Chapter 1 of (Untitled)

14 posts
User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 23
Hi,
This is a very rough draft of chapter 1 of my first story. Any critiques would be more than welcome :D ! Don't be afraid to go tough :wink:. I am working on the prelude and chapter 2 right now. Thanks.

Chapter One

A dark, sullen being with seal brown hair and piercingly clear blue eyes was just barely distinguishable sitting on a mahogany platform bed. Piles of dirty laundry, CD cases, magazines, and books were strewn about on the grey, carpeted floor. Pictures of various rock bands were plastered askew on the walls and door. Why me? thought the indistinct 15 year old to himself. Every day they pick on me about my name, appearance, heritage, everything! A burst of light shattered the darkness as the door flew open.
“Cuileìn, Cuilén” yelled his eight year old sister, Elizabeth, as she bounded into the room. “Guess what I did today!”
“I don’t care” he yelled back as he shoved her to the floor. As she plummeted to the ground she struck the corner of his dresser and released a yelp of pain. Their mother, Annaìbla, rushed to the source of the screams. “What is the meaning of this?” she demanded as she cradled Elizabeth in her arms.
“I dunno” he shrugged, “She must have slid while she was running”.
His mother eyed him sharply. “How was school?” she asked gently.
“It was fine” he snapped back.
“Have you finished your homework? If so could you please bring Grandpa back the book he lent to Elizabeth?” Annaìbla inquired.
“Aw, Mom! Not Grandpa John! He’s crazy! He always is trying to sick on me some dumb story or get me to recite a knight’s code.” Cuileìn said with an exasperated toss of his arms.
Annaìbla sighed, “Please just do this for me and mind your Grandpa. You may not appreciate it now but it might come in handy someday”.
“Fine!” he growled, “I’ll go”.
As Cuileìn left the house, Elizabeth, who had been stifling a sob, crumbled into her mother’s arms and began weeping.
“Oh Mom!” she sobbed, “Why does he keep acting that way? We used to laugh and have fun together, now whenever I come near he acts as if he can't stand me!”
“I don’t know” Annábla sighed, “I just don’t know.”

As he trudged along the snow covered streets of Chicago to his grandfather’s city slum apartment Cuileìn defiantly huffed. Who cares about some stupid fight that happened centuries ago and people that are dead. Not like it has anything to do with me.
Grandpa John was thought to be some sort of mastermind historian. If he wasn’t inventing some sort of contraption he was working on research of the middle ages. When you walked into Grandpa John’s apartment you could find pretty much anything but the floor. The shelves were crammed with all sorts of inventions and Celtic medieval artifacts. His roll top desk was covered with all sorts of calculations and thesis’. Grandpa John’s apartment always smelled of musty books and sometimes of experiments that went less than perfect. As Cuileìn entered the apartment his Grandpa’s Labrador Retriever cross, Tothel, jumped up on him barking joyously and wagging his tail. “Get down, you crazy dog” he muttered, trying to shove the dog down. After removing Tothel from his chest Cuileìn shouted “Grandpa, I brought back the book Elizabeth borrowed”.
“Who’s there?” asked his Grandpa.
“It’s me, Cuileìn, your grandson” he sighed.
“Dag nabbit! Where are my glasses?” asked his Grandpa as he started searching through a precarious stack of papers. Once found, Grandpa John delicately wiped the lenses on his shirttail and placed them on his face. “Oh” he beamed, “It’s you Cuileìn. Why didn’t you say so? You’re just the one I wanted to talk to”.
“Why? What?” Cuileìn questioned.
“I have some books and articles for you about Celtic culture and the Vikings” Grandpa John replied.
“I don’t want your stupid books Grandpa!” said Cuileìn.
Grandpa John sighed, “When you Elizabeth’s age you loved to come here and read my books. Laughing, Grandpa John said, “I used to have to force you to go home. What happened”?
“I guess I grew out of pretending in fairytales unlike some people” said Cuileìn with a look of icy disdain.
Grandpa John frowned deeply as he turned around and walked to his desk. After being attacked by various falling items and muttering a few indistinguishable words, Grandpa John extracted a CD and handed it to Cuileìn. “Here, take this. I made it for your 18th birthday but I believe you should have it now” he said. Cuileìn sighed, took the disk and shoved it deep in the pocket of his down jacket. “Now, be gone with you and don’t come back here until you’ve completed that” Grandpa John said making a motion towards Cuileìn’s pocket. Being finished exchanging words, Cuileìn turned on his heels and left. “That boy doesn’t even know what he’s getting into” Grandpa John muttered to himself as he scratched Tothel behind the ear. “I pray to God that everything turns out alright”.

