Melancholy

8 posts
Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 38
This is just a little section from larger piece I'm writing, but wanted it to be critiqued. Suggestions on how to amplify Melancholy's weird-ness wound be appreciated.

Here we go!

The next morning, my emotion-liquor hangover allowed me to get out of bed and dressed without feeling my newly-realized heartache. I didn’t feel my heart tear as I started to wake up and use it again. I was numb.
The stress put on mi corazon had slowly started a fissure when I was in dreamland, not knowing that every second I was blissfully happy, my heart was breaking in more and more places.
I stumbled downstairs, everything was blurry. The world around me shifted, and nothing had depth. Nothing had meaning anymore. The toaster was just metal and the floor was wood nailed together. My drunkenness made my head hurt like I had been dealt a blow to the temple. Crashing into the kitchen, I sat down at a bar stool where I normally ate breakfast and talked to my mom when she ate dinner. My head fell into my hands and the sweat mixed with the blood of my heart to create an acid so potent it burned my lungs like bleach. Tears didn’t wash the hurt away. But the Vodka of my feelings might. This vodka had a brand. Her name was Melancholy.
“Hello, Sarah.” Melancholy appeared like an angel in the kitchen doorway and looked at me. I must have been a pathetic sight, too; hair fresh from bed, tears and sweat smeared on my face. Her perfectness alarmed me. Like when someone is so perfect in a horror movie, you know they’re the killer. And she would have played a kick butt killer.
“Get away from me.” She was freaking me out. For one, where the hell did she pop up from?
“You know, you shouldn’t have started drinking.” There was an almost empty bottle of brandy on the counter. But it wasn’t mine. It was my father’s. He’d been drinking a little more than never lately since he was having problems with his job. This behavior hadn’t bothered me because Dad wasn’t an abusive slobbering drunk or anything, we were just Italians who like fine wine. Drinking was a respectable part of my family. But as Melancholy held the bottle as Exhibit One and sneered, the alcohol seemed childish and immature.
“I wasn’t drinking.”
“Sure you weren’t.”
“No really, get away from me.” I sat up straighter and backed up to the very edge of my stool.
“But you don’t even know who I am.” She smiled and a honey-sweet voice dripped from her lips. Perfect lips; she was beautiful. Every line where it ought to be. Refined nose. Complexion the color of fallen snow. Long, angel blonde hair. But her eyes were, at the least, horrifying. Glowing blood red on the rims and deep violet in the middle, they seared into my head and drilled a hypnotic stare into my soul. I remember in science that red was the longest wavelength of visible light and violet was the shortest.
Her eyes.
She was first and last. Melancholy was here to take the whole of me.
“I am Shiva, the goddess of death. I am Hades. I scream your name while holding you in an iron clasp you will never escape from. I am Zeus of the heavens. I am death. I am fear. I personify evil. I am everything you hope for. I am what you never wanted to see.” Her eyes flashed and undulated the colors of my mortality. They glowed, searing their mark of shadows onto my heart. I felt her mark like a brand on my chest. She had me owned like we people own cattle.
“I will be your sunlight,” she held her hand up to a ray of morning light coming through the window and grabbed onto it. Somehow, she took that wave of brightness and strangled it, until it became only a shadow on her palm. She them returned her gaze back to me and the mark of servitude on my heart steamed, glowing red like hot iron. “and I will also be your darkness.” She scared the shit out of me.
Melancholy reached for me, glacier hands cold and dank, wanted to clasp my very soul. They came towards me, inching, flowing, even in her death grip, graceful. Fingers entwined themselves through my hair. She ran her nails across my hot cheek, saw-like hands ravaging my feverous skin. Her fingers traced around my face and then down towards my mouth. Melancholy’s muscles tensed, her wrists tightened. I watched her toxic blood pulse through her veins that popped beneath her translucent skin. I sucked in one last breath. I wasn’t sure if she was going to give me any more.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6400
Reviews 497
Hi Squishy! Man, your username is awesome. Love it. :D
Anyway. I am Saint, if I haven’t introduced myself before, and I shall be your critiquer today!

Personally speaking, you should really put your notes in italics. It avoids confusion; some people will think it’s part of the story. ^^

The stress put on mi corazon had slowly started a fissure when I was in dreamland, not knowing that every second I was blissfully happy, my heart was breaking in more and more places.

Mi = my, and this may be my own ignorance, but what’s a Corazon?

Also, this may just be because this is an excerpt, but I’m kind of confused insofar. I’m gonna bite my tongue on the rest until I finish reading.

I stumbled downstairs, everything was blurry.

This is not the place for a comma -- use a hyphen or semicolon.

The world around me shifted, and nothing had depth. Nothing had meaning anymore. The toaster was just metal and the floor was wood nailed together. My drunkenness made my head hurt like I had been dealt a blow to the temple.

