[Removed]

14 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3263
Reviews 158
[Removed]
Last edited by thewritingdoc on Wed Dec 31, 2008 1:26 am, edited 6 times in total.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 20
This was AMAZING!

True, there are some spelling and grammatical errors, but I got into this so much I forgot about them!

Some things could be a little more clear, but other than that, amazing,
especially the end.
"although you were biased I love your advice; your comebacks they’re quick and probably have to do with your insecurities; there’s no shame in being crazy, depending on how you take these words that paraphrasing this relationship we’re staging"




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 6




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 45
Verrrry nice. I love the imagery and everything. There was only one thing I didn't like.
maliciousness in his voice and a devilish sense

Maybe you could change this to "malicious tone in his voice, and a devilish gleam" or something like that. It seems stilted and breaks the rhythm where everything else flows smoothly.
Hope I helped!
Keep up the awesome work.
:D RG




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3263
Reviews 158
Thanks guys. Honestly, I feel like I need to be TONS more clearer when I'm writing.
I'm working on the issue.
I'd like more critisim because I sent this in to a friend of mine whose an author so that he could discuss it seriously with me, (I mentioned to him I haven't touched it editing wise as you can see).
I'll do some now, maybe more later.
    I'd rather write about this world than live in it
    and I'd rather play music all day
    and read and wander around bookstores
    and watch humans
    but not be one of them.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 24
Overall, I like it. But I can't help feeling there's something not quite right. I'm not entirely sure what it is, but I think it felt a bit crowded while I was reading it. You're dealing with some pretty intense stuff with your choice of subject matter, and it took me a while to get my head round some of the complicated stuff. Then, as soon as I did, it moved on a bit too quickly for my liking. My advice would be to slow it down a bit.

tennisprincess wrote:The decision is yours to make, but I am your spiritual guide, Mikal, and that is my advice.


This for example, I thought was a bit unnecessary. You menation and name this guide, which then proceeds to play a small role. The name is never used again. It's things like this that cluttered the piece for me, and made it feel a bit rushed.

On the other hand, there were a couple of lines that I thought were pretty much perfect. The first line started it off really well, and I loved some of the imagery you used, like the reference to the "sea green serenity". And I loved this line :

tennisprincess wrote:The image of her in her mind proved that love did exist in this loner’s heart


Good luck with it :D It's definitely full of potential.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1075
Reviews 842
First, I must say that you need to space out your paragraphs more then they are now. I caught myself reading the same sentence over and over again because they were so closely spaced.

Other then that, I thought this was good. Different from all the other things I've read but I agree with Sugarbowl that this was WAY too casual for such complicated stuff. And I think you move WAY too fast. This needs to be stretched out to make it easier on the reader. You throw so much stuff at us that it's hard to "wrap your head around it", as Sugarbowl said above ^^^.

Now, I only noticed a few things:

Rosie’s head automatically replied, “Listen to me, and he will not harm you. Just do ask he asks.”


Umm, the last part of this sentence confused me. Just do ask he asks?? I think you meant, Just do what he asks.

The normal sea green serenity was restored.


Okay, I put this in here only for the fact that I loved this sentence. This was beautifully written! :D

Suddenly she wanted to embrace him and say how she missed him, but she did not want to touch the figure and words felt unworthy.


There should be a comma after Suddenly.

All her confusion built up into one, perhaps she would collapse like she often did when she was overwhelmed and would be dragged into an option she did not choose herself.


I think this needs to be two sentences. Like: All her confusion built up into one. Prehaps she would collapse like she often did when she was overwhelmed and would be dragged into an option she did not choose herself.

Overall, this was a decent piece. But, I do advise again that you need to go more in-depth with some of the stuff you talk about. It was some pretty deep stuff you talked about but you threw the information at us instead of showing us.
"Woe to the man whose heart has not learned while young to hope, to love—and to put his trust in life."
~ Joseph Conrad


"Music washes away from the soul the dust of everyday life."
~ Red Auerbach




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 83957
Reviews 1464
Hello! :)

Grammar and First Impressions

Rosie always heard and saw things.
We all know that healthy, normal children see and hear things everyday, but Rosie was never any of those things to the people around her. To them; [comma instead] she was delusional and mental.