Along the way home, Cuileìn decided to take a shortcut through some side alleys. As he rounded a corner Cuileìn ran into J.K. and the Vultures. Now, The Vultures, as they were called, were a group of about twenty, ages ranging from 14 to around 20. They were branded with their name because of their trademark way of circling their prey, giving biting remarks that would sink through the flesh of even the toughest skinned individuals. When they felt the urge, they also lashed out with physical abuse. The gang chose weak prey and feasted, like the monstrous vultures that they were, on the collapse of their victims esteem. The Vultures leader, J.K., although already had filled out his 18 years in height and weight, was only in the 10th grade. He and Cuileìn shared Mrs. Violous’ history class. At the beginning of the year, Cuileìn was a straight A student at the head of his class. J.K., who was lucky to scrape by with a C, became infuriated with Cuileìn’s cleverness at something that he was a complete dunce at and made him the center of the Vultures’ attention.

When J.K. spotted Cuileìn, he rose up from his throne on the hood of an old Camaro.
“Cuileìn, our favorite little buddy” said J.K. with a wicked smile.
Cuileìn froze midstride in his tracks. No,No! Please not again, thought Cuileìn, his eyes darting nervously back and forth searching for a way out. Cuileìn’s appearance now was one of a trapped animal with a stiff, rigid form and dilated, fearful eyes. He spotted what appeared to be an open area to the left and made a mad dash for it. Right as he began to believe that he would was going to make it through, a giant Vulture stepped out, blocking the path.
“Guys, looks like his royal highness, Cuileìn, here thinks he’s too good for us. Why don’t we do him a favor and teach him some manners” said J.K. with a disdainful look cast in Cuileìn direction. J.K. then gave an invisible signal to two gang members, one short and stout, the other tall and thin. They stepped out towards Cuileìn, the tall one grabbing his arms while the stout fellow delivered a blow right into Cuileìn’s gut, bringing him to his knees. Once down, each Vulture took a turn beating him and yelling derogative names. At first Cuileìn released loud screams of pain but gradually they became lesser and lesser until they were just barely audible. After about 6 minutes, which seemed like an eternity to Cuileìn, J.K. lost interest and called the Vultures off. “Well now, Cuileìn” he hissed, “Hopefully you’ve learned some proper manners now.” With that being said, The Vultures vacated, leaving Cuileìn bleeding and quivering on the damp ground. Cuileìn remained curled up in a ball for a few minutes waiting for all his muscles to relax. Okay, you can do this, he thought, Pull yourself together. Forcing himself to relax, Cuilén slowly pulled himself up on the rough, craggy wall pausing when he felt nauseated. He lightly fingered a hole in the wall, cursing himself for going in an alley instead of staying on the sidewalk.

