NN -- Prologue: Dark Water, Pale flame

17 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7715
Reviews 522
I don't have any nitpicks, (other than ones already pointed out) either. ;)

Overall, this was much much better, although very different from the first one.

In answer to your questions:


1: Did you get a basic feel for Isaria's and Guinevere's personalities? If so, what were the indicators? If not, how could I improve?

Um.... Yes I suppose I did. I was a little confused by Guin's change though... It seemed as though one second she was compltely terrified, and the next thinking about what 'bastards' the Cørra were. ;)

Isaria was kinda more of a mystery, but I don't object to that, especially as this is only the prologue.

2: Did you notice any clichés? If so, what were they?

Hmm, I really like your idea about the 'second natures' of Ayra and Isaria, but the whole thing with the Cørra is a bit cliche. :) (You know, there is always one 'evil' race in a story.)


3: Did you find it interesting, as a prologue? If so, what caught your attention? If not, why?

Yes, I did. The beggining moved a little fast for me, and was a bit confusing, but in the end I was hooked! Very nice.


Put me on the list please. :)


See ya~

~Lupis




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7241
Reviews 721
Ooh! I was randomly shuffling through your portfolio and saw this -- and decided to revisit it. :D

Random note: I just remembered why the name Isaria sounded so familiar to me! I had a character in a story I wrote a while ago (never to be posted on YWS) named Saria... weird, huh?

Also, I think it would be really awesome if you showed more of a difference in the way she thinks when she's in wolf form from when she's in normal form. You do that a little bit (with thoughts of blood, and such) but if you made the transition much more noticeable, that would be lovely. Maybe rather than having narrative (such as "Isaria growled from low in her chest, lifting her lips to reveal teeth like ivory thorns. She swung a broad, powerful black head and forth, her steel-grey eyes fixed on the other side of the river.") ONLY have her thoughts -- which you do quite nicely. So in other words, while she's in second nature the narrative will all be her thoughts (such as "Cørra on the riverbank. Dark water lapping at the shore. Do not swim in it -- the night of StarFell, it is unsafe to venture into water. Get the girl."). I just think that would be really neat if you did that. Because you tell us that her thoughts become more feline, but this would be a way of showing it as well. :D

You haven't abandoned this, have you? I really wanna read more of it. ^_^

~Azila~



cron
i don't need to search the stars to know myself
— soundofmind