen, who was in charge..."

She then proceeded to raise me. Normally that would not be allowed since the coven permitted no girls under the age of nine to be present at the coven. The age rule did not apply to orphan boys though. I was the one and only exception since it was Sister Margeret who had found me.


Erk...I'm still having a bit of trouble with this, as while I know Riley's a girl, I can still see some unsuspecting reader mistaking her gender nonetheless. Maybe..."Normally that wouldn't be allowed since the coven, while taking in orphan boys of all ages, permitted no girls under the age of nine". Or something like that...maybe that's even more awkward, but...>_> I dunno; it's your call.

During that time I would be in the care of another sister usually of high rank.


Grammar fix.

That is when Sister Margeret took me to one of the student classes for first years.


That "is" should be a "was", and I feel you could reduce the wordinessa and explain the point better as "...one of the first year student classes". But again, it's your call; that could be even more confusing. >_>

All this information at once had caused me to become confused.


Again, an example of telling as opposed to showing. You don't need to go so in depth with this one, since it describes an event that happened in the past, but all the same, try to show younger-Riley's confusion. Although, now that I think about it, I don't know exactly how. *gets shot*


It was that first class that I had met Sam.


Erm..maybe you should elaborate on their first meeting a bit? Unless you're going to touch on it further in the story, which in that case it becomes unnecessary. If that made sense.

The news of her being present is very strange.


Again, stick to a consistent tense--"was" rather than "is". :D

Even though the news of seeing Sister Margeret caused me to be overjoyed, nervousness still lurked inside me. I did my best not to show it though.


I already think I mentioned this in my first review, but I'm reinforce you--you should show Riley's joy and nervousness. The best way I can think to do it (this is how I try to "show, at the very least), is by describing her physical reaction--i.e. her heart started beating faster with joy at the news of seeing Sister Margaret again, but nervous butterflies still lurked in the pit of her stomach, etc. I don't know if there's a better way as I'm an amateur myself, but it's the way I've always done it. I tend to think of things in very physical terms though, but you may not. In that case...>_> There may be a more vivid way of showing rather than telling, but if there is I don't know it.

the head sister arrived scurrying through the door.


The verb "scurrying" implies meekness, hesitation, and indecisive and nervous personality. As you've previously described Sister Margaret as being a strong and powerful person, this just doesn't...jive. More IC would probably be to have her enter in a stately, sedate way, or, if she must be an a hurry, describe her as harried and rushed, but not scurrying.

When she entered I immediately stood up with my hands at my sides, as was protocol when in the presence of a head sister.


Nothing to say to this, but the standing up is a nice touch. I must say I really do like the way you're building up your world--not through huge infodumps (and when you must expound on concepts, such as the colored tunics, you do it an entirely natural and easy-flowing way), but through letting bits and pieces get revealed throughout the narrative. This little touch with the standing up is quite nice and shows us another facet of the world of the covens, but isn't intrusive or jarring. So good job. :D

“Oh do sit down Riley. I am much too tired to for properness at the moment,” stated Sister Margeret. I was a little taken aback, but I obeyed anyway.


Show, don't tell, Riley's "taken aback"ness. I'm sorry if I sound like a broken record but I can't reinforce this enough. Showing instead of telling is one of the central skills a writer should master (not saying that I have, not at all). It's hard, I know--in many cases it's easier to give into temptation and just say "Character X felt Y emotion", but in the end, being able to descriptively show your character's emotions and have your audience connect with them helps liven up your narrative, and makes it more realistic.

Sister Margeret sat down lazily on the couch taking in deep breaths.


There's a bit of a disparity-slash-disconnect here--you describe Margaret as sitting down "lazily", but then have her taking "deep breaths"...definitely not a sign of languid, self-assured casualness, as the adverb "lazily" would imply. I think what you're intending is for Margaret to be tired, and in that case the correct word would be "wearily", "wornly", "haggardly", etc.

Her clothes were clearly worn from her travels. She wore black, mud stained breeches tucked into matching boots. She wore a loose purple shirt and a black hooded cloak. Sister Margeret’s apparel showed no trace of her rank, which meant she must have not wanted anyone to recognized her. Normally head sisters wore gold tunics with the insignia of the coven they represented on them.