Cuilén walked slowly home waiting for the bleeding to stop and for his head to stop spinning. It was half hour after dark when he reached his small, suburb house. Cuileìn tried to sneak in the back door dismayed to find his mother sitting in a chair, waiting for him. “Where where you?” his mother demanded, leaping up, her hazel eyes sparkling with anger. “I was worried sick! I called Grandpa and he said that you left hours ago” she said.
“I was just taking a walk” he replied sheepishly.
“What happened to you? You have cuts and bruises everywhere” she asked in a concerned voice. She gently extended her hand to touch his eye. Cuilén avoided her touch and said “I’m going to my room”.
“Wait. We need to talk” his mother said, “Mrs. Violous called a couple hours ago. You’re failing history”.
“It’s not my fault Mom” Cuileìn argued.
“Don’t start with me Cuileìn, maybe if you would spend more time studying and less time playing on the computer than we wouldn’t be having this conversation” she snapped. “Now, your teacher agreed to let you pass if you get an A on this next test”.
“Whatever” he said and slammed the door of his room only to open it back up a few seconds later.
“Where is all my stuff?!”
“Until you bring your grades back up you are grounded from TV, computer games, and all your video games!”
“That’s not fair!”
“It is and there will be no argument you understand?”
“Yes Mam” he whispered hotly turning to go back to his room. Cuilén abruptly turned around and shouted “you’re the worst mom ever!” After the words escaped Cuileìn’s lips he immediately regretted them as he saw a painful look come over his mother’s face and a tear roll down her worn cheek.

Cuileìn sullenly went to his room and took out his frustration on the room as he searched for his history book, finding it in the back of his closet, under a pile of laundry. After studying for an hour, Cuileìn decided that any game would be better than studying. Grandpa must have forgot to tell Mom about the game he gave me he thought smugly as pulled the game out of his jacket pocket. When he opened the disk’s case, a list of instructions floated gently to the floor by his feet. He didn’t even bother to pick them up and read them as he inserted the disk. A few seconds later the agreement to download screen popped up. Lazily Cuileìn pushed the “I agree” button without reading the words not realizing the significance of what he had just done. To a casual observer the downloading screen looked like any other but if read closely along with the normal items it would have said:
“Who so downloads this vortex era alterer will be transported back in time and will not come back until their prophecy is fulfilled. The producer of this vortex era alterer is not responsible for any injuries or death while in use.”
The computer started humming as the disk began loading. Suddenly his room seemed to start spinning with the disk. Cuilén shook his head, thinking that it was just his head bothering him from being hit so many times. The lights then started flickering a light, hazy blue color as the humming grew louder. Terrified, Cuileìn tried to scream but to no avail. As the lights went out completely he felt the air suddenly become damp around him. He started hearing savage screams and roars, and a metallic noise that startled him even more. The noises seem to come closer and closer as he slowly began to see light appear in front of him. With a sudden gust of wind, Cuilén was suffused by light. As his eyes adjusted to the light, Cuilén was surprised to see what appeared to be a battlefield. He felt himself gently land right in the middle of it, men and horses were running in every direction. OK thought Cuileìn, There is no way this is real, I must be dreaming. When he turned around he was surprised to find a massive, menacing man clothed in furs right behind him with a club. The next thing he knew, Cuileìn felt severe pain rush up and down his body as a blunt force hit him in the head. Everything began to go dark as Cuileìn collapsed on the ground. Before his eyes closed on their own accord, he saw what appeared to be a brilliant, emerald dragon flying overhead, scorching the group of soldiers next to him with its scarlet flame. “Impossible!” he whispered.
"Life is not about how many breaths you take, but how many moments take your breath away"
-Anonymous




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 23
Oops! Sorry. I just realized that my MC's name spelled different ways. Its supposed to be spelled Cuilén.
"Life is not about how many breaths you take, but how many moments take your breath away"
-Anonymous




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1478
Reviews 220
I haven't completely read it yet (I have to go sleep =P) but the very first thing I notice is how squished together your text is. Try separating it a bit more (between the descriptive paragraphs and the dialogue would be a god spot for another return). I'll come back and read the rest tomorrow and give you a more detailed opinion.