First, I think the first sentence can be reworded for more of a grab. Second, I don't like the we used here. Third...well, let's just reword the entire thing. It's rather clunky, ignoring the punctuation faults. In the second sentence of the second paragraph, it sounds like you're saying she's never see and hear things when you mean healthy and normal.

Well...I'll just talk about the intro at the bottom. ^^

Since age 2, she had claimed to hear voices. Voices that told her dark from light, right from left, the future from the past, good from evil. [s]It[/s] They guided her everywhere she needed to go.


You had voices as a plural, so let's keep it plural, shall we? ^^

It was when she was 5 and she told her mother, “Uncle Danny says not to hide when you see him at night. He’s only saying hi,” that her mother decided to put her into therapy. She insisted that she had never spoken a work of these late night visits from her deceased brother to her young child and in fact, it was completely unexplainable because Rosie had been born after the death and mourning were long gone. Since then, the therapist has been sprouting shit saying that these ‘hallucinations’ stemmed from an unsolved emotion lying in the young girl’s conscience. Of course, this made no sense. What on earth could a five-year-old possibly have to feel guilty [s]of[/s] for?


Underlined: This is a run-on that can be broken down into smoother sentences. She was five years old when her mother decided to put the girl into therapy. I couldn't figure out how the quote relates to the sentence at all, by the way. It seems so random and unnecessary.

Italics: Another run-on, worse than the one before it. Haha. Plus, it doesn't make sense. I can't even rewrite a suggestion for you because I don't understand where you're getting at. *feels bad* :?

Rosie grew up alone with her mother. She had never known her father -- and that was a nerve the therapist liked to hit at. [dash instead] [s]But[/s] but over the years, Rosie’s short, [no comma] and choppy answers to those questions [s]still revealed[/s] continued to reveal [or “constantly revealed”] nothing. She knew nothing of him, [no comma] nor cared. This became apparent as she grew older into her troubled teen years, [no comma] as did her hate for her mother. You see, even though she gave her life and kept her through the years, Rosie knew it was out of solitary obligation. In turn, because her mother felt nothing for her, she felt nothing towards her mother. That fact would never change. And so, Rosie grew up a loner, [no comma] with not a single friend in the world. Except the voice that was always with her.


Underlined: :lol: I liked this.

Italicized: Notice the repetition of as. We shall rid ourselves of such repetition and rewrite the sentence completely! *pause* You do it. :P

One day as 13-year-old Rosie’s hormones got a hold of her, she yelled at her mother after a discussion about how she was coping in therapy. “Well, it’s been 8 years, and he still hasn’t found the so called “unsolved emotion” that causes all this! Mom, don’t you think it’s time to give this up? I’m 13, and I have a social life. And you’re ruining it by calling me crazy!”

“Young lady, I think I know what is right for you, and I will make the decisions around here. I am the adult! And don’t speak to me in that tone.”


I don’t think this conversation between mother and daughter is very realistic at all. The teen would yell something like, “He’s not making anything better!” and the mom would say something like, “Don’t talk like that!” or “Don’t use that tone with me!” The dialogue’s not very realistic.

Underlined: Um.. single quotes instead. ‘single quotes,’ not “quotation marks.” ^^

Rosie knew things had gotten serious now. All her anger locked up over the years [s]never released[/s] finally boiled up to this. Her eyes grew a deep, [no comma] dark red that was [u]as thick as the blood running through the veins of a stroke victim as she stared at her mother like she was a building marked for demolition. [/u]Suddenly a scream erupted from Rosie’s lips at the top of her breath, and [s]then,[/s] she collapsed. Just like that. All the emotions she had never set free before overwhelmed her.


Underlined: Repetition of as again. With those sentences like this one, try to split it up into two sentences or shorten it up. Sometimes you have a lot of useless information in it that drags it down, or it’s too short and can be spiced up a bit more.

