Watching Windows - Chapter 9

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 202
Chapter 9

It was seven in the morning on the first day back at school after the summer, and I felt all the groggy misery that went with that fact. My alarm was still blasting an old CD on my bedside table, but I was too groggy to be bothered to turn it off. It was time for a self-examination.

I squinted at my reflection in the long mirror, standing there in my Winnie The Pooh nightie. My dark brown hair was an unkempt bob sticking up around my head, and my face was blotched and sleepy. Letting out a heavy sigh, I tried to straighten up, glaring back at my image as I did.

I bent down and picked up a pair of black trousers. Yanking up the zipper and squeezing into them, I eyed myself critically again. Now all the bulk was squeezed into a tight space, I had more of a form, but nevertheless.
(I need help redoing this following paragraph. It's really badly constructed!) Who was I kidding? What was the point of going to school? What was the point, when everyone despised me and I didn't have a single friend, and all the teachers thought I was useless? The only thing motivating me to go to school was English. It was the only subject I did well in and seemed to hold any future for me. I desperately didn’t want to become a failure, so I made myself get up every morning and face it

In the morning, registration was havoc. It was the same back-to-school scene as normal. There were girls hugging, squealing, catching up on the summer, exchanging stories of holiday flings. There were the boys, less affectionate, giving each other friendly punches and engaging in their usual conversation centred around a Playboy magazine hidden inside a copy of ‘Much Ado About Nothing’.

Shakespeare would have turned in his grave.

As usual, I just sat alone at my desk and stared into space. Sooner or later, I caught sight of an equally solitary pupil that I had never seen in our tutor group before. He was sitting alone reading a small book with a leather cover. He wasn’t that tall for a boy nor too muscular, and his nose and cheeks were lightly scattered with freckles. His eyes had flecks of green and grey swirling around in the pupils. He looked serene and comfortable, and didn’t seem to notice or care that people were already staring at him and judging him.

Suddenly, he looked up from his book and instantly caught my eye before I had a chance to avert my gaze elsewhere. I felt mortified about the fact that he’d caught me staring at him. Even worse, he closed his book and walked across the classroom to stand in front of my desk. I stared up at him, looking like a rabbit caught between the cross lights, waiting for an insult, a taunt. It didn’t come. He just smiled at me and said, “Hey there. I’m Douglas. I’m the new guy.”

His accent was unmistakably American.

While I was trying to calm myself and thinking of what to reply to this angelic presence that was standing in front of me, I noticed that Kirsty was ignoring her Mini-Ks and watching us. Watching us with extreme interest, a pout hovering on her lips.

It had been obvious she liked the look of Douglas from the start, seeing the way she was simpering over him when he entered the room. The sight of him reading had probably put her off at first, but when she had seen the self-respect he harboured, this had most likely changed her mind. All the girls were gravitating slightly around him, at any case.

I didn’t know how he was so confident. He wasn’t reading and thinking to himself, “Oh- my-God-I-look-like-a-nerd-and-everyone-else-is-going-to-think-I-look-like-a-nerd-and –maybe-I-better-stop-now.” Probably what I would have been thinking, hence the fact I never read in public.

He was reading, uncaring of anyone else’s opinion and not fearing people’s reactions and thoughts.
Before I could reply to him Kirsty sidled up towards us, a strange look on her face. I could almost see a pair of ruby horns appearing on her raven hair and a long pointy tail sprouting from her infinitesimal behind.

“Ooooh, am I interrupting the two love-birds?” Kirsty cooed. “Isn't that sweet? Amelia's finally managed to get herself a boyfriend. Though, um...” she whispered loudly in a confidential manner to Douglas, "Watch out. She smells.”

He raised an eyebrow, looking at her like she was a UFO that had happened to plant herself in the middle of our conversation. Though I didn’t notice the way he was looking at her. I was too ashamed to meet his glance. It was such childish teasing, so immature, but I couldn’t face it.

"Sure!" I muttered, becoming redder and redder in the face. I turned on my heel and stomped out. I dared to hope I looked aloof but I knew inside that I'd always look ridiculous to Kirsty.

In double maths, I made a fool of myself again. We were doing algebra, and I was scribbling away in a notebook hidden under the desk. I was engrossed in a story I was writing, partly based on the girl I had dreamt up that night I had been window watching.

Mr Graves, a portly, moustached man of about fifty who obviously hated teaching more than anything else in the world, singled me out for an answer.