Till then,
^_^




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 52
Every day they pick on me about my name, appearance, heritage, everything!
I would change every thing to any thing, it shows that they find any reason to pick on him and makes the readers more emotional over him

“What is the meaning of this?” she demanded as she cradled Elizabeth in her arms.
two things a quote always starts a new paragraph and it would be rather hard to hold an 8 year old in your arms

His mother eyed him sharply. “How was school?” she asked gently.
ummm this part is kind of contrasting you have her eying him sharply and meanly, but then she's calm and peacefully

As Cuileìn left the house, Elizabeth, who had been stifling a sob, crumbled into her mother’s arms and began weeping.
“Oh Mom!” she sobbed, “Why does he keep acting that way? We used to laugh and have fun together, now whenever I come near he acts as if he can't stand me!”
I especially love this sentence it shows his life and how his little sister kind of tries to get him into trouble and make him seem worse

you use a lot of good description and so far your story is excellent

As he trudged along the snow covered streets of Chicago to his grandfather’s city slum apartment Cuileìn defiantly huffed
in this part you might want to put a comma after apartment, because it kind of runs Cuilein and apartment to gether as if that was the apartment's name

Who cares about some stupid fight that happened centuries ago and people that are dead. Not like it has anything to do with me.
you just kind of threw this part in, it doesn't fit in yet, maybe there is another part you could put it in, like back when he was explaining to his mom why he didn't want to go to his grandfathers, that way you would be actually SHOWING how he feels about his grandfather's stories

The shelves were crammed with all sorts of inventions and Celtic medieval artifacts. His roll top desk was covered with all sorts of calculations and thesis’.
this part you repeat 'with all sorts of' it makes the sentence seem simple and not as good as it really is

Grandpa John’s apartment always smelled of musty books and sometimes of experiments that went less than perfect.
you are using his (grandpa john) a little too much in this paragraph, maybe change a few to his or something of that nature

Grandpa John sighed, “When you Elizabeth’s age you loved to come here and read my books. Laughing, Grandpa John said, “I used to have to force you to go home. What happened”?
here you forgot to put the other " after books

Cuileìn’s appearance now was one of a trapped animal with a stiff, rigid form and dilated, fearful eyes.
I LOVE the way you compared him to a scared animal and described it extremely well!!!!!!

The producer of this vortex era alterer is not responsible for any injuries or death while in use.”
this is an extremely entertaining sentence. it lets the reader know that some thing possibly dangerous is coming, but in a way of humor, allowing the reader to laugh

“Impossible!” he whispered.
at this part you might want to add something to the extent of "Impossible!" he whispered as he fell slowly into unconsciousness. or something to show that he is now knocked unconscious by the blow

other than those few things this is a great story!!! this is probably one of the best I've read so far!!! send me a message when you get the second part out, I'd LOVE to read it!!!!

lulu
I open my lunch box Hopin' to find a sandwich, an apple some cookies or cake but there, coiled and hissin' and set to unwind Is anouther big venemous poisonous snake leaving me hungry as can be you think my mother's mad at me?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1478
Reviews 220
He always is trying to stick on me some dumb story or get me to recite a knight’s code.


I think that's what you meant to write but I think you might want to try a different word alotogether because "stick on me some dumb story" is a very unusal way to say that.


The Vultures leader, J.K., although already had filled out his 18 years in height and weight, was only in the 10th grade.


A bit awkward. "...J.K, had already filled out his 18 years in height and weight, although he was still only in the 10th grade."

At first Cuileìn released loud screams of pain but gradually they became lesser and lesser until they were just barely audible.


I think softer would be better than lesser.

"Well now, Cuileìn” he hissed, “Hopefully you’ve learned some proper manners [s]now[/s].”


No need to repeat the now.

“Who so downloads this vortex era..."


I think it's who so ever. (maybe not spelt that way though).

“Impossible!” he whispered.


If he's losing consciousness, and whispering. I don't think you should put an exclamation point there. =P

Wow, not alot of mistakes in this. I like your story, it's a cool concept and it's well written. I look forward to finding out what happen to the protagonist. Good work! ^_^




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 23
Thank you both so much! :D I am going to fix that stuff right now.

this is probably one of the best I've read so far!!!

I highly doubt that but thank you :D.