Rosie awoke [s]on a hard bed and[/s] to a fake smile and show put on by her mother.
“Oh, thank goodness you’re alright, sweetheart, [period instead]” [s]her[/s] Her mother grabbed Rosie and pulled her towards her bosom. Quickly, Rosie pulled away remembering the incident before the blackness arrived.
“Who is he?” She pointed, referring to the man dressed in a type of apparel she associated with religion. Her mother had never taken her to church, although she had known she was a Catholic. In fact, there had never been a referral to God in their household.


Talk about the bed later than that point if it’s important.

Underlined: Who? Using way too many pronouns, and the fact that they’re both female doesn’t help the reader any. :lol:

“This is Father Markus, and he is here to help us with your gift,” she replied, smiling that drawn on lipstick smile. She showed it only when she wanted to appear normal, calm and collected. In reality, it was impossible for her to be any of those things.
Rosie got up and sized the man up. He looked tense, although there was a smile on his face. There was a book in his hand. He held on to it so tightly that his knuckles appeared white [s]like[/s] as if no blood ever flowed there. It was a bible. That was clear. The voice in Rosie’s head automatically replied, “Listen to me, and he will not harm you. Just do ask he asks of you.”
The things that Father Markus asked her to do were actually comical to her and they wouldn't really help the situation. A smile spread across Rosie’s face. All the anger that she had previously known was gone and certainly any similarity between the color of her eyes and the blood of a dead corpse had completely dissipated. The normal sea green serenity was restored.


Maybe some contractions would be handy and help the dialogue out.

Underlined: By it, it sounds like you refer to the knuckles, but then it should be plural. Don’t get carried away with pronouns.

It appears to be working, [semi instead] the demon is leaving the child’s body,” Father Markus said, [s]and[/s] a flicker of hope and pride [s]sheered in his heart[/s] [some other visible description].
After the long process was over, Rosie pretended that the voices had stopped in order to avoid the constant annoyance of her mother and other raving lunatics like her who saw Rosie as the odd one out. The frequent therapist visits halted, and a priest never entered Rosie’s home again. All in all, her life appeared normal. In truth, [s]though[/s],the voices continued, now even stronger than ever.


Underlined: I assume you’re referring to exorcism practiced by Catholics, but.. this seems a bit superstitious to me, at least for the time period you assumed. The story’s more modern, so I don’t know how it affects the Catholic church in regards to exorcism. Play around with the dialogue, I guess.

Her premonition was confirmed by the high-pitched squealing only she could hear in her ears that announced that a spirit was about to speak.


Underlined: Repetition – so close together too. Rephrase the sentence a bit so we can ignore that. ^^

She always sensed them and was aware of their presence and could speak to them and hear them but now, speaking to this spirit she could see his outline in a pale blue-white light.


Run-on! And must be completely rewritten. Maybe split it up or shorten it – I dunno, but it’s long. Probably all those and’s in there. :P

It was as if a sudden realization had hit Rosie Bauer. The figure came into full contrast, and she was not afraid. Memories came pouring back, and now, [no comma] it was as if every moment of her life she had known her father. Visions of his figure standing over her crib and loving every inch of her that her mother did not. Suddenly she wanted to embrace him and say how she missed him, but she did not want to touch the figure, and words felt unworthy.


Underlined: This is a fragment of a sentence. I let you get away of other shorter fragments, assuming that as your style and trusting you know the proper grammar to write in, but this is a longer and more awkward fragment. I’d suggest making it a complete sentence or combining with another.

Italicized: This is a run-on. Having two max of the underlined words is a good guideline to follow until you get even more advanced and amazing. Trust me: I’m not there yet. :lol:

“You don’t need to say anything. Your aura tells me all that you’re feeling,” the familiar and comforting voice said. “You could come away with me, you know. Leave this cruel place where you do not belong. You heard my voice all your life because you missed me, you longed for me, and there was unfinished business between you and I. You have learned enough in this life and now you need to relax. [no period] [s]With[/s] with me, [no comma] in heaven, [dash instead] wouldn’t you like that?”