“Um...” I said, still wrapped up in my thoughts, “Flashlight?”

The class, chiefly led by Kirsty Brightman, exploded with laughter, until they were stopped by a chilling glance from Mr Graves.

He marched up to my desk before I had a chance to hide my notebook, which he grabbed from me furiously. “What,” he puffed, “may I ask, is this?”

Fortunately, I was saved by the bell, signalling break time, and the end of this lesson. As pupils desperate to leave the classroom, grabbed their bags and filed out, Mr Graves beckoned me to his desk, where he was now seated.

“Do you know why I kept you after the bell, Miss Harper?”

I sighed. “Because my attention is being diverted by the writing of ludicrous stories that suck me into an unrealistic world that is both distracting to the course of your lesson and stopping me from progressing in mathematics,” I said, almost word for word, memorised from the lecture I got almost every day.

Mr Graves looked up from my notebook in his pudgy hands, raised his eyebrows disapprovingly, and stared at me over his over-sized horn-rimmed glasses.

“Yes,” he said. “You obviously remember we’ve been over this before.” He leaned back in his chair, his brow furrowing.“This is starting to become a real issue, Amelia. Your inability to cope with the real world.”

Mr Graves stared at me, waiting for some sort of response, but I refused to give him the satisfaction. What he had said was so true that it had gotten right under my skin and was giving me goose bumps and prickly eyes. I gazed around the room, sinking back into another daydream.

After a few seconds of silence, Mr Graves let out an enormous sigh, and then said, “I’ll be notifying your father after school. I mean, um, your mother...um, I mean...” He went extremely red and coughed throatily into a handkerchief. “I’m sorry, Amelia, I didn’t mean anything like that. I understand the situation is hard at home, but the fact that you seem like an able student should warrant a good performance in class. I would excuse it were it apparent to me that you were not a particularly bright pupil, but it is obvious that you are competent, if you tried and did not put yourself down so much.”

I nodded, not feeling the need to protest or to contradict him. He didn’t understand. He didn’t understand anything.

***

To finish off an unbelievably bad start to the year, the last lesson was P.E. I was emotionally drained and to have to participate in sport was too much for me. Miss Griffiths, the sports teacher, was a woman who resembled a celery stick and walked around in tracksuits all the time. I approached her, clutching my stomach and grimacing.

“Um...Miss Griffiths? I’m sorry but I really don’t think I can do P.E. today. I’m having awful stomach pains. They think it’s...um...appendicitis.”

Miss Griffiths sighed exaggeratedly. “Amelia, I am beyond sick of your pathetic contrives to excuse yourself from my P.E. lessons. There is no good reason why you should not play sport today, so I suggest you go and get changed before I lose my temper.”

Ten minutes later I was standing at the top of the playing field, in an oversize rugby jumper and tracksuit bottoms, freezing myself to death. To make matters worse, now was the moment where the teams were going to be organised.

Team member picking was a mortifying torture session which happened every time we started a new sport. Hip hip hooray, today Miss Griffiths had started football season, because it was September, the first month of school. After Christmas, for we'd play bench ball and mess around with beams and rackets for the rest of the year. But football was to be taken seriously, and played till Christmas. That meant we stayed in the same teams for three months, more time than any sport we ever played. This also meant that team member choosing was very serious, because you'd be stuck with those people for three whole months.

Kirsty, this year, as usual, got nominated for team captain, and Wendy Haskins, amazingly-fit athlete, for the other team. Kirsty used every opportunity she could to steal all the best players. The Mini-K's were average, fairly good in some sports, but not as skilled as Kirsty or Wendy.

It was sickening to see the Mini-K's, looking at Kirsty as if she was some kind of goddess, waiting for her to choose them. They were standing there on the field, shivering in the September wind in their tiny black cycle shorts and tight white t-shirts, fashionable as always. However, she never picked them. Maybe loyalty to friends didn't exist in the Kirsty world. Rhiannon, Lucy and Martine all ended up in Wendy’s team, much to their disappointment. The circle of us waiting grew smaller and smaller, and soon I was left there alone, freezing and embarrassed, the two team captains looking at me reluctantly.
And it was Kirsty's turn for another team member.

"But Miss!" she squealed in a high-pitched voice that would have broken glass. "Can't Wendy have her? We have enough, yeah? I don't want another member in our team!" I wished the field would split open and swallow me up.

