Song of the Secret Keepers

28 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 46
(deleted)
Last edited by Kel on Wed Sep 12, 2007 2:05 am, edited 5 times in total.
Write from the heart and nothing can go wrong. It's when you write from the wallet that the feeling goes away.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 46
(deleted)
Last edited by Kel on Wed Sep 12, 2007 2:05 am, edited 1 time in total.
Write from the heart and nothing can go wrong. It's when you write from the wallet that the feeling goes away.




User avatar
Gender Non-binary
Points 1979
Reviews 1176
First Part:

Good beginning. :) Didn't spot any errors; there were just a few odd sentances that could have been worded better. Like here:

Kel wrote:The crowd roared in approval as Morthin crawled to lie next to the other.


When I first read that, I was going, "The other what?"

Kel wrote:The eyes of the Stygian clan were always the same starting with Ryal's mother, Quill. They were all a very brilliant shade of lime green.


The bit about "starting with Ryal's mother" is awkward, and you could run the second sentance onto the first to make one long, flowing one.
"TV makes sense. It has logic, structure, rules, and likeable leading men. In life, we have this. We have you." -Abed Nadir




User avatar
Gender Non-binary
Points 1979
Reviews 1176
Second Part:

Little warning bells started going off when I read this:

Kel wrote:Sitting back, Morthin let his head fall to gaze out of the eastern window. The sunlight seemed to explode through both sides of the building, bathing the entire common room in a warm and sensuous light. It caught his hair and cast dramatic shadows over his face. He failed to notice Ryal watching not the surroundings, but Morthin himself.


To this:

Kel wrote:Ryal shrugged and refused to meet his companion's eyes.


Surely you're not going to spoil what looked like a great story with undertones like this? Please don't.

Kel wrote:The main room was swathed with gold and red silk, dripping with fine, glittering gold chains from what seemed like everywhere.


From what seemed like everywhere is... cheap. Either make the chains come from some place specific, or don't say where they come from at all.

The bit of description where Daki is talking about making the tea was very well written, and you have good description here throughout. :) No grammer errors (THANK YOU!!) and apart from said undertones, this looks to be very good. And I like the Oriental theme to it.
"TV makes sense. It has logic, structure, rules, and likeable leading men. In life, we have this. We have you." -Abed Nadir




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 46
Thanks for the tips, ST.

The word "companion" only meant that. Like a compatriot, friend.

As for the undertones, you're the only one that caught it. But "companion" didn't refer to any sort of life-partner.

I just wanted some clarification on how "from what seemed like everywhere" is cheap? They're supposed to be coming from everywhere.

Not a lot of people have ever sat down and experienced a cup of tea. It's a wonderful thing.
Write from the heart and nothing can go wrong. It's when you write from the wallet that the feeling goes away.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 113
This was absolutely amazing! I hope you continue it! You must! I beg you! You are an excellent writer. I hope to be like you one day! Such detail and ellegence flows from every sentence! It is absolutely amazing! Keep up the good work!
"It is better to save than to destroy, and that justice is most righteous which is tempered by mercy." Mark Twain




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 46
(deleted)
Last edited by Kel on Wed Sep 12, 2007 2:06 am, edited 2 times in total.
Write from the heart and nothing can go wrong. It's when you write from the wallet that the feeling goes away.




User avatar
Gender Non-binary
Points 1979
Reviews 1176
Great! The way you described the pouring of the tea nd the drinking was fab; you really built up a picture of what it would look like. :)

Only this bothered me:

Kel wrote:Ryal and Morthin remained enrapt, staring as Daki halted the stream, hovering it high over another. It was repeated twice more to fill three cups.


Rephrase this. It doesn't sound right. Perhaps, The action was repeated twice more? Or the gesture?

And have you got this in the wrong place?

Kel wrote:"Uncle you've got to use it. I ordered it already and paid for half of it. Besides, your leg isn't --"
---------------
Ch2
---------------

Kytus son-Lamra Dragonsbane cut off his nephew with a wave of his hand, an aggravated expression on his face.


Doesn't Lakyle's dialogue belong in the second chapter?

Good, once more!
"TV makes sense. It has logic, structure, rules, and likeable leading men. In life, we have this. We have you." -Abed Nadir




Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 7
The smug smirk of the over confident graced Ryal's thin lips.

Seems a bit off to me, I'd suggest using "The smug smirk of over confidence graced Ryal's thin lips." instead.

With a good-natured chuckle, Morthin lifted himself onto his black leather boots, fine suede trousers in the creamiest of white tucked into them. His fine linen shirt was torn in places, mudded in others, the collar askew though he made no move to adjust it.


Just me being picky as per usual, but the word fine used twice in the same paragraph to describe the same set of clothes irks me. Perhaps a synonym?

Ryal's attire was similarly scuffed due to the final fall. Picking himself up the eldest of the Stygian children dusted off the maroon tunic he wore, tugging it down beneath his ruddy leather belt. Black linen trousers were tucked into his beaten boots. "I was only a fool to turn my back on a Dornex."