These sentences seem kinda choppy to me. The fluency in them is lacking. Also, “nothing had meaning anymore” is *such* a cliché line. You’d be better off without it. It’s too much telling, anyway, rather than showing. Try varying the lengths of the remaining sentences. Read them aloud, too, to make sure they flow well.

My head fell into my hands and the sweat mixed with the blood of my heart to create an acid so potent it burned my lungs like bleach.

Oh puh-leeze. The blood of my heart? Lame. “My blood” will suffice, and not make you look immature.

But the Vodka of my feelings might.

The “vodka of my feelings?” What does that even mean?

This vodka had a brand.

Don’t most vodkas? ;)

Her perfectness alarmed me.

“Perfectness” is not a word. Perfection, however, is.


“No really, get away from me.” I sat up straighter and backed up to the very edge of my stool.

The dialogue here feels *really* unnatural. Something more like, “No really, it’s not mine” would feel more right. And *then* you can put in the “get away from me” bit.


Glowing blood red on the rims and deep violet in the middle, they seared into my head and drilled a hypnotic stare into my soul.

I am *choking* on the clichéd phrases here. Really, take it easy. “Drilled a hypnotic stare into my soul?” Um, ew? Far too clichéd. You can do better.

Her eyes flashed and undulated the colors of my mortality.

Again. The colours of my mortality? I never knew mortality had colours.

They glowed, searing their mark of shadows onto my heart.

Cliché, cliché, cliché. Come on, I *know* you can do better. Loads better. Stop with the heart & soul stuff. It’s unnecessary and just bogs down your story.

She had me owned like we people own cattle.

“We” is unnecessary.

*skims the rest* Oy, really. Take it easy on the clichéd descriptions. You can do so much better than abusing a thesaurus and making yourself sound smart. Writing is not a contest of intelligence. Bigger words are not always better. Use what feels natural. There are certain descriptions that just make your reader gag. Most of the time, descriptions involving blood, colour, souls, hearts, all that poetic nonsense are yucky. It feels like you’re trying too hard. Don’t. Just let it come naturally; description isn’t *everything,* although it does account for something.

Sorry to sound so harsh, but sometimes all one needs is a firm boot up the rear. ^^

-Saint Razorblade
The Official YWS Pirate :pirate3:
"2-4-6-8! I like to delegate!" -Meshugenah
"Teague: Stomping on your dreams since 1992." -Sachiko
"So I'm looking at FLT and am reminded of a sandwich." -Jabber




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 158
Hello :wink:

I won't echo Saint Razorblade's nit-picks, I will merely comment in an over-all sorta way.

It's very, er, descriptive. You seem to analyse each and every thing that happens, in a rather melodramatic way. That's good in some cases, but can get a little tedious for the reader. E.g.
Nothing had meaning anymore. The toaster was just metal and the floor was wood nailed together. My drunkenness made my head hurt like I had been dealt a blow to the temple.
But as Melancholy held the bottle as Exhibit One and sneered, the alcohol seemed childish and immature.
Melancholy was here to take the whole of me.
Melancholy reached for me, glacier hands cold and dank, wanted to clasp my very soul. They came towards me, inching, flowing, even in her death grip, graceful.


Melancholy, Melancholy, Menancholy. A different technique in need, methinks?


However, you have a range of superb vocab. Not limited one bit. You just need to consider that you may be a tad over-zealous with your wording. I've been in the same damned boat.

Over-all: Clever idea. Original. *Clap clap*




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 6
Hi.
In my opinion, to be honest about 90% of Saint's pickings were that necessary. I read it and didn't think that much was kinda cliche.
There was probbably a bit too much to do with the heart, blood, soul and that stuff. I think it delivered an effect and don't wan't to know if you are that melancholy in real life. It might of been a bit over descriptive, i'll admit that, but otherwise i think it was great.

Fang
To fly or not to fly, that is the question.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 60
The next morning, my emotion-liquor hangover allowed me to get out of bed and dressed without feeling my newly-realized heartache.

I love the idea of an "emotion-liquor hangover."

The stress put on mi corazon had slowly started a fissure when I was in dreamland, not knowing that every second I was blissfully happy, my heart was breaking in more and more places.

What's a "corazon"?

Nothing had meaning anymore.

Cliche alarm!

Melancholy appeared like an angel in the kitchen doorway and looked at me.

This made me feel as if the MC liked the fact that Melancholy appeared, by saying angel. Maybe you could switch it up a bit to get the same meaning but different feel to the sentence.

She was freaking me out.

We already know this.

She smiled and a honey-sweet voice dripped from her lips.

This is pretty cliche too. The "honey" voice is used, though in different ways. Ex: "...he said, honey oozing from his voice." "...she said, a voice thick with honey."

I remember in science that red was the longest wavelength of visible light and violet was the shortest.

To me, this was kind of random.

Her eyes.