She was getting really frustrated, jumping about in the cold air and protesting against having me in her team. Miss Griffiths saw this, and so perceptive and understanding as ever, guess what she did? Refused to send me to Wendy's team because, "Wendy already has enough people."

Teachers. They understand children so very well.

Kirsty looked at me in a rage. Her green eyes grew shiny and mean, her lips clamping together in a thin, angry line.

"I'll get you for this, Amelia Harper. Watch out, worm," she muttered underneath her breath, digging her long, pointy fingernails into my palm so hard I flinched. I looked down at my hand and there was already a red bruise starting to form.

We started playing. I got positioned at the far end of the field where I didn't see how the ball would ever get to me, so I thought I was safe. Kirsty wouldn't get angry because I wouldn't have the ball at all.

So I just stood there, pulled my sleeves out as far as they would go to cover my fingers that were stinging so much with the cold it was agony, and started dreaming.

Dad would come right into this P.E lesson, driving straight across the field in a Mercedes Benz, and then he'd park in a cloud of smoke, punch Kirsty Brightman right in the nose, and then pick me up like I was as light as a feather and we'd drive off together, away from the school, away from the flat, away from -

"Kirsty!" Yeah! How'd they know?

"Ball! Ball!" Oh. Football. Hi-ho.

"Can't! Too late! The ball’s out there!” Kirsty yelled. "Amelia, hello-o?"

My head jerked up from my daydream. "Huuuh?"

"Amelia, you idiot, the ball!" she yelled.

I looked down and sure enough, the ball was coming towards me. No. Go away. Go away, ball...

Kirsty Brightman kicked it at me, a blooper. I missed, and fell over backwards, winded. The hard football had hit me right in the stomach. The other team got the ball right under control as easy as anything. Most people were laughing and jeering at my mistake, but Kirsty started screaming at me.

"You idiot!" she shrieked dementedly. "You stupid fat idiot! You're crap at football, you're crap at everything!"

All I could do was gasp. I had started to feel very faint. The ball had winded me.

"Kirsty, after-school detention for behaving in that appalling manner. Letter home if it happens again. I’m warning you, Kirsty. Are you alright, Melia?” the teacher asked.

My stomach made a faint gurgling noise, and I groaned.

I heard Kirsty whisper, "God, she sounds like a sick elephant,” of course bringing on a fit of laughter.

"Kirsty, take Amelia down to the nurse's office, please," said Miss Griffiths calmly.

"Miss!" Kirsty squealed. "I'm on centre."

"That's quite alright. Rachel can run for you."

"But..." she squeaked.

"Go on now. Help her up," Miss Griffiths said evenly.

Oh, she helped me up alright. She dug her horrible nails into my shoulders as hard as possible and
yanked me up, muttering, "Get on with it, saddo."

She frog-marched me, nails still in shoulders, all the way across the field. By the time we'd got to the end and were nearing the building, I finally decided to ask the ultimate question.

"Kirsty?" I burst out abruptly, "Why do you hate me so much? What have I ever done to you, apart from not being your perfect type of person?"

She missed a beat then, and stared at me with a confused but not completely bewildered expression on her face, her hands dropping from my shoulders. Then she completely changed, gained back her composure, turned away and smiled disdainfully.

"Amelia," she said, "How could I not hate you?"
Had I the heavens embroider'd cloths,
I would spread the cloths under your feet.
But I being poor, have only my dreams,
So tread softly, for you tread on my life.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 140
It was quite a long chapter, so this is quite a long critique coming up!

It was seven in the morning on the first day back at school after the summer, and I felt all the groggy misery that went with that fact. My alarm was still blasting an old CD on my bedside table, but I was too [s]groggy[/s] (use a different word) to be bothered to turn it off. It was time for a self-examination.

...

I bent down and picked up a pair of black trousers. [s]Yanking up the zipper and [/s] Squeezing into them and yanking up the zipper, I eyed myself critically again. Now all the bulk was squeezed into a tight space, I had more of a form, but nevertheless. Nevertheless what?

(I need help redoing this following paragraph. It's really badly constructed!) Who was I kidding? What was the point of going to school? What was the point, when everyone despised me and I didn't have a single friend, and all the teachers thought I was useless? The only thing motivating me to go to school was English. It was the only subject I did well in and seemed to hold any future for me. I desperately didn’t want to become a failure, so I made myself get up every morning and face it.


