Elaine and Edward

10 posts
Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 2
This is the first piece of fiction I've written in a long time. I don't know how good it is. I would like to know what you all think of it. I hope to make it longer. But I'm stumped right now, and I'd like to get some reviews on it.


**UPDATE**

-----

The house was huge! Elaine couldn’t believe it when she had first seen the house from the car. It was so much bigger than their old house! It was like a mansion! As soon as she got inside she wanted to explore.

When she started to take off, her mother grabbed her hand, “Don’t you want to see your new room, Elaine?”

“Yeah! Where is it? Is it pretty? Is it big? I bet it is. This place is huge!” Elaine said as she was led up the stairs and to the back of the house by her mother. “WOAH!”

“Do you like it, honey?”

“Yeah, it’s big!”

Elaine’s mother laughed, “I’m glad you like it.”

Abruptly, Elaine turned around, “Can I see the rest of the house?”

Surprised, her mother asked, “Don’t you want to unpack your stuff.”

Elaine told her mother that she didn’t, she just wanted to see the house.

“Well, alright, then, hon, I’ll show you the rest of the house.”

“I wanna look at it on my own,” Elaine wanted to explore, not be shown around the house.

“Well, ok then, honey,” her mother said as Elaine took off down the hall, Elaine had always been a loner, maybe in this new town she’d make some friends.

Elaine explored every nook of the old house. All the floors were wood and stained a deep shiny color, almost the same as Elaine’s hair. It was very old fashioned and very fascinating. Her old house had been so tiny, her old room had been over flowing with stuffed animals. Suddenly, she was afraid the room would be too big for her and her stuffed animals. She had to go see the room again. What if the room was scary at night? She ran upstairs as quick as her feet could carrier her. When she reached the landing at the top of the stairs, she stopped.

There was a man down the hall way. He was dressed funnily, not at all like her father dressed. His clothing was fancy, and he had a funny hat on.

“Mister! Mister,” the man stopped and turned his head, “Mister, are you allowed to be here? This is my house,” the child asked with a five year olds impetuousness.

The man looked absolutely taken aback, “Pardon me, miss, but you can see me?”

"Yes, silly! I can see you! And this is my new house; I live here with my mommy and my daddy! Are you allowed to be here?”

“I live here as well.”

“Mister, can you be my new friend? I don’t have any friends here.”

How could the man refuse such an offer? It had been so long since anyone had been able to see him. He hadn’t conversed with another soul, let alone another person, for years.

“Of course I will be your friend. But first, I shall have to know your name.”

Taking her new friend by the hand she said, “My name’s Elaine. What’s yours?”

“I am Edward,” the man said as Elaine led him off to play.

“Do you want to see my room, Edward? It’s huge! This whole house is huge! Huger that my old house. Way huger,” Elaine led Edward off without waiting for his answer. She led him to the end of the hallway on the second floor, past her parent’s room, which was larger than hers, past the bathroom, past the linen closet, and through an open door at the end of the hall.

The room was a monstrosity, to Elaine at least, Edward, however, was more familiar with the scale. Light streamed through the big windows, four in all. The walls were pale and spotless which accentuated the high ceiling.

“Isn’t it huge?” Elaine asked, jumping in the air, clearly excited.

Edward chuckled. The girls enthusiasm as contagious, but he still didn’t know how or why she could see him. Of all the children of all the families who had lived here why was this one different? Elaine ran to a corner where some boxes had already been placed. She quickly dug into one marked ‘toys’ and emerged triumphantly with a small red ball, which she promptly threw at Edward.

Instinctively, somehow he still had instincts, he put his hand out to catch it, and it landed silently in his hand. He was stunned. He stared at the ball. Physical objects usually just glided through him or he through them. But he had caught this shiny red ball. Edward was utterly bewildered, how had this happened?

“Edward! Throw it back! That’s how you play the game!” Elaine yelled. And Edward threw it back, still stunned. The pair played catch, but not for long, Elaine soon decided she was hungry.

“I’m gonna get the rest of my Oreos! Wait right here Edward!” And Elaine rushed out the cavernous room, down the hall, and clambered down the stairs.

Marie, Elaine’s mother, heard her daughters noisy rush down the stairs and smiled; she hoped Elaine would adjust to the move. There were more changes than just a new house, Elaine would be starting kindergarten in the fall. Marie was optimistic for the future, however.