Underlined: This sounds awkward. Leave this cruel place. Okay. The rest, though.. it’s like you put it there to confuse me. I think it sounds like extra information being glued into the sentence. Try to smooth it in better or just get rid of it.

Italicized: Here, you’re listing all these fragments – which is fine! – but you’re inconsistent with your commas. Example first:

I have red, blue, and purple socks.

I have red, blue and purple socks.

Check out the difference in my examples – the comma. Choose one or the other, but don’t switch around. Jabber likes consistency and suggests you keep it consistent. ^_^

Rosie remained [s]quite[/s] quiet as her thoughts of pleasure and logic dueled with one another.


The figure that had called [s]itself[/s] himself Rosie’s father grabbed her hand.


Keep the gender consistent. I don’t think it’s possible even for spirits to switch genders like that. :lol:

She liked what she saw at the end, [no comma] and wanted it.


There must be a subject and a verb on both sides of and to have a comma there. ^^

[s]It said, [/s]“Do not follow him. He is trying to maim and bribe you into a world of treachery and dishonor. The decision is yours to make, but I am your spiritual guide, Mikal, and that is my advice.”


That tag seems useless.

All her confusion built up into one, [semi instead] perhaps she would collapse like she often did when she was overwhelmed and would be dragged into an option she did not choose herself.


I was debating what to do with this: to rewrite or to insert punctuation there. I guess a semi could work, but if you can reword this entire thing, that would be amazing. ^^

Underlined: Built up into one…what? Kinda left us hanging there. :P

“No,” this new, [no comma] braver Rosie said.


Commas between adjectives really aren’t necessary. :)

By now it had transformed into its true, [no comma] ugly form.


It lunged at Rosie but missed because apparently, [no comma] Rosie had the ability to fly here in this place between worlds.


Apparently had the ability to fly? Really. That’s honestly worded poorly. The reader can’t trust you as the author if you make it sound so obvious like that as well as “duh” statements. It’s not “duh” to the reader and should be smoother transition. Plus it’s cliché. :P

As she rose in the air, [s]involuntarily[/s] a ball of light involuntarily arrived in her hands.


The reader’s thinking, “This is getting ridiculous.” It rings cliché.

Her advisor proved worthy again, [period instead] “Throw it and aim for his face.”


She wasn’t surprised, [no comma] after all the amazing events she had witnessed today.


Underlined: Surprised of what? Floating? >.<

She arrived at the doorstep; everything [s]at[/s] in/about/something else her home seemed fine.


“Oh, you know, [ellipses or dash instead] out and around,” Rosie replied with a knowing smile.


Rosie didn’t know what changed her that day but it felt like her mother had given her strength. The image of her in her mind proved that love did exist in this loner’s heart. She was capable of emotions, [no comma] just like everyone else. And from that moment on, she knew her mother loved her, and she returned the feeling.
Rosie never again heard her advisor from heaven. Her belief in a higher power never wavered. After all, there was no need for him to acknowledge his presence, [no comma] because Rosie knew that he would always be there. No matter what. Now though, there was just no need for him to stay around all the time. [no period] Because her unfinished business with demons of her past were now history.


Because is so special that it doesn’t need punctuation before it. :D

Contractions

They’re there, so you should use them, especially in dialogue. It’ll make it sound more realistic especially in modern settings. Shall I use especially again? Nah.. :wink: But do consider using them. It’ll make the dialogue flow more easily too.

Realism

This started off alright – didn’t completely ring cliché yet. Then I hit the ending with the magic and the flying and the whole deal – *sings* cliché! And how it’s worded is cliché. Short stories are difficult to write in that the write must work to make the cliché sound not so cliché and write everything in a more unique way. The reader won’t notice it then.

Speed

It was…rushed, I guess. Rushed terribly in the end, but the timeline thing was…weird. Boring almost. Why do I care for Rosie? Why should I care for her? I didn’t attach to her very well, which leads to…

Characterization

They weren’t introduced very well. I didn’t attach to Rosie; I didn’t feel sorry for her during those childhood memory things in the beginning. Her mom also was unrealistic…kind of a mess-ish. Organize your thoughts a bit and think how you can introduce the characters to the reader so we can imagine the story as well as you are.