Well, you have to work out what it is you want to say in the paragraph. Was your main point regarding English classes? Or the fact that she doesn’t have any friends? What does the ‘Who was I kidding?’ refer to? Was she trying to fit in with her classmates by trying to improve her figure with the trousers?

I had little reason to go to school: I didn’t have any friends and the teachers thought I was useless. The only thing motivating me to attend was English, which I did well in. It was the only subject that seemed to hold a future for me, and since I desperately didn’t want to become a failure, I forced myself to get up every morning.

I’m not sure if that helps at all!

As usual, I just sat alone at my desk and stared into space. [s]Sooner or later,[/s] I soon caught sight of an equally solitary pupil that I had never seen in our tutor group before. He was sitting alone reading a small book with a leather cover. He wasn’t that tall for a boy, nor too muscular, and his nose and cheeks were lightly scattered with freckles. His eyes had flecks of green and grey swirling around in the pupils. How far away is she? Would she be able to tell what his eyes were like? This description could come later, when he speaks to her. [s]He looked serene and comfortable, and[/s] He didn’t seem to notice or care that people were already staring at him and judging him. You were saying essentially the same thing in both parts of the sentence.

Suddenly, he looked up from his book and instantly caught my eye before I had a chance to avert my gaze elsewhere. I felt mortified [s]about the fact[/s] that he’d caught me staring at him. Even worse, he closed his book and walked across the classroom to stand in front of my desk. I stared up at him, looking like a rabbit caught [s]between the cross lights[/s] in the headlights, waiting for an insult, a taunt.

It didn’t come. He just smiled at me and said, “Hey there. I’m Douglas. I’m the new guy.” Would he not say something like ‘I’m new here’? ‘The new guy’ makes it seem as though everyone has been gossiping about him and he has a reputation, and he's like 'Yep - I'm him, the new guy'. I know people have been talking about him, but not to Amelia.

His accent was unmistakably American.

While I was trying to calm myself and thinking of what to reply to this angelic presence that was standing in front of me, I noticed that Kirsty was ignoring her Mini-Ks and was watching us. Watching us with extreme interest, a pout hovering on her lips.

It had been obvious she liked the look of Douglas from the start, seeing the way she was simpering over him when he entered the room. Amelia never saw him enter the room, so she wouldn’t know Kirsty had been eyeing him up. The sight of him reading had probably put her off at first, but when she had seen the self-respect he harboured, this had most likely changed her mind. All the girls were gravitating slightly [s]around[/s] toward him, [s]at[/s] in any case.

I didn’t know how he [s]was[/s] could be so confident. He wasn’t reading and thinking to himself, “Oh-my-God-I-look-like-a-nerd-and-everyone-else-is-going-to-think-I-look-like-a-nerd-and–maybe-I-better-stop-now.” Probably what I would have been thinking, hence [s]the fact[/s] I never read in public. Hm, I think this still sounds a bit awkward. He was reading, [s]uncaring of[/s] unconcerned with anyone else’s opinion [s]and not fearing people’s reactions and thoughts. [/s]

Before I could reply to him, Kirsty sidled up towards us, [s]a strange look on her face[/s]. I could almost see a pair of ruby horns appearing on her raven hair and a long pointy tail sprouting from her infinitesimal behind.

“Ooh, am I interrupting the two lovebirds?” Kirsty cooed.


Again, ‘the two lovebirds’ implies that there were already rumours about them, which obviously there weren’t since they just met. I know Kirsty’s a cow so she’s just trying to be irritating, but I think her first line of speech could be cut, leaving:

“Isn't this sweet? Amelia's finally managed to get herself a boyfriend. Though, um...” she whispered loudly in a confidential manner to Douglas, "Watch out. She smells.”


He raised an eyebrow, looking at her like she was a UFO that had happened to plant herself in the middle of our conversation. Though I didn’t notice the way he was looking at her. I was too ashamed to meet his glance. It was such childish teasing, so immature, but I couldn’t face it.


I wouldn’t put in his reaction if Amelia can’t see it, since this is in the first person.

"Sure!" I muttered, becoming redder and redder in the face. I turned on my heel and stomped out. I dared to hope I looked aloof but I knew inside that I'd always look ridiculous to Kirsty.


I think this should be revised. Amelia was sitting, so you could have her scrape her chair back and hurry from the class (although don’t use ‘hurry’, that’s a rubbish example). I don’t think she should mutter anything. I didn’t really like the third sentence as it is. She could dare to hope she looked composed but know that everyone would see through it or something similar.