“Mommy, Mommy,” Elaine streaked into the kitchen where her mother was unpacking glassware, “My new friend and me want my Oreos! Where are they?”

Marie turned around, “Your new friend?”

“I met him upstairs, his name is Edward."

Marie nodded and reached for Elaine’s cookies, “Mind if I go with you to meet your friend?” she asked.

A big smile crept across Elaine’s face, “Yeah! Come on! You’ll love him,” she said quickly and led her mom upstairs running.

“Edward! My mom wants to meet you,” Elaine streaked back up the stairs and down the hall to her room. “Edward, my mom wants to meet you,” she repeated as she neared the door.

A funny half smile stretched across his face. Perhaps this girl’s mother would be able to see him as well, “By all means, Elaine, bring her in.”

Marie entered the room, and looked around. She saw no one. She had expected as much, but relief still washed over her; Marie was a worrier. Elaine had an imaginary friend; the only thing that surprised Marie is that she’d taken so long to invent one. Marie reached down towards her daughter, “I see, honey, you have an imaginary friend. How nice.”

“No, He’s right there, Mommy,” Elaine pointed to a spot directly in front of her mother.
Elaine looked up at her mom, confused. Why couldn’t her mom see Edward? She repeated her self. Edward was right in front of them.

“Here are your cookies, hon, have fun,” Marie handed Elaine the cookies and exited the room.

Elaine had tears swelling in her big eyes, “Edward, why couldn’t she see you?”

Edward sighed, disappointed, he shook his head, so it was just something special about Elaine. Why her?

“Edward, Edward,” Elaine said, trying to get his attention, tears streaming down her face, “Why couldn’t my mom see you, Edward?”

He looked her full in the face, the poor girl looked utterly confused. Edward was as well, but he at least knew why her mom couldn’t see him. He saw the pain on Elaine’s face and he reached out to her. She fell in to his arms, weeping. He was again shocked that she didn’t fall right through him, but she fell into him, as though he were still alive. Edward pulled Elaine up in his arms and carried her to the bed, which had already been set up. He propped her up against the pillow and wiped the tears from beneath her eyes. She looked at him, searching for an answer.

Edward wasn’t sure what to say. He didn’t have the slightest clue as to how to explain himself. He took a deep breath, “Elaine, I’m not like you, I’m not like your mother; I am not living. I died long ago.” He looked at Elaine. He wished that was enough, but he knew it wasn’t. Her piercing green eyes still stared right into his, “I suppose what you’d call me is a…ghost.” He hated the word, but what else could he say?

“But, but…” Elaine stammered, still crying, “you’re not scary though, ghosts have to be scary.”

“Scary or not, Elaine, I am not alive, I am a spirit, a soul, imprisoned on earth, between life and death. I’m sorry, Elaine,” Edward rose up off the bed, and began to exit the room.

As he neared the door Elaine called for him to wait, “Edward, can ghosts still have friends?”

Edward turned back towards the child on the bed and a smile crept across his face, “Yes, Elaine, ghosts can have friends.”
Last edited by shesarebel on Fri Aug 08, 2008 3:29 am, edited 1 time in total.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5120
Reviews 317
Aloha!

Interesting story. It sort of reminds me of Casper and Wendy. =)

There are a few grammar/punctuation mistakes. At first I couldn't pinpoint exactly what was wrong in this story. I had a feeling there was something not right. After reading it two times I realized exactly what it was.

I think you need to spend more time with five year olds. The dialogue didn't seem realistic because actual five year olds don't talk like that.

I feel you tried to create a child without knowing much about children. Well that's what it looks like from your writing.

Another thing; when does this story take place?
I ask this because, kids rarely go around calling people "Mister, Mister" these days. Especially five year olds. I don't understand why people think children talk like that. "Mommy. Mommy" or "Daddy, Daddy", "Teacher, Teacher."

I've seen this in a lot of places. Five year olds don't talk like that. Maybe kids younger than five. But definitely not five.

I also feel that as a reader I don't have much of a connection with Elaine. And I think that could be because as the writer, you don't either. Hmm? Build more on Elaine. Make her real. Make her unique, special, different from others. And when you get know her troubles, her wishes, her dreams then you will start caring more about her and we as readers will also feel the connection.

Don't treat her like a child, though she is one. Children rarely treat themselves like children and we need to stop imposing the cliche image of children.