Same thing, with the word "tucked", sorry babe, you know me.



Clowns of Entee Village, Ryal and Morthin were not often far from trouble and mayhem.


I know, I already told you about this sentence in real life, but it is still a slightly difficult one to understand through the first reading. Perhaps, "Having always been known as the clowns of Entee Village, Ryal and Morthin were not often far from trouble and mayhem."?

"If you boys're done messin' around in front of my shop, per'aps you'd best get to these errands." Toc son-Lanil Angelusi leant against the sturdy pikes that bespoke the border of the fighting ring. His meaty hands enveloped the soft, worn wood of the top, callused palms rubbing against it. He was slightly rotund with a wide girth about him due to years of heavy lifting with his stomach. He had a merry grin and pale blue eyes the likes many in Entee had never seen before. Despite his build, Toc had a gaggle of ladies searching for his devotion.


Good paragraph, but too many pronouns starting the sentences off for my personal tastes...sorry, I know I'm picking, but you asked me to!

Ryal rolled his vibrant eyes over to Morthin, pulling his lips back from his teeth in an agitated snarl. The eyes of the Stygian clan were always the same starting with Ryal's mother, Quill. They were all a very brilliant shade of lime green.


Do you really need the last two sentences here to be separate? I'd consider joining them myself.


"Aw, Toc, can't we test out some of yer weapons? Brings in customers every time." Morthin opened his hands in a plea, furrowing his pale brown brows at the smith. When he saw Toc's face darken into a scowl he knew to back off.

"Best do as he says, else we'll never hear the end of it. Don't we gotta go to the church? There's a delivery of this cane over there. I know Kytus ain't one for a cane, so who's it for?" Morthin asked as he guided Ryal well away from the bubbling Toc.


I like these two paragraphs, nicely describing a secondary character using primary characters views.

I'll do more after taking you to work.




Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 7
Ryal gestured with a flapping hand to a stall of shellfish. The ridged facades of clams glinted in the early afternoon sun, scales of fishes flashing as they passed. Bright pink gills, salty smells all beckoned the boys to buy. The port town of Entee welcomed many varying adventurers from all across the world to sample the sea.


Nooooo.... Not "fishes" please, please don't.

That caused the Stygian boy to cringe in jest before striding with long legs into a little cafe next to a man hawking cheap jewelry. Morthin paused to eye a particular bracelet that sparkled a rich maple color amidst the braided gold.


You left me hanging here between this post and the next. Just what about the bracelet drew his attention? Why? What did he do with it? Did he buy it, steal it, what?


Her brilliant honey hair was braided in an intricate pattern, woven over her head in and out of itself and more of the gold chains.


Could be wrong here, but.. a possible predicate, ending in a preposition?

Morthin grimaced and Ryal flushed before the fair friend claimed, "Just the main hall, please. We're only here for a brief respite before we head to the church." Morthin fixed the Lilitian beauty with a charming smile.


The words used by Morthin here seem to be off given the readers (mine) impression of the characters general intelligence from previous dialogues.



The serving girl gave a grandiose bow and swept her arm to the side. Her dress appeared to be made of the passion of air, the color so vibrantly red and the make so light it seemed to blaze about her in a haze. Tiny bells jangled at her ankles and wrists as she led the two to a cozy little table clothed in a gold cloth. Her bare feet made no sound on the polished wood floor.

"Please sit," she offered before placing two small cards atop the cloth. They were stiff linen and edged in scarlet lace, the wording embroidered in gold thread. "I will send Daki to you to serve. Peace be, Madura. Daki will attend shortly."


Gold all around, very rich establishment.

A laugh tinkled from its throat, a wispy sleeve of spun gold floating about its arm as it laughed into the back of its hand. Hair of the most brilliant auburn cascaded in rich and lustrous curls down its back, tiny roses in gold dotting the mane. A very long skirt in glittering gold was clipped at its hip so it split when it walked, bare feet whispering across the floor.


Laugh/laughed used twice in the same sentence, sorry, again I'm picky.



"This is the pot in which the water will be poured. It is poured gently over the tender white leaves of the tea, swirling them in a dance of flavor and passion. It is said that tea awakens the passions in many. After I experienced White Snow for the first time, I found myself enflamed with the desire to share such a thing with others. Perhaps the two of you may become enflamed with desire."


Oh?

(Edit: Sorry, pasted the whole thing in that last quote.)
(Second Edit: Finishing critique.)

"There's no seeds." Ryal peeled apart the fragile flesh of the fruit to peer inside.

"Of course not," Daki replied with a secretive smile. "The trees don't produce seeds, Madur Stygian."

"Then how is it they make more?" Morthin interjected as Ryal continued to dissect his fruit. There were bits of it on his fine napkin as he poked around, eating small pieces as he delved into it.