In double maths, I made a fool of myself again. We were doing algebra, and I was scribbling away in a notebook hidden under the desk. I was engrossed in a story I was writing, partly based on the girl I had dreamt up that night I had been window watching.

Mr Graves, a portly, moustached man of about fifty, who obviously hated teaching more than anything else in the world, (Ha! Teachers like that can be so funny!) singled me out for an answer. Maybe add in a simple bit of speech: “Well, Amelia? What is the answer?” Then cut out ‘for an answer’ in the previous sentence.

“Um...” I said, still wrapped up in my thoughts. “Flashlight?”

The class, chiefly led by Kirsty Brightman, exploded with laughter until they were stopped by a chilling glance from Mr Graves.

He marched up to my desk before I had a chance to hide my notebook, which he grabbed from me furiously. “What,” he puffed, “may I ask, is this?”

Fortunately, I was saved by the bell no comma signalling break time no comma and the end of this lesson. As pupils desperate to leave the classroom no comma grabbed their bags and filed out, Mr Graves beckoned me to his desk where he was now seated.

“Do you know why I kept you after the bell, Miss Harper?”

I sighed. “Because my attention is being diverted by the writing of ludicrous stories that suck me into an unrealistic world that is both distracting to the course of your lesson and stopping me from progressing in mathematics.” [s]I said, almost word for word, memorised from the lecture I got almost every day. [/s] I don’t think you need this because of what Mr Graves says.

Mr Graves looked up from my notebook in his pudgy hands, raised his eyebrows disapprovingly, and stared at me over his over-sized horn-rimmed glasses.


The last paragraph is clunky. Try:

Mr Graves looked up from the notebook in his pudgy hands, and peered at me disapprovingly through his over-sized glasses.

After a few seconds of silence, Mr Graves let out an enormous sigh[s], and then said,[/s]. “I’ll be notifying your father after school. I mean, um, your mother... um, I mean...” He went extremely red and coughed throatily into a handkerchief. “I’m sorry, Amelia, I didn’t mean anything like that. I understand the situation is hard at home, but the fact that you seem like an able student should warrant a good performance in class. I would excuse it were it apparent to me that you were not a particularly bright pupil, but it is obvious that you are competent, if you tried and did not put yourself down so much.”

I nodded, not feeling the need to protest or to contradict him. He didn’t understand. He didn’t understand anything. I like these last couple of paragraphs.

***

To finish off an unbelievably bad start to the year, P.E. was the last lesson. [s]was P.E.[/s] (I didn’t like the full stop of ‘P.E.’ also acting as the sentence’s full stop – it didn’t look finished.) I was emotionally drained and to have to participate in sport was too much for me. Miss Griffiths, the sports teacher, was a woman who resembled a celery stick and walked around in tracksuits all the time. I approached her, clutching my stomach and grimacing.

“Um... Miss Griffiths? I’m sorry but I really don’t think I can do P.E. today. I’m having awful stomach pains. They think it’s... um... appendicitis.”

Miss Griffiths sighed exaggeratedly. “Amelia, I am beyond sick of your pathetic [s]contrives[/s] (I don’t think ‘contrive’ is a noun, but I can’t think of an alternative at the moment) to excuse yourself from my P.E. lessons. There is no good reason why you should not play sport today, so I suggest you go and get changed before I lose my temper.”

Ten minutes later, I was standing at the top of the playing field (no comma) in an oversize rugby jumper and tracksuit bottoms, freezing [s]myself[/s] to death. To make matters worse, [s]now was the moment where the teams were going to be organised. [/s] we were about to organise the teams.

Team-member-picking was a mortifying torture session that happened every time we started a new sport. Hip hip hooray, today Miss Griffiths had started football season, because it was September, the first month of school. Have either ‘September’ or ‘the first month of school’. After Christmas, [s]for[/s] we'd play bench ball and mess around with beams and rackets for the rest of the year. [s]But[/s] Football, however, was to be taken seriously and played until Christmas. That meant we stayed in the same teams for three months, more time than any sport we ever played. This also meant that [s]team member[/s] choosing team members was very serious, because you'd be stuck with those people for three whole months.

