All the Birds

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1108
Reviews 404
All the Birds
\
By Gadi C.



All the birds have flown up and gone;
A lonely cloud floats leisurely by.
We never tire of looking at each other -
Only the mountain and I.


--Li Po


The girl on the swing flew up and down as the wind coiled her braids like a wedding gown. A lonely cloud shifted up above her. She bragged to her friend on the carousel that she could go higher than her. Higher than anyone and everyone, in fact, she could swing as high as she wanted, than all other kids. When her friend boarded the other swing, she already knew that she was right.

And she was. The girl was higher than her friend. The swing creaked under her weight, under the motion of the swing, and when the half circle almost came full circle the friend screeched with admiration.
Of course, as little kids they both attempted to come full circle. But now it seemed that only one was closer than the other has ever been.

The wind blew in from the west, and they traded swings, just to ensure that nothing was wrong with either swing, that she could achieve the same feat on another swing. And as she repeated the cycle, another boy came to watch, apprehensive. Her feet were fluttering around like feathers.

“I can go higher than that,” the boy swanked, “easily.”

As her friend climbed down and the boy climbed on, the girl was terrified. What would happen if he was right and she was wrong? What if he could come full circle, while she never will? The breeze was flickering leaves at her, and she bounced her feet to catch a rhythm, and started to swing furiously until her feet gave out. She looked to the north and watched as the boy also began to cease. He wasn’t even close.

“I could. I really could.” He cried as he walked away. “I ain’t lying. It happened before. I promise!”

Soon, a short line of kids stood next to the swing. The girl competed against every livid one; every child that climbed onto the swing fully-prepared and blissful came down irritated and fruitless. They came to the line like balloons, big and brave, prepared to fly upwards; but the girl popped each and every one of them and they all danced in the wind, broken. Each and every one gawked at the girl with envy and repulsion. By the end of the day, all the children in the neighborhood gave up on the swings and the only true champion was the girl.

In every house except hers, a young boy or girl was sulking about the playground competition. He would yell at his parents about how the girl beat him, how she brought him down to the ground. How he failed. How she won, he lost. And as the evening carried on, the parents would blow their sacred balloon to its full size and again, prepare them for the next day, that maybe another child could win, another child could come full circle on the swing.

The next afternoon the girl leaped on the swing while her friend was watching. She was only a little green-eyed, but more praiseful. A new line formed next to the other swing, but with the same balloon-heads as the last time trying to regain their status on the swing set. There were several older kids too. Bullies, teenagers, even high-school students forgot about their homework in order to defeat the girl.

Again, she crushed them. When the last boy shot off the swing irately, the girl on the swing simpered. Her friend waited next to her, for her to climb off. To play a different game, now that she already showed the other kids.

But the girl on the swing remained there. She asked for her friend to fight her again, to see which one was better. After several attempts of persuasion, she watched her friend walk off like the first boy, without looking back, towards the houses. Now, the girl was all alone on her swing.

The next day after school, the girl was waiting patiently on the swing, excited to conquer the neighborhood kids once again. She sat on the swing, hunting for a silhouette crossing the field to fight against her. She waited desperately, but every time she saw a shape drawing towards her, it disappeared in the distance. Maybe someone will come, her heart beat! But her mind already understood. She swung by herself, lingering hopefully for anybody. If an adult would come, that would be okay with her. She was still the best!

Then, she closed her eyes and thought, Please—I don’t care who would come! Just someone I could swing against! Even if I lose.

Dark was the only thing that came to her. The sky was a spider web of lilac and indigo, a depressing combination reflected on the blades of grass floating in the icy draft. Maybe, to wait just a bit more! But she decided to swing one more time. And then, it happened—she cried with joy!—the wind slapped her face forcefully, callously as it happened, as her legs swayed upside down in the air. She came full circle! Now she was higher than anyone, everybody, all the neighborhood kids, all the adults, even all the mountains and planes, than all the birds in the world. She was higher than God himself.

All of a sudden she was tired. She would tell her friend about it tomorrow, she would! And her friend would congratulate her. As she walked away from the swings, she lingered hopefully in those thoughts. Success never tasted so bad.
Last edited by Gadi. on Tue Aug 07, 2007 1:56 am, edited 3 times in total.
my world isn't only beautiful
it is so far away




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 188
Awww. I loved this. It was...weird...the girl was like retarded or something...but it was so good! I loved the last line!

-evangelina
Break the boundaries, hunt the hunter, and leave me a tip.
----to kill or not to kill




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 335
This was really original and well-written, and says a lot about our obsessive desire to always be the best, even if it's only something as trivial as swinging. I also loved the haiku. :D

A few nit-picks:

"the wind flapped her hair like a wedding gown."

I would use a different word than "flapped." The image of a wedding gown is lovely, but "flapped" is kind of an ugly word, and it messes up the simile for me. I would replace it with "billowed" or something like that.

"When her friend boarded the other swing, she already knew that she was right.

And she wasn’t wrong."

"And she wasn't wrong" sounds a bit awkward... just say:

"When her friend boarded the other swing, she already knew that she was right.

And she was."

Yeah, just little stuff. Great work, otherwise. I look forward to reading more of your work!
"I myself am composed entirely of flaws, stitched together with good intentions."- Augusten Burroughs




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 6831
Reviews 594
Hey Gadi. :) Let's see what I can do with this, shall we?

gadi wrote:All the Birds
\
By Gadi C.



