By Sun, By Moon - Chap. 5

9 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1068
Reviews 582
Chapter Five

Before the judgement

The bonfire and the Pack shrank behind me as I darted through the woods. I didn’t know where I was going; I just had to get rid of thoughts of Jeff and images of Mark and Harriet. But they chased me mercilessly, a step behind me as I continued to run.
Mark nuzzling Harriet’s chest…
If you keep pulling away, I’ll find someone else…

Jeff wouldn’t. He loved me. He had been waiting for me for years. And I was close to giving in, I knew. Why would he give up on me now?
For a time, I didn’t focus on where I was going. I had four legs now, and I was flying. The wind whistled in my ears and the trees slid past in a shadowed blur. I heard a howl behind me, and I recognized Keith’s high voice. He’d come to find me, probably pouting that I hadn’t danced with him. Idiot. He’d alert the Pack that I was gone, and I wanted to be alone.
Keith was easy to outrun. Too easy. Part of me had wanted the thrill of the chase, despite the identity of the wolf—pup, really—behind me. Keith had always been weak.
My ear picked up the sound of him crashing in the brush far back on my trail. I couldn’t circle him; he’d smell me. So I kept going, ignoring his whimpers and howls, until a huge shadow, different than that of a tree, towered over me. A slope jerked up before me, and I paused, looking up.
The Mackenzie mountain range created the shadow. I’d never crossed them before; hunts never went this far north. The elk and deer like to eat in the grasses to the east side of the valley. I’d never realized the range was this close to our large homes.
Keith was drawing closer. I growled. Why wouldn’t he give up and turn around? I again glanced up at the mountains. There were rules against going over them. There were humans on the other side. But, really, what harm could come from just looking at what lay beyond them from the top? I wouldn’t go down, I promised myself. I just wanted to look.
Excited, eager to forget about Jeff and the others, I began the long climb up the slope. It wasn’t too difficult; my body was hard and trained from the long hunts. Digging my claws into the ground, I gritted my teeth when the mountain became more vertical. But even then I didn’t stop. I wanted to see beyond the valley. Beyond the mountains.
Keith had lost me when the rocks began. I could hear him down below, sniffing around. He didn’t bother smelling the area where the mountain began—he wouldn’t, of course. It was forbidden to go there, and he believed me as one who followed the Law.
Now, in a way, I thought I understood Mark and his disregard of the rules. It was oddly exhilarating. I felt more free, relieved. It was as if invisible shackles had been clamped around my legs. But as I climbed, they seemed to fall away. Doing this was a way to escape the Law, the Pack, the constant loyalty and ties that had placed a burden on me that I hadn’t even known was there. Perhaps his romps with the other females was Mark’s way of escaping—however trivial and pathetic.
Before I realized it, I was at the top. I’d been so deep in my musings that I had lost focus again.
It was dark, but the moonlight was much brighter on the other side. It spilled out in a pale, luminous curtain over the trees. The waters of a river far below glinted and shivered.
But none of this is what held my attention and riveted my eyes.
In the distance was the orange glow of a fire. Not a wild fire, as we’d experienced at times, but a fire carefully made by hands. Human hands. The hackles instinctively rose on my back, and my lips pulled back in a snarl. It was what my father and the Pack had taught me: Humans were to be feared. Humans were to be avoided. They didn’t understand our ways, and killed our kind because of their resentment for their own weakness.
The sound of Keith whimpering some more reached my ears again. Impatiently, I looked down. The fool was still trying to find me. He knew I’d not headed back, but didn’t know where else I could have gone. The truth didn’t occur to him.
If I went down now, he’d know that I had been up the mountain. He would tell my father and Uncle Richard and I wouldn’t be allowed on the hunts for months. I would be kept at the houses, where someone could always keep an eye on me.
That just wouldn’t do.
But I wasn’t going to stand here all night, waiting for Keith to go away, or wait for him to glance up and see me, silhouetted against the moonlight.
So I did the unbelievable, I did the forbidden: I went down the mountain.
Last edited by KJ on Fri Aug 01, 2008 5:08 pm, edited 2 times in total.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2209
Reviews 106
That was quick, but I am so not complaining. This chapter was just as brilliant as the rest. I think you should have made it a tad longer. I can't wait to learn more about Mark, Genny, and the others. Keep up the great work!!
If I can impact one person, just one, with my writing before I die, then I've lived a great life




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6517
Reviews 402
I is here, KJ!

The chapters are getting very short. Of course, that equals easy reading and reviewing on YWS so.... yay. :D In your actual word document though, I think you should combine some of the chapters though since they are so short, but post them here how you wish.

It was exhilarating, oddly

Instead of having "oddly" hanging at the end, I think it'd be best to phrase it like this: "It was oddly exhilarating."

He would tell my father and Uncle Richard, and I wouldn’t be allowed on the hunts for months. I would be kept at the houses, where someone could always keep an eye on me.