[s]Kirsty, this year, as usual,[/s] Kirsty, as usual, got nominated for team captain, and Wendy Haskins, an amazingly-fit athlete, was appointed to choose the other team. Kirsty used every opportunity she could to steal all the best players. The Mini-Ks were average: fairly good in some sports, but not as skilled as Kirsty or Wendy.

It was sickening to see the Mini-Ks looking at Kirsty as if she was some kind of goddess, waiting for her to choose them. They were standing there on the field, shivering in the September wind in their tiny black cycle shorts and tight white t-shirts, fashionable as always. However, she never picked them. Maybe loyalty to friends didn't exist in [s]the[/s] Kirsty’s world. Rhiannon, Lucy and Martine all ended up in Wendy’s team, much to their disappointment. The circle of us waiting grew smaller and smaller, and soon I was left there alone, freezing and embarrassed, the two team captains looking at me reluctantly.

And it was Kirsty's turn for another team member.

"But Miss!" she squealed in a high-pitched voice that would have broken glass. "Can't Wendy have her? We have enough, yeah? I don't want another member in our team!" (new paragraph)

I wished the field would split open and swallow me up.

She was getting really frustrated, jumping about in the cold air and protesting against having me in her team. Miss Griffiths saw this, and so perceptive and understanding as ever, [s]guess what she did[/s] what did she do? Refused to send me to Wendy's team, because "Wendy already has enough people."

Teachers. They understand children so very well.

Kirsty looked at me in a rage. Her green eyes grew shiny and mean, her lips clamping together in a thin, angry line.

"I'll get you for this, Amelia Harper. Watch out, worm," she muttered under[s]neath[/s] her breath, digging her long, pointy fingernails into my palm so hard I flinched. How does Amelia let Kirsty dig her nails into her hand? I looked down at my hand and there was already a red bruise ? starting to form.

We started playing. I [s]got[/s] was positioned at the far end of the field. [s]where[/s] I didn't see how the ball would ever get to me, so I thought I was safe. Kirsty wouldn't get angry because I wouldn't have the ball at all.

So I just stood there, pulled my sleeves [s]out[/s] down as far as they would go to cover my fingers, which [s]that[/s] were stinging so much with the cold it was agony, and started dreaming.

Dad would come right into this P.E lesson, driving straight across the field in a Mercedes Benz, and then he'd park in a cloud of smoke. He’d punch Kirsty Brightman right in the nose, [s]and[/s] then pick me up like I was as light as a feather and we'd drive off together, away from the school, away from the flat, away from -

...

I looked down and sure enough, the ball was coming towards me. No. Go away. Go away, ball...
Kirsty Brightman kicked it at me, a blooper. I missed, and fell over backwards, [s]winded[/s]. (She comes back to this.) The hard football had hit me right in the stomach. The other team got the ball [s]right[/s] under control [s]as easy as anything[/s] effortlessly. Most people were laughing and jeering at my mistake, but Kirsty started screaming at me.

"You idiot!" she shrieked dementedly. "You stupid fat idiot! You're crap at football, you're crap at everything!"

All I could do was gasp. I had started to feel very faint; the ball had winded me.

"Kirsty, after-school detention for behaving in that appalling manner. Letter home if it happens again. I’m warning you, Kirsty.” The teacher turned to me and called, “Are you alright, Melia?” [s]the teacher asked. [/s] Would the teacher call her 'Melia'?

My stomach made a faint gurgling noise, and I groaned.

I heard Kirsty whisper, "God, she sounds like a sick elephant,” [s]of course[/s] which naturally brought on a fit of laughter.

...

She frog-marched me, nails still in shoulders, all the way across the field. By the time we[s]'d got to the end and[/s] were nearing the building, I finally decided to ask the ultimate question.

"Kirsty?" I burst out abruptly. "Why do you hate me so much? What have I ever done to you, apart from not being your perfect type of person?"

She missed a beat then, and stared at me with a confused but not completely bewildered expression (This sounds like a strange expression! Could you express it a bit more clearly?) on her face, her hands dropping from my shoulders. Then she completely changed, regained [s]back[/s] her composure, turned away and smiled disdainfully. How can Amelia see her smile if Kirsty turns away? You could just cut ‘turned away’.

"Amelia," she said, "How could I not hate you?"


Well, this was an interesting chapter! It looked like we were actually going to discover what makes Kirsty tick, but not quite yet!

I liked the introduction of ‘the new guy’, although I think the scene with him needs edited quite a bit. (I think I mentioned everything that seemed unnatural there.)