Again, I like how you slipped in a little tidbit about coven life and organization in the natural course of your narrative. One of the reasons I dislike high fantasy is that too often the author is obsessed with hammering you over the head with paragraph after paragraph of mundane information about the world. It's enough to make the reader (in this case, me) throw the book down in disgust and search for one that's a little more interested in telling a story and less obsessed with building a world. This is one of the major things I'm enjoying about your "Coven Born" piece so far--how you've avoided bashing the reader over the head with loads and loads of information, but instead incorporate it naturally into the text. You let the reader pick up the little details for themselves, without once interrupting the flow of the story being told, and for that I am eternally thankful. :D

Sister Innet cleared her throat and began to speak once again


The "once" interrupts the flow of the sentence and is unncessary, so feel free to excise it.

“Yes,” I replied as expected.


I don't quite understand what you mean by "expected". Would you care to elaborate on that a little?

“Good, now that that is over with, Sister Margeret do you have the book?” asked Sister Innet.


Perhaps'd be better phrased as "Good, now that we're over with that...Sister Margaret, do you have the book?" but that could be my personal preferences speaking.

All in all...this is surprisingly in-depth; I honeslty hadn't meant to be so thorough. O_o I'm glad I did, though, and it's a good sign I was able to get enough into the text to just keep reading and critiquing.

I like your ideas, I really do. Maybe it's because I don't read much high fantasy (I think I've explained my reasons for disliking the genre above), but your word truly does seem original and well thought-out. I'm liking the idea of the nunneries in this world being less a place for austere young women to sew and pray, and more like a traveling mercenary force...but still maintaining some of the trappings of being a convent. The coven system you've laid out is very detailed, but never once do you just stop your story to dump tons of unimportant, story-unrelated information on the covens; you just slip the information into the story at strategic points, describing your world without losing the reader's interest. And that's a very good thing. Too often, as speculative fiction authors, we're just tempted to infodump because that's the easy thing to do--but it doesn't make for compelling narration. I think it's wonderful that you've resisted doing that. Also, I like the characters you've painted--Sister Margaret, though she's barely been in this, seems to be quite the character, and I like the way you wrote Sam as a caring-but-sardonic friend (at least until her speech). Riley, too, is easy to sympathize--who doesn't want to be at the same level of their friends, and advance a little higher? Her friendship with Sam is very realistic and heartwarming, and that's a good thing as I do believe character relationships are the heart of any story, whether they're literary fiction or high fantasy, as in this case.

That being said...on to the things I didn't like. Namely, you still make quite a few spelling/grammar errors that, as previous critiquers have said, could be resolved by simply reading the whole thing out loud. Also, the most major problem I detected prose-wise was your tendency to TELL the reader what was happening rather than SHOW. I know, I know it's a cliche to say "show, don't tell", but it is most definitely TRUE. There's a world of difference between "Bob was nervous" and "Bob trembled, feeling butterflies flit back and forth in his stomach" (okay, cruddy example, but you get the picture). One just states the characters' feelings but doesn't bother delving into how the character actually feels; the other tries to paint a picture of the characters' emotions, and lets the reader sympathize and experience it too. It's much easier to just say "Bob was nervous", but it lacks much of the impact of the second one (even if that sentence sucks; I wasn't really trying). So wherever you can, strive for a deeper level of detail, and try to show the audience your characters' emotions rather than tell them. Emotions are the most important facet of your characters, after all, and if your readers aren't able to empathize with them and FEEL their emotions as if they're real, you run the risk of alienating the readers.

Granted, I'm not the best at teaching the difference between "show vs. tell", and in some cases for convenience's sake it IS probably better to just "tell"...in particular, the way I've always done it is describing my characters' physical reactions, because...I don't know why, it's easier for me to feel something if it's physical. There are probably better and more refined ways of doing it, but physical is a good place to start.

All that aside, keep on trying! That's the one sure way to improve yourself as a writer. You've got good ideas and characters, now just try to raise your prose up to that same level! :) This is a work with a lot of potential, and I really do want to see more of it. :D PM me if you have any questions, and hope that uber-long critique helped!
Ah, it is an empty movement. That is an empty movement. It is.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2209
Reviews 106
I haven't looked at this forum in awhile. Oh, and before when I said that it reminded me of Terrier I only meant her outfit. That's all.
I've already told you my take on this story......(I'm bored)

-Moony :D :) :( :o :shock: :? 8)
If I can impact one person, just one, with my writing before I die, then I've lived a great life



Nouns can verb very well actually, they verb better than some verbs do.
— winterwolf0100