Plot

Wasn’t much of a plot. So a girl’s hearing voices…and she suddenly gets super powers! :shock: I’m not seeing much there, and what you have is, again, cliché.

Format

Space out the paragraphs. Every single paragraph gets its own bubble. That way you gain more readers/reviewers. Crammed words like here hurts people's eyes when they read.

And the numbers. 1-20 at least can be written out in words. Using the actual numbers makes the author look lazy in my opinion.

Intro

A hook. You gotta grab the reader. What will grab the reader. Your first sentence was bland. She always heard and saw things. If it was worded differently, then it might work; however, it can be improved as well as the following paragraph. And I also dislike the singling out the reader with we and you. It's a pet peeve of mine probably, but I don't like it much. It's not quite narration. If it was consistent throughout the entire piece, it would probably pass depending how it's used. However, using this PoV to only grab the readers isn't doing a good job of it. ^^

Overall

This can probably use some cleaning-up/fixing-up before you have a nice shiny gem in your hands. There were some good stuff in here, but it can be improved. :)

Keep writing!

Jabber, the One and Only!
I make my own policies.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 273
How my reviews word - I copy and paste the whole thing then I'll sum it all up at the end :D

Rosie always heard and saw things.

We all know that healthy, normal children see and hear things everyday but Rosie was never any of those things to the people around her. To them; she was delusional and mental.

Since age 2 I don't like this bit, it's a tad awkward, maybe have Since the age of two or since aged two, don't use numbers in a piece of writing unless you are saying a year or it's in diary form , she had claimed to hear voices. Voices that told her dark from light, right from left, the future from the past, good from evil. It guided her everywhere she needed to go.I like that bit :D

It was when she was 5 and she told her mother, “Uncle Danny says not to hide when you see him at night. He’s only saying hi,” that her mother decided to put her into therapy. She insisted that she had never spoken a work of these late night visits from her deceased brother to her young child and in fact, it was completely unexplainable because Rosie had been born after the death and mourning were Was not were long gone. Since then the therapist has been sprouting shit saying that these ‘hallucinations’ stemmed from an unsolved emotion lying in the young girl’s conscience. Great description Of course, this made no sense. What on earth could a five year old possibly have to feel guilty of? Very intriguing :D

Rosie grew up alone with her mother. She had never known her father and that was a nerve the therapist liked to hit at. But over the years, Rosie’s short, choppy answers to those questions still revealed nothing. She knew nothing of him, nor cared. This became apparent as she grew older into her troubled teen years, as did her hate for her mother. You see, even though she gave her life and kept her through the years, Rosie knew it was out of solitary obligation. In turn, because her mother felt nothing for her, she felt nothing towards her mother. That fact would never change. And so, Rosie grew up a loner, with not a single friend in the world. Except the voice that was always with her. Aw, I feel so sorry for her :'(


One day as 13 year old Rosie’s hormones got hold of her she yelled at her mother after a discussion about how she was coping in therapy. “Well, it’s been 8 years and he still hasn’t found the so called “unsolved emotion” that causes all this! Mom, don’t you think it’s time to give this up? I’m 13 and I have a social life. And you’re ruining it by calling me crazy!”


“Young lady, I think I know what is right for you and I will make the decisions around here. I am the adult! And don’t speak to me in that tone.”


Rosie knew things had gotten serious now. All her anger locked up over the years never released finally boiled up to this. Her eyes grew a deep, dark red that was as thick as the blood running through the veins of a stroke victim as she stared at her mother like she was a building marked for demolition. Suddenly a scream erupted from Rosie’s lips at the top of her breath and then, she collapsed. Just like that. All the emotions she had never set free before overwhelmed her. Great imagery ;)


Rosie awoke on a hard bed and to a fake smile and show put on by her mother.

“Oh, thank goodness you’re alright sweetheart,” her mother grabbed RosieIt should be her mother grabbed her here, not her mother grabbed Rosie. and pulled her towards her bosom. Quickly, Rosie pulled away remembering the incident before the blackness arrived.