If either of you ever need a critique let me know. Hopefully I'll have chapter 2 and the prelude posted soon.
"Life is not about how many breaths you take, but how many moments take your breath away"
-Anonymous




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1040
Reviews 83
This was very good. One thing i noticed though was you had a lot of description in some areas and a lack of it in others. A lot of description is good, but the lack of it isnt. For ex. the whole seen where he got beat up. Describe it more. Like describe where he got hit if certain hits were less painful than others. Did J.K. hit him? Get what i mean? if you dont PM me and ill go into more detail

-Mike
It doesn't think, doesn't feel.
It doesn't laugh or cry.
All it does from dusk 'till dawn
is make the soldiers die




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 23
Thank you :D . I'll work on that.
"Life is not about how many breaths you take, but how many moments take your breath away"
-Anonymous




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1544
Reviews 169
I only caught one thing the others over looked.

“Yes Mam” he whispered hotly turning to go back to his room.


The bolded word is supposed to be Ma'am.

Otherwise it was pretty much okay. If you need some one to crit the next part ask me. This story seems intrestin'. I will read on if I spot the next part our you can PM me.

*pawprint*
Lethero the Werewolf
Fly, Fight, Win . . . in Air, Space, and Cyberspace.
-Air Force Mission Statement-

Integrity First
Service Before Self
Excellence In All We Do
~Air Force Core Values~

*Lethero*




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 23
Thank you :D . If you ever want a critique let me know.

-Falcon_Ablaze
"Life is not about how many breaths you take, but how many moments take your breath away"
-Anonymous




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 33
I'm impressed.

Do some more spacing, make the name of your MC consistent and fix some of the errors that have been pointed out and it's fine with me. You captured Cuilén's apathy well, and I'm interested to know why he grew out of his passion for history. That's something for later chapters, though. Or not at all, if you want it to stay enigmatic.

Keep posting, you're definitely writing well for a fourteen year old.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 5577
Reviews 672
Hey there Falcon_Ablaze, and welcome to YWS :D .

A dark, sullen being with seal brown hair and piercingly clear blue eyes was just barely distinguishable sitting on a mahogany platform bed.


Ask yourself this: Do all the adjectives in this sentence have relevance with the plot? Does it have a big impact on the story? Personally, I think you wasted your adjectives. I suggest rewriting this sentence, using only the adjectives which are important to the plot, hence keeping it as clean and concise as possible.

Why me? thought the indistinct 15 year old to himself. Every day they pick on me about my name, appearance, heritage, everything!


Omit "thought the indistinct 15 year old to himself". If the text is in italics, then it is registered by the reader that this is a thought bubble of the main character. 15 year old is an info dump. If you have shown your character's age better, then you don't need to tell us that he is 15 years old.

“I don’t care” he yelled back as he shoved her to the floor.


I was expecting a exclamation mark after the word "care" so that the dialogue carries with the verb "yelled".

As she plummeted to the ground she struck the corner of his dresser and released a yelp of pain.


Comma after the word "ground".

“I dunno” he shrugged, “She must have slid while she was running”.


This is grammatically incorrect. This is how I would had written it:

"I dunno," said [insert character name here] and shrugged, "she must have slid while she was running."

“It was fine” he snapped back.


"It was fine," snapped [insert character name here].

Annaìbla sighed, “Please just do this for me and mind your Grandpa. You may not appreciate it now but it might come in handy someday”.


The "P" in "please" should be lower case. The full stop at end should be included into the speech marks.

“Oh Mom!” she sobbed, “Why does he keep acting that way? We used to laugh and have fun together, now whenever I come near he acts as if he can't stand me!”


"Oh Mom!" sobbed [insert character name here], "why does he keep acting that way? We used to laugh and have fun together. Now, whenever I come near, he acts as if he can't stand me!"

“I don’t know” Annábla sighed, “I just don’t know.”


I don't know," sighed Annábla, "I just don't know."

As he trudged along the snow covered streets of Chicago to his grandfather’s city slum apartment Cuileìn defiantly huffed.


Comma after the word "apartment". Also, this sentence is somewhat wordy and kinda rigid in its structure which distrubs the flow of the plot. You might want to rewrite this sentence but with a more fluid flow.

If he wasn’t inventing some sort of contraption he was working on research of the middle ages.


Comma after the word "contraption".

When you walked into Grandpa John’s apartment you could find pretty much anything but the floor.