"That, dear Madura, is a secret known only to the Liliti. The tea is ready." Daki stood as the short time elapsed, her dainty hands picking up the glass pot. The leaves lay swollen on the bottom, giving off an aroma all their own.


Reminds me rather of how a mushroom spawns really (the non-spore kind), or mint. How new buds will sprout directly from the roots and then develop their own roots still connected to the main, runners basically.


Ryal and Morthin remained enrapt, staring as Daki halted the stream, hovering it high over another. It was repeated twice more to fill three cups. She placed the pot atop the tray and sat, lifting her own glass. Leaves were still suspended in the liquefied sunlight.


Hovering it over another what exactly?


Ryal took a little more time to savor the last dregs of tea in the bottom of the cup, pushing it at Daki. "Could you put these in something for luck, please, Daki?" He smiled back at her as she picked up the cup. "Thanks."
&
"Ryal, we need to go and now. The sun's already more in the windows on the west. We've been here for hours." Morthin's voice was taut with anxiety as he hoisted the cane onto his shoulder. It was then that the Lilit returned with a small pendant on a slip of red silk string.


Something for luck? This thought seems incomplete to me, even with the closing paragraph. More development here on just what "for luck" means as at first read, I thought you meant for her to put some tea into something for later. Like a doggy-bag.

Pinching the bridge of his nose, Kytus sighed heavily and brushed his shoulder-length brown hair over his shoulder with his free hand. The sleeve of his white robe flapped to collapse at the crook of his elbow. He turned his eyes to the acolyte and asked, "How is using a cane going to ease the villagers into letting a lame priest care for their wounds, Lakyle?"


No real need to describe his hair as shoulder length three words prior to stating that he brush his hair over his shoulder.


Both priest and acolyte jumped as the doors to the church were flung open, flooding the stone floor with a wash of yellow light. Two sillouhettes broke the shard of sun as Morthin and Ryal careened across the floor, through an invisible Seal set into the building, and stopped, gasping, in front of Kytus and Lakyle.


You complain about my use of comas? How about a new sentence or such here?

BTW, for those that don't know, I'm Kel's in real life husband.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 113
Excellent! You have helped me realize how I need to write. I love you're signiture! You are absolutely amazing! XD I have never read so good of a writer who is unpublished!
Or, are you published? Please keep writing! I love the story! I can't wait to read more!
Love, in awe, 007
"It is better to save than to destroy, and that justice is most righteous which is tempered by mercy." Mark Twain




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 46
Stillgrave wrote:Nooooo.... Not "fishes" please, please don't.


Yes, fishes. Not changing that part. It fits. It's a real scientific word.

You left me hanging here between this post and the next. Just what about the bracelet drew his attention? Why? What did he do with it? Did he buy it, steal it, what?


The glinting of the maple gem. He passed it by, which is why he just paused. He left it alone.


The words used by Morthin here seem to be off given the readers (mine) impression of the characters general intelligence from previous dialogues.


I'll make a note about it. He's more or less trying to sound "better" here because of the surroundings. That or maybe he always sounds like this? We don't know...


Laugh/laughed used twice in the same sentence, sorry, again I'm picky.


I'll change it to chortled or giggled.


Hovering it over another what exactly?


Another cup. It was in the previous paragraph. If I'd said "cup" again, that would be way too often. So it's an implied subject.


Something for luck? This thought seems incomplete to me, even with the closing paragraph. More development here on just what "for luck" means as at first read, I thought you meant for her to put some tea into something for later. Like a doggy-bag.


She implies that the leaves are for luck, so they go into something the person can wear. Necklace, bracelet, ring, etc etc. So it's like the name on a grain of rice thing and put inside a glass tube or something to keep forever.

I can see how it can be vague, so I'll do my best to emphasize somehow. D:

No real need to describe his hair as shoulder length three words prior to stating that he brush his hair over his shoulder.


But then it could be down to his waist and still brushing it over his shoulder?


You complain about my use of comas? How about a new sentence or such here?


Example me, since I couldn't think of a tasteful way to do that.



And thank you, 007!!!
Write from the heart and nothing can go wrong. It's when you write from the wallet that the feeling goes away.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1419
Reviews 161
I really like your first few lines from the first chapter.

To me, they seemed to describe he thrill of competing very well. Time seems to stop running like fluid during crucial moments for me.

Keep up the good work!!!




Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 7
My wife pointed out to me that I apparently forgot to include what good I thought of her story. Might have been a copy/paste problem on my end as I did the critique in word first then pasted here.

Anyways, the fight scene was very well done as the previous poster did comment. The description of things via character interactions helps to nicely show their surroundings. So far it appears to contain pretty well thought out development with some interesting characters, such as the tea server.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 46
(deleted)
Last edited by Kel on Wed Sep 12, 2007 2:07 am, edited 1 time in total.
Write from the heart and nothing can go wrong. It's when you write from the wallet that the feeling goes away.



Maybe we're all just complex human beings with skewed perceptions of each other.
— Ventomology