I hope you understand what I meant and please take my criticism positive though it may seem harsh. I mean well.

Keep writing and let me know if you have any questions.

=)

-Mizz Iceberg
I'm a godmother, that's a great thing to be, a godmother. She calls me god for short, that's cute, I taught her that.
--Ellen DeGeneres




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3129
Reviews 108
I'm going to put all my comments in bold so you can see them better.



“Mister! Mister,” the man stopped and turned his head, “Mister, are you allowed to be here? This is my house,” the child asked with a five year olds impetuousness.

The man looked taken aback, “Pardon me, miss, but you can see me?”

“Yes, silly! I can see you! And this is my new house; I live here with my mommy and my daddy! Are you allowed to be here?”

“I live here as well.” ooOoooOoooh... ghost?

“Mister, can you be my new friend? I don’t have any friends here.”

How could the man refuse the offer? It had been so long since anyone had been able to see him. He hadn’t conversed with another soul, let alone another person, for years. “Of course I will be your friend. But first, I shall have to know your name.”

Taking her new friend by the hand she said, “My name’s Elaine. What’s yours?” that's cute. =]

“I am Edward,” the man said as Elaine led him off to play.

“Do you want to see my room, Edward? It’s huge! This whole house is huge! Huger that my old house. Way huger,” Elaine led Edward off without waiting for his answer. that's really realistic. I know little kids that just keep talking without waiting for answers to their questions. This is realy cute so far. She led him to the end of the hallway on the second floor, past her parent’s room, which was larger than hers, past the bathroom, past the linen closet, and through an open door at the end of the hall.

The room was a monstrosity, to Elaine at least, Edward, however, was more familiar than the scale. that last phrase sounded confusing. Did you mean more familiar with the scale? Light streamed through the big windows, four in all. The walls were pale and spotless which accentuated the high ceiling. “Isn’t it huge,?” Elaine asked, jumping in the air, clearly excited.

Edward chuckled. The girls enthusiasm as contagious, and he simply accepted that she could see him. He doesn't wonder why? Elaine ran to a corner where some boxes had already been placed. She quickly dug into one marked ‘toys’ and emerged triumphantly with a small red ball, which she promptly threw at Edward.

Instinctively, surprisingly, I would strike surprisingly. It sounds like too much somehow he still had instincts, he put his hand out to catch it, and it landed silently in his hand. He was stunned. He stared at the ball. Physical objects usually just glided through him or he though through them. But he had caught this shiny, i dont think you need the comma red ball. Edward was utterly bewildered, how had this happened?

“Edward! Throw it back! That’s how you play the game!” Elaine yelled. And Edward threw it back, still stunned. The pair played catch, but not for long, Elaine soon decided she was hungry.

“I’m hungry,” I don't think you need to have her say it, since you just told us that. she whined as she rubbed her stomach, “I’m gonna get the rest of my Oreos! Wait right here Edward!” And Elaine rushed out the cavernous room, down the hall, and clambered down the stairs.

Marie, Elaine’s mothercomma heard her daughter's noisy rush down the stairs,no comma and smiled,semi-colon she hoped Elaine would adjust to the move. In addition to the move I would take out in addition to the move because it doesn't flow nicely. Maybe just say, "There were other changes as well..." or something like that. there were other changes, not only was there a new house to get together, Elaine would be starting kindergarten in the fall. Marie was optimistic for the future, however, I would make this two seperate sentences. perhaps Elaine would make some new friends or get a hobby and would become less bothersome.

“Mommy, Mommy,” Elaine streaked into the kitchen where her mother was unpacking glassware, “My new friend and me want my Oreos! Where are they?”

Marie turned around, “Your new friend?”

“I met him upstairs, his name is Edward.”

Marie nodded and reached for Elaine’s cookies, “Mind if I go with you to meet your friend?” she asked.
new paragraph when the speaker changes A big smile crept across Elaine’s face, “Yeah! Come on! You’ll love him,” she said quickly and led her mom upstairs running.

“Edward! My mom wants to meet you,” Elaine streaked back up the stairs and down the hall to her fairy princess room. “Edward, my mom wants to meet you,” she repeated as she neared the door.

A funny half smile stretched across his face. Perhaps this girls mother would be able to see him as well, “By all means, Elaine, bring her in.”