Comma after the word "apartment".

As Cuileìn entered the apartment his Grandpa’s Labrador Retriever cross, Tothel, jumped up on him barking joyously and wagging his tail.


Comma after the word "apartment". Comma after the word "him".

“Get down, you crazy dog” he muttered, trying to shove the dog down.


Comma after the word "dog".

After removing Tothel from his chest Cuileìn shouted “Grandpa, I brought back the book Elizabeth borrowed”.


Comma after the word "chest". Full stop after the word "shouted".

“It’s me, Cuileìn, your grandson” he sighed.


Full stop after the word "grandson". The "h" in the word "he" should be upper case as a result.

“Oh” he beamed, “It’s you Cuileìn. Why didn’t you say so? You’re just the one I wanted to talk to”.


Comma after the word "oh". Again, the full stop should be inside the speech marks. -.-

“I have some books and articles for you about Celtic culture and the Vikings” Grandpa John replied.


Comma after the word "Vikings".

Grandpa John sighed, “When you Elizabeth’s age you loved to come here and read my books. Laughing, Grandpa John said, “I used to have to force you to go home. What happened”?


There should be a full stop after the word "sighed" instead of a comma. Insert a comma after the word "age". Insert a speech mark after the word "books". (make sure the full stop is in the speech marks). The question mark should be inside the speech marks.

“I guess I grew out of pretending in fairytales unlike some people” said Cuileìn with a look of icy disdain.


Omit "in". Insert a comma after the words "fairy tales" and "people".

“Here, take this. I made it for your 18th birthday but I believe you should have it now” he said.


Comma after the part "18th birthday". Insert a full stop after the word "now". Omit the part "he said".

Cuileìn sighed, took the disk and shoved it deep in the pocket of his down jacket.


Comma after the word "disk".

“Now, be gone with you and don’t come back here until you’ve completed that” Grandpa John said making a motion towards Cuileìn’s pocket.


Comma after the word "that". Switch "said" and "grandpa john" around. Then, put a comma after "grandpa john".

“That boy doesn’t even know what he’s getting into” Grandpa John muttered to himself as he scratched Tothel behind the ear.


Comma after the word "into".

“I pray to God that everything turns out alright”.


My God, include your fullstops into your speech marks please.

Now, The Vultures, as they were called, were a group of about twenty, ages ranging from 14 to around 20. They were branded with their name because of their trademark way of circling their prey, giving biting remarks that would sink through the flesh of even the toughest skinned individuals. When they felt the urge, they also lashed out with physical abuse. The gang chose weak prey and feasted, like the monstrous vultures that they were, on the collapse of their victims esteem. The Vultures leader, J.K., although already had filled out his 18 years in height and weight, was only in the 10th grade. He and Cuileìn shared Mrs. Violous’ history class. At the beginning of the year, Cuileìn was a straight A student at the head of his class. J.K., who was lucky to scrape by with a C, became infuriated with Cuileìn’s cleverness at something that he was a complete dunce at and made him the center of the Vultures’ attention.


BIG info dump. This is a no no. You want to show what is happening, not tell. If you info dump like that, you will bore the reader and makes your piece read more like a text book than something that should be enjoyable.

“Cuileìn, our favorite little buddy” said J.K. with a wicked smile.


Insert a comma after the word "buddy".

Cuileìn’s appearance now was one of a trapped animal with a stiff, rigid form and dilated, fearful eyes.


This sentence is very inconsistent with the style of the piece. What is the point of comparing Cuilein randomly with an animal. Not only is it pointless, but it is borderline to purple prose.

“Guys, looks like his royal highness, Cuileìn, here thinks he’s too good for us. Why don’t we do him a favor and teach him some manners” said J.K. with a disdainful look cast in Cuileìn direction.


Omit the commas and Cuilein to make the dialogue feel more natural. Question mark after "manners". Use another word for "disdainful" as you have used it already in the piece.

After about 6 minutes, which seemed like an eternity to Cuileìn, J.K. lost interest and called the Vultures off.