This is kind of confusing because I thought she was in deep trouble anyway, so I don't know why she would worry about this?

Anyway, this is really short, so I don't have much to say. I like where the story is going still. I like how you had her understand the exhilaration of going against Pack Law. I feel like we're getting into her head more, so that's good.

Sorry I couldn't write more!

~ Clo
How am I not myself?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1068
Reviews 582
Thank you both for the reviews :)

And I know the chapters are getting short; it works better for me that way, because otherwise I feel like I'm dragging it out, and then there would be pointless paragraphs in this.

But thanks for reading. Chap. 6 coming along either tonight or tomorrow morning.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1215
Reviews 378
*gasp* down the mountain? *nibbles fingernails nervously* I'm going to run and read chapter six immediately.

I do have a suggestion, because that was such a short chapter - couldn't you just combine two chapters, if they're getting too short? You could make two different sections and fit it into the same chapter. Just a thought.

Anyway, cheers!

~MeAgain 8)
"Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe."
~Albert Einstein




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7596
Reviews 287
I’d never realized the range was this close to our large village-like place.


I don't like the wording of village-like place. Maybe, our large wolf village?

It was as if invisible shackles had been clamped across my shoulders.


I have always thought of shackles as being round like hand-cuffs and so to clamp them onto shoulders, it would be an awkward fit. I think if you say around your ankles it would still have the dramatic effect you are going for.

Perhaps his romps with the other females was Mark’s way of escaping… however trivial and pathetic.


Got ourselves a little player, ohhhh. Lol, back on topic. I think you should delete the .... and replace them with a comma. Mark's way of escaping, however trivial and pathetic. Idk I'm not all that good with commas. But I don't like the dot dot dot.

Other than that, good job. Your chapters are getting shorter, so I would do like Clo suggested and combine them. But for now they are good for YWS.
I am not addicted to reading, I can quit as soon as I finish one more chapter.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2242
Reviews 695
Wow so this is what she did to deserve the judgment, by the way there's no 'e' in judgement. Well anyways, I liked the way her thoughts were still frazzled from the fact that Harriet and Mark were together...it brings out her human side. Well I have nothing more to say except I like this story and I will keep reading,
Angel :D :D :D
True love, in all it’s celestial charm, and
star-crossed ways, only exist in a writer’s
mind, for humans have not yet learned
how to manifest it.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1075
Reviews 842
Again, much better than the previous chapters. It seems that you are gaining momentum with this story. It seems to be coming much easier to you than before. Which is good because I am becoming attached :D

I only noticed two things:

Perhaps his romps with the other females was Mark’s way of escaping—however trivial and pathetic.


“were” instead of “was” here.

The sound of Keith whimpering some more reached my ears again.


“Keith’s” instead of “Keith”

And again, the ending was one of those that force the reader to continue.

Beautifully done, Kels!
"Woe to the man whose heart has not learned while young to hope, to love—and to put his trust in life."
~ Joseph Conrad


"Music washes away from the soul the dust of everyday life."
~ Red Auerbach




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6100
Reviews 121
Another great chapter. We finally get to see what got her into trouble, but the best part is that there's still more to learn. We know what got her into trouble, but we still don't know the story. Very captivating and I do love how you're going from the present to the past and back again. :D

If you keep pulling away, I’ll find someone else…

I think these should be in quotes, or have some other way of showing that she's recalling that. Unless I'm wrong, and this wasn't what Jeff said to her.

Keith was easy to outrun. Too easy. Part of me had wanted the thrill of the chase, despite the identity of the wolf—pup, really—behind me. Keith had always been weak.

I like this part, I don't know why. But, I like the glimpse of the wolf mentality and the glimpse of the character that we get.

I’d never crossed them before; hunts never went this far north.

I'm curious about this part. She says that the hunts never went that far north, so does that mean that the hunts take place away from their settlement and the settlement is near the mountain? Or, am I just not remembering things from the earlier chapter and they picked the place for the bonfire outside the usual? And, now I do realize that you do say something to explain part of this, but I am still a bit curious. :D

He knew that I’d not headed back, but didn’t know where else I could have gone.

This is probably more stylistic, or just a nitpick, than anything. One of those weird connector words, not exactly necessary. Although, I tend to use them in description more than dialogue.

So I did the unbelievable, I did the forbidden: I went down the mountain.

And, again, stylistic nitpick, I don't like the comma there. I don't know, it just seems weird to me, reading it. Meh, I would like a full stop, or deleting the 'I did' in the second part.

All in all, a really great read. Hardly any thing to comment on, and most of those were just nitpicks. :D Beyond that, I love the glimpse of what got her in trouble. I mean, we know that it had something to do with the other side of the mountain, and the humans, but we still have more to learn. I really like this story.

Off to review the next part of this!
Some people fall in love and touch the sky.
Some people fall in love and find Quicksand.

- Incubus



If a dog will not come to you after having looked you in the face, you should go home and examine your conscience.
— Woodrow Wilson