I think this should go before the description of Melancholy's eyes to show how different they were from the rest of her appearance.

Somehow, she took that wave of brightness and strangled it, until it became only a shadow on her palm.

I loved this.

I sucked in one last breath. I wasn’t sure if she was going to give me any more.

Wonderful description in the last paragraph, and this last line was brilliant.

I really liked this story, but for some reason the name Melancholy bothered me. It sounds good as a name but somehow not right for this "angel." I know the name is supposed to be more connected to the MC, but I think it should have to do more with the actual character of Melancholy. From your description, her name should be like...oh, I don't know--Creepy? Haha, just kidding--that's an awful name.

By weirder, do you mean creepier and more threatening? Because I think it would be kind of interesting if during the last paragraph she changes completely in physical form. Like before she looks nice except for her eyes, but as she's killing Sarah she could "monsterize" further.

I personally really liked this. You do have a few instances of telling without showing, but I think if you use a fine-toothed comb and run it through this piece you can catch some of that.

You still get a gold star from me!
"Jump off cliffs and build your wings on the way down." --Ray Bradbury




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1072
Reviews 40
The next morning, my emotion-liquor hangover allowed me to get out of bed and dressed without feeling my newly-realized heartache. I didn’t feel my heart tear as I started to wake up and use it again.

I was confused on this part, with the word "it". What is the MC going to use again?

The stress put on mi corazon had slowly started a fissure when I was in dreamland, not knowing that every second I was blissfully happy, my heart was breaking in more and more places.

Just like what the others said, what's corazon? I'm having a feeling it's another language... *thinks Spanish* does it, by any chance, mean "heart"? By reading this sentence, I can deduce that.

[quote] My head fell into my hands and the sweat mixed with the blood of my heart to create an acid so potent it burned my lungs like bleach.[quote] Okay... I think you should rewrite this. Somehow, it seems to me that sweat is inside his lungs. Or, that he's having some sort of nosebleed. (yeah, that comment was random)

Other than those, what I want to point out have been pointed out.

Overall, I loved this piece. Exquisite would be the word to put in nicely. I like Melancholy. From what I've read, I think her name is perfect for her. However, I didn't like the part wherein she started to have her little speech (the one wherein she claimed she was all these gods and the sort). In that part, she felt boring. She is weird, right? Perhaps more dramatics as she spoke would amplify her "other-worldliness".

Keep on writing. I hope to see more of Melancholy. :wink:
Always act like a duck on water; appear calm and unruffled, but paddle like the devil underneath.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 2
Hi Squishy. I'm Senri, and I'm pretty new. I decided that your story will be the first on crit. You should most definitly follow Saint RazorBlades Critique, it will be most helpful in improving your story.
________________________________________________________________________


Quote:
The next morning, my emotion-liquor hangover allowed me to get out of bed and dressed without feeling my newly-realized heartache. I didn’t feel my heart tear as I started to wake up and use it again.


I don't understand what you mean when you say she didn't feel her heart tear. How does your heart tear? Isn't the heart always in use, or did you mean that figurtively?

The stress put on mi corazon had slowly started a fissure when I was in dreamland, not knowing that every second I was blissfully happy, my heart was breaking in more and more places.

I know "mi corazon" means my heart, but not all readers will know that, and it might confuse them.
________________________________________________________________________

Now, I understood the story, yet at the same time I was lost. First of all, what is the main character's problem, and why did she drink herself into a stupor? Unless you reveal this in the next chapter, I think you should tell the reader by the end of this chapter.

Also, you should make her reaction to Melancholy more realistic. If a person popped up in front of me like that, I would say more than just, "Get away from me."

I liked how you made it seem that the alchohol was taking over her life, and how meloncholy was trying to sway her. This gave your story some bonus point in my opinion. The main character gives the impression of being someone who solves her problems with liquor constantly; it's good that the reader sees that. :D

I like how you used your similies and metaphors, even though some of them got a little ridiculous(Saint Razorblade shows them to you).

The story gives off a sort of mystifying kind of aura, a feeling that I like. The way you described Melancholy was very good.

Rating on plot: 7/10
Rating on character analysis: 8/10
Rating on other Literary skills: 8/10
Que Sera Sere- "Whatever will be, will be. What won't happen, won't."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 9
This was really interesting. Melancholy is definitely an unusual character. I have to admit though, that I was slightly confused through the whole thing. I also got lost, and had to reread. In the beginning the first two paragraphs were very confusing. I couldn't tell the difference between Sarah and Melancholy. Also, I think you need more of Sarah's thoughts because it seemed to happen too quickly. And that all Sarah thought about this was , "This is really scary" Really good, but work needed. =]
"Writers make dismal lunch partners, we're always staring into space, listening to that other story..."

<b>GOT YWS??</B>



No person can be a great leader unless he takes genuine joy in the successes of those under him.
— W. A. Nance