Marie entered the room, and looked around. She was I'm assuming you meant saw no one. She had expected as much, but relief still washed over her, semi-colon? Marie was a worrier. Elaine had an imaginary friend and no wonder, she had left her only playmate behind with the move. Marie reached down towards her daughter, “I see, honey, you have and an? imaginary friend. How nice.”

“No, He’s right there, Mommy,” Elaine pointed to a spot directly in front of her mother.
Elaine looked up at her mom, confused. Why couldn’t her mom see Edward? She repeated her self. Edward was right in front of them.

“Here are you your cookies, hon, have fun,” Marie handed Elaine the cookies and exited the room.

Elaine had tears swelling in her big eyes, “Edward, why couldn’t she see you?”[/quote]



well, i thought it was very good. There were a few little mistakes, but i like the idea of this story a lot!!! i really hope you continue because it's interesting. i wonder what edward's story is... -ponders-


lol, very good job, hopefully it'll continue!! =DD the only advice i would give you is try to make Elaine more unique b/c she seems like a very generic little kid, and since she can see ghosts, she certainly isn't average. Maybe say more about how she might be a loner, or maybe she's had "imaginary" friends before or something.

-kailamarie
... :D ...
[url]spottedturtle.tumblr.com[/url]




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 2
mizz-iceberg, kailamarie, Thanks for your reviews. I hadn't realized that I had so many typos! I'm definitely writing more, though!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1207
Reviews 86
Heyy!

this was really interesting, I liked it a lot. I found some typos but I'm not going to repeat them. I like the thought of a little girl seeing ghosts, it's very interesting. I can't wait to read more!!

~Dommy :D
This is our decision, to live fast and die young.
We've got the vision, now let's have some fun.
Yeah, it's overwhelming, but what else can we do,
Get jobs in offices, and wake up for the morning commute?




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 2
Alright, so I wrote some more and this is what I got. There might still be a lot of grammar mistakes because I'm not so good at catching those, but hopefully the Elaine's character comes into play a little better.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3129
Reviews 108
i really liked the updates!!

good job. there were still a few typos, but i'm not in the mood for nit-picking. lol.

I think this story is really cute, and I'm looking forward to more of it. =D

As he neared the door Elaine called for him to wait, “Edward, can ghosts still have friends?”


Edward turned back towards the child on the bed and a smile crept across his face, “Yes, Elaine, ghosts can have friends.”


I loved this line!! good job.
... :D ...
[url]spottedturtle.tumblr.com[/url]




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1207
Reviews 86
Aww!! I'm so happy Edward and Elaine are going to be friends! The characters are great and I liked how you captured Elaine's innocence and how you made her mom think she has an imaginary friend. It's what every person blames a child's imagination on.

It's a wicked good idea!

~Dommy :D
This is our decision, to live fast and die young.
We've got the vision, now let's have some fun.
Yeah, it's overwhelming, but what else can we do,
Get jobs in offices, and wake up for the morning commute?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 158
Hi there!
Now, before I get onto the main things, I'm wondering what age group you're aiming this at. Because that allows different things.
For example, this is clearly a book for children, not adults, and if it is for under eights, I think you've more or less nailed it. It isn't stenuous to read.
However, if it's aimed at more ten years old and above, I really think you need to spend more time on the description, the dialogue and, if possible, give Edward a little quirk for us to remember him by. Maybe a pocketwatch that he lovingly strokes, and later turns out to have been given to him by a sweetheart, many many years before? Who knows! It's your choice. That's the fun of it.

My problems with this are mainly that I can't picture most of it. The house is 'huge', you tell us, and probably old because there's a ghost. But can you tell us more? Are there any secret passage-ways that Elaine can go into and disappear for hours, and let her imagination run riot?
Children's fiction is all about the magic, the other-worldly-ness.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 10
watch you vocabulary.
"There was a man down the hall way. He was dressed funnily, not at all like her father dressed. His clothing was fancy, and he had a funny hat on."
I don't believe funnily is a word.
I thought the story was really funny and cute. I know you know you made some spelling and grammer mistakes so I'm not going to hound you on that.
I think you did a nice job on paragraphs and making it easy to read. Keep writing, your very talented. I think this would make a very nice children's or young teen's book.
good luck writing.
D ETDF & DTUA haha my modo!



I think that was when I began to realize that reputation isn't everything. I should focus less about how others perceive me and more about what makes me happy. Because, in the end, I have to live with myself.
— Seraphina