“Who is he?” She pointed, referring to the man dressed in a type of apparel she associated with religion. Her mother had never taken her to church, although she had known she was a Catholic. In fact, there had never been a referral to God in their household.


“This is Father Markus, and he is here to help us with your gift,” she replied, smiling that drawn on lipstick smile. She showed it only when she wanted to appear normal, calm and collected. In reality, it was impossible for her to be any of those things.

Rosie got up and sized the man up. He looked tense, although there was a smile on his face. There was a book in his hand. He held on to it so tightly that his knuckles appeared white like no blood ever flowed there. It was a bible. That was clear. The voice in Rosie’s head automatically replied, “Listen to me, and he will not harm you. Just do ask he asks of you.”

The things that Father Markus asked her to do were actually comical to her and they wouldn't really help the situation. A smile spread across Rosie’s face. All the anger that she had previously known was gone and certainly any similarity between the color of her eyes and the blood of a dead corpse had completely dissipated. The normal sea green serenity was restored.


“It appears to be working, the demon is leaving the child’s body,” Father Markus said and a flicker of hope and pride sheered in his heart.

After the long process was over, Rosie pretended that the voices had stopped in order to avoid the constant annoyance of her mother and other raving lunatics like her who saw Rosie as the odd one out. The frequent therapist visits halted and a priest never entered Rosie’s home again. All in all, her life appeared normal. In truth though, the voices continued, now even stronger than ever.



One night in her sixteenth year, as Rosie returned from a late party, she felt the presence of what she had come to recognize as a spirit in her room. Her premonition was confirmed by the high pitched squealing only she could hear in her ears that announced that a spirit was about to speak.

“Rosie, it’s been far too long.”

Rosie sensed that this was a male spirit. Not many males had influenced her life, so it was blind guessing at who this was. Rosie decided to ask.

“Who are you?”

The spirit seemed to sigh. Rosie never could actually see the spirits she had spoken to in the past. She always sensed them and was aware of their presence and could speak to them and hear them but now, speaking to this spirit she could see his outline in a pale blue white light. Something about him seemed comforting, but she was still afraid to get too close.

“I suppose you were too young to remember my presence. And I know for a fact that Cecilia has not mentioned me.” This expression seemed to strike melancholy in the spirit. And Rosie began to feel it too.

“How do you know my mother?” Rosie asked uncertainly. Now the figure’s features were coming into shape. It was as if his name was on the tip of her tongue, but she still could not grasp it.

“It’s me, Rosie. It’s Arnold, your father.”

It was if a sudden realization had hit Rosie Bauer. The figure came into full contrast and she was not afraid. Memories came pouring back and now, it was as if every moment of her life she had known her father. Visions of his figure standing over her crib and loving every inch of her that her mother did not. Suddenly she wanted to embrace him and say how she missed him, but she did not want to touch the figure and words felt unworthy.

“You don’t need to say anything. Your aura tells me all that you’re feeling,” the familiar and comforting voice said. “You could come away with me you know. Leave this cruel place where you do not belong. You heard my voice all your life because you missed me, you longed for me, and there was unfinished business between you and I. You have learned enough in this life and now you need to relax. With me, in heaven, wouldn’t you like that?”

Now the voice did not appear loving. Rosie sensed this. He sounded suddenly like a bad car salesman. There was maliciousness in his voice and a devilish sense in his eyes. Rosie remained quiteQuiet not quite as her thoughts of pleasure and logic dueled with one another. I love that idea of pleasure and logic duelling

The figure that had called itself Rosie’s father grabbed her hand. He began leading her down a long tunnel of white light. She liked what she saw at the end, and wanted it. Then she was jerked in a different direction. A face appeared in her mind. It was her mother’s. She heard the voice that had been with her all her life, the one that aided her in everything. It said, “Do not follow him. He is trying to maim and bribe you into a world of treachery and dishonor. The decision is yours to make, but I am your spiritual guide, Mikal, and that is my advice.”