All the birds have flown up and gone;
A lonely cloud floats leisurely by.
We never tire of looking at each other -
Only the mountain and I.


--Li Po


Nice way to begin the piece.



The girl on the swing flew up and down as the wind coiled her braids like a wedding gown.


Hmm... That's an odd simile, and I'm not sure how it's supposed to fit... Do wedding gowns normally coil? What significance does it have, anyway? Just a strange choice...

She bragged to her friend on the carousel that she could go higher than her.


Too many pronouns in this sentence. Technically, it would also be "higher than she." It's an abbreviation of the thought, "He could go higher than she could go." (Had to take liberties with pronouns to make my point, apologies.)

Higher than anyone and everyone, in fact, she could swing as high as she wanted, than all other kids.


I don't know, I'm just not a fan of this paragraph. Why do I care about the girl on the swings?

When her friend boarded the other swing, she already knew that she was right.


Ouch. Sort of demeaning, eh? Instead of "boarded," I might put "mounted." Boarded makes me think of planes (although what doesn't these days, haha).

And she was. The girl was higher than her friend.


Okay, college connotations aside, you still have the problem with the pronouns. Are you ever going to name them? This might be a lesson story, but I still think it would flow smoother without the confusion.

The swing creaked under her weight, under the motion of the swing, and when the half circle almost came full circle the friend screeched with admiration.
Of course, as little kids they both attempted to come full circle. But now it seemed that only one was closer than the other has ever been.


Huh? Confusing and unnecessary. So far I'm not really impressed with the story, to be honest. You haven't held my interest.

Her feet were fluttering around like feathers.


Okay, I do love this sentence. Very cool simile.

“I can go higher than that,” the boy swanked, “easily.”


Swanked? Is that... legal? *laughs* I don't know if it can be used in this way, but I do like it.

“I could. I really could.” He cried as he walked away.
Comma after the second "could" instead of a period. Lowercase "he." You know, usual grammar stuff.

They came to the line like balloons, big and brave, prepared to fly upwards; but the girl popped each and every one of them and they all danced in the wind, broken.


Love this comparison.

And as the evening carried on, the parents would blow their sacred balloon to its full size and again, prepare them for the next day, that maybe another child could win, another child could come full circle on the swing.


Good continuation of the metaphor.

Then, she closed her eyes and thought, Please—I don’t care who would come! Just someone I could swing against! Even if I lose.


I think this may be just a personal preference, but I like to italicize thoughts, just to make them stand out.

All of a sudden she was tired. She would tell her friend about it tomorrow, she would! And her friend would congratulate her. As she walked away from the swings, she lingered hopefully in those thoughts. Success never tasted so bad.


I dunno, that ending left me really unsatisfied.

Overall, I have to say I was fairly unimpressed. Your strongest part was in the middle, maybe toward the end, but that's not the important part. If you have a weak beginning, you'll fail to catch the reader's attention. If you have a weak ending, you'll leave the reader wondering why s/he read it. You want to make your opening interesting and your ending powerful. I got none of that here.

I'm not even really sure what the whole point was. Yes, the girl beat everyone and realized it wasn't worth it. So? I just feel like I'm missing so much substance...

The worst part about it all is that I can't help you. Adding more depth and intrigue to a piece can only be done by the author; no one can tell him how to do so. You have some lovely imagery, and you'll notice there's a huge chunk I didn't comment on. I liked that part. It had motion and substance. Make the rest of it like that.

We don't need a million instances of the girl telling everyone how much better she is than them. Show, don't tell. Of course, her bragging is part of the point, so it's okay to mention it once, but I wouldn't say it more. I think part of the problem is that the story just dragged on and remained stagnant for the longest time, before finally coming together as more people challenged her.

Work on it, and I'm sure it'll be cute. It does need a lot of work, however, and I'll leave it up to you to decide whether or not it's worth it.
Love and Light




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6523
Reviews 657
Hey! Thanks for the PM. :D

The girl on the swing flew up and down as the wind coiled her braids like a wedding gown.

This rhymes, and doesn't make sense. I think you should revise it, since it's especially important that your first sentence be great.

Higher than anyone and everyone, in fact, she could swing as high as she wanted, than all other kids.

You could end this after 'wanted,' and it would sound much better.

But now it seemed that only one was closer than the other has ever been.

Maybe try: But now, one was closer than the other had ever been.

What if he could come full circle, while she never will?

This should be: What if he went full circle, while she never could?

The breeze was flickering

Flickering is like blinking on and off really fast like an old light bulb or candle about to go out. Maybe you mean flicking?

There are some other grammatical mistakes, but I think Crysi found them. :)

I like your topic. The girl's desire to be the best is really nice. Your paragraphs are repetitive, though, and in the beginning, I wasn't sure what was going on. If you added more physical description, that would help.

The point of view in this goes all over the place! I think that's fine, but you should control it a little better. If you want to change POV, at least wait until the end of a paragraph, and add a transition sentence.

The way you talk about everything gives me a picture of a very foggy, twilight playground; almost under water. It's told a little like an old folk tale, or a myth. Very nice. :)

With a bit of editing, this could be really wonderful. Thanks for posting!
Jennafina's Love Your Body Already Dammit Campaign

forum353.html

(To find out what it really is, just click.)



Worry does not empty tomorrow of its sorrow, it empties today of its strength.
— Corrie Ten Boom