Apart from that, I was just changing words and so on that sounded strange to me. They’re all just suggestions, of course. If you read it aloud you can hear the sections that sound a bit awkward and it should make it easier to edit them.

Good luck with this! I’ll keep reading!
Click for critiques :)

Dancing through life down at the Ozdust, if only because dust is what we come to – Wicked the Musical




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 147
Hello there! Looks really good.


Who was I kidding? What was the point of going to school? What was the point, when everyone despised me and I didn't have a single friend, and all the teachers thought I was useless? The only thing motivating me to go to school was English. It was the only subject I did well in and seemed to hold any future for me. I desperately didn’t want to become a failure, so I made myself get up every morning and face it

Yeah, I ask the same questions every day. Okay, I have a few suggestions Who was I kidding? What was the point of going back to school? There is no point when everyone despises me. I don't have a single friend! Even the teachers think I'm useless and a waste of their time. The only thing that is remotely motivating my going back is English. It's the only subject I did well in and seemed to hold any future for me. Despite all of the taunting, I forced my sleepy eyes open every morning and faced the world. Or something like that. Play with it a little and reword some sentences.



Shakespeare would have turned in his grave.

Love this.


His accent was unmistakably American.

Haha! Definitely didn't see that coming.



"Sure!" I muttered,

I'm not exactly sure that this would be the right reaction here. She wasn't asked anything, right? Try something else like "Excuse me," I muttered, my face becoming redder and redder.


Mr Graves, a portly, moustached man of about fifty who obviously hated teaching more than anything else in the world, singled me out for an answer.

“Um...” I said, still wrapped up in my thoughts, “Flashlight?”

Haha. My response to something like this is always 'purple?' Sadly, I said it too often and it got old.

.“This is starting to become a real issue, Amelia. Your inability to cope with the real world.”

He is a math teacher, not an English teacher. Take out the period after Amelia and turn it into a comma. Math teachers can use improper English because they teach a ridiculous subject.
My math teacher, Mr. Lyon, took away my books and notebooks because I never paid attention to his lectures. It's not my fault the subject is outrageously boring. Haha, good connection!



Somewhere in the beginning you talked about Douglas' eyes. The colors would dance in the iris not the pupil, the pupil is black. Haha.
I really really love your connections with the modern teenage stick out. It pulls me in and I get lost in Amelia's world. Great job!!!
"Sometimes the worst bad guy makes the best good guy." Nigel--Untouched




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 202
thanks Jasmine.

haha :lol: you're so right about the maths teacher thing.

Thanks a lot.

Sarah


xxx
Had I the heavens embroider'd cloths,
I would spread the cloths under your feet.
But I being poor, have only my dreams,
So tread softly, for you tread on my life.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 35199
Reviews 878
Hi, Sarah!

I liked this chapter! And I like Douglas already, can't wait to find out more about him.


I felt all the groggy misery

I was too groggy


These are close to each other, so you're just making it sound repetitive with two "groggy"s. Change one of them to something else.


He was reading, uncaring of anyone else’s opinion and not fearing people’s reactions and thoughts.


How can he be reading if he's talking to Amelia?


He raised an eyebrow, looking at her like she was a UFO that had happened to plant herself in the middle of our conversation. Though I didn’t notice the way he was looking at her.


You're being contradictory – how can Amelia see his expression if she's not watching?


"Sure!" I muttered


I'm not entirely sure to whom she is saying this. Or is it just like, "Sure, I smell, glad you noticed" kind of irony? If that's so, you could expand it or just explain it a little more.


"I'll get you for this, Amelia Harper. Watch out, worm,"


Is she angry because Amelia was the last one to get picked? I can kind of understand it, but at first it just feels really weird.


They think it’s...um...appendicitis.”

“Um...” I said, still wrapped up in my thoughts, “Flashlight?”

Oh. Football. Hi-ho.


Oh, I just adore Amelia! You're doing very well in her development! I love these parts, great job.


This was a good and interesting chapter. You should thank heavens for having as great reviewer as Sapphire, she's doing an amazing job. :D

Can't wait to read more!

Demeter xxx
"Your jokes are scarier than your earrings." -Twit

"14. Pretend like you would want him even if he wasn't a prince. (Yeah, right.)" -How to Make a Guy Like You - Disney Princess Style

Got YWS?



A woman knows the face of the man she loves as a sailor knows the open sea.
— Honore de Balzac