All her confusion built up into one, perhaps she would collapse like she often did when she was overwhelmed and would be dragged into an option she did not choose herself. Instead, she stood her ground. She pulled away from the demon. “No,” this new, braver Rosie said. “I am brave. A brave person cannot live in a land of cowardice where you are trying to lead me. I know your true identity. You can’t fool me.”

A grin, spread across the face of the scorpion. By now it had transformed into its true, ugly form. “Very well, I shall have to use force then. We need more feisty ladies like you around the underworld. You’ll make good company,” the serpent hissed. It lunged at Rosie but missed because apparently, Rosie had the ability to fly here in this place between worlds.

As she rose in the air, involuntarily a ball of light arrived in her hands. She felt the power of it in her heart. Her advisor proved worthy again, “Throw it and aim for his face.”

It seemed like the light blinded the demon. In any case, he slipped back to his world and the portal closed. Rosie seemed to almost float down to the ground. She wasn’t surprised, after all the amazing events she had witnessed today.

She arrived at the doorstep; everything at her home seemed fine. She entered to find her mother sitting in the family room.

“Hey, sweetheart, where have you been?”

“Oh you know, out and around,” Rosie replied with a knowing smile. Her mother would be the one person that would never believe her. “What’s on TV?”


Rosie didn’t know what changed her that day but it felt like her mother had given her strength. The image of her in her mind proved that love did exist in this loner’s heart. She was capable of emotions, just like everyone else. And from that moment on, she knew her mother loved her, and she returned the feeling.

Rosie never again heard her advisor from heaven. Her belief in a higher power never wavered. After all, there was no need for him to acknowledge his presence, because Rosie knew that he would always be there. No matter what. Now though, there was just no need for him to stay around all the time. Because her unfinished business with demons of her past were now history.



I really love some of your description, but I feel that as a story this was a bit rushed. It got into the action but was done within the next two minutes. You should add to it. On the other hand the description was good and some of your thoughts are clearly interesting. Keep at it, edit a little more and it'll be great. Well done :D
Kirsten x
for what are we without words and stories?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1090
Reviews 241
You are a very imaginative storyteller. This was pretty good. You need to watch your tenses though - you switched from past to present a few times. Also, I feel like this would be even better if you added a little more characterization and dialogue instead of using the constant narration. The storyline is too good for you to just rely on narration. :)
“We’re still here,” he says, his voice cold, his hands shaking. “We know how to be invisible, how to play dead. But at the end of the day, we are still here.” ~Dax

Teacher: "What do we do with adjectives in Spanish?"
S: "We eat them!"




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3263
Reviews 158
Well, I kind of abandoned this piece but here I am, editing it again.
I just posted a reviewed version and I'm not quite sure if I got all the tense changes.
I would really like some help with that.
I also tried to add more dialogue to the piece so that it's more interesting for the reader and tried to make it make more sense.

Please, any reviews would help. :)
Thanks.
    I'd rather write about this world than live in it
    and I'd rather play music all day
    and read and wander around bookstores
    and watch humans
    but not be one of them.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 7
i really enjoed this work, i found it to be very clear and simple. I got what you were trying to portray.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 7
I found this piece to be very simple and clear. I had no trouble trying to figure out what you were trying to portray. It runs on sometimes, but then again so does life, your really cuting and pasteing there. True art in its raw form, nothing can be more truthfull then that.

Your first draft will always be your best because thats the piece when it is first born, still covered in gel and attached by the cord. Its beautiful.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1574
Reviews 3
Oh wow! That's an awsome story!
I couldn't stop reading to turn on the light so now my eyes kinda hurt.
But it was totally worth it.
I loved your characters and you have a great imagination to make that up.
You did switch between past and present tense but it made me pay close attention to the whole thing and stuff... :D
"School is practice for the future, and practice makes perfect and nobody's perfect so why bother?" - Tre Cool

“Now are any of these vegetables magic? I mean if I rub that bean on my foot will I run faster?” - Mike Dirnt

I would act my age if it was a more reasonable number... - Me



i am neither a loose leaf nor do i like loose leafs. really, i am a piece of wide-ruled looseleaf paper.
— looseleaf