Show, don't tell. The way that this sentence lacks any further elaboration and explain gives it a cliche sort of feel to it, as in many novels, when a character is in a bad situation, the writer says that it feels like a eternity. Seriously, that's so cliche.

Cuileìn remained curled up in a ball for a few minutes waiting for all his muscles to relax.


Comma after the words "minute". Mind you, I am actually happy that your main character just got pwned. ( I will provide you with a reason in the last part of the critique.)

Okay, you can do this, he thought, Pull yourself together.


Cliche thought bubbles. My God, your main character has just got beaten up and that's all you have to potray his emotions by? Do you not care about him? If you don't, then why should we?

Cuilén walked slowly home waiting for the bleeding to stop and for his head to stop spinning.


Comma after the word "slowly".

It was half hour after dark when he reached his small, suburb house. Cuileìn tried to sneak in the back door dismayed to find his mother sitting in a chair, waiting for him. “Where where you?” his mother demanded, leaping up, her hazel eyes sparkling with anger. “I was worried sick! I called Grandpa and he said that you left hours ago” she said.


As realistic as the dialogue is, I think that it is rather dull and uninspired. Come on man, use your creativity.

“I was just taking a walk,” he replied sheepishly.
“What happened to you? You have cuts and bruises everywhere,” she asked in a concerned voice. She gently extended her hand to touch his eye. Cuilén avoided her touch and said, “I’m going to my room”.
“Wait. We need to talk,” his mother said, “Mrs. Violous called a couple hours ago. You’re failing history.”
“It’s not my fault Mom,” Cuileìn argued.
“Don’t start with me Cuileìn, maybe if you would spend more time studying and less time playing on the computer than we wouldn’t be having this conversation,” she snapped. “Now, your teacher agreed to let you pass if you get an A on this next test."
“Whatever,” he said and slammed the door of his room only to open it back up a few seconds later.
“Where is all my stuff?!”
“Until you bring your grades back up you are grounded from TV, computer games, and all your video games!”
“That’s not fair!”
“It is and there will be no argument you understand?”
“Yes Mam” he whispered hotly turning to go back to his room. Cuilén abruptly turned around and shouted, “you’re the worst mom ever!” After the words escaped Cuileìn’s lips, he immediately regretted them as he saw a painful look come over his mother’s face and a tear roll down her worn cheek.


I basically made the appropriate changes with the punctuation in the quote box. Also, one more thing:


Cuileìn’s lips, he immediately regretted them as he saw a painful look come over his mother’s face and a tear roll down her worn cheek.


That's just thrown in there for shock value! I did not think there was enough development for it to merit a tear rolling down the side of her mother's cheek. It felt rushed and had hardly any depth to it. As a result, it feels forced and awkward.

A few seconds later the agreement to download screen popped up. Lazily Cuileìn pushed the “I agree” button without reading the words not realizing the significance of what he had just done. To a casual observer the downloading screen looked like any other but if read closely along with the normal items it would have said:
“Who so downloads this vortex era alterer will be transported back in time and will not come back until their prophecy is fulfilled. The producer of this vortex era alterer is not responsible for any injuries or death while in use.”
The computer started humming as the disk began loading. Suddenly his room seemed to start spinning with the disk. Cuilén shook his head, thinking that it was just his head bothering him from being hit so many times. The lights then started flickering a light, hazy blue color as the humming grew louder. Terrified, Cuileìn tried to scream but to no avail. As the lights went out completely he felt the air suddenly become damp around him. He started hearing savage screams and roars, and a metallic noise that startled him even more. The noises seem to come closer and closer as he slowly began to see light appear in front of him. With a sudden gust of wind, Cuilén was suffused by light. As his eyes adjusted to the light, Cuilén was surprised to see what appeared to be a battlefield. He felt himself gently land right in the middle of it, men and horses were running in every direction. OK thought Cuileìn, There is no way this is real, I must be dreaming. When he turned around he was surprised to find a massive, menacing man clothed in furs right behind him with a club. The next thing he knew, Cuileìn felt severe pain rush up and down his body as a blunt force hit him in the head. Everything began to go dark as Cuileìn collapsed on the ground. Before his eyes closed on their own accord, he saw what appeared to be a brilliant, emerald dragon flying overhead, scorching the group of soldiers next to him with its scarlet flame. “Impossible!” he whispered.


This is desu ex machina, a literacy device used to describe an event of an impossible or highly unlikely outcome to reveal more on the plot or to resolve a conflict. It is recommended that you stray away from this, as it feels unnatural with the story, and such use of desu ex machina is often forced or feels artifical and affects the flow of your story in a negative way. If you are going to have a game that can take you to an alternate time or place, at least have a good reason as to why this is so.

Overall impressions:

I have to disagree with everyone that has critiqued this piece. I did not like this piece at all. There is nothing special or memorable of this piece. It feels more like a carbon copy of fantasy cliches.

Cuilén, your main character, is dull, flat and boring. All he does is whine, whine and more whining. Nothing else. If you are going to have a main character that is a victim to bullying, at least provide further explanations and reasons as to why he is bullied. Elaborate your ideas further. Right now, he is third string at best.

Other characters were flat too. You have described many settings, but fail to link it with your characters and make them feel more involved with the story. This also doesn't help with the rather uninspired dialogue and cliches that exist in this piece. Use your creativity to elaborate further and portray the deeper meaning.

Your style in this piece is rather rough. Adjectives and adverbs in this piece were wasted and fail to hook the reader in any way. The style also lacks consistency in terms of wording and as a result, lacks the expression for the reader to digest. It also felt kinda rushed, as you wasted it on describing irrelevant things in your plot instead of focusing on the character vs character interactions and the emotion of certain scenes.

Also, I suggest that you know how to use your punctuation correctly. Your entire piece is littered with punctuation errors. I suggest browsing the site and find a guide on the correct use of punctuation marks when it comes to dialogue, as well as comma usage in sentences.

You also use a lot of dialogue tags, making it harder to follow and the piece more wordy than it should had been. Use dialogue tags only when it is necessary.

Lastly, elaborate your ideas further. Give reasons as to why things happen and provide explanations as to why it is so. Everything that happens has a consequence (this applies near the end of the piece).

I hope this critique helped. I apologize if this critique was harsh, but I want to provide to you my honest opinion to this piece. This is what critiquing should be about.

Andy.
Last edited by Squall on Wed Jan 09, 2008 4:19 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"To the edge of the universe and back. Endure and survive."




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 23
Thank you both for taking the time to review my work.

Squallz- Thank you so much for giving me your honest opinion. It helps a lot. I must agree with you that all of my characters are rather flat.

Cuilén, your main character, is dull, flat and boring. All he does is whine, whine and more whining.

He's supposed to seem whiny :) .

You also use a lot of dialogue tags, making it harder to follow and the piece more wordy than it should had been. Use dialogue tags only when it is necessary.

*Feels dumb* What are dialogue tags?

Falcon_Ablaze
"Life is not about how many breaths you take, but how many moments take your breath away"
-Anonymous




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 11
The plural of thesis is theses.

Overall I think the idea is great so far, I agree with what most of the others have said about it needing some refinement in the way some things are structured and worded though. Particularly, the portion introducing the gang has some odd bits, such as the fact that the number of gang members and the max age are the same, and in one sentence together makes it awkward.

Use sentence structure to convey different environments, mental states, etc. For instance, toward the end where Cuilein is mentally mumbling is mindless disbelief,

"There is no way this is real, I must be dreaming."

is what you wrote, which is rather coherent. Sometimes grammatical conventions can be abandoned for effect.

"There is no way... This can't be real... I must be dreaming..."

However, I disagree with those that feel that you should extend the last sentence. You have already said "everything began to go dark" and "before his eyes closed of their own accord". In this case it's better to trust that your reader is going to be capable of deducing that he does fall unconscious; it detracts from the ending to explicitly state it again.

Good start, I look forward to reading more of it Em!



the children yearn for instagram reels instead of bbcode
— floodlights